Tag Archives: lynx spider

Four Spiders

A Study in Contrasts

Evolution has become something of a unifying theme for these blog posts. It didn’t start out that way. My original plan was just to write short pieces about the subjects of some of my photos. As time passed, however, the articles grew longer and more detailed, and since, as the evolutionary biologist Theodosius Dobzhansky wrote, “Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution”, 1 I inevitably found myself writing more and more about the evolutionary history of my subjects.

Of course, evolutionary history is sometimes hard to come by. The fossilization process favors organisms with hard parts, living in specific kinds of environments. As a result, the fossil record for many organisms is very sparse — sometimes even nonexistent. Fortunately, these days we can infer a lot about evolution from molecular studies. Unfortunately, funding for such studies is limited, so they’ve only been done for a small fraction of taxonomic groups.

For this post, I thought I’d write about a spider. I first considered writing about the western black widow (Latrodectus hesperus). Another possibility I considered was the green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans). Both are visually striking, and I have some very nice photos of both species. There’s also a fair amount of info online about them. The problem was, I couldn’t find much about their evolution.

Then I had an idea… L. hesperus and P. viridans are markedly different, both visually and behaviorally, yet they are both members of the suborder2 Araneomorphae, the most widespread and “modern” of living spiders. So I thought, why not write about both in the same article? This would allow me to compare and contrast them, while speculating about the evolutionary forces that led to their remarkably divergent traits.

As I turned the idea over in my head, I thought of the many other spiders I’ve photographed over the years. One of my favorites is the spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera). It, too, is in Araneomorphae, and although it lacks the striking coloration of L. hesperus and P. viridans, it makes up for it by having a body completely covered in spiky bristles. In the right light, this makes for some great photos.

And then there’s the silver argiope (pronounced are-guy-oh-pee) or Argiope argentata, also in Araneomorphae. This large spider has a body that looks like it’s made of polished silver!

So, in the end, I decided I would write a single blog post that covered all four spiders. It’s a bit of an experiment, but we’ll see how it goes.

First up…

Western Black Widow (Latrodectus hesperus)3

A female western black widow (Lactrodectus hesperus)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18

You’ve almost certainly heard of black widows. You’ve probably seen more than a few of them. Actually, there are several species that are commonly called black widows. All are members of the genus Latrodectus — the “true” widows. (There are also “false” widows, such as the noble false widow, which is very common in Southern California. It doesn’t look much like the true widows, in my opinion, but I guess most people don’t look all that closely.) Not all widows are black, though. There’s also a brown widow (Latrodectus geometricus), which is found around the world, but probably originated in South America.4 There’s even a red widow (Latrodectus bishopi), which is found in Florida.

There are three species of Latrodectus in North America that are known as black widows. The southeast has the southern black widow, L. mactans. That’s the one I used to see in Virginia, before I moved to the West Coast.5 Then, there’s the northern black widow, L. variolus, which is most common in New Jersey, Delaware, and Maryland.6 Finally, there’s the one that’s native to the western U.S. — the western black widow or L. hesperus.7

A female western black widow (Lactrodectus hesperus)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18

Adult females of L. hesperus are usually shiny black with an hourglass-shaped red mark on the bottom of their abdomen. The hourglass can sometimes be yellow or, very rarely, white. Males are about half the length of the females and are usually tan colored.

A male western black widow (Latrodectus hesperus)
Author: Juan Carlos Fonseca Mata
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

Black widow males are rarely seen, as they are much shorter lived than the females. As with humans, the male’s only real purpose in life is to find a female and mate with her. If he’s lucky, he may get to mate several times before he dies. The term “widow”, by the way, is taken from the supposed habit of the female to eat the male after copulation. While this does occur, it probably happens more frequently in captivity than it does in the wild. (It’s harder to make a hasty retreat when you’re doing it in cage). Cannibalism seems to be even less common among western black widows than it is among some other members of the genus.

Latrodectus is in the cobweb family, Theridiidae. Like many cobweb spiders, L. hesperus spins messy, tangled webs. After constructing the top part of the web, the spider constructs “gumlines” running from the web to the substrate beneath. These gumlines are stretched taught, and they’re coated near the bottom with sticky silk. If a bug walks into one of the these lines, the sticky silk clings to it. When the insect struggles to free itself, the gumline breaks free from the substrate and snaps up, propelling the unlucky bug into the tangled web above.

While we’re on the subject of webs, the male black widow has an interesting habit. When he finds a female he wants to mate with, he starts by trashing her web. A male will cut out large sections of a female’s web and bundle them up in his own silk. Why, you ask? Researchers have found that this makes the web less attractive to rival males. Male spiders find females by following the scent of their pheromones. One theory is that when a male cuts up a female’s web, he’s selectively cutting up the parts where the female’s pheromones are the most concentrated. He doesn’t destroy the whole web — that would only cause the female to get to work building a new one. Typically, he’ll destroy about half of it — just enough, presumably, to deter other males, increasing the chances that it will be his sperm the female will use to fertilize her eggs. 8

Black widows enclose their eggs in round, pale, cream colored sacs. The newly hatched spiderlings have totally different colorations from the adults, as you can see in the following photos.

Western black widow spiderling (Latrodectus hesperus) fresh out of the egg sac.
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18
Another angle

I can’t possibly leave the subject of black widows without discussing their bite. Black widows are probably the most feared spiders in North America because of the supposed danger their venom poses to humans. And, to be fair, black widow venom is reputed to be 15 times stronger than that of the prairie rattlesnake!9 Of course, that’s by volume, and a spider is going to inject a much smaller volume of venom than a rattlesnake (assuming the rattlesnake injects any venom at all, which it often doesn’t. See my earlier blog post: Rattlesnake!) 10

So, how dangerous is their bite? Not all that dangerous, actually. It is painful, and it can cause nausea, muscle aches, and paralysis of the diaphragm, which might make it hard to breathe. Nevertheless, most bite victims suffer no lasting damage. That said, a bite can be fatal to small children, the elderly, or people in poor health.11

Given that very few people actually die from black widow bites, it’s a bit surprising that they have such a bad reputation. Perhaps it’s because that shiny black body with its bright red hourglass just makes them look kind of evil. Then again, maybe it’s because, before indoor plumbing, most black widow bites happened in outhouses.

You see, outhouses tend to smell. And those kinds of smells attracts flies. Spiders eat flies. Probably for this reason, black widows like to hang out under the toilet seats of outdoor privies. And, definitely for this reason, most black widow bites are on penises. To quote from the article where I found this lovely bit of trivia: “A 1944 case study published in the Annals of Surgery noted that, of 24 black widow bite cases reviewed, eleven bites were on the penis, one was on the scrotum, and four were on the buttocks. A full 16 of the 24 victims were bitten while sitting on the toilet.”12

Green Lynx Spider (Peucetia viridans)13 14

Green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans) with a captured honey bee
San Diego County 10/3/17

The green lynx spider is a beautiful spider. Yeah, yeah, I know… No spider is beautiful! They’re horrid, ugly creatures that should be wiped from the face of the earth! So, why are you reading this post again? I suspect you don’t really believe that. More likely, like me, you know how to appreciate a beautiful spider when you see one. And this is one beautiful spider.

A lynx spider, in general, is any member of the family Oxyopidae. Most lynx spiders are ambush hunters. Despite this, they tend to be fast runners and jumpers, and have excellent eyesight. Apparently, their rapid movements and agility reminded someone of a lynx; hence, the common name. Most species, including P. viridans, have large, stiff bristles on their legs, which act as spines, helping them hold on to their prey.

Another view of the green lynx spider from the last photo with its captured honey bee
San Diego County 10/3/17

Lynx spiders tend to be drably colored and small to medium in size. Members of the genus Peucetia, however, tend to be larger, and they’re often a vivid green. This helps them blend in with the green shrubbery where they’re usually found.

A male green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/7/21
A closeup of the pedipalps — the two appendages on the front of the head. The complex structures on the ends are the palpal bulbs. The spider loads these organs with sperm and uses them to transfer the sperm to the female’s receptacle during mating.15
A view from above
A view of the distinctive eye pattern of a lynx spider. We’re looking toward the front of the head from a little bit above the body. So the front of the head is on the right in the photo.

Like black widows, P. viridans constructs a roughly globular egg sac. However, the lynx spider’s sac is covered with large protrusions. I don’t know what’s inside the sac that causes the protrusions. When I get a chance, I’ll dissect one and post what I find.

Green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans) with egg sac
Los Penasquitos, San Diego County 9/16/17

A green lynx spider tends to flee when approached by a human. Unless, that is, it’s a mother spider guarding its eggs or offspring. In that case, she not only stays put, she may even spit venom into the intruder’s eyes! This behavior was first reported in the 1940s by a WWII soldier who suffered impaired vision and conjunctivitis (pink eye) when a green lynx spider sprayed him. The behavior was confirmed 40 years later by Linda Fink, a researcher who was sprayed on 15 different occasions by mother spiders guarding their egg sacs. (I assume she was wearing eye protection.)16

The green lynx spider very rarely bites humans, and, unlike the black widow, it’s bite is not dangerous to people. (It also doesn’t typically hang out under toilet seats.)

Spotted Orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera)17

Spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera)
Batiquitos Lagoon, San Diego County 10/7/18

Note: I should probably mention that Wikipedia and at least one other website I found described N. crucifera’s range in the U.S. as extending west only as far as Arizona. This appears to be incorrect, as the iNaturalist website shows a large number of observations in California, including the San Diego area, where I live. My own photos of what I believe to be spotted orbweavers have been identified as such, both on iNaturalist and on BugGuide. I’m not an expert on spider identification, though, so if anyone wants to set me straight, feel free to post a comment.

The spotted orbweaver, as the name suggests, builds orb webs. These are flat, vertically-oriented, wheel-shaped webs — the kind you typically think of when you think ‘spider web’. They tend to build them more or less at eye level, so I’ve gotten many a spotted orbweaver web in my face while hiking at night, when they’re most active. The spiders usually build their webs at dusk and take them down before sunrise. The webs are quite large, which contributes to the frequency with which I blunder into them.

In constructing orb webs, N. crucifera is very different from both lynx spiders, which don’t build webs for prey capture, and black widows, which build cobwebs. Another thing to notice when comparing these three spiders is that both black widows and spotted orbweavers have very tiny eyes. The lynx spider, on the other hand, has large eyes — especially the front two — and has excellent vision for a spider.

This makes sense. L. hesperus and N. crucifera both use webs to trap their prey. All they have to do is sit in their webs and wait. When a bug gets caught, the vibrations it sets up in the strands of silk let the spider know exactly where it is. The spider doesn’t really need to see at all when it comes to finding prey.

The lynx spider, however, is a hunter, not a trapper. Granted, it often hunts by ambush, sitting still and waiting for something to wander by, but since it doesn’t use a web, it’s important for it to be able to see what it’s ambushing. Plus, lynx spiders don’t always wait in ambush. Sometimes they actively stalk prey.

Spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 8/10/18
Another view
A closeup of the abdomen

The bite of N. crucifera is not dangerous to humans, and the spider is not aggressive. When it does bite, it’s comparable to a bee sting.18

Silver Argiope (Argiope argentata)19 20 21

Silver argiope (Argiope argentata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/26/18

Maybe I shouldn’t have raved quite so much about the green lynx spider. The silver argiope certainly gives it a run for its money in the beauty department. That silvery metallic sheen makes it look a little like a (maybe slightly morbid?) Christmas ornament.

Like N. crucifera, the silver argiope is an orbweaver. Both the spider and the web are large and conspicuous. Unlike the spotted orbweaver, A. argentata is diurnal (active during the day). And, since it tends to build its webs on prickly pear cacti, it don’t have to worry too much about running into them. (And if I did run into one, I’d probably be more focused on the cactus than the web.)

Silver argiope (Argiope argentata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/26/18

As if its large size and striking coloration weren’t eye-catching enough, the silver argiope builds decorations called stabilimenta into its web. In mature spiders, these stabilimenta take the form of zigzag patterns like the ones visible in the above photo. Often, the spider will build four zigzag patterns and arrange its front and back legs to line up with them. It’s not known if these decorations are for defense or for luring prey. Arguments have been put forth in support of both possibilities. One suggestion is that they make the web more visible to birds, so they’re less likely to fly into them.

Silver argiope (Argiope argentata)
Lake Murray, San Diego County 7/22/18

Many other spiders build stabilimenta into their webs (although N. crucifera is not one of them), and the decorations vary in design from species to species. I’ve seen some very impressive ones in photos online. In Southern California, though, I haven’t seen anything that compares to the web decorations of A. argentata.

Evolution: Notes and Speculations22 23

Spiders make up the order Araneae, which is subdivided into three suborders. As mentioned, all four of the spiders discussed here are in one of those suborders, Araneomorphae. Araneomorphae was the last of the three suborders to evolve. And, since the araneomorphs represent, by far, the most widespread and successful of the spiders, we’re probably justified in thinking of them as the most “modern” spiders.

The araneomorphs have a number of features that tend to give them advantages over other spiders, but probably the most important are their innovations in silk production. Araneomorphs have evolved entirely new forms of silk, which allow them to build webs capable of catching flying insects. This has greatly expanded their ability to find prey. Eventually, one group of araneomorphs developed major ampulate silk or MA silk — the toughest of the silks — and this, together with the development of flagelliform silk and aggregate silk protein glue, has allowed them to create the beautiful orb webs for which they are famous.

Two of the spiders in this article weave orb webs: the spotted orbweaver and the silver argiope. This might lead you to assume that they’re more “evolved” than the western black widow and the green lynx spider. Surprisingly, this is not the case. These latter two spiders likely evolved from orb weavers. In fact, the largest clade24 of araneomorphs — the RTA25 clade — for the most part, don’t use silk to capture prey!

It’s strange to think that after evolving all these sophisticated varieties of silk, so many spiders would then abandon building webs for prey capture, but having a large repertoire of new silks allowed spiders to explore new methods of prey capture that were not possible with the earlier silks. For example, bolas spiders target male moths, which they attract by giving off pheromones that mimic the pheromones of female moths. The spider hangs by a line of MA silk, and dangles another line below it, which ends in a droplet of sticky liquid silk. When the spider detects a moth close by, it swings the droplet at the insect. The liquid silk is able to soak past the dusty coating of scales and stick to the moth’s wings or body, and the spider reels it in. This technique was not possible until the araneomorphs developed the sticky protein glue used in the droplet. It also would not be possible without the strength of MA silk.26

A lynx spider doesn’t use silk at all in prey capture, but it hunts above the ground, in bushes or trees, and it’s likely that it never would have gotten off the ground if it hadn’t evolved from web weaving ancestors.

As far as black widows and other cobweb spiders are concerned, transitioning from an orb web to a cobweb might seem like a step backward, but that’s just our human tendency to think of cobwebs as less advanced because they’re less aesthetically pleasing. In fact, the cobweb has some advantages over orb webs. Perhaps the most important one is that it surrounds the spider, protecting it from predatory wasps. And, as we’ve seen, a cobweb can be supplemented with gumlines to increase its effectiveness at prey capture.

When you look at insects, you find a dizzying variety of forms and lifestyles. Most have wings, but not all. Most have six legs, but some have none. They include predators, herbivores, and detritivores. Spiders, by comparison, are more conservative. All spiders (with the exception of one herbivorous species) are carnivores. All have the same general body plan, although they’ve refined that body plan in countless ways: enlarging, shrinking, and stretching parts, and adding colors, spines, and sensory hairs.

The reason spiders are more conservative when it comes to form and lifestyle can probably be attributed to the essential part that silk production plays in their lives. No insect produces more than one variety of silk. A single spider, on the other hand, may produce half a dozen varieties, which it uses for many different purposes. Tinkering with the composition and use of silk is largely responsible for the great variety of spiders we see today.

Still, silk isn’t the only thing that evolution has tinkered with in spiders. The lynx spider, which is mostly an ambush predator, has evolved to blend in with its environment. The black widow, which has unusually potent venom and doesn’t need to blend in, has taken the exact opposite approach — developing a pitch black coloration with a bright red hourglass mark on its abdomen. These two features act as a warning to would-be predators that they don’t want to mess with it. (It’s not always an effective warning, as some wasps, such as dirt daubers, routinely prey on black widows.)

The reason for the polished silver coloration of the silver argiope is not clear, but it’s known that it reflects UV light. Many flowers reflect UV light to make them stand out to pollinators, so maybe the silver color makes the spider look like a flower to approaching insects.

So, why are some spiders covered in hairs, while others… not so much? First, I should mention that they aren’t technically hairs. Hair is a mammal thing. The bristles on spiders evolved independently of mammal hair. Nevertheless, for convenience, I’ll continue to refer to them as hairs.

So, why are some spiders so hairy? In the case of lynx spiders, the bristles are mostly on the legs, and they’re stiff and sharp — an obvious adaption to the spider’s hunting style. In many other spiders, the hairs are mostly sensory in nature. Some types detect chemicals. Those are used for smelling and tasting. Other are tactile in nature. Some of these provide the spider with a sense of touch. Others are used to detect the movement of air currents, which may alert the spider to approaching predators.

The spotted orbweaver builds its webs more or less out in the open, and it builds them at night. I would speculate that having lots of sensory hairs allows these spiders to keep a lookout for things that might want to eat them, even in the dark. A black widow also builds webs, but it builds them in more enclosed, out of the way places, where it’s less exposed. As a result, the widow has less need for sensory hairs to warn it of predators. The silver argiope also builds its webs out in the open, and it’s diurnal, so you would expect it to have lots of sensory hairs. It does have a lot of hairs on its legs, although it’s body appears to be mostly hairless. Maybe that’s because it needs to keep its body bear in order to use that silver coloration most effectively.

I should emphasize that this is speculation on my part. I haven’t read any articles that explain why some spiders have more hairs than others.

Hopefully, this article has given you some appreciation of the many forces that have shaped spider evolution. If you’d like to learn more, please check out my earlier post on Silk.