Actually, if you’re an insect, a lot of horrors lurk among the flowers. Today, though, we’ll be discussing my favorite flower-lurking horror, the crab spider. Crab spiders are so-called because their first two pairs of legs are greatly elongated, making them look a bit like crabs. They even tend to move backwards or sideways in a crab-like manner.1
A typical crab spider with its greatly elongated front legs Agua Dulce Trail, San Diego County 7/1/23
Crab spiders don’t spin webs to catch prey. Some are active hunters, but mostly they’re ambush predators, hanging out on flowers or fruit, waiting to snatch up an unwary insect that comes too close. Their venom is potent enough that they can catch insects much bigger than themselves. (It’s not potent enough to be a danger to humans, though, and they rarely bite people.)
Crab spiders make up the family Thomisidae. Spiders in this family are also called flower spiders or flower crab spiders. There are a few spiders in other families that are also called crab spiders, but in this article I’ll limit myself to the members of Thomisidae.
So, how can you be sure that the spider you’re looking at is a crab spider? The elongated front legs are a good clue, but there are a few species in which the difference in leg length isn’t that great. Another clue, if you can get a close-enough view, is the arrangement of their eyes. Every spider family has its own distinctive eye pattern. Like most spiders, the spiders in Thomisidae have eight eyes. In the photo below, you can see six of the eyes. The other two aren’t visible because they’re attached to the back of the two large protuberences that you can see on each side of the visible eyes. So, the spider can see in front and behind at the same time.
The eyes of a crab spider viewed from the front
The next photo should give you an idea what the eye pattern would look like from above. You can also clearly see one of the two eyes that aren’t visible in the last photo.
Crab spider San Diego County 6/23/18
Despite having a very wide field of view, a crab spider’s eyes are relatively small, so it doesn’t have great vision. It probably relies a lot on vibrations to sense prey.
Given how common crab spiders are, it’s surprising how many people have never seen one. They do tend to be small spiders, but not that small—you don’t need a magnifying glass to get a good look at one. They also often blend in with their surroundings, sometimes even taking on the color of the plant part they’re hiding in. Nevertheless, if you make a habit of looking closely at flowers, you’ll soon start spotting them.
Although crab spiders don’t use webs to ensnare their food, they do use silk for other purposes. Notably, they all use it for drop lines. In the following photo, you can see the line of silk stretching out behind the spider.
Crab spider San Diego County 3/20/17 Note: It does have eight legs. Some of them are out of focus.
If a spider feels threatened, it simply drops from its perch. Then, when the threat has passed, it climbs back up the line.
Once you get into the habit of looking for crab spiders, you’ll be surprised how often you find them with a newly-caught bug. I suspect this is partly because the size and struggles of the prey attract attention, but it’s also a testament to the crab spider’s effectiveness as a predator. Plants in bloom often get a regular stream of insect visitors, so the spiders get lots of chances to score a meal.
This crab spider has caught a small native bee (probably a fairy bee), and it looks like another crab spider is coming to investigate. (I don’t know if these spiders are in the habit of stealing prey from each other. I suppose they could have just been hanging out on the same flower.) The flower, by the way, is a beardtongue (genus Keckiella). Culp Vally, Anza Borrego Desert State Park, San Diego County 5/12/19
A species is sexually dimorphic if the sexes have different characteristics (not counting the reproductive organs).5 Sexual dimorphism is common in crab spiders. Some species exhibit different color patterns between the sexes. Another common difference is in their sizes. Males are often much smaller than females. For example, females of Misumena vatia are about twice as large as the males. Sometimes, the size difference is much greater—in Thomisus onustus (pictured below), females are more than 60 times larger than the males!
An interesting thing about Misumena vatia is that the males supplement their diets by eating pollen and drinking nector from flowers, which just seems like a weird thing for a spider to do. They probably need the extra food, though, since they move from flower to flower searching for mates. The females, on the other hand, spend most of their time passively waiting around for prey and mates to come to them.
Another interesting thing about M. vatia is that it can change color—an ability they share with several other species. They can change from white to yellow and back again. They do this to match the color of the flower they’re on. It’s a slow process. M. vatia‘s baseline color is white. To change to yellow, it produces a yellow pigment that it secretes into the outer cell layer of its body. This takes from 10 to 25 days. To change back to white, it just excretes the yellow pigment. This is a much faster process than producing the pigment in the first place, so it only takes around six days.
Identification Fails
You wouldn’t think that crab spiders would be all that hard to identify, at least to the genus level. That doesn’t seem to be the case, though. I spotted this spider on the yellow flower of a Weed’s mariposa lily.
Crab spider on a Weed’s mariposa lily San Diego County 5/30/23
I caught it so I could take it to show my nephew’s kids. I ended up keeping it for about a month, feeding it small insects (mostly fairy bees) that I caught on my hikes. I also kept bringing it fresh mariposa lily blooms. After a few weeks, it had changed to a bright shade of yellow that just about perfectly matched the color of the flowers. I guess when I first saw it, it had just moved from a white flower (probably a morning glory) to the yellow mariposa lily and hadn’t had time to change.
This is the same spider a few weeks later. I used a more powerful lens to get a closer view. I released the spider back into the wild soon after I took this photo.
So, what kind was it? There are only a few species of crab spider that are known to change color, and, based on my reading, it seemed like this one must have been Misumena vatia. However, when I posted the first photo on bugguide.net, the best feedback I got was “something in Mecaphesa, I think”6. Another post on a forum devoted to spiders got no response at all.
I’ve had similar problems identifying other crab spiders I’ve photographed. So, I decided to play it safe and just leave out all the identifications for the photos in this article (except for a couple that I downloaded from Wiki Commons).
Crab spiders in the genus Phrynarachne are called bird dung or bird dropping crab spiders because they’ve evolved to look like bird droppings. Yes, bird droppings. They did this, of course, because it reduces their chances of being eaten. At least one species, P. ceylonica, not only looks like feces, it smells like it, too. The odor that it discharges simultaneously repels predators and lures prey. (No word on what it does for the opposite sex, but they’re still around, so I guess they manage.)
P. ceylonica is found in China, Japan, Taiwan, India, and Sri Lanka. Sadly, no members of Phrynarachne are found in California.10 (All is not lost, however. I’ve heard that there are some caterpillars that look like bird droppings, too, and I think we might have some of them around here. Fingers crossed.)
A Gallery of Crab Spiders
I’ll devote the rest of this article to some random pics of crab spiders with just occasional commentary.
A crab spider preying on a moth Palm Canyon, San Diego County 5/12/19
Crab spider on a Palmer’s mariposa lily Sunshine Mountain, San Diego County 6/2/19
Another view
This is the same spider. It crawled onto a nearby twig.And one more view
The next few photos show a beautifully-colored crab spider. It’s caught a large scarab beetle.
Crab spider with scarab beetle Pine Valley, CA 6/19/22
Another view
And another
Just in case you’re wondering what a baby crab spider (aka spiderling) looks like, here’s a photo of one. Note that it has the typical crab spider eye pattern.
A very young and very tiny crab spider San Diego County 7/4/23
A crab spider on a Palmer’s mariposa lily Sunshine Mountain Trail, San Diego County 6/4/23
Another view
So, just how hard is it to spot a crab spider? Not all that hard, really. Here’s one on a wild rose.
A crab spider sitting pretty on a wild rose Agua Dulce Trail, San Diego County 7/1/23
A closer look
Closer still (Same photo shown at beginning of the article)
In this case, the spider’s color doesn’t matching the flower, and, since pink probably isn’t in its repertoire of colors, it won’t be able to change to match it. How, then, can it hope to catch anything, you ask? Insects don’t see the same range of colors that we do. It’s quite possible that a visiting bee won’t be able to distinquish between the white or yellow of the spider and the pink of the petals.
A crab spider lurking on a flower Hauser Canyon, San Diego Canyon 5/19/18
Ironically, as I write this, I have an ear infection. It’s made me partially deaf in one ear. It’s also made me appreciate what a bang-up job my ears do under more normal circumstances. We hear so much about the amazing hearing abilities of other animals that you might assume humans have a rather poor sense of hearing. In fact, humans, like most mammals, have very good hearing. But I’m getting ahead of myself. Way ahead, in fact…
No, I’m not going to tell you that if you play Mozart to your houseplants they’ll grow better. That nonsense has long since been debunked. Plants don’t care about music. They probably don’t care about anything. But there are things that are important to them, like locating water, protecting themselves from herbivores, and attracting pollinators. To achieve these goals, they’ve evolved the capacity to respond to things in their environment. They ‘know’ to grow in a direction opposite the pull of gravity; they react to light and to the position of the sun; they follow chemical gradients; they even communicate with each other and with animals through chemicals; and evidence is mounting that at least some plants can hear.11
Sound waves cause objects in their path to vibrate. That’s how we hear things—sound shakes our eardrums. Leaves and petals aren’t as good as eardrums when it comes to vibrating, but they still do it. Is it possible that some plants have evolved to respond to certain types of vibrations?
A study published in 2014 showed that Arabidopsis, a plant in the mustard family, turns up its production of chemical toxins in response to caterpillar chewing sounds. When the cabbage butterfly caterpillar munches on an Arabidopsis leaf, it makes a distinctive, high-pitched sound. Researchers recorded this sound, then played it back to one group of plants for two hours, while leaving another group in silence. The plants exposed to the sound increased their production of mustard oil, a chemical that makes their leaves distasteful to most insects. The researchers tried playing other sounds to the plants, including sounds made by non-threatening insects. The plants showed no response. This was the first study to show evidence that some plants can detect sound.
In a 2017 study, evolutionary biologist Monica Gagliano and colleagues placed pea seedlings in pots shaped like upside-down Ys. One arm of each “Y” was placed in dry soil. The other arm was placed in either a tray of water or a coiled plastic tube that had water flowing through it. The roots always grew towards the arm with the water, even when the water was inaccessible inside the plastic tubing. Gagliano believes that the only way the plants could have known the water in the tubing was there was by the gurgling noises it made. She suggests that plants use sound waves to detect water at a distance, but use moisture gradients when they get closer to the source.12
Plants produce sugary nectar to attract pollinators. Sugar production comes at a metabolic cost, though—it uses energy. So, ideally, a plant should produce the sweetest nectar only when there are pollinators around for it to attract. But how can a plant tell if that’s the case? Recent studies suggest that some plants can hear them coming! Researchers studying evening primroses (Oenothera drummondii) found that when they played the sound of bees buzzing nearby, within minutes the plants increased the concentration of sugar in their nectar by 20%.
The scientists conducted several experiments on more than 650 evening primrose flowers, measuring their nectar production in response to silence, sound at three different frequencies, and recordings of buzzing bees. The recorded buzzing (and low-frequency sounds that closely matched the recorded buzzing) resulted in the plants starting to increase sugar concentration in their nectar in just three minutes! The other sounds had no effect.
The researchers repeated the experiments on flowers that had some of their petals removed. These flowers didn’t change their nectar production in response to buzzing sounds, implying that it’s the petals that are used to detect the vibrations. This could be one reason why many flowers, including those of evening primrose, are bowl-shaped since this shape tends to concentrate sound.13
Annual evening primrose (Oenothera deltoides ssp. deltoides) Note: This is not the species the study was done on. And its color is different—Oenothera drummondii has yellow flowers. But the flowers are a similar shape (and I don’t have any photos of Oenothera drummondii). Anza Borrego Desert State Park, San Diego County. 1/29/23
Invertebrates are animals that don’t have backbones—everything from sponges to squid in other words. There are, unsurprisingly, an enormous number of invertebrate species, so it might come as a surprise to learn that the ability to hear has only evolved in two groups of them—insects and crabs—and it’s only evolved in a tiny subset of those groups.
Why is this? Well, many invertebrates are able to sense vibrations in the substrate—the ground or leaf or whatever—that they’re standing on. That’s probably good enough for most purposes. And evolution always favors good enough. It doesn’t waste time and resources on perfection.
That said, there are a lot of insect species, so even though hearing is very rare among them, their sheer numbers ensure that there are a lot of insects that can hear. Ears can be found in butterflies, moths, grasshoppers, katydids, crickets, lacewings, preying mantids, honeybees, mosquitoes, flies, true bugs, beetles, and cockroaches. And the diversity of their ears is extraordinary. Unlike vertebrates, which tend to have ears on the head, insects can have them on almost any body part—abdomen, legs, wings, mouth—some even have them on their tongues!15
One reason for this diversity is that ears didn’t just evolve once in insects. Scientists believe they evolved independently at least 20 times. In butterflies and moths alone, they evolved on six different occasions!
But there’s another reason. With a few exceptions, insect ears are modifications of chordotonal organs.16 These are sensory organs found in insects and crustaceans but not in any other type of animal. A chordotonal organ stretches between two segments of a joint. When the segments move relative to each other (that is, when the appendage bends at the joint), it increases or decreases the tension on the organ, allowing it to sense the movement. Usually, chordotonal organs are used for proprioception—that is, giving the insect a sense of how its body parts are positioned—but they are often repurposed for other functions, including hearing. They are found at almost every joint, so it follows that insects can evolve ears on almost any body part.1718
The insect in the following photo is a katydid (a relative of grasshoppers and crickets).
Least katydid (Brachyinsara hemiptera) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 11/7/18
Here’s a closeup of one of its legs. The arrow points to one of its ears.
A closeup, showing the ear
The ear, in this case, takes the form of a tympanal organ. This is a membrane (the tympanum) stretched across a frame. When sound causes the membrane to vibrate, the vibrations are picked up by a chordotonal organ that’s attached to it.
So, what do insects do with all those weird ears? As diverse as their ears are, so too are their uses. Various insects use them for courtship, to establish territories, for social communication, even to locate hosts to parasitize. And, in some cases, they use them to detect bats…
Bats Go High (Frequency)
The philosopher Thomas Nagel once wrote a paper about the nature of consciousness entitled “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” In it, Nagel asserts that “an organism has conscious mental states if and only if there is something that it is like to be that organism—something it is like for the organism.” He further asserts that we can never truly understand what it’s like to be a bat (or any other presumably-conscious organism) because we are limited to our own subjective viewpoint, which is very different from that of a bat.19
Why, we might ask, did Nagel choose a bat to illustrate his ideas? Bats are bizarre animals in many respects. For example, they are the only mammals that can fly. But I doubt Nagel was thinking about their flying ability when he chose them. More likely, he was thinking of their echolocation.
Echolocation is the ability to perceive one’s surroundings by emitting pulses of sound (aka clicks) and using the rebounding echoes to build a mental model of nearby objects. Most bats fly at night, and although they aren’t blind, they don’t need to see in order to hunt and find their way around. They can do it all with sound.
Bats echolocate using ultrasound—sound that’s at a frequency too high for humans to hear. When a bat searches for prey, it emits loud, long pulses that carry as far as possible. It also spaces the pulses out, so that the outgoing calls don’t interfere with the returning echoes. The frequency of each click typically varies from beginning to end. Different frequencies bounce off parts of an object in different ways, and this allows the bat to resolve shape and texture. In the search phase, the energy of each pulse is concentrated into a narrow range of frequencies. This improves the bat’s chances of detecting small objects at a distance, but limits its ability to identify them. (The resolution of the echoes is lower, in other words). So, the bat can tell that a small object in the distance might be an insect, but it won’t know for sure until it enters the second phase of the hunt.
In this phase, the bat homes in on the object. As it does, it broadens the frequency range of its calls to increase their resolution, and it calls more frequently to get faster updates. At the same time that it’s packing more frequencies into each click, it also shortens the click length. This is necessary to keep outgoing clicks from overlapping with incoming echoes, since it’s clicking at a faster rate. Finally, it softens the clicks. I suppose it does this because it’s getting closer to the target, so it doesn’t need to click as loudly.
All of this, mind you, is happening over a very short period of time, and the differences in wavelength of the incoming echoes are very small. And yet, the bat’s brain is able to process all this incoming information in real time, all while flitting around at high speed!
There are a lot of bat species, and not all of them do things exactly the same. For example, not all bats vary the frequency of their clicks. Most do, and those are called FM, or frequency-modulated, bats. However, around 160 species use single-note calls. These bats are called CF, or constant-frequency bats. CF bats have evolved fascinating ways of using that single note to their advantage. I won’t go into any of that here—we’ve got too much territory left to cover—but if you want the details, check out “An Immense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden World Around Us” by Ed Yong.20 It’s a great book and one of the main resources for this post.
What I’ve given you in this section is a very condensed and simplified introduction to bat echolocation. I encourage you to read Yong’s book to learn more. There are a couple of other things I’d like to mention, though. First, bat clicks are very loud. The call of a big brown bat can be 138 decibels—about as loud as a siren. Of course, since we’re talking about ultrasound, we can’t hear them—undoubtedly, a good thing! But how, you might ask, does the bat avoid going deaf from its own calls? Each time they make a call, they contract the muscles of their middle ears to muffle the sound, then relax them to listen for the echoes. Even more remarkably, bats are able to adjust the sensitivity of their ears as they get closer to an insect, so that they percieve the echoes at the same steady loudness. This probably helps to stabilize their hearing.21
The other thing I wanted to mention is something that at first glance might seem like a contradiction. Sometimes, when people have barricaded cave entrances to limit access, they’ve later found the bodies of bats that accidentally flew into the barricades. Similarly, if you see a bat flying around overhead and toss a small pebble into the air, the bat will often catch the pebble, thinking that it’s a bug. If bat echolocation is so sophisticated, why do they make such seemingly dumb mistakes?
Probably because they aren’t paying attention. Focusing takes energy. A small object sailing through the air is a lot more likely to be a bug than a pebble, so why bother checking? As for that barricaded cave entrance, when large numbers of bats enter or exit a cave at the same time, if they’re all echolocating, they’re going to have a very hard time distinguishing the echoes of their own calls from the calls and echoes of the other bats. Fortunately, they don’t need to. They’ve probably flown in and out of that cave hundreds of times. They know it like the backs of their wings. So, again, it’s not that they’re bad at echolocation, they’re just not paying attention. That barricade has never been there before, so they aren’t expecting it.
Human Echolocation
Seeing with sound is such an alien-sounding concept that it hardly seems possible. But remarkably, there are human beings who have learned to do it! As a newborn, David Kish had an aggressive form of eye cancer that left him blind by the age of 13 months. (In fact, both his eyes had to be removed.) Shortly thereafter, he started clicking with his tongue. By the age of two, he was crawling out of his crib and exploring the house, using his self-taught ability to echolocate. One night, he even crawled out of his bedroom window, dropped into a flower bed, and wandered around outside, clicking all the while. He remembers sensing the chain-link fence around his backyard and the house on the other side. He climbed that fence and others until, finally, a neighbor called the police, who took him back home.
Kish is now in his 50s. When he walks around outside his home, he uses a long cane to sense objects at ground level but uses clicks to locate everything else. And locate he does! Ed Yong, author of “An Immense World”, describes how Kish accurately narrated everything they passed as they walked around his neighborhood. He easily located houses, porches, shrubbery, and parked cars, and when they came to a place where a large tree branch had overgrown the sidewalk, Kish knew to duck under it.
Kish and people like him offer at least some push-back to Nagel’s assertion that we can never know what it’s like to be a bat, because, as Yong points out, Kish has language. So, even if he can’t explain what it’s like to be a bat, he can explain “what it’s like to be Kish”.22 According to Kish, when he clicks, “he gets a series of `’flashes’, like matches being struck in the dark, each one briefly illuminating the world around him.” Objects that return sharp echoes, like stone walls and glass panes, Kish describes as “bright”. Objects that return coarser echoes, such as foliage and rough stones, are “dark”. (Although, he has no memory of what it was like to see, he naturally uses the language of sight because that’s the language used by the sighted people around him.)23
Bugs Fight Back
For millions of years, bats have been eating bugs. Moths, being mostly nocturnal, are especially vulnerable. After reading about how good bats are at using echolocation to detect and then home in on flying insects, you might wonder how there are any moths left in the world. But millions of years of evolution have provided them with a few defenses.
First, they’re covered with scales. For some readers, this might come as a surprise. Moths certainly don’t look very scaly. However, if you look at a moth wing under a microscope, you’ll see what I mean. Their wings, and often their entire body, are covered in thousands of microscopic scales. These scales are useful in several of ways, but the one that concerns us here is their effect on a bat’s echolocation. Because the scales are so tiny and so numerous, they function as a soft, powdery, sound-absorbing coating, muffling the echoes of the calls.24
Painted tiger moth (Arachnis picta) Jamul, CA 10/25/22 The color patterns on the moth are created by thousands of minute scales. The next couple of images show closeups of the scales.
A closeup of the wing of the moth in the last photo.A closer view of the scales
Moths are not limited to passive defenses. More than half of moth species have evolved ears capable of hearing bat calls.25 In fact, that’s the only thing they’re used for. And they give the moths a significant advantage. When a bat emits a call, it has to wait for the sound to travel to the moth and back again. The moth, meanwhile, only has to hear the incoming sound. While the bat is still waiting for the echo, the moth can begin evasive maneuvers. Also, the sound that reaches the moth is much stronger than its echo, so the moth might have even more time to react before the bat detects it (or detects its latest dodge).26
Some moths have ears for detecting bats, but can’t be bothered with evasive maneuvers. Tiger moths in the family Arctiidae have a pair of drum-like organs on their thorax (chest area).27 When a tiger moth hears a bat, it vibrates these organs at high-speed, producing ultrasonic clicks that literally jam the bat’s sonar! Many tiger moths also contain chemicals that make them taste bad. In this case, the clicks also serve as a warning, letting the bat know that they aren’t worth eating.28
Yet another strategy moths have evolved is the ability to create illusions. Luna moths are large insects with lime-green wings that end in long streamers. I used to see them occasionally when I lived in Virginia.
Luna moths don’t have ears, and they don’t have any fancy, sonar-jamming organs. What they do have are long tails that flutter and spin behind them as they fly. Somehow, the tails produce echoes that trick bats into attacking them instead of the moth’s body. The moth might lose its tails, but it can live just fine without them (as long as it doesn’t run into another bat).29
As far as we know, only two major groups of animals have developed echolocation. We’ve already covered one of them: bats. The other group is dolphins.
Bats and dolphins are both mammals, which means they have a lot in common, but they also have some very obvious differences. Bats are small, flying animals that live on land. Dolphins are much larger and spend their entire lives in the water. Dolphins and most bats echolocate, but they evolved that ability independently. So, it’s to be expected that they would go about it somewhat differently.
Scientists first discovered echolocation in bats. In 1947, Arthur McBride, the curator of Marine Studios (later Marineland) in Florida, noticed that bottlenose dolphins were able to avoid nets in the dark. This made him wonder if they might be using some form of echolocation. Other scientists conducted research that proved McBride’s hypothesis.31
Dolphins are technically a type of whale—they belong to the group Odontoceti or odontocetes, aka toothed whales. The other members of this group, including such fan-favorites as sperm whales, orcas, and narwhals, also echolocate. All other whales belong to the group Mysticeti or baleen whales. They don’t need to echolocate, since they’re filter feeders. (Except that maybe they do. See the section “Whales Go Long” later in this article.) 3233
Whales evolved from land animals. As their ancestors gradually adapted to marine life, their noses migrated to the tops of their heads and became blowholes. In the nasal cavity just below the blowhole, whales have two pairs of organs called phonic lips. These evolved from what was originally the nostrils. By forcing air past the phonic lips, the dolphin sets them to vibrating. The sound travels forward through a large, fatty organ called the melon. This organ focuses the sound, producing the clicks the dolphin uses for echolocation. The melon is also what gives dolphins their bulging brows.
Note that no vocal cords are involved in the production of the clicks. In fact, dolphins no longer have functional vocal cords. All that’s left of them are structures called vocal folds, and these lost the ability to make sound millions of years ago.34 So, a dolphin’s click begins in its nose and passes out through its forehead—a very different strategy from that of a bat, whose clicks begin in the throat and exit through the mouth or nose.
Dolphins (and other toothed whales) also capture returning echoes in a novel way. Part of a dolphin’s lower jaw is hollow with very thin walls and is filled with the same fats found in the melon. When the echoes arrive at the jaw, these fats channel the sound to the inner ear. In Ed Yong’s words, “A dolphin is an echolocator that clicks with its nose and listens with its jaw.”35
This beautifully-simple animation shows how a dolphin’s ping originates in its phonic lips and is focused by the melon. The returning echo is channeled through its lower jaw toward the inner ear. Author: Malene Thyssen Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled GNU Free Documentation License. This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
Despite major differences in the way they generate sounds and intercept echos, dolphins use their clicks in much the same way as bats. They manage the duration and frequency of their calls so that they don’t overlap with the returning echoes. They produce shorter clicks closer together when they need a more detailed ‘view’. They even adjust the sensitivity of their ears to avoid being deafened by their own calls and so that returning echos are all heard at the same steady volume.
But living in water allows dolphins to do things with their sonar that bats can only dream of. Sound travels faster and farther in water than in air, so dolphin echolocation has a much greater range than a bat’s. A dolphin’s large size also allows it to channel more energy into its calls. A bottlenose dolphin’s click can contain 40,000 times more energy than that of a big brown bat!
One thing that living in water allows dolphins to do is downright mind-blowing. Sound waves traveling through a substance (water, air, or whatever) tend to reflect back when they encounter another substance that has a greater density. If the new substance is dense enough, then most of the wave will be reflected. If it’s not that much denser, then only some of the sound is reflected (i.e. a weak echo is produced.) If the new substance has exactly the same density as the original substance, then the sound wave won’t be reflected at all.
Now, here comes the cool part. You’ve probably heard that your body is mostly water. The same is true of other animals. So, animal bodies have about the same density as water. Water is much denser than air, so when a ping from a bat encounters an insect, the insect’s body produces a strong echo. But dolphins live in water, so when a dolphin produces a click, it travels through the water, hits a fish whose body is not much denser than the surrounding water, and continues traveling into the fish’s body. Of course, the body of the fish is a little denser than the surrounding water, so some of the sound does get reflected back, but a large part of it continues on. And when that part hits a bone… Well, bone is quite dense, so most of the sound gets reflected back.
You can probably see where this is going. The returning echos don’t just carry information about the fish’s shape and texture. They allow the dolphin to perceive what’s inside the fish! In short, dolphin echolocation is very much akin to x-ray vision!
It’s hard to exaggerate the significance of this. If you go swimming with dolphins, they can see your lungs and skeleton. If you’re pregnant, they can probably see the fetus. Dolphins can perceive the swim bladders of the fish they eat. They can almost certainly identify the type of fish by the shape of its bladder. They can tell when a fish has a metal hook in it. In Hawaii, false killer whales will steal tuna off fishing lines, deftly avoiding being caught by the hooks themselves, presumably because they can “see” where the hooks are located in the fish.
The skulls of beaked whales (a type of toothed whale) are often decorated with crests, bumps, and ridges. These weird growths are invisible to us unless we dissect the whale—the head is perfectly smooth from the outside—but they would be easily detected by another whale’s echolocation. So, what are they for? A clue perhaps can be found in the fact that they are often only found in the males. Could they be sexual displays, used to attract mates? Normally, we would expect such displays to be on the outside of the body, but when your potential mates all have x-ray vision…
Yet another advantage to echolocating in water is something we briefly touched on earlier: greater range. Sounds travel farther in water before they dissipate too much to be useful. A flying bat typically has less than a second to decide what to do when it encounters a possible target. A swimming odontocete has more like 10 seconds. As Yong so eloquently puts it, “A bat must always react. A whale can plan.”36
This extra time also allows them to work together. At night, spinner dolphins hunt their prey in teams of up to 28 individuals. When they find a group of fish or squid, they form a tight row and plow into their prey, forcing them to crowd together. Then they surround them and take turns darting in from opposite sides to snap them up. The dolphins coordinate the sequence of their movements with precision, and they’re more likely to click when transitioning between steps in the sequence.
Spinner dolphins are obviously using echolocation to coordinate their movements, but exactly how they’re using it isn’t clear. Are they sending commands? Are they tracking each others positions? Are they able to use each other’s echoes to extend their own sense of their surroundings? We don’t yet know.
In 1984, zoologist Katy Payne was observing Asian elephants at the Portland Zoo, when she felt an unusual vibration in the air. This led her to suspect that the pachyderms might be using infrasound to communicate. (Infrasound is the opposite of ultrasound—its frequency is too low for us to hear.) Payne and her colleagues were able to confirm her suspicions by showing that the elephants changed their behaviors when exposed to recorded infrasonic calls, and they did so in ways that couldn’t be explained in any other way.
Payne and other researchers have gone on to spend many years studying infrasonic communication in elephants. It’s now known that elephants can produce lower-frequency sounds than any other land animal. They can also produce and detect sounds over a wider range than any other nonhuman mammal. Human hearing has a range of roughly 20Hz to 20,000Hz. In one study, a female elephant was shown to respond to frequencies from 17Hz to 10,500Hz. Other studies have found that elephants can respond to frequencies lower than 10Hz!
Scientists have shown that much of elephant communication occurs in the infrasonic. It’s possible that most of it does. But how and why did elephants evolve to communicate at such low frequencies?
Elephants evolved mostly in forested habitats. In dense forest, a relatively large animal like an elephant can’t rely on vision to keep track of other members of its group. So, early elephants evolved keen senses of smell and hearing to compensate. Hearing must have been especially important for communication.
But why favor low-frequency sounds over high-frequency? Partly, it could have been just a matter of anatomy. It’s hard to imagine a big animal making high-pitched squeaks or chirps. Deep, barrel chests are just more suited to low-pitched calls. But setting anatomy aside, low-frequency sound is just better suited to communicating in a dense forest. It passes easily through thick vegetation that would quickly dissipate higher frequencies. And the lower the frequency, the better, allowing a herd to spread out widely and still keep in touch.
When an elephant emits a low-frequency call, it doesn’t just set the air vibrating—the earth itself vibrates in response. The sound of the call travels through both air and earth. So, another elephant doesn’t just detect the sound as it passes from the air to its eardrums, it also detects the sound as it passes from the ground to its feet! That’s right, elephants hear with their feet!
What good, you might ask, does it do an elephant to hear two versions of the same call? Sound travels at different speeds through different mediums. In general, it travels faster in liquids and solids than through gases like air.41 So, the sound of the call reaches the elephant’s feet before it reaches its ears.
You might have heard that you can estimate the distance to a thunderstorm by counting the seconds between a flash of lightning and the crack of thunder that follows it. Since light travels so much faster than sound, the flash gets to you almost instantly. Sound, on the other hand, takes roughly 5 seconds to travel a mile in air.42 So, divide the time between the flash and the crack by 5 and you’ve got the approximate distance to the storm.
Similarly, when an elephant hears a call with its feet and then hears the same call with its ears a short time later, this allows it to estimate how far away the other elephant must be. Maybe this is inate or maybe it’s learned. Either way, the elephant gets an idea how far away the other elephant is.
At the same time, sound waves traveling through the air generally arrive at one of the elephant’s ears before the other one, giving the elephant an idea of the direction that the call is coming from. This isn’t anything out of the ordinary. We sense the direction of sounds the same way. However, by combining these two pieces of information—distance and direction—the elephant ends up with a pretty good idea of where the other elephant is in relation to itself!
I should mention that elephants probably don’t just detect sounds traveling through the ground by the touch sensors in their feet, although they do have a high concentration of such sensors in their foot pads. There’s also evidence that sound travels by bone conduction from their feet to their ears. So to some extent, they probably hear the sound coming from the ground with their ears, as well.
Before we move on, I want to mention one other interesting tidbit—elephants can hear clouds. Storm clouds, anyway. Apparently, storm clouds produce sounds at a frequency that’s below the range of human hearing, but not of elephant hearing. In a 2015 study, seven years’ worth of GPS data on the movements of elephants in 14 different herds was compared to weather data for the same region and period. In several instances, elephants in different areas all moved in the direction of the infrasound coming from distant storms.4344
In 2013, I visited an elephant sanctuary in Thailand. It’s a place where they take care of elephants that have been injured or abused. Visitors can feed them (like the little girl is doing in these two pics) and “bathe” them (the elephant stood in the river, and we threw buckets of water on them.) If you go, make sure you pick a place that doesn’t let you ride the elephants. I’m sure that would be great fun, but it’s very bad for the elephant.
Another view. Somehow, sometime, I’m going to have to find a way to work elephant trunks into a blog post. Extraordinary animals!
Whales Go Long
We covered toothed whales or odontocetes in an earlier section, where we learned that they echolocate using ultrasound. The other whale group, the mysticetes or baleen whales, followed a different route. They evolved to use infrasound.
Mysticetes feed on tiny crustaceans called krill, which is a bit weird, given that mysticetes are themselves massive creatures. They include the blue whale, the largest animal on Earth. Obviously, one or two krill isn’t going to be much of a meal for such an animal. A baleen whale searches for huge swarms of krill, and when it finds one, it opens its mouth wide and engulfs as much of the swarm as it can, filtering out the krill and expelling the water. It filters the krill using baleen—bristle-like structures made of the same material as our fingernails.45
Krill are found all over the world, but they aren’t distributed evenly, so whales have to migrate long distances to find enough krill to sustain themselves. One whale, working alone, might have a hard time locating enough swarms, but what if a pod of whales could spread out over a wide area and let each other know when they find a good feeding area?
In 1971, biologist Roger Payne published two ground-breaking papers about baleen whales. The first introduced the public (and other scientists) to the haunting songs of humpback whales. These songs are low-pitched, but still within the hearing range of humans. (I suppose they could have an infrasound component, too, but I don’t know.) The second paper showed that fin whales—the second largest animals in the world—communicate using infrasound. Payne calculated how far a fin whale’s infrasonic call could travel in water. The answer he came up with was an astonishing 13,000 miles! To put this in context, the Pacific Ocean is only 12,300 miles across at its widest point!
Payne’s conclusion—that fin whales could communicate with other whales across an ocean—seemed so preposterous that other researchers scoffed at the idea. His career was almost ruined. Some people even questioned his sanity. Nevertheless, newer research supports Payne’s ideas. To be clear, we don’t know that the whales are actually communicating across that distance—it’s possible that they’re just using very loud calls to communicate with whales closer to them—but what would be the point of using louder calls than you need? Also, research has shown that blue and fin whales will repeat the same notes over and over at precise intervals. That kind of redundancy is often used by engineers when designing a system that will be used to communicate over very long distances. The Martian rovers, for example, use this strategy when sending data back to Earth.
I said earlier that baleen whales don’t use echolocation. But is that really true? A fin whale’s song can last for several seconds, and the wavelengths can be as long as a football field. If we could build a sonar system that used sound like that, we could map an entire ocean. And researchers have found evidence that whales could be doing just that. Blue whales have been observed traveling directly from polar waters to tropical Bermuda, singing as they go. Whales often swim directly from one landmark to another, even when those landmarks are hundreds of miles apart. Their movements certainly suggest that they have a mental map of the oceans—one they might have built up over their lifetimes using the echoes of their songs.
Bird songs are clearly audible to human ears, and we usually find them beautiful. But what does bird song sound like to a bird? The answer is a lot more complicated than you might expect.
For starters, birds seem to hear “faster” than we do. The song of a whip-poor-will, to our unaided hearing, has three notes. But if you slow it down, you’ll find that it actually has five. And when a mockingbird, which mimics the songs of other birds, mimics the song of a whip-poor-will, it mimics all five notes. So, the song sounds more complex to the mockingbird, and presumably to the whip-poor-will, than it does to us.
Researcher Robert Dooling performed a series of experiments that tested the ability of songbirds to distinquish between songs that differed only in their temporal fine structure. He presented the birds with two different buzzes. One of the buzzes consisted of chunks of sound that fell in pitch. That is, a chunk would start off high and end low, and the next chunk would repeat the pattern. The other buzz consisted of chunks that rose in pitch—each chunk started low and ended high. If the chunks were longer than three or four milliseconds, humans could detect the difference, but if the chunks were shorter than three milliseconds, they couldn’t. The birds tested performed better. Canaries and parakeets could distinguish between the buzzes until the chunks got down to one or two milliseconds, and zebra finches were able to tell the difference down to one millisecond, which was the limit of the researchers’ electronics! So, the birds could hear complexities that were too fast for human ears.
It’s interesting that songbirds are more sensitive to temporal fine structure than humans, but later experiments by some of Dooley’s colleagues and students produced more surprising results. A zebra finch always sings the same sequence of syllables, which we can represent as A-B-C-D-E. In one experiment, the researchers reversed one of the syllables: A-B-(reverse C)-D-E. Zebra finches almost always noticed the change, but humans couldn’t tell the difference. However, when the gap between two of the syllables was doubled, humans could hear the difference, but the zebra finches couldn’t.
Then things got really weird. Two of the students tried shuffling the order of the syllables: C-E-D-A-B. Unsurprisingly, the human listeners could easily tell the difference. But the zebra finches couldn’t.
Even though zebra finches always sing the same sequence of syllables for their entire life, they don’t actually care about (and apparently don’t even hear) the order of the syllables or the lengths of the gaps between them. The only thing that matters to them is the structure of the individual notes. And we humans can’t hear that structure. What does this mean? A zebra finch could be encoding all sorts of information in the fine structure of its song—sex, health, identity, who knows what—and to us it would sound like the exact same song repeated over and over again.
Owls are superbly adapted for hunting at night. In my earlier post The Story of Eyes: Part 2, I wrote briefly about the eyes of owls, which are some of the most unique eyes among vertebrates. Tubular, rather than globular, they act like telescopes, amplifying distance vision. And their huge size, taking up much of the owl’s head, allows them to collect as much light as possible.
But even on dark, moonless nights, an owl can still hunt. No, it doesn’t have echolocation. It depends on the faint sounds of its quarry—usually some luckless rodent—to tell it where to strike. Some species, like the great grey owl, can even snatch up small mammals hidden under a layer of snow.49
Let’s focus on barn owls, since they’re fairly representative of their ilk (and I happen to have pictures of one). We use the flaps of our ears to collect sound and funnel it towards our eardrums. Barn owls don’t have ear flaps. Instead, the stiff, dense feathers that make up their facial disk channel sound towards the ear holes. And the ear holes are enormous! In some owl species, if you part the feathers and look into the ear, you can see the backs of the eyeballs!
Barn owl (Tyto alba) Dictionary Hill in Spring Valley, CA 5/13/23 A couple of rangers gave a talk about a red-tailed hawk and this barn owl that they have in captivity.
All this, plus a large eardrum and cochlea, give an owl very sensitive ears. But being able to hear the faint sounds of its prey isn’t enough. It needs to be able to pinpoint where the sounds are coming from. Since our ears are positioned on opposite sides of our skulls, a sound usually reaches one ear before the other. It’s also slight louder for that ear. This allows us to get an idea what direction the sound is coming from. This is true for owls, too. But because our ears are on the same level, sounds coming from above or below reach both ears at roughly the same time. In most owl species, the left ear is higher than the right. Having one ear positioned slightly above the other allows the owl to locate a sound’s source with much better accuracy. I couldn’t find a good, copyright-free image of an owl skull that showed the positions of the ear holes, so I’ll link you to an article with one. Click here to check it out.
Owls have one more feature that makes them formidable birds of prey: almost silent flight. I say feature, but it’s really a suite of features. First, they have large wings compared to their body mass, so they can fly very slowly with more gliding and less flapping. Second, they have comb-like serrations on the leading edge of their wing feathers. These break up the turbulance that’s responsible for much of the sound other birds make when they fly. Third, their feathers have a soft, velvety texture that further dampens the sound of their wings, as well as the sound that their body makes as it moves through the air. And fourth, they have a soft fringe on the trailing edge of the wings to break up the turbulance trailing behind. Almost silent flight has the obvious advantage of not alerting the owl’s prey, but it also makes it easier for the owl to detect faint sounds, since it doesn’t have to hear them over the sound of its own wing beats.50
The following video shows the same barn owl that was in the earlier photo. It’s in slow motion, but there is sound. You might have to turn the volume up on your computer or mobile device to tell. That’s just how quiet they are.
Terrestrial vertebrates—amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals—are called tetrapods because they have four legs. (Some of them, like snakes, have lost them, but that’s another story.) Tetrapods are descended from fish, so that’s where we need to start if we want to trace the evolution of their hearing. Fish have a number of ways to detect sound, including cilia (nerve hairs), swim bladders, ossicles, otoliths, and various mechanoreceptors. We’ll save all that for some future article. What we’re interested in here is their transition to land.
The first fish to make that transition probably didn’t have eardrums. Those seem to have evolved independently at least three, and maybe as many as six, times. Terrestrial vertebrates that lay their eggs on land (i.e. all of them that aren’t amphibians) are called amniotes.54 In early amniotes, the stapes bone was a large bone that was used to support the braincase. It couldn’t be used for hearing. However, there is evidence that by the Permian (298.9 to 251.9 million years ago), amniotes had evolved eardrums that connected the stapes to the inner ear. So, the stapes became the first of the three tiny bones called ossicles that modern mammals have in their inner ears. Reptiles and birds still have only the one ossicle.
The way mammals ended up with two extra ossicles is unexpected to put it mildly. When tetrapods first moved onto land, the organs that had allowed them to hear in water were useless for hearing in air. However, they could detect vibrations in the ground using the bones of their lower jaws. Those bones ended close to the ears, so when they laid their lower jaw on the ground (which those low-slung early tetrapods probably did most of the time), vibrations would pass from the ground to the ears through bone conduction. So, one could argue that they weren’t totally deaf, but they were certainly a long way off from having good hearing. As already noted, tetrapods did eventually evolve eardrums connected to the stapes bone, which was repurposed as part of the inner ear, and this gave them the ability to pick up sounds directly from the air.
At some point, the tetrapods split into two lineages—one that led to us mammals and another that led to all other amniotes. In the ancestors of mammals, the jawbones underwent some major changes. Figure 1 shows the jaw joints of an early mammal and a non-mammalian amniote.
Figure 1. Jaw joints in mammals and non-mammals Author: Philcha This image is in the public domain. Taken from the Wikipedia Commons page: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jaw_joint_-_mammal_n_non-mammal.png
Note that the lower jaw of the non-mammalian amniote consists of three bones, the articular, angular, and dentary bones, whereas the lower jaw of the mammal consists of just the dentary. Also, the upper jaw of the non-mammalian amniote has a large bone called the quadrate that was part of the jaw joint.
As the color coding in the images shows, the quadrate, articular, and angular bones are still present in the mammalian skull, but they’ve been greatly reduced in size, disconnected from the jaws, and repositioned. In fact, two of them—the articular and quadrate—have connected up with the stapes and become part of the inner ear! We now call them the malleus and incus, respectively. ‘Malleus’, ‘incus’, and ‘stapes’ are from the Latin and translate to ‘hammer’, ‘anvil’, and ‘stirrup’, respectively, which are the other common names for the ossicles. (In case you’re wondering, the other former jaw bone, the angular, now supports the eardrum and is called the ectotympanic bone, which is rarely mentioned.)
What drove this remarkable transformation is not fully understood, but it’s been proposed that mastication (chewing) provided the selective pressure. The reconfiguration of the bones allowed mammals to move their jaws from side to side, which is what makes chewing possible. And chewing was a great advance over just tearing up one’s food and gulping it down. But decoupling the ear from the jaw had another advantage. Hearing and mastication were now able to evolve independently.55
Having three ossicles in mammalian ears gave evolution more ‘knobs’ to play around with when fine tuning mammalian hearing. One result of this tuning, is that mammals are able to detect higher frequency sounds than reptiles and birds. They can also detect a wider range of frequencies overall.
To sum up, two things—the increased complexity of their inner ears and the decoupling of their hearing and chewing ‘modules’—have increased mammals’ evolvability or capacity to evolve.56
Kangaroo rat San Diego County, CA 3/4/23 Kangaroo rats have such sensitive, and fast, ears that they can hear the strike of a rattlesnake, jump, turn in midair, and kick the snake with their powerful hind legs before making their escape.57
In Conclusion
As usual, this has been a long one. At least I resisted the temptation to break it up into two parts, like I did with eyes. There’s so much more material I could have covered. I already mentioned Ed Yong’s excellent book “An Emmense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us”. It covers, not only hearing, but many other animal senses. I can’t recommend it highly enough.
I recently made a trip to Florida to visit family. Walking on a beach there, I came across a small piece of driftwood that was covered in marine life. There was a sponge, some globs of algae, and a bunch of barnacles. It was the barnacles that caught my attention.
I don’t spend a lot of time at the beach, so I don’t have much experience with barnacles. Prior to researching this article, I knew about as much about them as most people do, which is to say, next to nothing. I did know they were sedentary animals, so, zooming in for a close shot with my camera, I was surprised to see them moving. They were extending some kind of feelers and swaying back and forth on their stalks.
Here’s a video I recorded. I later identified them as Lepas anserifera, a species of goose barnacle.
I guess I shouldn’t have been so surprised. Sedentary just means rooted to one spot – it doesn’t mean the animal can’t move at all. A barnacle has to get its food somehow, and that means some kind of movement.
A weird, boring animal that most people know nothing about? Obviously, a blog post was in order. Speaking of not knowing much about them, it’s possible that some of you might not have even realized that the animals in the video were barnacles, if I hadn’t told you. You probably think of barnacles as looking like tiny volcanos. These are the acorn barnacles, and there are certainly plenty of them around. Here’s a photo of some of these more ‘traditional’ barnacles that I saw on a beach in California.
Little brown barnacles (Chthamalus dalli) Swami’s Beach, Encinitas, CA. 5/8/2022
A barnacle is an arthropod, like insects, spiders, and scorpions. More specifically, it’s a crustacean, which means it’s related to things like crabs, crayfish, and shrimp. That might come as a surprise. At first glance, a barnacle certainly doesn’t look very shrimp-like. However, if you were to pry apart the hard plates, you would see that the animal inside actually does look a bit like a shrimp lying on its back with its legs sticking up in the air. The legs are what it uses to sweep the water for small animals and other edible particles. The great Victorian zoologist Louis Agassiz described it beautifully – the barnacle, according to Agassiz, is “nothing more than a little shrimp-like animal, standing on its head in a limestone house and kicking food into its mouth.”23
Those legs, modified in the adult for filter feeding, are called cirri (singular cirrus). Here’s a diagram of a cross section of a typical acorn barnacle.
If you were to see a barnacle larva, its crustacean nature might be more apparent. A barnacle starts out life as an egg, which hatches into a nauplius (plural nauplii). Nauplius is the name used for the first larval stage of many types of crustaceans. In this stage, the larva has three pairs of legs and one eye. It has no thorax or abdomen – just a head and a telson. The telson is the last segment of the body – the one that would come after the abdomen, if it had one. The legs are attached directly to the head.2649
The nauplius drifts around as part of the zooplankton,56 feeding and growing and occasionally molting. A barnacle’s last larval stage is called a cyprid or cypris. In this form, it doesn’t eat. It’s sole purpose is to find a nice place to settle down.
Source/photographer: English: Calman, W. T. (1911 ) Life of Crustacea, Category:New York: the MacMillan Company This is a photograph from the Freshwater and Marine Image Bank at the en:University of Washington. Materials in the Freshwater and Marine Image Bank are in the public domain. No copyright permissions are needed. Acknowledgement of the Freshwater and Marine Image Bank as a source for borrowed images is requested.
Cyprids have to be picky about where they settle. Since they are sedentary in their adult forms, it’s important to find a place where there’s plenty of food, hopefully not too much predation, and lots of other barnacles of the same species around for mating purposes. It searches its environment by probing with its antennules (the first pair of antennae in crustaceans57) and by sensing a chemical released by others of its kind.58 A cyprid can live from days to weeks, depending on the species. As it begins to exhaust its energy supply, it becomes less fussy and may settle for a site that’s less than optimal.
Once it picks a location, the cyprid cements itself headfirst to the spot, using a cement excreted from its antennae. Then it metamorphoses into its adult form. In the case of acorn barnacles, it grows four, six, or eight hard, calcareous59 plates to surround and protect it.
This is the best image I could find on Wiki Commons for barnacle anatomy. It would be perfect if the labels weren’t in French. Still, you can probably figure out what most of the terms mean.
In an acorn barnacle, two of the plates form an operculum, which may be recessed into the ring formed by the other plates. The operculum opens to let the barnacle extends its cirri for feeding. In species of barnacles that inhabit tidal areas, the operculum closes up when the tide goes out to keep the barnacle from drying out.
Click here to see an article that has a nice diagram of the arrangement of plates for a typical acorn barnacle. It also has a nice diagram of the internal anatomy. For an article that shows both acorn and goose barnacle anatomy, click here. The latter article is written for kids, but it’s worth a read. It sums up a lot of the stuff I cover here in a very simple and approachable way.
As with many other groups of organisms, barnacle taxonomy has changed quite a bit over the years and is still changing. To avoid going down a taxonomic rabbit hole, I’m going to stick to the larger, hopefully more stable, groupings. I’m also going to stick mostly to the classification scheme presented by Wikipedia.62
As of 2021, barnacles are classified as follows: Phylum: Arthropoda Subphylum: Crustacea Class: Thecostraca Subclass: Cirripedia63
The most important grouping here is the subclass Cirripedia. Barnacles make up this subclass, so scientists often refer to them as cirripedes. Cirripedia is further broken down into three infraclasses: Thoracica, Rhizocephala, and Acrothoracica. Since these are super important, I’ll give each of them their own section.
Infraclass Thoracica includes both the acorn barnacles and the goose barnacles. Goose barnacles are also called gooseneck barnacles or stalked barnacles. They attach to the substrate via a thick, muscular stalk called a peduncle. For this reason, they are also sometimes called pedunculate barnacles. Goose barnacles used to make up order Pedunculata, but researchers have now reclassified them into multiple orders (which I won’t get into).
I included a video of some goose barnacles that I saw in Florida at the beginning of this post. Here are a few still photos.
Goose Barnacles (Lepas anserifera) on a piece of driftwood Lantano Municipal Beach, Lantano, FL 5/3/2022
Notice the tiny barnacle of the same species next to the two larger ones. When the cyprid first metamorphoses into its adult form, that form is very small. Probably much smaller even than this one.
This species of barnacle is wide, thin, and delicate-looking. Unlike the more robust species of goose barnacle pictured later in this section.
Extending the cirri
A close look at those cirri If the barnacle was underwater, the cirri would be spread out, instead of clumped together.
Soon after I got back from Florida, I drove to Swami’s Beach in Encinatas, California, just 30 miles from where I live. I spent some time taking pictures of the gooseneck barnacles (Pollicipes polymerus) in the tide pools there. I included a few of photos below. As you can see, they are quite a bit more robust-looking than the goose barnacles I saw in Florida. This is because they’re a tidepool species and have to withstand the pummeling of the waves. Life attached to a piece of driftwood is usually a lot more laid back.
Gooseneck Barnacle (Pollicipes polymerus) (There are a few little brown barnacles visible on the face of the rock on the left-hand side.) Swami’s Beach, Encinitas, CA 5/8/2022
A closeup with my fingers for scale
Up close, the many small plates give these barnacles a rough, kind of “prehistoric” look, like they’d be right at home with a few dinosaurs splashing around in the surf.
In the right half of the photo, you can see a bunch of dark, almost black, mussels. The barnacles have to compete with the mussels for space on the rocks.
An even closer look. Notice the tiny scales on the stalk. This is a very well-armored barnacle.
Here, you can see some of the barnacles extending their cirri. The waves were occasionally crashing over them, so I guess it was worth their time to try to filter out plankton from the spray.
You might be wondering why pedunculate barnacles are called goose barnacles. It’s an interesting story. The word ‘barnacle’ was originally the name of a type of goose. The barnacle goose, Branta leucopsis, breeds mainly on the Arctic islands of the North Atlantic. From there, they migrate to Europe. Since they were never seen to nest or lay eggs in Europe (and it had not yet become generally known that birds migrate), people in the Middle Ages concluded that they must develop from barnacles through spontaneous generation.68
The idea was apparently inspired by the similarity in shape and color between these two otherwise wildly dissimilar organisms. Here’s a picture of some barnacle geese.
You can see the similarity. As if more evidence were needed, the tuft of brown cirri that protrudes from a goose barnacle’s capitulum (shell) even resembles the down on an unhatched gosling. (I guess even people in the Middle Ages knew that other types of geese hatch from eggs.)
Since goose barnacles are often found on driftwood, people figured they must have been attached to branches that later fell into the water. One has to wonder how they explained the fact that they never found these branches while they were still attached to the tree, but, in any case, this was the explanation given by the archdeacon of Brecon, Gerald of Wales, in his literary work, Topographia Hiverniae,69 written around 1188.70
All this led to the English names “goose barnacle” and “barnacle goose”. Even the scientific name reflects this strange belief. The “anserifera” part of Lepas anserifera comes from the Latin word for goose: anser. As late as 1678, one writer wrote of “multitudes of little Shells; having within them little Birds perfectly shap’d, supposed to be Barnacles. (By “Barnacles”, he meant the birds.)
Lest we conclude that our ancestors were not very scientific in their thinking, here’s an old illustration that shows how they imagined the stages of development from barnacle to goose.
Some Catholics reasoned that since barnacle geese were “neither flesh, nor born of flesh”, they could get away with eating them on days when eating meat was forbidden by the church. Not every Catholic agreed. The Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II, for one, examined some barnacles, and, noting that there was no evidence of any embryonic birds in them, decided the whole thing was basically horse puckey. (Not his words.)71
While we’re on the subject, I just couldn’t resist including the following photo. It’s a taxidermy exhibit in the Zoological Museum in Copenhagen illustrating the myth of the barnacle goose.
Moving on, acorn barnacles form the order Balanomorpha.72 They are a type of sessile barnacle. Sessile barnacles make up the group Sessilia. According to Wikipedia, “Sessilia is an unranked clade of barnacles, comprising the barnacles without stalks, or acorn barnacles. They form a monophyletic group and are probably derived from stalked or goose barnacles..” Don’t worry… I’m not going to try to break down that quote. I only include it because it mentions that acorn barnacles probably evolved from goose barnacles.
I showed you a photo of some acorn barnacles earlier in the post. Here’s another one, which shows a few more of the same species.
Little brown barnacles (Chthamalus dalli) These are much smaller than either of the goose barnacles in the earlier photos. Swami’s Beach, Encinitas, CA 5/8/2022
Notice how the barnacles are clumped together. A cyprid always does its best to settle next to other barnacles of the same species. Otherwise, its chances of reproducing are pretty slim.
A closeup of one of the barnacles. Notice how the outer shell is divided into plates. Because this species of barnacle lives in the tidal zone, the waves, along with their load of sand and other particles, are constantly eroding the barnacle’s shell, making it irregular and dirty-looking. Acorn barnacles that live below the tide line, tend to have much more pristine shells.
As I was placing these images on the page, I noticed that there are some individuals of what might be a different species of acorn barnacle in the lower right of this photo. It’s possible that they are just a more immature form of the same species, but the shells look very different in both shape and color, so idk.
Stalked and acorn barnacles are not the only members of infraclass Thoracica. Wart barnacles make up the group Verrucomorpha, which is either an order or a family (different articles give it different rankings). These are the asymmetrical barnacles. They differ from the other sessile barnacles in having the plates asymmetrically arranged, often giving them a lop-sided appearance.73 Then there’s the family Neoverrucidae. I’ve found very little info online about this group. Apparently, it contains the genus Neoverruca, whose members are found around hydrothermal vents.74
The barnacles in infraclass Rhizocephala are all parasitic on other crustaceans. Some of them even parasitize thoracican barnacles. Rhizocephalans are fascinating, if somewhat gruesome. As nauplii, they don’t feed at all, although they do go through several molts. The cyprid also does not feed. In the (now deprecated) subgroup Kentrogonida, the female cyprid settles on a host and metamorphoses into a form called a kentrogon. The kentrogon has no appendages other than the antenna that it uses to attach to the host, and its body has no visible segmentation. Its only purpose is to inject a mass of cells called a vermigon into the host’s body. It does this through a stylet on its head. In the (also now deprecated) subgroup Akentrogonida, the kentrogon stage seems to have been lost. The cyprid injects the vermigon through one of its antennules.
Inside the body of the host, the vermigon grows into a network of root-like threads, called an interna, mostly centering on the host’s digestive system. It feeds by absorbing nutrients directly from the hemolymph (what passes for blood in crustaceans). The barnacle then grows an externa, a sac-like structure that extrudes from the host’s abdomen. This, as you might have guessed, is the reproductive part of the female. The following photos show the exerna of barnacles protruding from a couple of crabs.
The externa is located where the host’s egg sac would normally be. The barnacle castrates the host and chemically alters its behavior, so that it cares for the externa as if it were its own egg sac (even if the host happens to be male!)
So where is the male barnacle while all this is going on? The male cyprid is attracted by pheromones released by the female. What happens next depends on the particular the type of rhizocephalan barnacle. In the order Kentrogonida, the male enters the externa through a special oriface called the mantle departure, which leads to two receptacle passageways. Once inside, a very short-lived male stage called a trichogen emerges from the body of the cyprid through the antennule opening. The trichogen is the homologue of the female kentrogon, which is to say, they both evolved from the same structure. But in the male, this structure has been “reduced to an amoeboid unsegmented cuticle-covered mass of cells consisting of three to four cell-types”.76 The trichogen sheds its cuticle before reaching the end of the passageway. Having two receptacles, the externa can accept two males. This has the advantage of increasing the genetic variability of the offspring.
Other subgroups of Rhizocephala do variations on the same theme. For example, in the order Akentrogonida, there is no trichogen stage. The male cyprid injects its cell mass through an antennule directly into the externa.
In injecting this mass of cells into the externa, the male barnacle is basically injecting itself. And, since the injected stage consists of just sperm-forming cells, it follows that, in this stage of its development, the male rhizocephalan is the simplest known form of male in the animal kingdom.77
Members of Acrothoracica are called burrowing barnacles because, in their cyprid forms, they bore into various kinds of calcareous80 materials, including mollusk shells, coral, crinoids, gastropod shells (both of live gastropods and those inhabited by hermit crabs), thoracican barnacles, bryozoans, limestone, and chalk. The cyprids have chitinous teeth that they use for boring. Once ensconced in their self-excavated burrows, they metamorphose into adult barnacles and live out the rest of their lives as filter feeders, much like acorn and goose barnacles. Burrowing barnacles, however, have no need of thick, calcareous protective plates – they have their burrows to protect them.
Individual acrothoracican barnacles are either male or female. The males are dwarfs and are sometimes found attached to the female or to the wall of her burrow.
Burrowing barnacles are smaller than most other barnacles, tending to be only a few millimeters long. Since many types live on the shells of other creatures, they can be thought of as having a symbiotic relationship with a host. In most cases, the relationship is probably a mutualism, in that the burrower benefits, but the host isn’t significantly harmed.81
Barnacle Sex
I’ve already briefly discussed sex in rhizocephalan and acrothoracican barnacles. In the thoracicans – the acorn and gooseneck barnacles – things work a little differently. For starters, most species are hermaphrodites. That is, every barnacle has both male and female sex organs. So when two thoracican barnacles meet, they can fertilize each other.
As I mentioned earlier in the article, when a cyprid is looking for a place to settle, it favors locations where there are already other barnacles of the same species. Both acorn and goose barnacles are found in large, crowded masses. Even so, you might think that internal sex would be out of the question for such sessile organisms, especially in the case of acorn barnacles. Not so. The thoracicans have come up with a very simple solution to the problem – the longest penises in the animal kingdom! – relative to body size, of course. A barnacle’s penis can be up to eight times its body length!82
I was so hoping to find a nice, copyright-free image of a barnacle penis, but I wasn’t able to find good one. Failing that, I found an article that contains an excellent photo of one. It’s in “Deep Sea News” and it’s by Dr. J. Matt Hoch. The article is short, very interesting, and has an awesome title. Click here to check it out. (Dr. Hoch, by the way, claims that a barnacle’s penis can stretch as much as ten times the length of its body. Since he has personally researched the subject, I suppose he should know what he’s talking about.)
But why settle for a photo when you can watch a video? Click here for a very strange music video about barnacle sex.
Barnacles don’t just attach themselves to nonliving substrates. They also attach to many types of marine animals. A few species of acorn barnacles have evolved to attach themselves to whales. Some species can live on a variety of whales. Others attach mostly to one species. Altogether, barnacles have managed to colonize around a dozen different whales species.
Some kinds of whale barnacle can grow quite large (for barnacles) – around the size of a small coffee cup. They also tend to be more spherical than cone-shaped. The following photo shows some barnacles attached to the underside of a dead humpback whale calf.
Barnacles attached to the ventral pleats of a humpback whale calf (photo taken during necropsy). Alaska, Peril Strait, Baranof Island. 2005 October 18 Author: Aleria Jensen, NOAA/NMFS/AKFSC. Source: NOAA Photo Library: anim1032 This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 2.0 Generic license. This image is in the public domain because it contains materials that originally came from the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, taken or made as part of an employee’s official duties.
Here’s a close-up. You can see the cirri inside the opercula. (Notice the whale lice hanging out among the barnacles. See my earlier post: Scuds, Skeleton Shrimp, and Whale Lice.) Since whale barnacles don’t normally need to worry about drying out, at least during their host’s lifetime, their opercula can’t close up.
When it comes to whale barnacles, one unanswered question is how the tiny larvae – each one about the size of a grain of salt – find a whale to attach to. Scientists do have a hypothesis. Barnacle larvae go through several developmental stages. It can take up to two weeks before they’re ready to find a whale and settle down, so they need to have whales in close proximity during that time. It seems likely that the adult barnacles wait until the whales gather in coastal areas for breeding to release their larvae. When the larvae are finally ready to settle, a chemical signal probably leads them to a nearby whale. This signal could be a pheromone emitted by adult barnacles, or it could be some chemical that sloughs off the skin of the whale itself.
Once it finds a whale, the larva doesn’t attach just anywhere on the whale. A whale barnacle eats the same plankton as its host, so it needs to settle someplace where it will have full access to the clouds of plankton that the whale swims through. This generally means the whale’s forehead, its tail, or the leading edges of its flippers.
How does such a tiny larva find the correct spot? While we don’t know for certain, the process is believed to go something like this: The larva attaches itself temporarily to the whale’s body by squeezing a drop of sticky polymer out of one of its antennules. It then squeezes a drop out of the other antennule, sticking that one down. It releases the first antennule and swings itself to a new spot. Then it does it again. And again. In this way, the larva can slowly grope its way all over the whale until it finds where it wants to be. The article I got this from describes the larva as “leaving little gluey footprints” as it makes its way around. (I don’t know if researchers have actually found such traces or if the scientist quoted just liked the idea of a larva leaving little ‘footprints’.)
Whale barnacles are not easy to study. For starters, there’s not much grant money available. What little funding there is usually goes either to trying to figure out how to keep barnacles from attaching to the hulls of boats or trying to develop new adhesives based on the glues that barnacles use to attach themselves to substrates. The life history of whale barnacles just doesn’t seem to be much of a priority in the world at large.
Even if you manage to get funding for a project, you still have to find barnacles to study. You can’t just pry a barnacle off a living whale – they’re too firmly embedded in the whale’s flesh for that. About the only way to obtain them is to find a dead whale washed up on the shore and try to get to it before all the barnacles die. And since, as I already mentioned, whale barnacles can’t close up their opercula to keep from drying out, you have to get to the carcass pretty quick.
On top of all that, no one has figured out how to keep whale barnacles alive in the lab. Researchers in Japan were able to keep some larvae alive for about two weeks, but that’s as long as anyone has been able to do it.
So, unsurprisingly, there aren’t a whole lot of scientists studying whale barnacles. And this means there’s a lot that we still don’t know about them. Still, there are a few hardy researchers working to correct that. One such researcher is Larry Taylor. For his PhD thesis, Taylor somehow managed to convince his advisor to let him work on whale barnacles.
As an acorn barnacle grows, it adds concentric rings of material to the bottom of its shell wall. It gets this material by pulling dissolved oxygen and minerals from the water around it. These rings act much like tree rings, storing a record of the changing conditions the animal experiences. But unlike trees, which only add one ring of new wood per year, a barnacle can crank out a new ring in a much shorter amount of time – in as little as a few weeks.
Taylor’s idea for his thesis was to analyze the chemical composition of the rings in fossilized whale barnacle shells to try to determine the migration patterns of the whales that they had been attached to in life. This information could be important for a number of reasons. For one thing, scientists would like to know when and why baleen whales started migrating. One idea is that they started doing it around three million years ago when the ice age was making it too cold for whales in some of their northern habitats. It could also have changed the distribution of the plankton that the whales fed on. Taylor’s results could help to confirm or refute these ideas.
The changing climate would also have affected the distribution of plankton from season to season. This would be reflected in the migration patterns of the whales. So, having a record of these migration patterns could provide clues to how changes in climate affect the oceans.
Taylor was able to discern a pattern of changes in the rings that provided clear evidence for migration. This at least confirmed that baleen whales have been migrating for a very long time. It’s just a start, though. Taylor and his colleagues hope to analyze fossil barnacles from many other time periods, helping scientists build a better picture of how Earth’s climate has changed over millions of years.
In the interest of brevity, I’ve glossed over many fascinating details of Taylor’s work. For a more complete treatment, check out this article: What Whale Barnacles Know.
Of all the many animals that Charles Darwin studied during his voyage on the Beagle, the Galápagos finches are probably the ones that get the most media attention. However, the influence of those finches on the development of Darwin’s ideas is probably exaggerated. (They didn’t even get a specific mention in “The Origin of Species”.) Surprisingly, the animal that played the biggest part in the development of his theory might very well have been – you guessed it – the barnacle.
On a beach in Chile, three years into his voyage on the Beagle, Darwin found a large shell that was peppered with hundreds of minute holes. Intrigued, he took it back to the ship and examined it with his microscope. He probed the holes with a needle and pulled out tiny, shell-less barnacles. These were the burrowing barnacles, infraclass Acrothoracica, that I described earlier in this post. Only, they didn’t have that name back then. In fact, Darwin was the first scientist to ever document them. He nicknamed the new type of barnacle Mr. Arthrobalanus. The name means “jointed barnacle”.
When Darwin returned to England in 1836, he was still a creationist. He had not yet formulated his famous theory. Then, Darwin read “Essay on the Principle of Population” by Thomas Malthus. The gist of the essay is that the human population always outgrows the available food supply, leading to a struggle for survival. Darwin realized that the same principle would apply to other organisms. It was this principle that led him to the idea of the survival of the fittest. If an organism varies from the other members of its species in a way that increases its chances of successfully reproducing, its lineage is more likely to continue. Further advantageous changes in some of its descendants could eventually lead to the emergence of a new species.
His theory was still far from fully developed, however. Within any given species, individuals seemed to be pretty uniform, at least to Darwin’s eye. This was a problem, because without variation, natural selection would have nothing to work with. Survival would be a matter of pure chance, not fitness. Not knowing how to solve this seeming flaw in his thinking, he wrote his ideas down, but didn’t publish them.
Years later, Darwin wrote a letter to his good friend, the botanist Joseph Hooker, sharing his theory on the origin of species. In response, Hooker pointed out that Darwin had never studied even one species in detail. This would make it difficult for him to get such a radical idea taken seriously by other scientists.
Hooker had a point. It may come as a surprise to some readers, but Darwin was an amateur scientist – a very serious, well-traveled, and accomplished amateur, to be sure – but he had never earned a degree in the natural sciences. And, as Hooker pointed out, he had never concentrated on one species. Darwin set out to remedy that. He decided to focus his efforts on his old friend, Mr. Arthrobalanus. He would spend a month or so describing the species, just to prove himself to the scientific establishment, and then he could get back to his theory.
To describe this new species, Darwin needed to know how it differed from other, previously described barnacle species. To that end, he began writing to museums, requesting specimens. He soon found out that existing barnacle studies left a lot to be desired. There were so many mistakes, gaps, and redundancies that Darwin realized he was going to have to clean up the mess himself, reclassifying everything, before he could even think about describing “his” barnacle.
He spent the next eight years doing just that. He requested more specimens, filling his study with piles of smelly boxes received from all over the world. He carefully dissected the specimens, studying them under his microscope, and making notes whenever he found something interesting. He worked so hard that his doctors warned him that we was ruining his health. He ignored them. He finally published his results in a series of exhaustive monographs in 1851 and 1854.87
Needless to say, eight years of tireless study made Darwin an expert on barnacles. (To this day, his monographs are still referenced.) And one result of becoming an expert was that he could now see all the subtle variations that his formerly untrained eye had missed. The variations were small, but they were enough for natural selection to work with. Training his eye to see variations in barnacles also made it easier for him to spot similar variations in other organisms. Moreover, by studying barnacles in such detail, Darwin was able to pick up on many of the tricks that evolution uses, such as repurposing an existing organ to serve a new function. There’s no doubt that the lowly barnacle played a great part in the development of Darwin’s ideas.
Well, in the words of the great Britney Spears, “Oops, I did it again”. In doing research for this post, I read somewhere that Darwin had been so impressed with how widespread and successful barnacles were that he suggested our present time should be called the “Age of Barnacles”. I thought, wow, I could work that into a title for my blog post. I eventually settled on “Here in the Age of Barnacles”. Unfortunately, I neglected to make a note of where I read about Darwin’s remark, and, naturally, now I can’t find the source. So, I guess you’ll have to take my word for it.
A Little Something Extra
I’m going to leave you with a link to one of the freakiest videos I’ve ever watched. What happened to this guy was like something out of science fiction. Trigger warning: some of you might find this video disturbing. It does have some beautiful cinematography, though. Click here if your curiosity outweighs your squeamishness.
I love flies. It’s not a popular sentiment. Most people associate flies with filth and disease and, while it’s a bit unfair to lump all flies together, it’s certainly true that many of them live and breed on things we humans find disgusting. And many of them do spread disease. A mosquito is a type of fly and everyone knows how closely associated mosquitos are with human disease. Thanks to the number of people who die of mosquito-borne illnesses every year, many people rank the mosquito as the most dangerous animal on Earth!7071
And then, of course, there are the maggots. Pretty much no one enjoys finding a rotting piece of — anything — infested with maggots. Even I don’t find that terribly appealing.
Nevertheless, I love flies. As a child, I was fascinated by house flies. Their speed and maneuverability enthralled me. I imagined them as intricate, finely-tuned little biological machines. Later in life, when I started taking macro photos of bugs, flies became a favorite subject.
I think the following photo perfectly encapsulates the mixed feelings that flies engender.
Common green bottle flies (Lucilia sericata) Torrey Pines Extension, San Diego 8/14/19
The flies in the photo are common green bottle flies. You have to admit, the colors are beautiful. I could easily imagine someone fashioning green bottle fly ornaments to hang on some entomologist’s Christmas tree. On the other hand, they’re feeding on dog poop… While that’s not immediately obvious from the photo, now that you know it, it probably detracts somewhat from the aesthetic appeal of the image.
Here’s another photo. Although most people assume it’s a bee, it’s actually a hover fly, aka syrphid fly. The adults of many species consume nectar and pollen and they’re very important pollinators. The larvae consume a variety of foodstuffs, depending on the species. (Alas, this does sometimes include decomposing animal matter.)
Hover fly (Eristalis sp.) in a mariposa lilly Sunshine Mountain, San Diego County 6/2/19
So, to sum up, yes, many flies spread disease; yes, many flies live in and/or eat disgusting things; and yes, maggots are gross. On the other hand, as you’ll see if you keep reading, adult flies are often beautiful; many flies are important ecologically and economically; some are super important in research; and all of them are endlessly fascinating.
What Makes a Fly a Fly?
Some insects that have ‘fly’ as part of their common name aren’t really flies. For example, dragonflies are definitely not flies. Not even close. On the other hand, some insects that you probably don’t think of as flies are flies. We’ve already seen one — the mosquito.
True flies are members of the order Diptera. The name comes from the Greek di-, meaning “two”, and pteron, which means “wing”. This is a nod to the fact that most flies have only two wings — one pair, in other words. (The only exceptions are wingless flies, which we’ll meet later.) Most other insects have two pairs of wings, so if it only has one pair, it’s probably a fly.
To be really sure, though, you need to use a powerful hand lens or, better yet, a jewelers loupe, to get a closer look. The ancestors of flies actually had two pairs of wings, but in the fly lineage, the rear pair evolved into small stalks ending in knobs. These are called halteres. All true flies have halteres and they’re always behind the wings. (There’s another group of insects that independently evolved halteres, but they evolved them from the front pair of wings. These insects are much less common than flies, though, so you probably won’t run into them.)
In the following photo, a haltere is circled in red.
Unidentified orthorrhaphan fly (Infraorder Orthorrhapha) Haltere circled in red San Diego County 6/17/19
Here’s a photo of a crane fly. If you look just below the wing, you can see the long, thin stalk and small knob of one of the halteres.
Crane fly (family Tipulidae) San Diego County 5/25/17
Halteres vary greatly in length and in the size of the knob. Their function is the same in all flies, though — they act as balancing organs. In flight, the halteres vibrate rapidly, acting like gyroscopes to stabilize the fly. Quoting from the Wikipedia article about them:77
“Halteres oscillate rapidly along with the wings and operate like vibrating structure gyroscopes:[2] any rotation of the plane of oscillation causes a force on the vibrating halteres by the Coriolis effect. The insect detects this force with sensory organs called campaniform sensilla and chordotonal organs located at the base of the halteres[2] and uses this information to interpret and correct its position in space. Halteres provide rapid feedback to the wing-steering muscles,[3] as well as to the muscles responsible for stabilizing the head.[4]“
In short (and with a bit less science-speak), halteres go a long way towards explaining the incredible flying abilities of many types of fly.
The oldest fly fossils are from the Middle Triassic Period, around 260 million years ago (mya). The dinosaurs also showed up during the Triassic — 243 to 233.23 mya is the current estimate89 — so, throughout most of their history, dinosaurs probably got pestered by flies.
The most “primitive” flies — that is, those that are most similar to the first flies — are those in the suborder Nematocera. The name means “thread-horns”, a reference to their long, thin antennae. Nematoceran flies also tend to have long, slender bodies and legs, and their larvae are mostly aquatic. Some of the major families in this group are mosquitoes, crane flies, gnats, black flies, and midges.90 The order Diptera went through a period of rapid evolutionary change about 220 mya, when lots of new species of Nematocera suddenly appear in the fossil record.
A second major period of change occurred when some species started to evolve chunkier, more robust bodies and shorter antennae. These changes led to the appearance of the suborder Brachycera around 200 to 180 mya. Brachycera means “short-horns”, referring to their short antennae.
A third major period of change occurred around 65 mya when the Brachycerans underwent a burst of speciation.91 Within Brachycera, a new section of flies evolved called the Schizophora. (A section is a taxonomic grouping below the suborder, but above the family.)92
You might be wondering what makes the Schizophora special enough to warrant their own section. Members of this group are unusual in that they form what’s called a puparium. Flies go through three life stages — larval, pupal, and adult. The pupal stage is the stage when the fly completely reorganizes its internal structure to form the adult body. In Schizophorans, when the larva enters the pupal stage, the last larval skin is retained and hardens to form a rigid, protective shell around the pupa. This is the puparium. When the adult fly is ready to emerge, it pumps hemolymph (fly blood) into an inflatable sac called a ptilinum that protrudes from the head, just above the antennae. This sac blows up like a car airbag and splits the puparium along a built-in line of weakness. The hemolymph is then drawn back into the body, deflating the sac and pulling it back into the head.
The point from which the ptilinum exited the head hardens, leaving a distinctive ridge called a ptilinial suture. It’s this suture that gives the group its scientific name. The word ‘Schizophora’ comes from the Greek words for “split” and “bearing” — bearing a split, in other words.93
A final, very important period of species radiation occurred within Schizophora when the subsection Calyptratae evolved. The thing that makes Calypterans special is that they have calypters that cover and protect the halteres. A calypter is a modified lobe on the back of the wing. It’s quite distinct from the rest of the wing, as you can see in the following photos.
An unidentified flesh fly (family Sarcophagidae) Calypters circled in red Santee, San Diego County 5/16/20
A closeup
The calyptrates went on to become the most dominant group of flies today. They include such common flies as house flies, bot flies, and flesh flies.
A More or Less Random Selection of Flies
There is so much to the topic of flies. I mean, so, so much. In the interests of keeping this blog post reasonably short, I’m going to spend the rest of this article discussing a small selection of flies, chosen in many cases because I have good photos of them, but also because they are representative of some of the most important groups in Diptera (or because they’re weird). In no way is this an exhaustive list of even the major families.
We may as well start with a member of the suborder Nematocera — the “primitive” flies. And we may as well start with the most infamous family in the group, Culicidae — the mosquitos. I expect most of you have a pretty good idea what an adult mosquito looks like. Although they vary quite a bit from species to species, they all have the long, thin antennae, long legs, and slender body characteristic of the nematocerans.
Also characteristic of the group, they have aquatic larvae. As familiar as most of us are with mosquitos, it’s entirely possible that you don’t know what a baby mosquito looks like. Let’s remedy that. Here’s a photo of a mosquito larva (Anopheles franciscanus).
Mosquito larva (Anopheles franciscanus) San Diego County 8/4/18
And here’s a nice diagram that shows the various parts. It’s of a different type of mosquito — one in the genus Culex.
Figure 1. The external anatomy of a mosquito larva (Culex restuans) Author: LadyofHats
This work has been released into the public domain by its author, LadyofHats. This applies worldwide. In some countries this may not be legally possible; if so: LadyofHats grants anyone the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.
Notice the siphon on the rear end of the mosquito in Figure 1. Culex mosquitos use their siphons as breathing tubes. The following photo shows how this works.
Mosquitos in the genus Anopheles, like the one in the first photo, don’t have siphons. To breath, they lie horizontally just below the water surface with their tail breaking the surface film.95
The next time you’re around a pool of stagnant water in the summertime, take a close look. There’s a good chance you’ll see some tiny mosquito larvae. They swim with a characteristic whipping motion that’s easy to spot. Click here to view a video of some mosquito larvae swimming about.
Before it can metamorphose into an adult, a mosquito must go through the pupal stage. The following photos show what a typical mosquito pupa looks like. (I think it’s another Anopheles mosquito, although I’m not sure.)
Mosquito pupa San Diego County 9/3/17
Another view
The bizarre structures on the top of the head are respiratory trumpets. They poke these up through the surface film to breathe.96
Another view
I’m not going to go into any detail about mosquitos as disease vectors. That’s a huge topic that I can’t possibly do justice to in a single blog post. Suffice it to say that mosquitos are responsible for spreading some of our deadliest diseases, including malaria, yellow fever, dengue, and many others.
Some people have suggested trying to completely eradicate the species of mosquitos that are responsible for some of these illnesses. While this may be possible, it’s probably not a great idea. Mosquitos are a major player in many ecosystems, serving as food for a wide variety of animals. Some are also pollinators, and the larvae are predators of other insect larvae. Deliberately wiping out an entire species can have devastating and unforeseen consequences. We should tread carefully when considering such extreme measures.
Note that crane flies make up an infraorder, rather than just a family. Frankly, this was news to me. I learned it just now as I was working on this section. Most references say that crane flies make up the family Tipulidae. But, according to bugguide.net,99 that family only includes the large crane flies. Presumably, there are some small (or maybe medium-sized?) crane flies out there that are not in Tipulidae.
In any case, Tipulomorpha is in the suborder Nematocera. The long slender bodies and incredibly long legs make this fairly obvious.
Crane flies are very common in Southern California during certain parts of the year. They’re quite large insects — their legs sometimes spanning over an inch. Crane flies are sometimes called mosquito hawks, because they look like giant mosquitos. Mosquitos are in a different group, though. (See the last section.)
Here’s a couple pics of crane flies that I’ve encountered near where I live. I’m afraid I never got around to identifying the species or even the genus, but I am sure they’re in Tupilidae.
Crane fly (family Tipulidae)
This next photo shows two crane flies getting it on.
Occasionally, the subjects of my photographs come to me. Such was the case with this little fly, which I found crawling on the wall above my bathtub. It’s a drain fly, aka moth fly, sink fly, filter fly, sewer fly, sewer gnat, or owl midge. It gets most of its common names from the fact that its aquatic larvae are commonly found in plumbing drains and sewage systems.
You may have seen these flies in your own bathroom. You probably didn’t get a good look at them, though, since they are very tiny — just a few millimeters long. I was pleasantly surprised when I zoomed in on this one with my camera and found out how cool it looked. I assumed it was a moth until someone on bugguide.net identified it as a fly.
A drain fly. Probably Clogmia albipunctata, but I’m not sure. La Mesa, CA 12/15/18
Drain flies make up the family Psychodidae, which is in the suborder Nematocera. This specimen certainly has the long antennae which are characteristic of that group, although it’s not as slender as some of its relatives. Its larvaeare aquatic, though, as has already been mentioned.
Drain flies are not known to carry any human diseases and are generally considered harmless, although they can be a nuisance. I think the one I found is Clogmia albipunctata — a very common and widely distributed species — but I haven’t been able to confirm that. Sadly, the genus name Clogmia probably doesn’t have anything to do with clogged drains. It’s an easy way to remember it, though. (The species name, Albipunctata, comes from the Latin for ‘white-spotted’.)
One interesting thing I learned while researching this article is that drain flies have the simplest wing venation (pattern of veins) of any fly — just a series of parallel veins with no crossveins. This must be a source of annoyance to entomologists, since wing venation is one of the most important characteristics used to identify insects.
The simple venation of a drain fly’s wing (A microscope image of the same specimen)
A very common plant in the chaparral of Southern California is a woody shrub called broom baccharis (Baccharis sarothroides).102 They often have small, bulbous growths on them called galls, like the ones in the following photo.
Several galls are visible on this twig from a broom baccharis plant. San Diego County 4/5/19
A gall is an abnormal plant growth similar to a benign tumor or wart. Galls can be caused by many things, including viruses, fungi, insect larvae, and mites. In the case of insect larvae, the gall is usually induced by a chemical injected by the larva. The resulting gall serves as both shelter and food source — the developing larva feeds on the tissues of the gall.
Occasionally, I’ll collect a few broom baccharis galls and take them home. After a few days, adult insects emerge. Often, these are very tiny wasps, but sometimes I get tiny flies instead. These are gall midges. One of the galls in the above photo produced the midge shown in the next couple of images.
Gall midge (supertribe lasiopteridi, Nematoceridae) San Diego County 4/5/19
Another view
There’s little question that gall midges (family Cecidomidae), with their long legs and antennae and delicate bodies, are in the suborder Nematocera. Most members of Cecidomidae produce galls.
Gall midges are often preyed on by parasitoid wasps. A female wasp will penetrate the gall with her ovipositor and inject an egg. The wasp larva will feed on the fly larva, eventually killing it. It then pupates inside the gall and emerges as an adult wasp. Parasitoid wasps are very common. I’m not sure, but I think that all the galls I collect from broom baccharis are created by gall midges. I probably see wasps emerge because most of the galls have been parasitized. (See my earlier post The Story of Stingers for more about parasitoid wasps.)
With soldier flies, we finally venture into the suborder Brachycera. As you can see from the following photos, their bodies are much more robust than that of the typical nematoceran, and their antennae are shorter.
I received this specimen from one of my hiking companions, a young woman named Amber. It’s a black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens). I expect it came from her compost heap, since the larvae are commonly found in those environs.
Black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) San Diego County 9/28/21
When I first saw this insect, I thought it was some kind of wasp, but as you can see in the next photo, it has only one pair of wings and its halteres are clearly visible. It’s probably a wasp mimic — a harmless insect that has evolved to look like a not-so-harmless wasp, so as to discourage predators.
Note the halteres and the single pair of wings.
Another view
I wish I could have gotten some better shots of its eyes — it had some incredible patterns on them — but this was the best I could do.
A closeup
Soldier flies vary greatly in size and habit, and the larvae can be either terrestrial or aquatic, depending on the species.
In the case of the black soldier fly (H. illucens) pictured above, the larvae are obviously terrestrial, since I’ve already mentioned that they’re common in composting heaps. In fact, H. illucens is so good at decomposing that the larvae are used commercially to compost waste or to convert it into animal feed. They’ve even earned their own acronym: BSFL (Black Soldier Fly Larvae).
Black soldier flies are not considered pests and are not known to spread disease. In fact, the larvae have proved beneficial to humans in many ways besides just composting. I won’t go into all those ways here, but you can check out the Human relevance and use section of the Wikipedia article, if you’re interested.
Robber flies, aka assassin flies, are the closest thing to a dragonfly among the true flies, as the adults are formidable predators. Typically, they’re ambush predators, attacking a wide range of prey from tiny bugs to quite large insects. They have a piercing proboscis with which they stab their victim and suck the juices out.
One of the most recognizable characteristics of these flies is their mystax — a dense moustache of bristles on the face. Scientists believe that it may help to protect the fly’s head and face when it has to deal with struggling prey. They can use such protection, since many types of robber fly will prey on stinging wasps, dragonflies, kicking grasshoppers, and even other robber flies.
The robber fly in the following images is in the genus Efferia, whose members are common in arid and semi-arid regions. I photographed this one in Anza Borego State Park in the Sonoran desert. It was feeding on a small bug — possibly some kind of hemipteran.107
Robber fly (Efferia sp.) Anza Borrego State Park, San Diego County 3/31/18
Long-legged flies, as the name implies, usually have long legs. They tend to be small, metallic green flies with large eyes. The following two photos were taken in Virginia on the east coast of the United States.
Long-legged fly (Condylostylus sp.) Emporia, VA 7/3/18
Another view
The males in Dolichopodidae often have unusually large genitalia. Entomologists love this because it helps in identification. (Really, that’s the only reason.)
Hover flies are also called flower flies or syrphid flies. You already saw one example of this family earlier in this article. Here’s a closer look at the same specimen.
Hover fly (Eristalis sp.) in a mariposa lilly Sunshine Mountain, San Diego County 6/2/19
Hover flies include some of the most beautiful flies. They get their common name from their habit of hovering around flowers. Many of them, like the one pictured above, are bee or wasp mimics. Indeed, they’re often mistaken for bees by the general public, who are usually careful to keep their distance, which just goes to show how effective the ruse is.
Here’s another hover fly. This one’s in the genus Chrysotoxum. Notice the tiny haltere. Presumably, hover flies don’t need to be as agile as some other types of flies, so they can get by with smaller halteres. That’s my theory, anyway.
Hover fly (Chrysotoxum sp.) Poser Mountain, San Diego County 10/26/19
Here’s another handsome specimen, although its wings are a bit worse for wear. I saw it in Mission Trails, a large park near where I live.
Hover fly (Allograpta obliqua) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/25/19
A closer view
I saw this next hover fly near Jamul, CA, also not far from where I live.
Margined Calligrapher (Toxomerus marginatus) Proctor Valley Road (betweenChula Vista, CA and Jamul, CA), San Diego County 5/16/20
Another view
And another
And, just for variety, here’s a hover fly with a much darker coloration. This one even has a common name — Mexican cactus fly! Too bad I couldn’t get it to turn around.
Mexican cactus fly (Copestylum mexicanum) Long Valley, Cuyamacha Rancho State Park, San Diego County 9/14/19
Another view
Finally, here’s what is supposedly a hover fly larva, although I have no idea what species or genus. It was identified as a syrphid by someone on bugguide.net.
Unidentified syrphid larva Sweetwater River Trail, San Diego County 8/26/18
Another view
The dark parts at the tip are probably the mouthparts. Compare with the photo of the fruit fly maggot in a later section.
Bee flies, aka humbleflies, make up the family Bombyliidae. In most species, the adults feed on nectar and pollen. To that end, they often have long proboscises. These proboscises don’t curl up like a butterfly’s proboscis. Instead, they extend almost straight out from the head, even in flight. This, together with the bee flies’ tendency to hover, can give them a menacing appearance — as if they might be ready to stab you with that beak. It’s not a stabbing beak, though, and the flies are harmless to humans. In fact, some of them are important pollinators.
The following photo shows a “typical” bee fly. I say typical because they often have a fuzzy body with wide, outstretched wings and, of course, a long proboscis. Apparently, I never got around to identifying this one.
Bee fly Plum Canyon Anza Borrego State Park, San Diego County 7/15/19
Bee flies aren’t all fuzzy, though. And the wings are often held in a swept-back position.
Bee fly (Apolysis sp.) on a yerba mansa flower Hauser Canyon, San Diego County 5/19/18
Another view
The larvae of bee flies are all either predators or parasitoids. They prey on the eggs or larvae of other insects, often beetles, wasps, or solitary bees.
The bee flies in the following photo look like they’re probably the same species as in the previous two photos.
Scuttle flies, aka phorid flies, are tiny, hump-backed flies that resemble fruit flies (which we’ll get to in a bit). They get the name scuttle fly from their habit of scuttling away (running rapidly), rather than flying, when threatened. One of the most common and widely distributed members of the family is Megaselia scalaris. I think the fly in the following photos is M. scalaris, although I haven’t been able to confirm that.
Scuttle fly (probably Megaselia scalaris) La Mesa, San Diego County 1/12/18
Another view
Scuttle flies have a number of claims to fame. For one thing, some of them routinely decapitate ants. A mother fly will inject her eggs into an ant. When the larvae hatch, they make their way to the head, where they feed on the brain and other organs. The ant continues to stumble around while this is happening (in a “mindless stupor”, according to one article). Eventually, the larvae release an enzyme that dissolves the connection between the head and body. They pupate in the severed head from which they eventually emerge as adults.111
There are hundreds of species of scuttle flies that utilize this behavior, each one specializing in its own type of ant. So, if you’re an ant, what can you do to defend yourself against these macabre parasites? One approach is to evolve to be so small that there’s not enough room in your head to house a maggot. In Thailand, for example, there’s the acrobat ant, Crematogaster rogenhoferi, which is just 2 mm long. Of course, the problem with this approach is that there’s nothing to stop the parasites from evolving to be smaller still, and that appears to be exactly what has happened. Enter the world’s smallest fly.
Euryplatea nanaknihali measures just 0.4 mm (0.016 in) — small enough that it could perch on the eye of a house fly. It was discovered by Dr. Brian Brown from the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County. We know very little about this new species, and no one has actually seen it parasitizing an ant. However, it has the typical ovipositor (egg-laying organ) that scuttle flies use to inject their eggs into their victims, and since all its relatives are ant decapitators, it’s likely that it, too, is a decapitator of ants. Plus, its closest relative is an African scuttle fly that also targets acrobat ants. Finally, Dr. Brown has found that there’s a linear relationship between the size of scuttle flies and the ants they target. Based on that relationship, E.nanaknihali should target an ant that’s 2 mm long, and the only ant around of that size is the acrobat ant.
E. nanaknihali is named after Nanak Nihal Weiss, a young boy who loves insects and often visits the museum where Dr. Brown works.112
Author’s note: Although most of the articles I found listed E. nanaknihali as the smallest fly, apparently a second contender for that record has been discovered — Megapropodiphora arnoldi. It’s also a phorid fly and may be very slightly smaller than E. nanknihali.113
Well. Ant-decapitating flies. I guess that’s about as weird as it gets, right? Oh, you poor, sweet child. One group of scuttle flies are called coffin flies, because some species are able to get inside fully-interred coffins. The adult flies are adept at digging — the adults of one species, Conicera tibialis, have been timed burrowing to a depth of about 50 cm (20 inches) in four days — and they’re tiny enough that they can squeeze their way into the very tiny gaps under the lid of a coffin. Once inside, they lay their eggs, and the developing larvae feed on the occupant. These flies can live for a year or more inside buried coffins, producing numerous generations before the body becomes too decomposed to support them.114
Some species of coffin flies have wings, but many are wingless. (Not much point in having wings if you’re just going to tear them up digging around underground.)115
Never heard of vinegar flies? How about fruit flies? Yes, there’s a good chance you’re all too familiar with those little buggers. If you’ve ever left banana peels in the trash for too long, you’ve almost certainly made their acquaintance. These tiny flies are in the family Drosophilidae, which is supposed to be the vinegar fly family. Most everybody calls them fruit flies, though, which is what I’m going to do.
As annoying as fruit flies can be to the average homemaker, they are incredibly important to scientists. Many species of fruit fly have become model organisms — organisms that are widely used in scientific research. (See my earlier post, A Model Mouse, for more about what makes a good model organism.) One species in particular, Drosophila melanogaster, has become the poster child for model organisms. It’s especially important in the field of genetics. Much of what we know about genetics today we owe to this tiny, unassuming fly.
I found the following two shots of D. melanogaster on Wikimedia Commons. The beautiful, bright red eyes are characteristic of this fly, but you’ll never see them unless you have a way to zoom in close — this is a very small fly. Females are only about 2.5 mm (0.10 in) long and males are even smaller.
Here’s one more pic. This one I took myself. It shows an adult fruit fly and a fruit fly maggot. They’re stuck in the moisture on the side of a glass jar. (Well, the adult’s stuck. The maggot’s probably doing okay.) The dark parts at one end of the maggot are its mouth parts.
Fruit fly adult and maggot (probably Drosophila sp.) San Diego County 7/2/21
With fruit flies, we’ve entered the realm of the Schizophora. So, when a newly-minted adult fruit fly is ready to exit its pupal sac, it uses that weird biological airbag, the ptilinum, to burst open the puparium and make its escape. (If you have no idea what I’m talking about, you obviously skipped the section “A Brief History of Flies”. Shame on you.)
‘Acalyptrate’ means ‘without calypters’. So, flies in this subsection don’t belong in the subsection Calyptratae, which, I suppose, explains why they’re not in there. Anyway, I’m just including them here because I have some pretty good photos of one.
Acalyptrate fly (Minettia flaveola, family Lauxaniidae) La Mesa, San Diego County 5/14/20
The botfly family, Oestridae, is in the subsection Calyptratae of the section Schizophora. So we’ve moved up another rung in the ladder of fly evolution. The botflies’ claim to fame is that their larvae are internal parasites of mammals. Some species grow within the gut; others grow in the flesh.
Dermatobia hominis is the only species of botfly that is known to routinely parasitize humans. This fly has evolved a remarkable way of infecting its hosts without having to come into direct contact. The mother botfly catches a female mosquito or other biting fly and glues an egg to it. When the mosquito (let’s just assume it’s a mosquito) lands on a potential host, the heat from the host’s skin stimulates the egg to hatch. The botfly larva drops or climbs down onto the skin. It then gains access to the host’s insides by squeezing into the hole left by the feeding mosquito!116
Apparently, among entomologists and even other biologists, there is some prestige associated with getting infected with a botfly larva and raising it to term. The larva develops under the skin until it’s ready to pupate, at which point it exits the skin, drops to the ground (or into the excited entomologist’s hand), and forms a pupa. The adult fly emerges around five weeks later.
One such account is related in the book “Super Fly” by Jonathan Balcombe. Rob Voss, a curator of mammals at the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH), was hiking in French Guiana. The day was hot, so he took off his shirt. A couple of mosquitoes, each bearing a botfly egg, must have alighted on Rob’s back and proceeded to feed. The botfly eggs hatched and the larvae took up residence under the man’s skin. When he became aware of the growing larvae, Rob visited a doctor, who identified them as botflies and removed one of them. Rob refused to let the doctor remove the other one, and (with the consent of his wife) allowed it to continue to develop. Apparently, the larva didn’t cause much discomfort. Maybe they secrete some kind of anesthetizing chemical, so that the host doesn’t feel them munching away on their flesh. Anyway, I won’t go into the full story. You can read more about it here, or, better yet, read the book. Suffice it to say that the fly was raised to adulthood and now resides in the AMNH’s entomology collection.117
We already met one botfly, the common green bottle fly (Lucilia sericata), earlier in the article. Here’s another photo. This particular botfly lays its eggs on carrion, rather than on a live host.118
Common green bottle fly (Lucilia sericata) Torrey Pines Extension, San Diego 8/14/19
On a personal note, I think I may have had an encounter with botfly larvae myself. I used to do some squirrel hunting when I was a teenager. (Yes, I know — barbaric — but it was a different time.) I once killed a squirrel that was infested with two or three large grubs. My guess is they were botflies, although I didn’t know it at the time. It was really gross. I mean, the grubs were huge, and squirrels are not large animals. I probably did the poor thing a favor by shooting it.
Bat flies are almost exclusively obligate blood-suckers of bats.122 (I say ‘almost’ because there is one known exception, which we’ll get to in a minute.) These strange flies are flattened and spider-like. Their eyes are either lacking or greatly reduced, and they have no wings. Oddly, they do still have halteres.123 I would guess that these halteres are not of much use. On the other hand, why would they retain them if they aren’t using them in some way? Maybe they can use still use them as balancing organs, somehow. Or maybe they’re useless, but there just hasn’t been sufficient selection pressure for them to lose them.
Bat flies rarely leave the bodies of their hosts, so, unsurprisingly, I don’t have any photos of my own to show you. Here’s a nice drawing from Wikimedia Commons, though.
And now for that exception I mentioned. Mystacinobia zelandica is a species of bat fly that lives only in New Zealand. Unlike other members of its family, it doesn’t drink blood. Instead, it feeds off the guano (droppings) of bats. This means that M. zelandica is not a parasite. In fact, it actually benefits the bats by cleaning up after them.
M. zelandica is remarkable in at least one other way. Guano is very sticky, and the flies are not able to thoroughly groom themselves. So, they hang around in small groups and groom each other. M. zelandica is the closest thing that scientists have found to a social fly!124
In Closing
So that’s a brief look at the order Diptera, the flies. It might not have seemed all that brief, but, believe me, I barely scratched the surface of the subject. Heck, I didn’t even get around to mentioning maggot therapy!
And then, there’s the traditional Sardinian cheese called casu marzu, which contains live maggots. The maggots are called cheese skippers because, when startled, they can jump up to 15 cm (6 inches). If you eat this cheese, you can either pick out the maggots or consume them — your choice. I should warn you, though, there has been at least one reported case of a maggot surviving ingestion and pupating in the diner’s body. The adult fly came out with the poop.
On that happy note, I’ll end this post. I hope you’ve enjoyed learning about these fascinating insects.
In one of my earlier posts, I covered woodlice — a group of crustaceans with a remarkable number of delightfully whacky common names. (See Cheesy Bobs.) In this article, we’ll take a look at another group of crustaceans with some very odd names — the amphipods.
Amphipods are closely related to woodlice. And like woodlice, they’re numerous, widespread, and largely ignored. If you spend a lot of time at the beach, you might know them as sand fleas or sand hoppers; if you’re an angler, you might use them as bait and know them as scuds, sideswimmers, or freshwater shrimp (they’re not shrimp); or, if you have an aquarium, you might know them as scuds and use them as fish food.96 Otherwise, there’s a good chance you don’t know them at all.
While woodlice are isopods, amphipods are… well, amphipods — members of the order Amphipoda. Like the isopods, they’re a diverse group, having more than 9,950 described species as of 2016. Many of them are marine organisms, but a large number live in freshwater, and a few have even adapted to life on land.123
My First Encounter with an Amphipod
The first time I saw an amphipod, I had no clue what it was. I was examining some mud at the edge of a stream and saw this ‘thing’ that looked a like a really tiny shrimp. I was pretty sure it wasn’t a shrimp, though. For one thing, it wasn’t in the water.125 It was also hopping around a lot (which shrimp don’t typically do). I took some photos and posted them on bugguide.net, hoping that someone would identify it. I wasn’t disappointed.126 It was, I was given to know, an amphipod — something I’d never heard of before.
A freshwater amphipod (possibly Hyalella sp.) San Diego County. 8/19/17
Another view
A closeup showing one of the relatively simple compound eyes
Figure 1 shows the body plan of an amphipod. If you read my previous posts about crayfish and woodlice, some of this anatomy might look familiar. That’s not surprising, given that they’re all crustaceans. They’re also all members of the largest class of crustaceans, the Malacostraca. Members of Malacostraca have bodies divided into head, thorax, and abdomen.128 Usually, the body is further divided into about 20 segments, but in amphipods, there are only 13. (Woodlice may have as few as 11.) 129130 Note that amphipods lack a carapace — that hard covering or shell that protects the thorax of most crustaceans.131
Within Malacostraca, amphipods and woodlice (but not crayfish) are included in the superorder Peracarida. The main characteristic of this group is the brood pouch or marsupium in females. The marsupium is an egg chamber formed by appendages called oostegites, which are attached to the first segments of the front pair of legs. The eggs are laid directly into the brood pouch. After hatching, the young remain in the pouch for several molts. When they finally emerge, they look like miniature adults and are called mancae.132133
The brood pouches of woodlice, by the way, are probably one of the things that enabled them to adapt to a life out of the water. The marsupium is able to hold enough water to keep the eggs and newborns alive until they develop the book lungs that will enable them to extract oxygen from just a film of water. As long as they can keep their book lungs wet, woodlice can adapt to just about any terrestrial environment.134135 Some amphipods seem to be following in the footsteps of the woodlice and using their marsupia to help them adapt to a terrestrial life.
In both amphipods and crayfish, the legs attached to the thorax are called pereiopods (or periopods). ‘Swimming legs’ called pleopods are attached to their abdomens, and flattened appendages called uropods are located at the tail end. In crayfish and shrimp, the uropods (one pair in crayfish and two in shrimp) fan out into wide tail flippers, which the animals can use to rapidly propel themselves backward. Amphipods have three pairs of uropods. They don’t fan out into a wide tail like they do on crayfish and shrimp, and they don’t use them to propel themselves backwards. However, many amphipods do use their tails to jump, so I suppose the uropods probably help with that.136 Notice that in a couple of the photos the amphipod has its tail curled under its abdomen, ready to flip down, propelling the animal up and away.
The pereiopods of amphipods are uniramous — that is, they aren’t branched. Compare this with crayfish, whose legs are all biramous (two branches). You can read my blog post on crayfish to learn more about biramous appendages.
One characteristic of amphipods that make them easy to recognize is that their bodies are flattened laterally. That is, they’re deeper from top to bottom than they are wide. This may have originally been an adaptation for swimming between dense vertical fronds of aquatic vegetation, such as kelp. (At least, I remember reading that somewhere. I really need to take better notes.) Most species usually swim with their bodies oriented on their sides — hence the name sideswimmers. I’m guessing they do this because of that odd lateral compression of their bodies. It seems like that would just naturally tend to make them tip over while swimming.
Some amphipods are blind, but most have large, flat compound eyes. Unlike crayfish and shrimp, the eyes are not on stalks.
For those of you who would like to get a bit more into the weeds, here’s a quick overview of the phylogeny of the class Malacostraca. Phylogeny, simply put, is “the evolutionary history of a kind of organism”.138 A phylogenetic tree is a branching diagram that shows that history.139
The one thing that scientists are pretty sure about regarding the group Malacostraca is that it’s monophyletic. This means that the group is composed of the common ancestor of the group and all its descendants. It’s a natural grouping, in other words.140 Beyond that, the relationships between the various members are not well-established. Before molecular genetics, phylogenetic trees were constructed using morphology or sometimes the biochemical characteristics of the different organisms, with the assumption that the more similar the organisms, the more closely related they must be. This, however, doesn’t take into account convergent evolution, which can lead to similarities even between organisms that are not at all closely related. Today, we can use genetic data, together with bioinformatics141, to determine genetic relationships. Even these techniques are not foolproof, though. Plus, they’re expensive, so not as many such studies have been done as we would like. Long story short, we still don’t know exactly how amphipods, crayfish, woodlice, and other malacostracans are related.
Figure 2 shows a number of phylogenetic trees that have been proposed for the group over the years. The first three were constructed using morphological data. The last three are based on molecular data, so I would tend to have more confidence in those, but, obviously, more studies need to be done.
Figure 2. Some possible phylogenetic trees for Malacostraca Author: Squidonius (talk) From the Wiki Commons page: “I, the copyright holder of this work, hereby release it into the public domain. This applies worldwide. If this is not legally possible: I grant any entity the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.“
A Bit of Microscopy
Recently, I bought a cheap USB microscope that attaches to my smart phone. (I’ve had several of these. They tend to break easily, but they’re good while they last.) I mainly bought it so that I could show my grandnephew some of the things you can see with a microscope.
The first thing I did was to collect some water, along with some bottom sediment, from the local river. The water contained a number of different organisms that were visible to the naked eye, including flat worms or planaria (which are awesome!), snails, and some kind of long thin worm. The snails laid eggs on the sides of the jar, which were pretty cool to look at, too. But the most numerous organisms, by far, were the amphipods. The water was full of them. We managed to catch a few with an eyedropper, so we were able to get a closer look. Here’s a video of one trapped in a drop of water. (The green oval is the petal of a duckweed plant.)
Here’s another video taken through the glass of the jar. A snail was gliding along the side, scraping it with it’s mouth, probably for algae. An amphipod decided to hitch a ride.
If you’d like to buy a microscope for a kid…
A lot of toy and hobby stores sell cheap, plastic microscopes for children. Don’t waste your money. These types of microscopes are hard to use, and you can’t see much with them. They won’t hold your child’s interest (or yours) for very long. A USB microscope is a much better investment. A lot of companies sell them. Make sure you get one that goes up to a magnification of 1000x. If the magnification is less than that, it can still be okay, but why skimp? The difference in price isn’t that much.
Click here to see the microscope that I bought on Amazon. You’ll probably also need a USB-C to USB adapter cable. Click here for a link for one of those. (I don’t have any affiliation with Amazon or with whatever company sells these products — they’re just the ones I purchased most recently. I’ve owned a couple of USB microscopes from another company and they worked just as well.)
You’ll need to download a free app on your phone. I would suggest CameraFi2. (I tried one other app, but it did something funky with the colors.)
My grandnephew is currently about four and a half years old. That’s probably around the minimum age for this kind of thing — his attention span is short, but not too short. By the way, don’t try to push your kid to be more interested. You can gently encourage their interest — “Hey, look at this! This is cool! — but young kids have short attention spans, and they want to explore things in their own way. You may be convinced that they would have more fun if they listened to you and followed your directions, but they don’t see it that way.
Here’s a photo of my USB microscope attached to my smartphone.
USB microscope attached to a smartphone
So what can you look at with your new microscope? Bugs are always a good choice. Of course, they tend to move around a lot if they’re alive, and maybe you just don’t have any handy. Another good choice is fabric. Focus the microscope on the sleeve of a shirt or on your pants leg (blue jeans are especially interesting). You’ll get a nice closeup view of the weave. Your kid should be impressed.
You can look at feathers. You can look at the hairs on your head or the fur on your cat. My nephew’s beard hair contained a lot of really thick black hairs that were very cool to see. You can look at the ridges on the tips of your fingers that form your fingerprints. You can look at leaves and flowers. You can… well, you get the idea.
The app allows you to take photos and videos. If you upload a good video to YouTube, be sure to post a link in the comments.
And now, back to scuds…
The Vast Variety of Amphipods
Amphipods, as we’ve seen, inhabit a wide variety of environments. Unsurprisingly, they have an equally wide variety of lifestyles. When it comes to feeding, there are herbivores, carnivores, omnivores, detritivores, and parasites. The family with the most species is Grammaridae, the members of which are called gammarids.142 The gammarids appear to be the most primitive of the amphipods, with other families showing more specialization in form, behavior, and ecological relationships.143 I think all the amphipods I’ve seen in my area have been gammarids.
While I haven’t encountered a lot of different kinds of amphipods in my own journeys, Wiki Commons has been a good source of public-domain photos of some of the more interesting species out there.
These beautiful amphipods go by the scientific nameIphimedia gibba. They are marine amphipods found only off the coast of South Africa. Hunchback amphipods are very small — at most 5 mm (0.20 in) long. As the name suggests, the body is hunched, which causes the head to face down.
Hunchback amphipods (Iphimedia gibba) surrounded by ornate amphipods (Cyproidea ornata) on a bright red sponge. Cape Peninsula, South Africa. Taken in 20 meters of water Author: seascapeza This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 3.0 Unported license.
The amphipod pictured below, Epimeria pandora, is in the family Epimeriidae. Members of this family are found in cold oceans all over the world. In fact, this particular species was found close to Antarctica. Epimeriids tend to be large amphipods. Their head-and-body length ranges from 0.8 to 8 cm (0.3–3.1 in). (Over three inches! That’s a big amphipod. Even 0.3 inches is pretty huge compared to the ones I see in my area.)
Epimeria pandora Bransfield Strait (near Antarctica) Author: d’Udekem d’Acoz, C., Verheye, M.L. 2017. Epimeria of the Southern Ocean with notes on their relatives (Crustacea, Amphipoda, Eusiroidea). European Journal of Taxonomy. 359: 1-553. DOI: 10.5852/ejt.2017.359 This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 3.0 Unported license.
They come in a variety of colors and some have striking patterns. Some, like the one pictured, have spines along their back and sides. These may help protect them against being eaten by fish, or they could serve as a form of camouflage, breaking up their outline.
Most epimeriids are predators or scavengers. They feed on various small, bottom-dwelling invertebrates. One species, Epimeria parasitica, may be parasitic on sea cucumbers.146
Lawn shrimp (a.k.a, landhoppers) are not really shrimp, of course. They are amphipods in the family Talitridae. Unlike other amphipods, which don’t do well out of water, lawn shrimp are able to survive for long periods on land, and some species in the Southern Hemisphere are entirely terrestrial. That, by the way, is not to say that they’re only found there. Some of those south-of-the-equator species have been introduced here in California, where they can be found in urban and agricultural environments. In Golden Gate Park and other parks in San Francisco, for example, an Australian lawn shrimp, Arcitalitrus sylvaticus, is found in large numbers in the leaf litter of Eucalyptus and other trees.148
Most members of Talitridae are only semi-terrestrial, though. They inhabit damp sand beaches, where they feed on seaweed that has been tossed onto the beach by the tide. For this reason, they are often called beachhoppers.
Talitridae sp. I think this might be a fully terrestrial amphipod because 1) it doesn’t appear to be in water and 2) it was in New Zealand, which is in the Southern Hemisphere. The Wiki Commons post doesn’t list the species name, though, so I’m just guessing. North Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand 8/30/2018 Author: Donald Hobern from Copenhagen, Denmark This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 2.0 Generic license.
In case you’re having a hard time believing these bizarre-looking creatures are really amphipods, figure 2 shows a generalized sketch of their anatomy, which you can compare to figure 1, which shows the anatomy of a more typical amphipod. As you can see, they have the same basic parts, arranged in the same basic order; although their abdomens are greatly reduced, while other parts have been stretched, distorted, or lost altogether.
Most of the species in Caprellidae are predators, ambushing their prey in much the same way as a praying mantis. The amphipod will attach itself to a frond, adapting a pose that, together with its protective coloration, makes it resemble another frond. There it will remain, motionless, waiting for something small and delectable to wander by. Often, this will be a small worm or a protozoan, which it snatches up in its gnathopods.
Other caprellids have more varied diets, feeding on detritus, protozoa, diatoms, the larvae of crustacea, or smaller amphipods.
The weirdness of skeleton shrimp is not limited to their appearance — it extends to their mating habits. First, the female can only mate just after she has molted and before her new exoskeleton has hardened. I have no idea why this is or why in the world it would have evolved to be like this. Maybe there are other arthropods that have this trait, but I’ve never heard of any.
Second, in some species, the female will kill the male after mating. She does this by injecting it with venom from a claw on her gnathopod. I assume she does this because he represents an easy meal, helping to ensure her survival and the survival of any offspring that result from their mating. (From an evolutionary point of view, that’s a win-win.)
Whale lice, as you have probably surmised, are not actually lice. They are amphipods in the family Cyamidae, and they’re closely related to skeleton shrimp, which we covered in the last section. Whale lice live their entire lives as external parasites on whales, dolphins, or porpoises.
They attach themselves to places on the host body where they’ll be protected from water currents, including natural body openings and wounds. The lice range in size from 5 to 24 mm (0.2 to 1 inches). Most species parasitize a single species of whale, and almost every species of whale has a whale louse that’s specific to it! Remarkably, when it comes to sperm whales, the relationship is sex-specific. Cyamus catodontis lives only on male sperm whales, and Neocyamus physeteris lives only on females and calves.
In one sense, whale lice live up to their namesake (lice) — on average, a single whale is host to around 7,500 of them. Surprisingly, though, they seem to be commensals. That is, although they are parasites, they don’t do any significant harm to their hosts. They mostly eat the algae that settles on the host’s body. They also usually eat the dead skin as it flakes off. Whale lice often settle in open wounds, and they can cause some minor skin damage, but they don’t usually cause significant illness.
As already mentioned, whale lice spend their entire lives on their host — they have no free-swimming life stage. Given their large numbers on any single whale, you’d think they would be a constant source of irritation. I don’t know for sure that they’re not. But whales and whale lice have been evolving together for a very long time, so I suspect that whales have evolved to ignore them.
The photo is of an amphipod named Hyperia galba in the family Hyperiidae. These amphipods live in the bells of various types of jellyfish. H. galba may or may not be an ectoparasite (a parasite that lives on the outside of the body of its host). Some scientists believe it’s a food parasite, but there’s no direct proof of this. It may seem like common sense that it must be parasitizing the jellyfish in some way, but it’s possible that the jellyfish just provides a good home for it. If nothing else, hitching a ride on a larger organism saves it the trouble of having to swim around on its own. In fact, some scientists maintain that the only truly parasitic amphipods are the whale lice (family Cyamidae) which I covered in the last section.154
But I’m wandering far afield of what I wanted to go in this section. In the section teaser, I mentioned something about bizarre eyes, and, as you can see in the photo, the eyes of H. galba don’t look much like the eyes of the other amphipods we’ve seen up to now. In fact, members of the family Hyperiidae sport a remarkable variety of innovative eyes. To quote Karen Osborn of the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History, “With about 340 known species, hyperiid amphipods have every variation on eye shape that you can imagine and several you would never think of, from no eyes, to eyes that take up nearly half their body, eyes out on long needles, mirrored eyes, to eyes that can see in 360 degrees.”155 The reason this particular family of amphipods have evolved such weird eyes is that they live in the dark depths of the ocean — a place where what little light is available filters down from the surface or is provided by bioluminescence — light produced chemically in the bodies of various organisms. With such little light to work with, they’ve had to get creative, and creative they’ve certainly got! Click here to view the article that I based this section on. You don’t have to read it (although it is very accessible) — just look at some of the wonderful photos of the different hyperiid species.
The article focuses on one particular species, Paraphronima gracilis. This amphipod has 16 retinas in each eye! Its two large compound eyes envelop its head “like a space helmet”, to quote the article. Each eye is divided up into ommatidia (see The Story of Eyes: Part 1). Each ommatidium is topped by a facet that focuses the light. The light travels down a long, thin, fiber optic-like piece of guide tissue that ends at a segment of orange retina.
This isn’t too different from the compound eyes of most crustaceans, except that in all other cases, the retina forms a continuous sheet. Each ommatidium just focuses light one particular spot on the retina. So normally, an organism with two compound eyes would have two retinas — not 32! Scientists know of no other animal with compound eyes that splits up the retina in this way.
So why has P. gracilis evolved such an unusual eye design? It’s not completely understood, but this design seems to help them see better in dim light. Apparently, splitting up the retina in this way allows the eye to collect lots of light without sacrificing resolution — that is, the ability to see details — which is a problem that other light-adapted organisms have. I don’t know for sure how this works, but I would guess that splitting up the retina in this way prevents light falling on one segment of retina from stimulating neighboring sections. That is, it it better isolates the light collected by the individual ommatidia.
P. gracilis feeds on siphonophores, strange relatives of jellyfish that I would love to go in to detail about.156 Alas, this is an article about amphipods, so I’ll leave it to you to google them. Anyway, as it swims, P. gracilis points its eyes upwards, so that any siphonophores swimming above are silhouetted against the down-welling light. A small portion of each eye also points to the side. Scientists believe this allows them to detect the bioluminescence of animals swimming nearby.
Oh, and one other thing. Again, according to Osborne, “…we think they may be able to switch between grouping light signals at depth or at night when there is less light and not grouping signals when in shallower water where there is more light.” Amphipods are so cool!
A number of aquatic amphipods live in silken tubes. According to one paper, “The tube-building corophioid amphipod Crassicorophium bonellii produces from its legs fibrous, adhesive underwater threads that combine barnacle cement biology with aspects of spider silk thread extrusion spinning.”160 I won’t go into any detail here on silk production, since I already discussed it (at great length, of course) in another blog post. (See Silk…) I was surprised to learn about these silk-producing amphipods, though, as I hadn’t come across them when researching that previous article.
Amphipods don’t often attack humans. In fact, it’s almost unheard of — almost. I did come across one bizarre instance of amphipods with a taste for human flesh.
The incident happened in Australia, because… of course it did. As reported in an article in The Guardian in 2017 (you can read the original here), a teenager was soaking his legs in the water at Brighton beach when the creatures “attacked”. The amphipods, a species in the family Lysianassidae, started feeding on the flesh around his ankles, causing a significant amount of bleeding, which the teen didn’t notice until he was walking away from the water. The article I linked to has a rather graphic photo of his bleeding legs. There’s also an interesting video. The kid actually ended up being taken to the hospital, because the bleeding didn’t stop when they wiped away the blood. (I don’t think he was in any real danger. His parents were just being cautious. Or maybe they were a little freaked out.)
Apparently, these amphipods will routinely nip at people in the water, but they don’t normally do any real damage. In this case, the boy kept his legs still for a long time, giving the wee animals a chance to dig in. It also helped that the cold water probably numbed his legs enough to prevent him from feeling their bites.
You may have found the last section on “flesh-eating” amphipods rather disturbing. This section, I’m afraid, is also disturbing, but in a much more serious way.
I wasn’t kidding when I said amphipods are widespread — they’ve been found even in the Mariana Trench — the deepest ocean trench in the world. The maximum confirmed depth of the trench is about 10,984 meters or 6.8 miles. Unconfirmed measurements put it even deeper. I don’t know if any amphipods have been found at those depths, but the species we’re going to discuss here was found at 6,500 meters (over 3.7 miles), which is plenty deep. Its name is Eurythenes plasticus. A female specimen is pictured below.
Eurythenes plasticus — an amphipod found in the Mariana Trench Author: WESTON, J.N.J. et al. 2020. New species of Eurythenes from hadal depths of the Mariana Trench, Pacific Ocean (Crustacea: Amphipoda). Zootaxa 4851(1): 151–162. Source: https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4748.1.9 This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 4.0 International license.
When this species was discovered, one of the specimens collected had plastic particles in its body. Plastic pollution is a very serious problem in our oceans. The plastic that ends up as trash in our landfills never decomposes, but it does break up into finer and finer particles, and many of those particles end up in the ocean, where they are ingested by marine life. Finding such particles in this new species of amphipod serves to highlight the seriousness of the problem. The plastic that our species has produced in such abundance and discarded so carelessly has found its way into the deepest depths of the ocean. There, some of it was ingested by an animal that we didn’t yet even know existed. The species name, plasticus, was chosen to draw attention to this disturbing fact.
“Insects got there first.” That’s a common refrain in articles about the evolution of flight, because insects were the first group of animals to evolve wings. So what does that have to do with amphipods, which are crustaceans — not insects — and definitely do not have wings?
Scientists used to think that insects evolved from myriapods (millipedes and centipedes). This presented a problem because those animals don’t have any structures that could have served as good starting points for the development of wings. So scientists figured that insects must have evolved wings from scratch. Then, in 2010, genetic studies revealed that insects were actually most closely related to crustaceans.
That’s where our amphipods come in. A paper published in 2020165 describes research that compared the genetic instructions that control the development of legs in the amphipod Parhyale hawaiensis to the genetic instructions that control the development of legs in insects, such as the fruit fly Drosophila and the beetle Tribolium. All these organisms share five leg-patterning genes that control the development of the six leg segments farthest from the body wall.166 The researchers discovered this by disabling the genes and noting that the last six segments failed to develop.
Insects only have six segments in their legs, but crustaceans, such as Parhyale, have seven. One of the researchers, Heather Bruce, wondered where this seventh segment went when crustaceans evolved into insects. Bruce started digging into the literature, and she eventually unearthed an old idea from 1893 that the ancestors of insects had re-enforced their body wall by incorporating the part of the leg region closest to it.
It turns out that Parhyale shows evidence that one of its former leg segments was incorporated into its body wall. Insects, however, incorporated two leg segments. If you click here to open an article from “UChicago News” and then scroll down a bit, you’ll see some nice illustrations which compare the leg segments of crustaceans and insects and shows how some of those segments ended up as part of the body wall.
So how does this relate to wings? Bruce kept reading and managed to find another theory developed in the 1980s which suggested that little lobes on a pair of these incorporated segments eventually migrated onto the back where they evolved into the wings. The genes for the musculature for those segments were already there — they just had to be reactivated and adapted to produce flight muscles instead of leg muscles.
The issue probably isn’t settled yet — I’m sure many more studies will follow — but the evidence is mounting that a segment in the leg of crustaceans was first absorbed into the body wall and later extended out of the wall again in another direction and developed into a wing! There are more details from other papers that I could get into, such as how “proto-wings” might have served as thermo-regulators before being adapted for gliding and eventually flight, but I’ll leave it to you to explore the topic further, if you so desire. Happy googling!
Why Amphipods?
It’s always fun to introduce people to an animal they’ve never heard of. The crazy thing about amphipods, though, is that they’re not uncommon. Yes, most of them are pretty small, but they’re not usually microscopic. When I collected that first jar of river water to explore with my grandnephew, it was full of them, and they were very noticeable — as long as you bothered to look.
And that’s the crux of it — most of us just don’t look. We dream of travelling to distant, exotic lands, while never noticing the worlds in our own backyards. That’s one of the reasons I started this blog. I hope that by giving you a close look at various organisms — both common and uncommon — you’ll come to realize just how much there is to explore — right in your own backyard.
Lots of animals and even some plants can sting. In this post, I’m going to limit myself to one specific group of stinging animals — the insects. All stinging insects are in the order Hymenoptera, which includes sawflies, wasps, ants, and bees, so I’ll be further limiting myself to that order. As we’ll see, it won’t be much of a limitation.
A lot of things about stinging insects may surprise you. For starters, they’re all female. That’s right, no male insect can sting. The reason is simple — stingers evolved from ovipositors. And what’s an ovipositor, you ask? Well, consider the word. ‘Ovipositor’ comes from the Latin ōvum (“egg”) and positor (“one who deposits”).155 An ovipositor is a tube through which an insect lays eggs.
A Few Examples
Ovipositors come in all sizes and a surprising variety of shapes. Some are short and fat; some are so long and thin that you wonder how they can possibly work; some are serrated so that their wielders can saw into a leaf or stem and deposit their eggs inside.
Jumping bristletails — One of my favorite examples is the jumping bristletail. These are insects in the order Archaeognatha,160 an ancient group first appearing in the fossil record in the Devonian, well over 358 million years ago.167 They’re called jumping bristletails because when a bristletail is threatened, it snaps its abdomen against the ground, causing the insect to jump up to four inches (10 cm). Modern bristletails have no wings, and none of their ancestors did, either. The group actually predates the evolution of wings in insects.168
A bristletail (order Archaeognatha) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/31/17
The reason bristletails are one of my favorite examples of ovipositing insects is simply that I have some cool videos of them laying eggs. Here’s one of them.
Parasitoids — A parasitoid is a parasite that kills its host. Many, many species of wasp are parasitoids. One example is shown below. It’s a carrot wasp in the genus Gasteruption, family Gasteruptiidae. Wasps in this family are called carrot wasps because the adults often feed on pollen and nectar from plants in the carrot family.
The larvae of carrot wasps prey on other wasps or bees. When an adult female wasp finds a bee or wasp nest, she will tap the cells in the nest with her antennae, trying to detect the presence of a larva by the vibrations. When she finds an occupied cell, she punctures the seal with her ovipositor and deposits an egg. When the egg hatches, the wasp larva eats the food left for the original inhabitant, or the original inhabitant, or both.169170
The photo below shows a wasp in the genus Apocrypta. These are parasitoids of certain species of fig wasps. The larvae of fig wasps develop inside figs. The parasitoid has to drill through the thick outer wall of the fig and root around inside the fruit to find the larva it wants to parasitize. Hence, the absurdly long ovipositor.171
Katydid — The insect in the next couple of photos is a least katydid (Brachyinsara hemiptera)172. This insect’s ovipositor has serrations for sawing. Katydids deposit their eggs in a variety of substrates, depending on the species. Since the one pictured here has serrations on its ovipositor, I would guess that it deposits its eggs inside a leaf or stem. I know this is true of another species of katydid, Scudderia furcata. This katydid curls its abdomen underneath itself and uses its ovipositor to saw into the edge of a leaf between the inner and outer layers and deposits its eggs inside. If you’re having trouble visualizing how this would work, click here to visit a website that has a nice photo of a Scudderia furcata in the process of laying eggs. The leaf in the photo is very thin, which means that the eggs the katydid is inserting must also be very thin. In fact, they’re so thin as to be almost transparent — one more example of a mind-blowing evolutionary adaption.173
Least katydid (Brachyinsara hemiptera) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 11/7/18
A closeup of the ovipositor. Note the tiny serrations on the right edge.
Cricket — The ovipositor of this tropical house cricket (Gryllodes sigillatus) wins the prize for simple elegance and refinement. It looks remarkably like a hypodermic needle.
Tropical house cricket (Gryllodes sigillatus) La Mesa 12/12/20 This was an escapee from a box of crickets that I got from a pet food store, so who knows where it originated.
A closeup
The cricket simply inserts her ovipositor into soft ground and injects an egg. Click here to watch a video of some crickets ovipositing.
Earlier, I described the ovipositor as a tube. This is true enough, however, it’s not a simple, one-piece tube like a straw. It consists of a number of separate parts that come together to form a tube-like structure. Often, when an insect dies, those parts will separate, splaying out behind the body.
The reason ovipositors are not simple tubes can be traced back to their evolutionary origins. Insects (and, ultimately, most other animals, with a few exceptions like sponges and jellyfish) are descended from annelid-like ancestors. Annelids are segmented worms. Some annelids, like earthworms, have no legs, but many annelids have a pair of legs attached to most of their body segments. The photo below shows a fairly typical annelid — a type of polychaete worm.
Bloodworm (Glycera sp.) — a type of annelid North Inlet – Winyah Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve. Author: Unknown Source: http://www.photolib.noaa.gov/htmls/nerr0328.htm This image is in the public domain because it contains materials that originally came from the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, taken or made as part of an employee’s official duties.
Most of the segments in an annelid’s body have the same sets of internal organs and are essentially identical. (Of course, there are some organs, like parts of the digestive tract, that necessarily span multiple segments.) This basic body plan is easily modified by natural selection. Segments can be added or dropped, and legs can be modified to form other types of appendages, such as antennae, mouthparts, and genitalia.
In the case of ovipositors, some of the appendages evolved to work together to form mechanisms for guiding the eggs as they leave the body. Sometimes additional appendages evolved to form a sheath around the ovipositor to protect it when not in use. This sheath will part to expose the ovipositor when the insect is ready to lay eggs.
I was able to find one scientific paper that describes in detail the stingers of a honeybee and a paper wasp. You can click here to access the entire paper. The images in the article (mostly electron microscope images) show the structure of the stingers. In both species, the stinger consists of a wide ‘stylet’ and two ‘lancets’. The lancets ride on two ‘rails’ that run along the stylet. When the insect stings, it moves the lancets rapidly back and forth in opposite directions for a short distance along the rails. This helps the stinger penetrate the substrate. The venom is pumped down the trough formed by the stylet and lancets. In the case of the honeybee, the venom exits the stinger through the space between the ends of the lancets and stylet. In the wasp stinger, the venom exits through an opening in the stinger much nearer the base. (I don’t know why this opening is so far from the tip in the case of the wasp. It seems like this would make it harder for it to inject venom, since it would have to almost completely bury the stinger first. But that’s apparently how they do it.)177
The images in the paper are a bit difficult to interpret. Another paper that it references has some images that are easier to understand. Click here to see one of the photos from it. You can see click here to see an abstract of the paper (and some more photos).
Insects have evolved endless varieties of ovipositors. To mention just one more example, according to Wikipedia, “In some species [of wasps], such as Apocrypta westwoodi, the ovipositor has zinc-hardened drill bits”.178 ‘Endless varieties’ really isn’t much of an exaggeration.
The Rise of Wasps
As we have seen, an ovipositor can be used to inject an egg into a substrate. Often that substrate is the ground, a leaf, or the stem of a plant. But it could also be another insect or even a mammal. Over the course of time, many insects have evolved to be parasitoids, laying their eggs near, on, or inside a host.
Many different kinds of insects, including flies and even some beetles,179 have produced parasitic species, but the undisputed masters of parasitism are the wasps. Most people would be astonished to learn just how many different kinds of wasps there are. And most of them are parasites. Many entomologists believe there are more species of parasitoid wasps — just parasitoid wasps — than there are beetle species. This seems hard to believe, since we see a lot more beetles than we do wasps. The reason for this seeming paradox is that the vast majority of wasps are very tiny, so they don’t get noticed very often. For a long time, scientists believed that beetles (order Coleoptera) were the most diverse of the insects, but as time passed, more and more minute species of wasp were discovered. Eventually, it become clear that for just about every species of beetle there was probably at least one species of wasp that was evolved to parasitize it. In fact, according to entomologist Lynn Kimsey, “…for each beetle species there are probably at least two wasp parasitoids: One [that targets] the eggs and one [that targets] the larvae.”180
Before we get too much further along, I should take a moment to explain just what I mean by ‘wasp’. As mentioned at the beginning of this article, the order Hymenoptera includes sawflies, bees, wasps, and ants. The order is further divided into two groups or clades181 — Symphyta and Apocrita. The members of Symphyta are called sawflies. Their main defining characteristic is the lack of a ‘wasp waist’ — instead, the junction between the thorax and abdomen of a sawfly is thick and relatively inflexible. Apocrita, on the other hand, includes all the members of Hymenoptera that do have wasp waists, namely ants, wasps, and bees. The point of having a wasp waist it that it allows the insect to move its abdomen independently of the rest of its body, which can be useful in all sorts of ways, such finding a vulnerable spot to sting an animal.
Now, you may be wondering why I’m covering all the Hymenoptera here, instead of just focusing on the subset of the Apocrita that make up the wasps. Well, it’s because things aren’t quite that clear cut. ‘Wasp’ is not a scientific term. It’s a popular name that’s used for a lot of different members of Hymenoptera, including some of those in Symphyta. Wood wasps (family Xiphydriidae), for example, are technically sawflies.182 I’m not a professional entomologist, but from my reading, I get the impression that the professionals tend to use the term ‘wasp’ rather flexibly — sometimes using it to refer to anything in Hymenoptera, other times using it in a more conventional sense. Both ants and bees, by the way, evolved from wasps (in the narrower sense of the word), so from a scientific perspective, I suppose they are just special types of wasps.183184
The Bizarre World of Parasitoid Wasps
Let’s take a look at a few more examples of parasitoid wasps.
Darwin or ichneumon wasps185186 — These are wasps in the family Ichneumonidae — one of the most diverse of all animal families. Almost all ichneumon wasps parasitize spiders or the immature stages of holometabolous187 insects. Typically, an ichneumonid wasp will sting a caterpillar, injecting an egg in the process. When the egg hatches, the wasp larva proceeds to dine on the caterpillar’s organs. Apparently, it does this very selectively, however, because the caterpillar continues to go about its development and eventually constructs a chrysalis in which it pupates. The wasp larva also pupates, still inside the caterpillar’s body. Eventually, an adult ichneumonid wasp emerges from the chrysalis. (The caterpillar does not.)
The term ‘ichneumon wasp’ is sometimes used to refer specifically to members of the genus Ichneumon within the Ichneumonidae, so it can cause a bit of confusion. For this reason, some entomologists have suggested that ‘Darwin wasps’ would be a better common name for the group. The reason they picked this name is because of a quote from Charles Darwin in which he expressed the profound horror that the ichneumonid lifestyle engendered in him:
“I cannot persuade myself that a beneficent and omnipotent God would have designedly created the Ichneumonidae with the express intention of their feeding within the living bodies of Caterpillars…”– Charles Darwin in a letter to a friend, 1860
Seems a bit perverse to name a group of insects after a guy who was horrified by them, but he’s not around to argue.
Here’s a couple of photos of a Darwin wasp in the subfamily Pimplinae. Note the very long antennae. This is one of the defining features of the family.
An ichneumonid wasp (subfamily Pimplinae) San Diego County 8/18/19
Another view
Braconid wasps188 — The family Braconidae is the second largest family in the order Hymenoptera. Braconids are mostly internal or external parasitoids of a wide variety of insects — usually beetles, flies, moths, or butterflies.
Here’s some photos of a braconid wasp in the subfamily Braconinae.
A brachonid wasp (subfamily Braconinae) San Diego County 3/31/18
A brachonid wasp (subfamily Braconinae) San Diego County 3/31/18
The next couple of photos show a jaw wasp (subfamily Alysiinae, also in family Brachonidae).189 The wasps in this genus are internal parasitoids of flies, ovipositing either into the fly larva or its egg. Yes, you read that right, some wasps lay their eggs inside the eggs of other insects! Not surprisingly, jaw wasps tend to be very small, usually less than 5 mm long. The wasp in these photos is sitting on a liverwort, so, if you happen to be familiar with liverworts, this should give you some idea just how tiny these wasps are.
Jaw wasp (subfamily Alysiinae) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 2/12/19
Jaw wasp (subfamily Alysiinae) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 2/12/19
Hyperparasitoids — Parasitoids, as we’ve seen, have rather gruesome lifestyles. But parasitoids have their own problems, such as other parasitoids. Believe it or not, quite a few wasps are parasitoids of parasitoids. In other words, they are hyperparasitoids!190
The following photo shows some cocoons of an unidentified braconid wasp. Braconid wasps, as we have seen, are parasitoids. But it wasn’t braconid wasps that came out of these cocoons. Instead, tiny conuran wasps emerged, having devoured the original occupants.
Cocoons of a braconid wasp San Diego County 062817
Conura is a genus in the family Chalcididae. Chalcididae is itself in the superfamily Chalcidoidea. Wasps in this superfamily are called chalcid wasps, and they often have a greatly enlarged hind femora (one of the leg segments), with a row of teeth on the lower margin. You can see this in the next photo, which shows one of the wasps that emerged from the cocoons.191
Most of you are probably familiar with aphids — those tiny, sedentary insects that spend their lives sucking sap from plants. Aphids have many enemies, but some of the most unsettling are the parasitoids. These wasps lay their eggs inside aphids. The larva develops inside and eventually pupates, usually still inside. At this point, the aphid is, mercifully, dead, and its body has been turned into a “mummy”. The body of a mummified aphid is swollen, papery, and brown, tan, or blackish in color, depending on the species of wasp that parasitized it. After the wasp metamorphoses into an adult, it chews its way out of the aphid, leaving a gaping hole in the aphid’s body.192
An aphid mummy San Diego County 5/18/18
An aphid mummy San Diego County 5/18/18
The wasp that parasitized these aphids was probably a braconid, but it wasn’t a braconid that came out. Instead, the parasite was itself parasitized by a wasp of the genus Pachyneuron in the family Pteromalidae.
A hyperparasitoid wasp (genus Pachyneuron, family Pteromalidae) San Diego County 5/18/18
Another view
While we’re on the subject of parasitoids, I should mention what’s probably the weirdest type: adelphoparasitoids. These are tiny parasitic wasps in the family Aphelinidae. The females are parasitoids of whiteflies or scale insects, but the males of some species are hyperparasitoids of the females of their own species and sometimes even of other males!193
Fairyflies or fairy wasps (family Mymaridae) — Fairyflies are some of the most common wasps, but you’ve probably never seen one. They are unbelievably tiny. Most of them are between 0.5 and 1.0 mm (0.020 to 0.039 inches) long. All known fairyflies lay their eggs inside the eggs of other insects, which accounts for their small size. As you can see in the following photo, they have very strange, feathery wings.194
A fairyfly (Mymar sp.) New Zealand Author: S.E. Thorpe License (as per the author): I, the copyright holder of this work, release this work into the public domain. This applies worldwide. In some countries this may not be legally possible; if so: I grant anyone the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.
Included within the fairyflies is the smallest known insect, Dicopomorpha echmepterygis. The males are blind and wingless and are about 40% smaller than the females (so it’s the male that’s the smallest insect). Their body length measures 186 μm, based on eight specimens. This makes them smaller than some species of Paramecium and amoeba. In other words, they are smaller than some single cells! 195
The fairyflies also include the smallest known flying animals. These are wasps in the genus Kikiki. The genus includes a single species, K. huna, which is found in Costa Rica, the Hawaiian Islands, Trinidad and Tobago, Argentina, and India. It’s very likely that they’ve been spread by humans, probably by stowing away on boats. The females range from 158 to 190 μm. Very few males of the species have been studied. The one measurement of a male put it at 235 μm. It’s believed that the females of K. huna represent the smallest that an insect can get and still retain the ability to fly.196197
Hyperhyperparasitoids? — If you’re like me, when you first learned about hyperparasitoids, your natural reaction was “So are there any hyperhyperparasitoids?” — that is, parasitoids of parasitoids of parasitoids? Apparently, the answer is yes. I don’t know if there are any parasitoids that parasitize only hyperparasitoids, but if the larvae of two hyperparasitoids happen to meet up within the body of a parasitoid host (which probably happens more often than you might expect), it’s quite possible that one will end up parasitizing the other.198
So are there any hyperhyperhyperparasitoids? Let’s just not go there.
Back to Stingers
So now we’ve got some insects stabbing their ovipositors into other animals. That seems like a good first step towards a stinger. But a yellowjacket doesn’t sting us in order to deposit an egg under our skin (which would presumably go on to hatch into a larva that would feed off our tissues and bodily fluids before bursting forth, xenomorph-style, from our body as a fully-formed adult.) Instead, it injects venom, whose sole purpose is to send us screaming. This seems like a bit of a leap evolution-wise. How do we get from injecting eggs to injecting venom?
I read one paper that described how a hypothetical enzyme could be transformed into a venom. The paper was focused more on snake venoms, but I think it still applies here. It pointed out that some venoms are related to immune system proteins that attack bodily invaders such as bacteria, and others are related to digestive enzymes. A subject that I’ve mentioned often in my blog posts is gene duplication. This is a common type of mutation in which the section of DNA that codes for a gene gets duplicated. At first, this just means that twice as much of an enzyme or other protein encoded by the gene may get produced. But having an extra copy of a gene means that one of the copies can evolve to perform a different function without the organism losing the ability to produce the original protein. So evolution is free to adapt the extra copy for a different purpose. Another type of mutation can change the signal that tells a gene where to become active. So, in the case of a snake, a mutation may tell a gene to make its protein in the mouth instead of the pancreas.199 In the case of an insect, a digestive enzyme could be redirected to the ovipositor.
So what would happen if such an enzyme were injected into another species? Hard to say. It could do nothing; it could make the target sick or even kill it; it could produce pain with or without actual damage or damage with or without pain. It could even have an effect on the target’s behavior (besides scaring it away or making it sick, I mean). After all, the substances manufactured by insects include hormones and neurotransmitters. In any event, a random foreign chemical injected into an organism will have a much better chance of having a negative effect on that organism than a positive one, especially if the chemical is, for example, a digestive enzyme. So it’s pretty easy to see how evolution could select for venoms that produce pain and/or damage.200
Some parasitoid wasps represent an intermediate step in the evolution from ovipositor to stinger. They use their stinger to inject an egg into the body of a host, but also inject venom along with it. The venom may paralyze the host or prepare it in some other way for consumption by the wasp larva. Eventually, some parasitoids developed a separate opening at the base of the stinger for depositing the egg, freeing up the stinger to became specialized for injecting venom.201
Some Stinging Wasps
In this section, we’ll cover some of the wasps that have full-fledged stingers. One thing you’ll notice when looking at the photos of these wasps is that, in most cases, the stingers are not visible. This is because they’re retractable — they are withdrawn inside the abdomen when not in use.
Umbrella wasp (Polistes dorsalis californicus) — Umbrella wasps are a type of paper wasp, which is a common name referring to any type of wasp that makes its nest out of chewed up wood fiber — paper, in other words.
It’s not surprising that paper wasps can sting. They have a nest to defend, after all. Surprisingly, though, the sting is generally described as only moderately painful.
Umbrella wasps (Polistes dorsalis californicus) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego California 6/27/20
The use of wood pulp in paper making was probably inspired by paper wasps. The first paper was made out of recycled rags of hemp, linen, cotton, or other plant fibers. When Europe suffered a shortage of cotton and linen in the sixteenth century, manufacturers started looking for alternatives. The French naturalist René Antoine Ferchault de Réaumur is credited with introducing the use of wood fiber in 1719. One of Réaumur’s most important works is the Mémoires pour servir à l’histoire des insectes in 6 volumes. My French is not exactly fluent, but I think this means something like “Reports on the History of Insects”. And, again, it was in six volumes! I think it’s safe to say that Réaumur would have been familiar with the way paper wasps make their nests.202
Milde’s tarantula hawk wasp (Pepsis mildei) — If you haven’t read my earlier post on tarantula hawks, The Stuff of Nightmares, please do so. These are some beautiful, fascinating, and gruesome insects. A female tarantula hawk hunts tarantulas. When she locates one, she paralyzes it with a sting and drags the still living tarantula into a burrow. She then lays a single egg on the abdomen of the spider and seals the burrow. When the egg hatches, the wasp larva proceeds to feed off the tarantula, eating the non-vital organs first to keep it alive and fresh for as long as possible.
I’ve had the good fortune to see a tarantula hawk dragging a paralyzed tarantula on two occasions. Here’s a couple of photos from one of those encounters.
Milde’s Tarantula Hawk Wasp (Pepsis mildei) Sweetwater River Trail 9/8/17
Milde’s Tarantula Hawk Wasp (Pepsis mildei) Sweetwater River Trail 9/8/17
And here’s a video of the wasp dragging its prey.
When it comes to stings, tarantula hawks are something special. According to the Schmidt sting pain index (which I’ll be discussing later in the article), the tarantula hawk has the second most painful sting of any insect!203 And we have them right here in Southern California! Fortunately, since they don’t have nests to defend, tarantula hawk wasps will not normally attack humans. In other words, don’t bother them, and they won’t bother you.
Eastern cicada-killer wasp (Sphecius speciosus) — I recently spent a week in Virginia on the east coast of the U.S. As luck would have it, the 17-year periodic cicadas (Magicicada cassinii) were emerging.204 Cicadas are extraordinary insects. There are many different species, but M. cassinii is one of the most remarkable. It spends most of its life as a larva, living underground, where it feeds on the roots of plants. At the end of 17 years, all the cicadas emerge from the ground at the same time205 and molt one last time, metamorphosing into their adult forms.
As if this weren’t incredible enough, once they finish molting, the males all start calling to attract females. They do this by vibrating a couple of membranes on their abdomens, and the sound this makes is difficult to describe. It’s a loud buzzing — really loud. Collectively, the sound can reach 100 decibels. How loud is that, you ask? One website compares it to the sound of an “ambulance siren, inside driver window down”. It can actually cause hearing damage.206
17-year cicada (Magicicada cassinii) Richmond, Virginia 7/27/21
17-year cicadas are large, meaty insects, so naturally, they have a lot of predators. One of those predators is the eastern cicada-killer wasp (Sphecius speciosus). As the name suggests, this wasp specializes in hunting cicadas. Just as a tarantula hawk wasp stings a tarantula to paralyze it and uses it to provision a burrow with food for its offspring, a cicada-killer wasp does the same thing with cicadas. Now, you might be wondering, how can it specialize in cicadas if they only emerge once every 17-years? I wondered this, too, and I haven’t found a definitive answer. My guess is that it hunts more than one type of cicada. (Most species of cicada are not ‘periodic’ — they spend much less time as larvae and emerge at random.) If you know the answer, please share your knowledge in the comments.
Once it stings a cicada, the wasp holds it underneath her as she flies off to a previously prepared nest cell. As already noted, 17-year cicadas are big insects, so the cicada-killer has to be big, too. It’s a large, scary-looking wasp with a wicked-looking stinger. Surprisingly though, its sting is actually quite mild — less painful than that of a honeybee.209
While in Virginia, I was fortunate enough to come across a dead cicada-killer wasp lying next to the path I was walking, so I was able to get some nice closeups.
A dead Eastern cicada-killer wasp (Sphecius speciosus) Maymont Park, Richmond, Virginia 7/25/21
Another view
The stinger
A closeup Notice how the sting protrudes from an opening in the abdomen. I would guess that, in life, it would be kept retracted inside.
Velvet ant (family Mutilidae)210 — Velvet ants are actually wasps. The females are wingless and look a bit like large ants. Female velvet ants are parasitoids, usually of ground-dwelling bees or wasps. Because they have to spend a lot of time crawling around out in the open looking for the nests of their prey, they’ve had to evolve some serious defenses, one of which is an extremely painful sting. The sting of one species, Dasymutilla klugii, is rated three out of four on the Schmidt sting pain index. It also lasts up to 30 minutes.211 Check out my earlier blog post, Cow Killer, for more about velvet ants.
Velvet ant (Dasymutilla sp.) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 9/16/19
Other Stinging Insects
While wasps (in the common, more restrictive, sense of the word) make up the vast majority of stinging insects, there are plenty of others among the ants and bees.
Harvester ants212 — Harvester ant is the common name for any kind of ant that collects seeds. This covers a lot of species and genera, so you might expect their stings to vary a great deal. But the following passage from Wikipedia seems to imply that they all have similar stings: “Harvester ants for their size have a rather potent venom. They inject it to [sic] their victim via sting by biting down and following up with a rapid sting from their abdomen, this causes 4-8 hours of sharp pain with effects similar to neurotoxicity such as piloerection213 and localized sweating around the area of the sting. ” If true, I suppose this is an example of similar lifestyles leading to convergent evolution.
Smooth harvester ants (Messor pergandei) Anza Borrego Desert State Park, San Diego County 3/17/19
Smooth harvester ants (Messor pergandei) attacking a very unlucky caterpillar Anza Borrego Desert State Park, San Diego County 3/17/19
Western or European honeybee (Apis mellifera) — Western honeybees are what most people think of when they think honeybee. They are, of course, highly social insects, and, since they have a hive to defend, one would expect them to have a fairly painful sting, and they do. On the Schmidt sting pain index, they rate a 2, which is moderately painful.214
Although I often got stung by wasps when I was a kid, as far as I can remember, I was never stung by a bee. That all changed on one of my recent hikes. A swarm of honeybees had built a hive inside the hollow of a tree. I used a friend’s phone to take a video of the swarm and was able to get quite close without being stung, resulting in a very nice video. Unfortunately, my friend’s phone malfunctioned shortly after this, and she lost the video. So the next time my hiking took me past the hive, I decided to try to get some more photos and videos.
I’m not sure why, but this time the bees seemed more aggressive. Maybe the first time, they were in the process of constructing the hive and didn’t have any eggs or young to defend, or maybe I was just too close for too long, but in any case, this time they were a lot more upset with me, and I got stung on the neck. Of course, my first thought was “What a great photo opportunity!”
I should explain. Honeybee stingers are barbed, which means that when they embed their stinger in your skin, they usually can’t pull it out again. When they fly away, the stinger is ripped out of their abdomen along with some of their guts. The bee, of course, dies from the injury. This may seem rather counterproductive, but it actually makes perfect sense from the point of view of evolution. The worker bees in a hive are all daughters of the same queen, so they share most of the same genes. As long as the hive survives, most of their genes will get passed down to future generations, regardless of the fate of any individual worker.
When the stinger is ripped out of a honeybee, the venom sac and the muscles connected to it are usually ripped out along with it. The muscles keep pumping for a while, insuring that a full dose of venom is injected into the target! So even if you swat the bee as soon as it starts to sting you, you’re still likely to suffer the full effect of its sting. Honeybees, by the way, are fairly unusual in only being able to sting once. Most stinging insects don’t leave their stingers behind and, thus, are able to sting repeatedly.215216
So, anyway, back to the story. I left the stinger in my neck, venom muscles presumably still pumping away. (It actually didn’t hurt very much, so it wasn’t that much of a sacrifice.) When I got home, I awkwardly managed to take a few pics of the embedded stinger using my bathroom mirror to aim the camera. Here’s a couple of them. A nice photographic touch for an article on insect stings, if I do say so myself!
A honeybee sting embedded in my neck (Apis mellifera) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/4/21
Another view
I didn’t think about it at the time, but I should have gotten one of the other hikers to take a video of it with their phone. Maybe it would have been possible to see the movements of the stinger as the muscles continued to pump venom. I also should have taken some photos of it after I scraped it off my neck. (I don’t know what I was thinking!) Here’s a photo someone else took of a honeybee stinger torn out of the insect’s body.
Finally (because I can’t seem to get enough of these ripped-out stingers), click here to view an amazing scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of a honeybee stinger.
Pseudo-stings
I mentioned at the beginning of the article that no male insects have stingers. That does not, however, prevent some of them from faking it. Many male insects have even evolved structures that look like stings and can be jabbed into an attacker, but that don’t inject venom. It’s an effective ruse. A quick jab from a pseudo-sting is often enough to startle even an experienced entomologist, giving the devious insect a chance to escape.217218
No article about insect stings would be complete without discussing the Schmidt sting pain index. The toxicity of a sting can be determined experimentally, but toxicity is not closely related to pain. In fact, there are plenty of insect stings that are excruciatingly painful, but not at all toxic. Tarantula hawk wasps and velvet ants are two examples. The only way we currently have of finding out how painful an insect’s sting is is for someone to get stung by that insect and tell us. The entomologist Justin O. Schmidt set out to develop a sting pain index based on his personal experiences. The index he came up with rates stings from 0 to 4, with 0 being no pain at all and 4 being the most painful.
Many popular articles about Schmidt’s index suggest that Schmidt developed it by deliberately letting himself be stung. Schmidt himself denies this. His ratings are based on a lifetime of work in the field of entomology, during the course of which he estimates that he has (inadvertently) been stung by the majority of stinging hymenopterans. Whenever he got stung in the course of his work, he would make a note of how painful the sting was and how long the pain lasted. Obviously, the assignment of scores to stings is very subjective. That’s one reason the index only goes from 0 to 4. That way, different stings are only very broadly differentiated. If a species of wasp and a species of bee both have stings rated as 2, it doesn’t mean they’re the same or even very similar — it just means they produce roughly similar levels of pain.
Let’s take a look at some examples of Schmidt’s ratings.
Level 0. No pain in humans.
Level 1. Slight pain. Generally lasts five minutes or less. According to Schmidt, “almost pleasant, a lover just bit your earlobe a little too hard.” Examples of insects with level 1 stings are Western paper wasps, Southern fire ants, and most small bees.
Level 2. Average. Generally lasting between five and ten minutes. The majority of stinging insects have stings at this pain level. Western honeybees, yellowjackets, and bald-faced hornets have level 2 stings. Schmidt describes a yellowjacket sting as “hot and smoky, almost irreverent. Imagine W. C. Fields222 extinguishing a cigar on your tongue.”
Level 3. Significantly more painful than level 2. Lasting anywhere from one minute to half an hour. Klug’s velvet ant and the Maricopa harvester ant have stings in this category. Schmidt describes the latter’s sting as “After eight unrelenting hours of drilling into that ingrown toenail, you find the drill wedged into the toe.”
Level 4. The highest level in the index. A species of tarantula hawk wasp, Pepsis grossa, has a level 4 sting, which Schmidt deems to be “blinding, fierce [and] shockingly electric”. Another insect that gets a level 4 rating is the bullet ant (Paraponera clavata), found in Central and South America. According to Schmidt, this ant has the most painful sting of all insects. He describes it as “pure, intense, brilliant pain…like walking over flaming charcoal with a three-inch nail embedded in your heel.”
Schmidt’s descriptions of the various stings might give you the impression that his pain index isn’t meant to be taken seriously, but he actually did have a serious purpose in developing it. He wanted to collect evidence to either prove or disprove the hypothesis that the evolution of sociality in hymenopterans required the evolution of venoms that were both painful and toxic.
Pain is meant to act as a warning to an organism that it’s in danger of suffering damage — the pain of a burn lets you know that you need to take your hand off the hot plate. But since pain and toxicity aren’t closely related when it comes to stings, a painful sting can signal a danger that isn’t really there. Early hymenopterans were solitary, so just causing pain in an attacker would usually give the insect a chance to escape. Plus, solitary insects don’t provide large predators with much of a reward, so a little pain is usually enough to discourage them.
The evolution of sociality changed the equation. A large number of insects grouped together in a colony, along with their eggs and offspring, is a target much more worthy of predation. If a sting is painful, but causes no real damage, an intelligent predator will quickly realize that the meal is worth a little pain and learn to ignore the stings. So insects, the hypothesis goes, had to develop stings that were toxic, as well as painful. To study this hypothesis, Schmidt needed a way to relate the level of pain to the levels of toxicity and sociality. Thus, the Schmidt sting pain index was born.
Another reason the Schmidt sting pain index has only four levels is that the figures represent an average over different locations on the body. For example, a honeybee sting to the back of the hand may only rate a 1.5, but a sting to the tongue from the same insect might be worthy of a 3. So, when assigning a level, Schmidt tried to estimate the average pain across a number of different body parts.
Michael Smith, a graduate student at Cornell University, decided to collect a bit more data. He proceeded to systematically test the pain levels of honeybee stings inflicted in random order to 25 different locations on his body. For six weeks, he received three test stings and two calibration stings a day until he had accumulated three stings to each location. The stings were rated on a scale from 1 to 10. The body locations chosen included “traditional” locations such as the upper arm, forearm, middle finger, thigh, upper lip, etc. Some of the more “non-traditional” locations included were the nipple, scrotum, and penis.
I would give you his results for all the various locations, but I know the only ones you really care about are the scrotum and penis. Unsurprisingly, both were “right up there near the top”.
Evolution has become something of a unifying theme for these blog posts. It didn’t start out that way. My original plan was just to write short pieces about the subjects of some of my photos. As time passed, however, the articles grew longer and more detailed, and since, as the evolutionary biologist Theodosius Dobzhansky wrote, “Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution”, 178 I inevitably found myself writing more and more about the evolutionary history of my subjects.
Of course, evolutionary history is sometimes hard to come by. The fossilization process favors organisms with hard parts, living in specific kinds of environments. As a result, the fossil record for many organisms is very sparse — sometimes even nonexistent. Fortunately, these days we can infer a lot about evolution from molecular studies. Unfortunately, funding for such studies is limited, so they’ve only been done for a small fraction of taxonomic groups.
For this post, I thought I’d write about a spider. I first considered writing about the western black widow (Latrodectus hesperus). Another possibility I considered was the green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans). Both are visually striking, and I have some very nice photos of both species. There’s also a fair amount of info online about them. The problem was, I couldn’t find much about their evolution.
Then I had an idea… L. hesperus and P. viridans are markedly different, both visually and behaviorally, yet they are both members of the suborder200Araneomorphae, the most widespread and “modern” of living spiders. So I thought, why not write about both in the same article? This would allow me to compare and contrast them, while speculating about the evolutionary forces that led to their remarkably divergent traits.
As I turned the idea over in my head, I thought of the many other spiders I’ve photographed over the years. One of my favorites is the spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera). It, too, is in Araneomorphae, and although it lacks the striking coloration of L. hesperus and P. viridans, it makes up for it by having a body completely covered in spiky bristles. In the right light, this makes for some great photos.
And then there’s the silver argiope (pronounced are-guy-oh-pee) or Argiope argentata, also in Araneomorphae. This large spider has a body that looks like it’s made of polished silver!
So, in the end, I decided I would write a single blog post that covered all four spiders. It’s a bit of an experiment, but we’ll see how it goes.
A female western black widow (Lactrodectus hesperus) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18
You’ve almost certainly heard of black widows. You’ve probably seen more than a few of them. Actually, there are several species that are commonly called black widows. All are members of the genus Latrodectus — the “true” widows. (There are also “false” widows, such as the noble false widow, which is very common in Southern California. It doesn’t look much like the true widows, in my opinion, but I guess most people don’t look all that closely.) Not all widows are black, though. There’s also a brown widow (Latrodectus geometricus), which is found around the world, but probably originated in South America.211 There’s even a red widow (Latrodectus bishopi), which is found in Florida.
There are three species of Latrodectus in North America that are known as black widows. The southeast has the southern black widow, L. mactans. That’s the one I used to see in Virginia, before I moved to the West Coast.224 Then, there’s the northern black widow, L. variolus, which is most common in New Jersey, Delaware, and Maryland.225 Finally, there’s the one that’s native to the western U.S. — the western black widow or L. hesperus.226
A female western black widow (Lactrodectus hesperus) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18
Adult females of L. hesperus are usually shiny black with an hourglass-shaped red mark on the bottom of their abdomen. The hourglass can sometimes be yellow or, very rarely, white. Males are about half the length of the females and are usually tan colored.
Black widow males are rarely seen, as they are much shorter lived than the females. As with humans, the male’s only real purpose in life is to find a female and mate with her. If he’s lucky, he may get to mate several times before he dies. The term “widow”, by the way, is taken from the supposed habit of the female to eat the male after copulation. While this does occur, it probably happens more frequently in captivity than it does in the wild. (It’s harder to make a hasty retreat when you’re doing it in cage). Cannibalism seems to be even less common among western black widows than it is among some other members of the genus.
Latrodectus is in the cobweb family, Theridiidae. Like many cobweb spiders, L. hesperus spins messy, tangled webs. After constructing the top part of the web, the spider constructs “gumlines” running from the web to the substrate beneath. These gumlines are stretched taught, and they’re coated near the bottom with sticky silk. If a bug walks into one of the these lines, the sticky silk clings to it. When the insect struggles to free itself, the gumline breaks free from the substrate and snaps up, propelling the unlucky bug into the tangled web above.
While we’re on the subject of webs, the male black widow has an interesting habit. When he finds a female he wants to mate with, he starts by trashing her web. A male will cut out large sections of a female’s web and bundle them up in his own silk. Why, you ask? Researchers have found that this makes the web less attractive to rival males. Male spiders find females by following the scent of their pheromones. One theory is that when a male cuts up a female’s web, he’s selectively cutting up the parts where the female’s pheromones are the most concentrated. He doesn’t destroy the whole web — that would only cause the female to get to work building a new one. Typically, he’ll destroy about half of it — just enough, presumably, to deter other males, increasing the chances that it will be his sperm the female will use to fertilize her eggs. 227
Black widows enclose their eggs in round, pale, cream colored sacs. The newly hatched spiderlings have totally different colorations from the adults, as you can see in the following photos.
Western black widow spiderling (Latrodectus hesperus) fresh out of the egg sac. Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 10/3/18Another angle
I can’t possibly leave the subject of black widows without discussing their bite. Black widows are probably the most feared spiders in North America because of the supposed danger their venom poses to humans. And, to be fair, black widow venom is reputed to be 15 times stronger than that of the prairie rattlesnake!228 Of course, that’s by volume, and a spider is going to inject a much smaller volume of venom than a rattlesnake (assuming the rattlesnake injects any venom at all, which it often doesn’t. See my earlier blog post: Rattlesnake!) 229
So, how dangerous is their bite? Not all that dangerous, actually. It is painful, and it can cause nausea, muscle aches, and paralysis of the diaphragm, which might make it hard to breathe. Nevertheless, most bite victims suffer no lasting damage. That said, a bite can be fatal to small children, the elderly, or people in poor health.230
Given that very few people actually die from black widow bites, it’s a bit surprising that they have such a bad reputation. Perhaps it’s because that shiny black body with its bright red hourglass just makes them look kind of evil. Then again, maybe it’s because, before indoor plumbing, most black widow bites happened in outhouses.
You see, outhouses tend to smell. And those kinds of smells attracts flies. Spiders eat flies. Probably for this reason, black widows like to hang out under the toilet seats of outdoor privies. And, definitely for this reason, most black widow bites are on penises. To quote from the article where I found this lovely bit of trivia: “A 1944 case study published in the Annals of Surgery noted that, of 24 black widow bite cases reviewed, eleven bites were on the penis, one was on the scrotum, and four were on the buttocks. A full 16 of the 24 victims were bitten while sitting on the toilet.”231
Green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans) with a captured honey bee San Diego County 10/3/17
The green lynx spider is a beautiful spider. Yeah, yeah, I know… No spider is beautiful! They’re horrid, ugly creatures that should be wiped from the face of the earth! So, why are you reading this post again? I suspect you don’t really believe that. More likely, like me, you know how to appreciate a beautiful spider when you see one. And this is one beautiful spider.
A lynx spider, in general, is any member of the family Oxyopidae. Most lynx spiders are ambush hunters. Despite this, they tend to be fast runners and jumpers, and have excellent eyesight. Apparently, their rapid movements and agility reminded someone of a lynx; hence, the common name. Most species, including P. viridans, have large, stiff bristles on their legs, which act as spines, helping them hold on to their prey.
Another view of the green lynx spider from the last photo with its captured honey bee San Diego County 10/3/17
Lynx spiders tend to be drably colored and small to medium in size. Members of the genus Peucetia, however, tend to be larger, and they’re often a vivid green. This helps them blend in with the green shrubbery where they’re usually found.
A male green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/7/21
A closeup of the pedipalps — the two appendages on the front of the head. The complex structures on the ends are the palpal bulbs. The spider loads these organs with sperm and uses them to transfer the sperm to the female’s receptacle during mating.234
A view from above
A view of the distinctive eye pattern of a lynx spider. We’re looking toward the front of the head from a little bit above the body. So the front of the head is on the right in the photo.
Like black widows, P. viridans constructs a roughly globular egg sac. However, the lynx spider’s sac is covered with large protrusions. I don’t know what’s inside the sac that causes the protrusions. When I get a chance, I’ll dissect one and post what I find.
Green lynx spider (Peucetia viridans) with egg sac Los Penasquitos, San Diego County 9/16/17
A green lynx spider tends to flee when approached by a human. Unless, that is, it’s a mother spider guarding its eggs or offspring. In that case, she not only stays put, she may even spit venom into the intruder’s eyes! This behavior was first reported in the 1940s by a WWII soldier who suffered impaired vision and conjunctivitis (pink eye) when a green lynx spider sprayed him. The behavior was confirmed 40 years later by Linda Fink, a researcher who was sprayed on 15 different occasions by mother spiders guarding their egg sacs. (I assume she was wearing eye protection.)235
The green lynx spider very rarely bites humans, and, unlike the black widow, it’s bite is not dangerous to people. (It also doesn’t typically hang out under toilet seats.)
Spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera) Batiquitos Lagoon, San Diego County 10/7/18
Note: I should probably mention that Wikipedia and at least one other website I found described N. crucifera’s range in the U.S. as extending west only as far as Arizona. This appears to be incorrect, as the iNaturalist website shows a large number of observations in California, including the San Diego area, where I live. My own photos of what I believe to be spotted orbweavers have been identified as such, both on iNaturalist and on BugGuide. I’m not an expert on spider identification, though, so if anyone wants to set me straight, feel free to post a comment.
The spotted orbweaver, as the name suggests, builds orb webs. These are flat, vertically-oriented, wheel-shaped webs — the kind you typically think of when you think ‘spider web’. They tend to build them more or less at eye level, so I’ve gotten many a spotted orbweaver web in my face while hiking at night, when they’re most active. The spiders usually build their webs at dusk and take them down before sunrise. The webs are quite large, which contributes to the frequency with which I blunder into them.
In constructing orb webs, N. crucifera is very different from both lynx spiders, which don’t build webs for prey capture, and black widows, which build cobwebs. Another thing to notice when comparing these three spiders is that both black widows and spotted orbweavers have very tiny eyes. The lynx spider, on the other hand, has large eyes — especially the front two — and has excellent vision for a spider.
This makes sense. L. hesperus and N. crucifera both use webs to trap their prey. All they have to do is sit in their webs and wait. When a bug gets caught, the vibrations it sets up in the strands of silk let the spider know exactly where it is. The spider doesn’t really need to see at all when it comes to finding prey.
The lynx spider, however, is a hunter, not a trapper. Granted, it often hunts by ambush, sitting still and waiting for something to wander by, but since it doesn’t use a web, it’s important for it to be able to see what it’s ambushing. Plus, lynx spiders don’t always wait in ambush. Sometimes they actively stalk prey.
Spotted orbweaver (Neoscona crucifera) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 8/10/18Another viewA closeup of the abdomen
The bite of N. crucifera is not dangerous to humans, and the spider is not aggressive. When it does bite, it’s comparable to a bee sting.237
Silver argiope (Argiope argentata) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/26/18
Maybe I shouldn’t have raved quite so much about the green lynx spider. The silver argiope certainly gives it a run for its money in the beauty department. That silvery metallic sheen makes it look a little like a (maybe slightly morbid?) Christmas ornament.
Like N. crucifera, the silver argiope is an orbweaver. Both the spider and the web are large and conspicuous. Unlike the spotted orbweaver, A. argentata is diurnal (active during the day). And, since it tends to build its webs on prickly pear cacti, it don’t have to worry too much about running into them. (And if I did run into one, I’d probably be more focused on the cactus than the web.)
Silver argiope (Argiope argentata) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/26/18
As if its large size and striking coloration weren’t eye-catching enough, the silver argiope builds decorations called stabilimenta into its web. In mature spiders, these stabilimenta take the form of zigzag patterns like the ones visible in the above photo. Often, the spider will build four zigzag patterns and arrange its front and back legs to line up with them. It’s not known if these decorations are for defense or for luring prey. Arguments have been put forth in support of both possibilities. One suggestion is that they make the web more visible to birds, so they’re less likely to fly into them.
Silver argiope (Argiope argentata) Lake Murray, San Diego County 7/22/18
Many other spiders build stabilimenta into their webs (although N. crucifera is not one of them), and the decorations vary in design from species to species. I’ve seen some very impressive ones in photos online. In Southern California, though, I haven’t seen anything that compares to the web decorations of A. argentata.
Spiders make up the order Araneae, which is subdivided into three suborders. As mentioned, all four of the spiders discussed here are in one of those suborders, Araneomorphae. Araneomorphae was the last of the three suborders to evolve. And, since the araneomorphs represent, by far, the most widespread and successful of the spiders, we’re probably justified in thinking of them as the most “modern” spiders.
The araneomorphs have a number of features that tend to give them advantages over other spiders, but probably the most important are their innovations in silk production. Araneomorphs have evolved entirely new forms of silk, which allow them to build webs capable of catching flying insects. This has greatly expanded their ability to find prey. Eventually, one group of araneomorphs developed major ampulate silk or MA silk — the toughest of the silks — and this, together with the development of flagelliform silk and aggregate silk protein glue, has allowed them to create the beautiful orb webs for which they are famous.
Two of the spiders in this article weave orb webs: the spotted orbweaver and the silver argiope. This might lead you to assume that they’re more “evolved” than the western black widow and the green lynx spider. Surprisingly, this is not the case. These latter two spiders likely evolved from orb weavers. In fact, the largest clade243 of araneomorphs — the RTA244 clade — for the most part, don’t use silk to capture prey!
It’s strange to think that after evolving all these sophisticated varieties of silk, so many spiders would then abandon building webs for prey capture, but having a large repertoire of new silks allowed spiders to explore new methods of prey capture that were not possible with the earlier silks. For example, bolas spiders target male moths, which they attract by giving off pheromones that mimic the pheromones of female moths. The spider hangs by a line of MA silk, and dangles another line below it, which ends in a droplet of sticky liquid silk. When the spider detects a moth close by, it swings the droplet at the insect. The liquid silk is able to soak past the dusty coating of scales and stick to the moth’s wings or body, and the spider reels it in. This technique was not possible until the araneomorphs developed the sticky protein glue used in the droplet. It also would not be possible without the strength of MA silk.245
A lynx spider doesn’t use silk at all in prey capture, but it hunts above the ground, in bushes or trees, and it’s likely that it never would have gotten off the ground if it hadn’t evolved from web weaving ancestors.
As far as black widows and other cobweb spiders are concerned, transitioning from an orb web to a cobweb might seem like a step backward, but that’s just our human tendency to think of cobwebs as less advanced because they’re less aesthetically pleasing. In fact, the cobweb has some advantages over orb webs. Perhaps the most important one is that it surrounds the spider, protecting it from predatory wasps. And, as we’ve seen, a cobweb can be supplemented with gumlines to increase its effectiveness at prey capture.
When you look at insects, you find a dizzying variety of forms and lifestyles. Most have wings, but not all. Most have six legs, but some have none. They include predators, herbivores, and detritivores. Spiders, by comparison, are more conservative. All spiders (with the exception of one herbivorous species) are carnivores. All have the same general body plan, although they’ve refined that body plan in countless ways: enlarging, shrinking, and stretching parts, and adding colors, spines, and sensory hairs.
The reason spiders are more conservative when it comes to form and lifestyle can probably be attributed to the essential part that silk production plays in their lives. No insect produces more than one variety of silk. A single spider, on the other hand, may produce half a dozen varieties, which it uses for many different purposes. Tinkering with the composition and use of silk is largely responsible for the great variety of spiders we see today.
Still, silk isn’t the only thing that evolution has tinkered with in spiders. The lynx spider, which is mostly an ambush predator, has evolved to blend in with its environment. The black widow, which has unusually potent venom and doesn’t need to blend in, has taken the exact opposite approach — developing a pitch black coloration with a bright red hourglass mark on its abdomen. These two features act as a warning to would-be predators that they don’t want to mess with it. (It’s not always an effective warning, as some wasps, such as dirt daubers, routinely prey on black widows.)
The reason for the polished silver coloration of the silver argiope is not clear, but it’s known that it reflects UV light. Many flowers reflect UV light to make them stand out to pollinators, so maybe the silver color makes the spider look like a flower to approaching insects.
So, why are some spiders covered in hairs, while others… not so much? First, I should mention that they aren’t technically hairs. Hair is a mammal thing. The bristles on spiders evolved independently of mammal hair. Nevertheless, for convenience, I’ll continue to refer to them as hairs.
So, why are some spiders so hairy? In the case of lynx spiders, the bristles are mostly on the legs, and they’re stiff and sharp — an obvious adaption to the spider’s hunting style. In many other spiders, the hairs are mostly sensory in nature. Some types detect chemicals. Those are used for smelling and tasting. Other are tactile in nature. Some of these provide the spider with a sense of touch. Others are used to detect the movement of air currents, which may alert the spider to approaching predators.
The spotted orbweaver builds its webs more or less out in the open, and it builds them at night. I would speculate that having lots of sensory hairs allows these spiders to keep a lookout for things that might want to eat them, even in the dark. A black widow also builds webs, but it builds them in more enclosed, out of the way places, where it’s less exposed. As a result, the widow has less need for sensory hairs to warn it of predators. The silver argiope also builds its webs out in the open, and it’s diurnal, so you would expect it to have lots of sensory hairs. It does have a lot of hairs on its legs, although it’s body appears to be mostly hairless. Maybe that’s because it needs to keep its body bear in order to use that silver coloration most effectively.
I should emphasize that this is speculation on my part. I haven’t read any articles that explain why some spiders have more hairs than others.
Hopefully, this article has given you some appreciation of the many forces that have shaped spider evolution. If you’d like to learn more, please check out my earlier post on Silk.
…the word resonates. Beyond the look and feel of the fabric, the thought of silk conjures up images of ancient China and silkworms, of the Silk Road and Marco Polo, of beauty and eroticism. The history of silk as a textile is long and fascinating, but in this article, we look at silk, not as a textile, but as a substance — what it is and what makes it special. Commercially, silk thread is harvested from the cocoons of silkworms. But silkworms are not the only animals that produce silk. While the world of commerce may only care about the silk of silkworms, other kinds of silk play a vital role in the lives of many different animals.
You can find a list of some of the animals that produce silk by visiting the Wikipedia entry entitled, appropriately, List of animals that produce silk. The list includes a lot of insects, but also arachnids, crustaceans, and even a mollusk. Some of the animals in the list may surprise you. One that probably won’t is spiders.
All spiders produce silk. In fact, it’s fair to say that silk is central to a spider’s existence. While no insect produces more than one kind of silk, a single spider may produce many different kinds. Spiders are the undisputed masters of silk production and much of this article will be devoted to them.
But I’m getting ahead of myself. Let’s start by answering a very basic question: What is silk?
‘Protein’ is one of those words that most people know and use without giving much thought to what it actually is. Briefly, a protein is a large molecule that is made up of one or more long chains of smaller molecules called amino acids.246 There are around 500 different amino acids, but only about 20 of them occur naturally in proteins.
We all know that proteins are important for our health, but, here again, most people couldn’t tell you why. Well, here’s why… our bodies use them for just about everything! For starters, much of the stuff in our bodies is built from proteins. They are structural elements, in other words. But proteins aren’t just for building things. Most enzymes are proteins. An enzyme is a catalyst — a chemical that can greatly speed up (or make possible) a chemical reaction without being used up itself in the process. Enzymes are central to all sorts of metabolic processes. Proteins can also act as signals, making cell to cell communication possible.
How is it that proteins can serve so many different purposes? It’s because they can take an almost endless variety of forms. As noted, a protein is basically a long chain or chains of amino acids. The various amino acids in the chains are attracted to and repulsed by other atoms and molecules in their surroundings and also by each other. This often causes the protein to “ball up” into some very complicated structure. This structure may be useful as a building block or it may contain some nook or cranny that’s just the perfect size for a smaller molecule to fit into. In the latter case, the protein may be able to function as an enzyme.
While many proteins naturally curl up into balls, they don’t all do it. Some of them form fibers. Some of those fibers can be used to form silk. And that (finally) is what silk is — a natural protein fiber.
Since proteins are so readily available in every living thing, it’s not too surprising that many different kinds of animals have evolved to use proteins for making silk. Many types of insects, in particular, have gone this route. Usually, it’s just the insect larvae that produce silk. The larvae of the domestic silkworm moth (Bombyx mori) is, of course, the best known example.
A silkworm produces raw silk in its salivary glands. The silk is extruded as a liquid which quickly hardens when exposed to air. The silkworm uses its silk to spin a cocoon around itself. Each cocoon is spun from a single thread of silk that, if stretched out, would be anywhere from 300 to around 900 meters long (1,000 to 3,000 feet). When the silkworm metamorphoses into an adult moth, it releases an enzyme (yet another protein!) that eats a hole in the cocoon so that it can escape. Unfortunately, this can cause the thread to break up into shorter individual threads, which seriously reduces the value of the silk. For this reason, silkworms are not usually allowed to go through metamorphosis. Instead, they are killed by boiling the cocoons before the silk is harvested.
Many other moths and butterflies, as well as other insects, spin silk cocoons. Many insects also use silk to construct shelters. The next couple of photos show a nest of fall webworm moth caterpillars (Hyphantria cunea). Presumably, the silk covering, flimsy as it is, serves to discourage small predators, such as parasitic wasps. (In case you’re wondering, the little black balls that have collected at the bottom of the webbing are caterpillar poop.)
Fall webworm moth larvae (Hyphantria cunea) Lewis Ginter Botanical Garden, Richmond, VA 7/1/18
A closer look
While it’s mostly the larvae that produce silk, there are a few examples of adult insects that do so. Webspinners are an entire order of insects, the Embioptera. They are all fairly similar in appearance with long bodies and short legs. Only the males have wings.
A webspinner’s silk glands are located in its “feet”. More accurately, they’re located in the last segment of the insect’s leg, which is called the tarsus (pl. tarsi). This segment is divided into subsegments called tarsomeres and it’s the first tarsomere (the one closest to the body) that contains the silk glands.249 These glands produce multiple strands of silk, which the insects use to construct the long, narrow galleries in which they live.
A male black webspinner (Oligotoma nigra) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/31/18
A male black webspinner (Oligotoma nigra) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/31/18
The swollen leg segment contains the silk gland
Webspinners are thought to be most closely related to walking sticks (order Phasmatodea), aka stick insects — the long, thin body being an obvious similarity.250
A Few Other Silk Producers
While it’s mostly insects and spiders that produce silk, there’s no law that says other animals aren’t allowed to try their hand (or foot or cerci) at it. It’s just that we don’t tend to expect it in other animals.
For instance, who would expect a mollusk to produce silk? And yet, the noble pen shell or fan mussel (Pinna nobilis) does just that. This is a huge Mediterranean clam whose shell can reach lengths of 120 centimeters or 4 feet. The clam attaches itself to the sea bed using long silk filaments called byssus that are secreted by a gland in its foot.
Up until the early 20th century, byssus was harvested to make a valuable fabric called sea silk. The cloth made from these filaments can be woven even finer than the silk from silkworms. It’s also warm and remarkably light.251252
Peramphithoe femorata is an amphipod (a type of crustacean) that lives in the ocean. It constructs a nest-like shelter on a blade of the giant kelp Macrosystis pyrifera. It does this by using silken threads to join together the edges of the blade to form a tube. These threads are excreted by glands on its 3rd and 4th pair of periopods (legs). The amphipod manipulates the threads with its other periopods, actually weaving the silk between the sides of the blade.253
Spider mites are very tiny arthropods in the mite family. They usually live on the undersides of leaves, where they often spin silk webs to protect themselves from predators.254
Diplurans are tiny, insect-like arthropods with two long, tail-like appendages called cerci. One family of Diplura have silk glands in their cerci, but I haven’t been able to find any details about how they use it.255
Pseudoscorpions are tiny arachnids that resemble scorpions, although they are not closely related. They extrude silk from glands in their jaws, using it to weave cocoons, which they use for mating, molting, and sheltering from cold weather.256
Carp, a large freshwater fish native to Europe and Asia, uses a fibroin-like substance to attach their eggs to rocks. (Fibroin is a silk protein that’s found in insect and spider silk.) This is very interesting, as no other vertebrate that I know of has evolved the ability to make silk.257
The Structure of Silk
Silkworm silk is made up mostly of two proteins — sericin and fibroin. It consists of 70 to 80% fibroin and 20 to 30% sericin. The sericin acts as a gum sticking the fibers of fibroin together. Fibroin is what actually gives the silk its structure.258
Spider silk does not contain sericin. It’s composed almost entirely of fibroin. (At least, that’s true of all the spider silks that have been studied so far.) The particular kind of fibroin that spiders produce is given a special name: spidroin.
Fibroin consists mostly of four amino acids: glycine, alanine, tyrosine, and serine. It does contain small amounts of other amino acids, but the various kinds of silks differ mainly in the quantity and arrangement of these four.
Silks also differ in the arrangement of their protein chains. Most types of silk contain lots of tiny, microscopic regions that are highly organized. These regions are made up of “stacked sheets of protein chains that cross-polymerize into sheets. The regular organization of the protein chains suggest the organization of a crystal and hence are called ‘crystalline'”.259 These sheets are called beta sheets — usually written as β-sheets, using the Greek letter for beta. The β-sheets are connected together by loose protein chains that are free to bend and stretch. The β-sheets contribute their strength to the silk, while the loose chains contribute flexibility and stretchiness. Figure 3 illustrates this.
All spiders produce silk. We know this because it’s part of the definition of what makes something a spider. If it doesn’t produce silk, it’s not a spider. Of course, this is a bit disingenuous. If there were things alive today that looked like spiders and didn’t produce silk, then we would probably still call them spiders. There aren’t, so we don’t.
But what about in the distant past? Evidence suggests that silk production evolved separately in insects and spiders. Nevertheless, the chemical structures of both insect and spider silks are very similar. They both contain mostly fibroin. (See the previous section, The Structure of Silk.) This is an example of convergent evolution. The structure of fibroin must represent the easiest, most natural way to make useful threads out of proteins.
Spiders belong to the class Arachnida, which includes such animals as mites, ticks, and scorpions. Arachnids colonized the land at least as far back as the late Silurian, more than 400 million years ago (mya). Land plants in those days were at most only a few centimeters tall (a little over an inch) and, although they had spread some distance from the water by that time, most of the land was still a barren desert. Few, if any, animals had evolved the ability to digest these new plants, so most terrestrial animals would have been either detritivores, eating dead organic matter, or predators, preying on the detritivores and on each other. Many animals probably hid in burrows, both to avoid being eaten and to escape the heat of the sun and its ultraviolet rays. (The plants were too short to offer much shade.)260
Not a lot is known about the very early evolution of spiders. It’s possible that some of their earliest ancestors produced silk — it would have come in handy for lining burrows — but we don’t have any fossil evidence one way or the other. Silk was probably not a requirement for surviving on land, though, because one of the most common fossil arachnids from the late Silurian were the trigonotarbids, and they do not appear to have possessed structures for producing silk. In many other respects, however, Trigonotarbids were similar to spiders.261
Figure 4. A reconstruction of a trigonotarbid Source: Dunlop, Jason A. and Garwood, Russell (2012). “Tomographic reconstruction of the exceptionally preserved trigonotarbid arachnid Eophrynus prestvicii“. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica. DOI:10.4202/app.2012.0032. Authors: Jason A. Dunlop and Russell J. Garwood This file is licensed under the Creative CommonsAttribution 4.0 International license.
In 1980, paleontologists excavating a site in upstate New York discovered the remains of hundreds of arthropods dating back to 380 mya. It took years to examine and prepare all these tiny fossils, but in 1988, a fragment was found that appeared to be a spider spinneret — the device a spider uses to extrude silk. Other fragments appeared to show spider legs. The fossil was named Attercopus fimbriunguis and the paleontologists announced it as the oldest fossil spider ever found.
The scientists were right about Attercopus producing silk, but they were wrong about it being a spider. Years later, in the mid-1990’s, some better preserved fossils of Attercopus were discovered eight kilometers from the first site. These revealed that the spigots this animal used to extrude silk were not located on spinnerets. Instead, they formed a double row on an abdominal plate. This is significant, because it means that Attercopus did not have nearly as much control over its silk as a real spider with real spinnerets. (Real spinnerets are part of the definition of what makes a spider a spider, which is, admittedly, somewhat arbitrary.) It turns out that in the original fossil, one of these abdominal plates had been folded up before being fossilized in such a way that it appeared to be a spinneret with a cluster of spigots on the end. Attercopus also differed from spiders in having a long, thin tail similar to that of a whip-scorpion (another member of Arachnida).
So Attercopus was not technically a spider, but it could have been an ancestor of spiders. In any case, it was certainly a close relative.262263
As already mentioned, the first terrestrial animals were not feeding on living plants. Land plants were a new thing in the world and animals had not evolved the ability to break down their tissues into usable nutrients. Bacteria, though, were another matter. Reproducing much more rapidly than animals and routinely trading genetic material by horizontal gene transfer, bacteria quickly gained the ability to break down and digest dead plants. Animals were able to absorb nutrients from this dead plant material because it was already pre-digested by bacteria.
In taking in rotting plant matter, animals also took in the associated bacteria. Eventually, some animals formed symbiotic relationships with them. One group that formed such relationships was the insects.
Insects evolved on land. They started out as predators and detritivores, but after they gained the ability to digest plant matter, thanks to the microbes in their guts, they were able to start feeding on living plants. The insects would chew up the plant tissue (killing it and thus neutralizing its defenses) and the microbes would take it from there. This meant that insects were no longer limited to burrowing in soil and leaf litter. They could climb up the stalks of plants and chew on the leaves and other parts. Eventually, they would even develop flight — the first living things to do so.264 At the same time, plants were getting taller and more widespread.
The Rise of Spiders
While we don’t know exactly when the first spiders evolved, the earliest fossil of a spider dates to around 290 million years ago. By that time, tall forests covered much of the land and insects had taken to the air. But while insects had already conquered almost every conceivable terrestrial environment, these early spiders were stuck on the ground. We know this because that first fossil spider belonged to a lineage that is still around today.265
In 1849, the entomologist Jørgen Matthias Christian Schiødte was examining some specimens collected from an island off the Malay Peninsula. One of the specimens was of a spider that was very different from any other spider known to science. Instead of having a smooth abdomen, this spider’s abdomen was segmented!
Spiders, and arthropods in general, evolved from a wormlike ancestor with a segmented body. Over millions of years, the various lineages that descended from that distant ancestor have lost, gained, and modified segments in countless ways. They’ve also lost, gained, and modified the legs attached to those segments to form other types of appendages. In most modern spiders, the segments that form the abdomen have become entirely fused so that the abdomen appears smooth, but in the spider that Schiødte examined, the abdomen retained its ancestral segmented condition.
Eventually, scientists found more specimens of this spider and learned more about them. This spider and its close relatives have been assigned to their own suborder called Mesothelae. The 290 million year old fossil mentioned earlier belonged to this suborder. Remarkably, many of the living mesotheles are almost identical to this fossilized specimen. In fact, all mesotheles are very similar to each other.
Since mesotheles have remained almost unchanged in appearance, it’s likely that their behavior has also remained largely unchanged. This is supported by the fact that much about the modern mesotheles seems primitive compared to other types of spiders. That term, “primitive”, should be taken with a grain of salt. Evolution does not inevitably work towards making organisms more advanced. It simply works to make them better adapted to whatever environments they happen to inhabit. For whatever reason, the features that the mesotheles evolved all those hundreds of millions of years ago have served them well enough to keep the lineage alive, at least in parts of Asia. So the mesotheles offer valuable clues to what early spiders were like. In the next few paragraphs, I describe some of what we know about modern mesotheles. It’s likely that their ancestors of 290 million years ago were very similar.
Like some modern spiders, adult Mesotheles have four pairs of spinnerets. But unlike any other modern spider, those spinnerets are located on the bottom of the abdomen near the center, instead of at the rear. This may sound like an awkward place for them, but spinnerets are very dexterous. They act much like fingers probing the substrate, so they work well enough in this position.
Mesotheles live in burrows which they dig themselves by shoveling out soil with their chelicerae and pedipalps (the second pair of appendages after the chelicerae). They press their bodies against the walls as they dig, compacting the soil, and use their spinnerets to line the walls with a thin film of silk. This helps to stabilize the walls. It also makes it easier for the spider to climb around in the burrow. After it finishes digging, the spider uses silk protein to glue soil and debris to the top of the entrance, fashioning a trapdoor.
Mesotheles are mostly nocturnal. When hunting, a mesothele waits just inside the entrance to its den. It keeps the trapdoor open a crack and arranges its legs around the bottom rim of the doorframe. When it detects the vibrations caused by a prey animal outside the door, it bursts out of its burrow and seizes it. Mesotheles have fangs on their chelicerae, but they don’t have venom glands. They have to kill their prey the hard way — by stabbing it with their fangs and crunching it up in their pedipalps. The spider then drags the carcass into its burrow where it can dine at leisure.
The Mesothelae have two different methods of hunting. Some species always keep at least one foot in the door when going after prey, so they have a very limited range. Other species have managed to expand their range a bit by laying down six to eight lines of silk radiating out a few centimeters from the doorframe. When an animal trips over one of these lines, it sets up vibrations that tell the spider exactly which way to go. The spider seizes its prey and follows the silk line back to its burrow.
What we can surmise from all this is that the first spiders were probably nocturnal ground dwellers with a very limited range. They lived in burrows and nabbed small prey that happened to pass close by. The many insects that inhabited vegetation above the ground and flew in the air were mostly out of their reach.266
The First Spider Silk
It’s likely that the first spiders produced a single type of silk from a single type of silk gland, but this situation probably didn’t last long (in evolutionary terms). Some species of living mesotheles have three different silk glands and each gland is divided into three regions, each producing a different kind of silk. Other species have four different glands, each of which may produce multiple types of silk.
Surprisingly, mesotheles do not use all these different silks for different purposes. Unlike most spiders, which have specialized silks for lining burrows, spinning webs, weaving egg sacs, etc., mesotheles seem to use different silks from different glands more or less at random. They may use a single type of silk or a mixture of silks for a task and later use entirely different silks for the same task.
This seems counterintuitive. What’s the point in having so many different kinds of silk if they’re all used for the same purpose? In fact, there are several advantages to this approach. Different types of silk are composed of different types of proteins, which are made up of different combinations of amino acids. Mesotheles get these amino acids from their prey. Exactly which amino acids are available to a spider and in what quantities depends on what kind of prey the spider is able to catch. So, given an abundance of certain kinds of amino acids, it may be better able to produce a certain type of silk. If the spider later begins catching a different type of prey, it may be better able to produce a different kind of silk. Thus, having the ability to produce a variety of silks increases the chances that it will always have enough resources to produce at least some kind of silk.
Being able to produce many different kinds of silk may also come in handy if food is scarce. Maybe some kinds of silk are of lower quality but are cheaper to produce. In that case, a spider that is in danger of starving may switch to the cheaper silk, thus conserving resources.
There is still another advantage to this approach. If the spider has lots of different amino acids available to it, it can produce a larger volume of silk, using some amino acids for one type and other amino acids for different types.267
Invasion of the Tarantulas (and their relatives)
By 240 million years ago, some spiders had begun to move out of their underground burrows and construct shelters aboveground. These innovators make up the infraorder Mygalomorphae, and their most famous members are the tarantulas. (See my earlier post Big, Hairy Tarantulas.) We know that mygalomorphs go back at least 240 million years, because a fossil mygalomorph of that age was found in Vosges, France.268
Spiders didn’t just abandon their burrows overnight, though. Even today, there are plenty of mygalomorphs that live in burrows and construct trapdoors, much like mesotheles.
California trapdoor spider (Bothriocyrtum californicum) San Diego County 10/27/16
Gradually though, the mygalomorphs began to extend their range beyond the ground just outside their dens. Some of them began surrounding their trapdoors with “tabs” — silk mixed with soil and sometimes moss that stretched out from the entrance. The tabs acted like the trip lines of the mesotheles. Prey crawling over them would set off vibrations that brought the spider running. This may not seem like that much of an advance, but tabs have one advantage over trip lines — they can slow prey down. To a bug, walking on a layer of silk may be a bit like you or I walking in thick mud — it’s harder to move around, and this obviously makes the bug easier to catch.
One group of mygalomorphs, the collar-door spiders, have dispensed with trapdoors altogether. Instead, they extend the silk lining of their burrows beyond the entrance and into the air above, forming a short “collar”. They camouflage and rigidify the collar by working soil, litter, and small pebbles into its outer surface. During the day, the spider cinches the collar closed, barring entrance to its den. At night, it opens it back up and waits for prey to wander by. The spider sits with its pedipalps and first two pairs of legs touching the inside of the collar. An insect crawling on the collar or even passing close by on the ground will set up enough vibrations to alert the burrow’s inhabitant. Again, this might seem like a very minor innovation, but research indicates that collar-door spiders do capture more prey on average than trap-door spiders.
Another group of mygalomorphs have gone collar-door spiders one better, building “turrets” that reach 7 to 10 centimeters (3 to 4 inches) above the ground. These are constructed similarly to collars but have more plant material woven onto the outside. This material extends farther into the surrounding area, including the airspace just above the ground. Besides increasing the range at which a spider can sense passing prey, the turret may attract insects whose natural inclination is to climb.
The purse-web spiders continued to expand on the “burrow extension” theme. These spiders, also known as ‘atypical tarantulas’,269 build a silken tube from the burrow entrance either along the ground or against a tree or other vertical support. This tube may be as long as 15 centimeters or 6 inches. In this case, the tube does not even need to be open at the end. When the spider senses a bug on the outside of the tube, it runs to a spot directly beneath the bug and stabs it through the silk with its fangs. The spider then slits the silk with one fang and drags the insect inside. Later it will repair the breach in preparation for its next meal.
Eventually, some mygalomorphs worked up the courage to do away with underground burrows altogether. Funnel-web mygalomorphs build their silken tubes under rocks or in crevices. They flare out the entrance of the tube into a funnel shape, suspending the edges of the funnel from nearby plants or rocks.
Finally, we come to the true tarantulas — those in the family Theraphosidae. Tarantulas are the most diverse group of mygalomorphs and they build a variety of shelters. A few may build no shelter at all. Many tarantulas do live in burrows. They don’t always do their hunting from there, though. Some species will roam around, actively seeking prey. Other types extend the silk lining of their burrow into a wide tab outside the entrance, as discussed earlier. Some tarantulas build silken shelters above ground under rocks, tree bark, plants, and so on. Some even build their shelters in trees.
Megalomorph Silk
So mygalomorphs as a group have expanded their range far beyond the entrance to their burrows (if they even have one). They’ve also extended their range vertically. Does this mean that they’ve specialized their silk production, making use of different kinds of silk for different purposes? Frankly, I’m not sure. I haven’t been able to find a definitive answer. Not much research has been done on megalomorph silk, so it’s possible that no one knows. Like modern mesotheles, they most megalomorphs produce multiple kinds of silk, but do they use them interchangeably? It’s not clear, at least not to me. The next group of spiders definitely does specialize, however.
Tarantulas have silk organs in their feet! To be clear, tarantulas have the usual spinnerets and silk organs in all the regular places, but they are also able to secrete silk from their feet to help them stick to smooth surfaces.
Although tarantulas have long been popular as pets, it was not until 2006 that someone finally noticed that tarantulas were extruding silk from their feet. (Or maybe some people noticed and just didn’t believe there eyes.) In that year, Stanislav Gorb from the Max Planck Institute noticed that Costa Rican zebra tarantulas leave behind silken footprints when they climb a glass plate. Gorb published his findings, but a few years later another researcher disputed them, arguing that the spiders got the silk on their feet by wiping them on their spinnerets.
In 2011, however, Claire Rind from Newcastle University published a paper supporting Gorb’s results. She tested tarantulas by placing them on glass plates and slowly raising the plates to a vertical position. The spiders were able to cling to the glass without falling, and they always left behind tiny threads of silk.
But Rind didn’t stop there. Gathering molted skins from several tarantulas, she examined the feet with an electron microscope. She saw strands of silk emerging from the tips of some of the setae (hairs) on the feet. These setae were noticeably longer than the other setae and each one had a small hole in its tip. One even had a droplet of silk coming out of it!
As bizarre as it sounds, it’s possible that these foot spigots may actually represent the origin of spinnerets in spiders. Arthropods evolved from segmented worms that had a pair of legs on each segment. Many of the seemingly very “unleg-like” appendages of modern arthropods started out as legs that were gradually modified to serve new purposes. It’s highly likely that spinnerets also started out as legs. And if those legs already had silk glands?…
All of this is discussed in more detail in a National Geographic article, Tarantulas climb by shooting silk from their feet. The article includes some fantastic electron microscope photos. I urge you to check them out.
The vast majority of modern spiders are in the infraorder Araneomorphae (also called Arachnomorphae). One important difference between araneomorphs and all other types of spiders can be seen in their chelicerae. To review, the chelicerae are the pair of appendages on the front of the head to which the fangs are attached. In mesotheles and megalomorphs, the fangs point more or less straight down (when unfolded) and they don’t cross each other. The spider has to raise its chelicerae in order to strike down with its fangs.
A view of the fangs of a tarantula from the bottom. To strike, the tarantula raises its chelicerae, unfolding the fangs, and strikes down. Anza Borrego State Park, San Diego County 9/4/17
In araneomorphs, the chelicerae are strikingly (ahem) different. The fangs open and close like pincers.
Another important difference between araneomorphs and other spiders is in the types of silk they produce and how they use them. As I already mentioned, mesotheles produce a variety of silks, but use them interchangeably. I’m not sure whether megalomorphs use different silks for different purposes, but one thing is certain — araneomorphs have come up with some very innovative types of silk and they most definitely use them for different purposes. The most important of the these new types of silk is major ampullate silk.
The success of the araneomorphs is due in no small measure to their invention of major ampullate silk. The name ‘ampullate’ comes from the shape of the gland that produces the silk, which resembles an ampoule — a type of small, sealed glass vial.274 All araneomorphs make major ampullate silk and no mesopheles or mygalomorphs do, so this is one of the defining characteristics of the group.
The thing that makes major ampullate silk special is its toughness. Toughness is not exactly the same as strength. Technically, it’s a combination of tensile strength275 and extensibility. Researchers studying the major ampullate silk of golden orb weavers (genus Nephila), have found that it’s both stronger and tougher than Kevlar. In an earlier section, I explained how silk gets its strength and flexibility from its unique microstructure. In major ampullate silk, spiders seem to have achieved a nearly perfect balance of all the factors that give silk both its strength and its stretchiness.
So what advantages did this new type of silk give the araneomorphs? First and maybe foremost, it gave them the ability to make a controlled descent. That is, they use it as a lifeline. Say you find an araneomorph spider sitting in its web, minding its own business, and you start harassing it. There’s a good chance the spider will attempt to escape your unwanted attentions by dropping from its perch and falling straight down. As it falls, it releases a thread of major ampullate silk behind it to slow its descent. It doesn’t do this to avoid injury — most spiders are small enough that they could jump from the top of a skyscraper without fear of injury — it does this so that it can stop itself from falling if it looks like it’s about end up in a worse situation than it just escaped from. The lifeline also makes it easy for the spider to crawl back up to its web after the danger has passed. Mesotheles and megalomorphs can’t do this because the silk they produce isn’t strong enough to support their weight. And the stretchiness of major ampullate silk means that, if the spider halts its descent by stopping the extrusion of silk, the lifeline will stretch in a way that brings the spider to a gentle stop.
So that’s one thing that spiders use major ampullate silk for. Another thing is for draglines. As they crawl from one place to another, all spiders (even non-araneomorphs) release a trail of silk behind them. Scientists aren’t completely sure why. It’s possible that they started doing this so that they could easily find their way back to their burrow. The silk may also be impregnated with pheromones that provide a trail for potential mates to follow. Araneomorphs use major ampullate silk for their draglines, maybe just because the resulting trail is more durable.
Major ampullate silk is also used for ballooning. If a species is to avoid extinction, it’s important for it to spread itself across as wide a geographical range as possible. That way, if conditions in one area become unfavorable to its survival, the species won’t be in danger of dying off altogether. So a species needs some way of dispersing itself far and wide. Many araneomorphs accomplish this by ballooning.
Some time after hatching and making its way out of the egg sac, a spiderling crawls to a high point in its environment and releases one or more threads of major ampullate silk. The threads (if more than one) fan out, and the spiderling is lifted from its perch. A spiderling may travel a very long distance — even thousands of miles — before touching down.
It’s natural to assume that when a spiderling releases silk threads to go ballooning, it’s the wind that provides the lift. The problem is that spiders have been observed ballooning on days when there was little or no wind, and, in any case, they often appear to be traveling faster than can be accounted for by air currents. This led some scientists to speculate that that they make use of electrostatic fields to lift themselves into the air.
On any given day, there are around 40,000 thunderstorms going on around the world. This creates a global electrical circuit called the atmospheric potential gradient. The surface of the Earth has a negative charge, while the atmosphere is positively charged, becoming more positive the higher you go. This creates a potential difference between the ground and the atmosphere. During a thunderstorm, this potential difference becomes so great that electrons jump from the ground to the clouds (where the positive charges accumulate) in a thick stream popularly known as a lightning bolt. (Yes, a lightning bolt travels from the ground to the cloud, not vice versa.)
A spiderling sitting on the ground or on pretty much anything connected to the ground, will pick up its negative charge. When it releases strands of silk, the silk, being also negatively charged, is repelled by the surface the spiderling is perched on and attracted by the positive charge of the surrounding air. This, so the theory goes, is enough to lift the spider into the air. And since the air tends to get more positive higher up, the spiderling is wafted high up into the atmosphere.
All this was only speculation until recently, when biologists from the University of Bristol put the theory to the test. They built a special box for housing spiderlings. The researchers were able to precisely control the electrical field inside the box. When little or no electrical field was present, the spiderlings didn’t try to take off. When a sufficiently strong field was applied to the box, the spiderlings displayed “tiptoeing” — raising up on their legs, lifting their abdomens, and releasing silk. In some cases, the spiderlings actually became airborne. If the field was turned off, the airborne spiderlings dropped.
Not only does this research support the theory that spiders use the electrical gradient for ballooning, it also shows that spiders can sense the strength of this gradient. They are probably able to do this because the tiny sensory hairs that cover their legs and body are moved by electrostatic forces in the same way that static electricity can lift the hairs on your head.
We’ve covered quite a number of ways spiders use major ampullate silk. Last, but not least, major ampullate silk is used for the outer rim and spokes of orb webs. But more than one kind of silk is used in building orb webs, so, before we get into the details of web construction, let’s get an overview of the different kinds of silk that modern spiders produce.
The Varieties of Araneomorph Silk
A particular kind of spider silk is not identical in every species that makes it. For instance, major ampullate silk differs slightly from species to species. But all major ampullate silks are similar enough chemically to be grouped together into the major ampullate family of silks. And the families are distinct enough in their properties that a spider rarely chooses to substitute one type of silk for another when performing a task. The families are also distinct enough that different types of glands are used to produce them. A silk gland is given the same name as the type of silk it produces. Major ampullate silk is produced by the major ampullate gland, for example.
We discussed major ampullate silk in the last section. We’ll be discussing the other types of silk that araneomorphs produce next. To make things easier, here’s a preview of what’s to come in the form of a cheat sheet:
Dragline Lifeline The outer rim and spokes of a web Ballooning.
Minor ampullate (MiSp1 protein)
Temporary scaffolding while a web is being constructed. Also used in conjunction with major ampullate silk in draglines and lifelines and in web building.
Flagelliform
The capturing lines of the web
Tubuliform
Egg cocoon silk
Aciniform
Wrapping prey Male sperm webs Stabilimenta
Aggregate
A liquid silk that forms sticky globules
Piriform
Used to form bonds between separate threads and for attachment points to objects
As a further learning aid, figure 6 shows an excellent schematic that sums up much of what we’ve discussed so far, what we will be discussing, and a lot of stuff we won’t have time to discuss. I suggest you study it a bit before proceeding.
Minor ampullate silk is stretchable, but non-elastic. In other words, it stretches, but doesn’t bounce back. Major and minor ampulate silk are similar in composition, but major ampulate silk has many more repeating sequences of the amino acid alanine (abbreviated A in figure 6), which is probably what makes it so much stronger.
Minor ampullate glands usually look like small versions of major ampullate glands. It’s likely that the latter evolved from the former in a duplication event. That is, a mutation could have caused a spider to grow two minor ampullate glands. This may have benefited the spider, as it would have allowed it to make more silk. But having two glands performing the same function meant that evolution was free to play around with one of them, eventually leading to the evolution of the major ampullate gland.281.
Araneomorphs sometimes add minor ampullate silk to their draglines (in addition to major ampullate silk), but its main purpose seems to be to serve as a temporary scaffolding when the spider is constructing a web.
And Now for All Those Webs…
When most people think of spider webs, they think of orb webs — those classic, vertically-aligned, two-dimensional structures that have come to symbolize spiders everywhere. But most spiders — even most araneomorphs — don’t make orb webs. In fact, orb webs didn’t come about until quite late in spider evolutionary history. They evolved gradually from intermediate forms and many of those forms are still used by various groups of araneomorphs today. And spider webs didn’t stop evolving when they got to orb webs. You might be forgiven for assuming that orb webs represent the pinnacle of spider web design, but as we’ll see later, you would be wrong.
Lampshade Spiders
Lampshade spiders (family Hypochilidae) are a group of araneomorphs that, as their name suggests, spin webs shaped like lampshades. Looking at the two photos below, it’s easy to see how these webs could have evolved from the funnel webs of megalomorphs. And perhaps it’s not too hard to imagine how they might represent a first step toward orb webs.
So could the earliest araneomorphs been similar to lampshade spiders? There are some features of lampshade spiders that seem to be more similar to megalomorphs than araneomorphs or to be halfway between the two. For instance, Mesotheles and megalomorphs all have two pairs of book lungs. Most araneomorphs have only one. Lampshade spiders, however, have two pairs like the megalomorphs.
Mesotheles and megalomorphs, as noted earlier, have chelicerae that move up and down, so they have to use a downward motion to stab their prey. Araneomorphs, on the other hand, have chelicerae that open and close like tongs, allowing them to grip a prey animal even if there is no substrate supporting it. Lampshade spiders have chelicerae that appear to be intermediate between the two. They move diagonally, starting at the top of a ‘V’ and meeting at the bottom.
Lampshade spiders produce major ampullate silk, so they are definitely araneomorphs, but their two pairs of book lungs and diagonally moving chelicerae suggest that they could be similar to early araneomorphs, which would have retained many of the features of their megalomorph ancestors.
One other feature — or lack of a feature — also suggests that lampshade spiders may be similar to the early araneomorphs. They don’t wrap their prey in silk. Like non-araneomorphs, they just keep stabbing their prey with their fangs until it stops moving.282
Besides major ampullate silk, lampshade spiders produce another innovative type of silk called cribellate silk. This silk is produced by an organ called a cribellum. The cribellum is a modified spinneret that resembles a flattened plate (or two plates in some species). The surface of the plate is packed with thousands of microscopic spigots. Each of the spigots is fed by its own tiny, berry-shaped silk gland.
The silk threads produced by these spigots are unimaginably fine — it would take about a thousand of them bundled together to make a strand as thick as a human hair. As these threads are extruded from the cribellum, the spider combs them with a special set of hairs on its fourth pair of legs called a calamistrum (Latin for ‘curling iron’). The threads combine to form a wooly type of silk that, under magnification, looks like irregular waves of… well, wool.
Bugs tend to be hairy. It’s not true hair (only mammals have that), but they have lots of hair-like structures called setae that act as touch sensors, among other things. When a bug lands on cribellate silk, some of those tiny setae come into direct contact with the wooly silk. Normally, when two surfaces come into contact, there’s still lots of separation on a microscopic scale. That is, tiny bumps and irregularities on the two surfaces get in between them, preventing a really good seal. But when the two surfaces are really tiny — like the microscopic threads that make up cribellate silk and the setae of the insect — they can get into really close contact. And when that happens, various forces, including physical interlocking, capillary forces, and van der Waal’s forces, come into play. I’m not going to go down a physics rabbit hole here. Suffice it to say, the silk sticks to the insect.283
So cribellate silk is not a wet silk, but it’s still sticky. A Lampshade spider constructs its web by laying out crisscrossing lines of major ampulate silk and covering them with cribellate silk. The spider hangs upside down from a mat at the top of the lampshade, clinging to the mat with two pairs of legs and to the lampshade with the other two.
Many features of the lampshade spider’s web harken back to its megalomorph ancestors. The silken mat at the top of the web is similar to the silken mats made by megalomorphs. The lampshade itself is similar to a funnel web. The cribellum may appear to be a rather extreme innovation, but there is evidence that it may have evolved from a fusion and flattening of two spinnerets. Spider legs are already hairy. The calamistrum is just a thickening of that hair. Even the combing and spinning of the cribellate silk may have evolved from the use of the legs to manipulate trip lines and the silk used to construct shelters.284
The Next Steps
The “standard” orb web is a vertical structure, designed to catch insects as they fly from place to place. The earliest orb webs, however, were horizontal structures. Many modern araneomorphs still build such webs. They build them in enclosed, shady spaces, such as the hollows of trees or in rotting stumps. Such places often attract flying insects looking for shelter or for the water that sometimes collects in them. Spinning a horizontal orb web in such a place allows a spider to catch insects as they come in for a landing or take off. Many insects, such as mosquitos, breed in stagnant pools, so a spider may catch an unlucky bug just after it molts into its adult, non-aquatic form.285
Horizontal orb webs still use wooly cribellate silk to catch prey. This works well because insects that are landing or taking off are not flying very fast. Eventually, some spiders rotated their orb webs into the vertical position and started building them in more open spaces, allowing them to capture flying insects when they’re in cruise mode. Hackled orb weavers (family Uloboridae) build vertical orb webs using the same wooly cribellate silk used by the builders of the horizontal webs. But vertical orb webs face the problem of catching insects that may be flying quite fast. The momentum of such insects often take them right through a web that uses cribellate silk. It’s just not sticky and stretchy enough to stop a bug that’s in a hurry.
Eventually, one group of araneomorphs, the Araneoidea, solved this problem by evolving two more kinds of silk: flagelliform silk and aggregate silk protein glue. The frame and spokes of an araneoid web are constructed using major ampullate silk, but the capture spiral is made of super-stretchy flagelliform silk beaded with droplets of aggregate silk. When a rapidly flying insect barges into such a web, the aggregate silk sticks to it like glue (which it is) and the flagelliform silk stretches to absorb the impact.286
Step 1: The spider starts by releasing a strand of major ampullate silk into the breeze. The strand has a dab of sticky silk on the end. With luck, the strand will stick to a branch or other surface some distance away. If not, the spider tries again. Once the far end of a strand is successfully anchored, the spider breaks the strand loose from it’s spinnerets and anchors it nearby. It then crawls along the strand, laying down a reinforcing thread. It does this over and over until it judges the strand strong enough to support a web.
Step 2: The spider hangs a very loose strand from the first one, fastened to the first at both ends so that it hangs down in the middle.
Step 3: The spider anchors another thread to the middle of the loose strand, drops down to a lower perch and pulls the thread taught before anchoring it. It now has a Y-shaped structure beneath the original strand.
Step 4: The spider spins more anchor lines, boxing in the Y.
Step 5: The spider constructs a bunch of strands running from the center of the Y to the frame, so that it ends up with a radial pattern of threads. The frame and radial lines are made of non-sticky silk, so the spider can walk on it without getting stuck.
Step 6: The spider uses more non-sticky thread to lay down a loose construction spiral.
Step 7: Next, it uses the construction spiral as a guide as it lays down a tighter spiral of sticky silk. So as not to waste silk, it eats the construction spiral as it goes.
Often, after a night of catching insects, a web will be too worn out to use again. In that case, the spider will eat the old web in the morning, leaving only the first line. It will rest during the day and construct a new web in the evening.
To watch a video of a spider spinning a web, click here.
‘Aciniform’ comes from the Latin for ‘grape-like’ and refers to the shape of the glands, which resemble bunches of grapes. All araneomorphs have aciniform glands. The silk produced by these glands is used for a number of purposes. The male spider uses it for the ribbon of silk on which he deposits his sperm before he transfers it to his palpal organs.
Many orb weavers use it to weave “decorations” into their webs called stabilimenta. Scientists aren’t sure what purpose these patterns serve. One suggestion that has received recent support from research is that they serve to make the web more visible, so that larger animals, such as birds, are less likely to blunder into them. The following photo shows a couple of stabilimenta woven into the web of a silver argiope.
Silver argiopes are quite common here in Southern California. They are usually found on prickly pear cacti. I recently saw one with four stabilimenta woven into its web. They lined up perfectly with the outstretched legs of the spider. Stupidly, I didn’t bother taking of photo of it.
Araneomorphs that wrap up their prey to subdue it use aciniform silk for the job. This isn’t too surprising, as aciniform silk is the toughest silk yet tested. This is probably also the reason that spiders use it for their egg cases.
The following three photos show a silver argiope that has captured some kind of insect. It’s hard to see any silk around it, but there must be some, because the insect appears to be tightly bound.
A silver argiope with prey Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 7/26/18
Another view
And another
These next few photos show another silver argiope with a much larger and more thoroughly-trussed victim.
A silver argiope with prey Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 8/15/20
A closer view
In this shot, you can see just a bit of the hapless victim. Still can’t tell what it is.
The next two photos show an egg sac from a silver argiope. In my experience, most spider egg sacs tend to be roughly spherical. This one’s a bit more elaborate.
Egg sac of a silver argiope San Diego County 9/29/20
Another view
Wolf spiders are unusual in that they carry their egg sacs around with them, attached to their spinnerets.
Wolf spider (Alopecosa kochi) with egg sac San Diego County 1/29/19
Another view
Here’s another kind of wolf spider with its egg sac. This one is a pirate wolf spider (genus Pirata). These spiders hang out near streams of water and can run around on the water’s surface. Judging by the clearly visible seams, the spider must have formed the sac in two parts, which it then joined together.
A pirate wolf spider (genus Pirata) with egg sac San Diego County – not sure of the date
A closeup
Another view
Another unusual thing about wolf spiders is that they’re the only spiders that carry their babies around on their abdomens after they hatch. Here’s a couple of photos of a mother pirate wolf spider doing just that. (Yeah, I know, this has nothing to do with silk, but those babies are just so darn cute!)
A pirate wolf spider (genus Pirata) with babies San Diego County – not sure of the date
A closer look at the babies
Tubiliform or Cylindriform Silk
The females of most types of araneomorphs possess long, tubular glands called cylindrical glands and the silk these glands produce is called tubiliform or cylindriform silk. It’s a fluffy silk used for only one purpose — it forms a protective layer around the eggs inside the egg case.
The next three photos show the contents of what I believe was a silver argiope egg sac. You can see the fluffy tubiliform silk that surrounded and cushioned the eggs in the sac. The eggs were extremely small, by the way — much smaller than the head of a pin.
The contents of a spider egg sac San Diego County 10/7/20
A closeup
One of the fun things about opening spider egg sacs is that it’s not always eggs that come out. Apparently, baby spiders tend to hang around in the sac for some time after hatching. More than once, I’ve opened an egg sac, expecting to find eggs, and had hundreds of baby spiders pour out instead. That was the case with the next photos. (These are definitely silver argiopes.)
Silver argiope spiderlings fresh out of the egg sac San Diego County 10/15/20
A closer view. You can see the fluffy tubiliform silk from the egg sac.
Another view
My grandnephew’s hand next to a few of the spiderlings that came out of the egg sac
All araneomorphs have clusters of piriform, or pear-shaped, glands, which produce the silk that the spiders use to anchor their major ampullate draglines to the substrate. Piriform silk uses a “nano-fibril network embedded in a cement-like matrix” — to quote a paper that delves into the mechanical properties of this silk.290 I don’t recommend reading the paper unless you’re way better at math than I am, but it does include an awesome illustration. You can check it out by clicking here.
Both mesotheles and megalomorphs have glands that resemble aciniform and piriform glands. There hasn’t been much genetic research on non-araneomorph spiders, but it seems likely that there is a close relationship between these glands in araneomorphs and non-araneomorphs.
Technically, a cobweb is a tangled, three-dimensional web that doesn’t have any particular overall form. (So a lampshade web is not a cobweb, even though it is pretty tangled.) There is a whole family of spiders, Theridiidae, that are called cobweb spiders, although not all of them actually weave cobwebs.
The theridiids are araneomorphs and, in fact, there is evidence that they evolved from orb-weavers. This may come as a surprise. Why would a group of spiders that are capable of weaving such “advanced” webs revert to building such simple ones?
There are two reasons. First, evolution doesn’t care about how “advanced” an organism is. If the organism can get along just fine without it’s “advanced” traits, it’ll probably ditch them.
Second: wasps. Many, many types of wasps prey on spiders. But evidence suggests that orb weavers evolved by at least 145 million years ago and they began to diversify by 125 mya. This was before predatory wasps evolved and much earlier than birds. A vertical, two-dimensional orb web may be great at catching insects, but it leaves its occupant exposed to any hungry wasp or bird that comes along. I doubt that a cobweb is very effective against birds, but it sure comes in handy for impeding the progress of a wasp.
One of the most familiar cobweb spiders is the black widow (genus Latrodectus). Here’s a few photos of one of our local species, the western black widow (L. hesperus). It was in a very small container, so it wasn’t able to build a full-size web, but you can see how tangled even this small version is.
Western black widow (Latrodectus hesperus) San Diego County 10/3/18
A close up of the spinnerets and that infamous hourglass
Many cobweb spiders, including the aforementioned black widows, build what’s known as a gum-foot line into their webs. The spider constructs the first part of its web using non-sticky major ampullate silk near some sort of ceiling — a rock overhang or the literal ceiling in the corner of a room, for instance. Then it drops down on a dragline to the ground or floor. It anchors the dragline using a dab of sticky aggregate silk. Next, it climbs back up the dragline, doubling it with a second strand of major ampullate silk. As it’s going, it coats the bottom part of the dragline with more sticky silk. When it gets back up to the web, it pulls on the gumline, stretching it like a rubber band, before reattaching it to the web. Now the gumline is spring-loaded.
The spider repeats this process, constructing more gumlines between the web and the substrate. If a bug crawling along the substrate bumps into one of these gumlines, it sticks to it. Naturally, it struggles to get free. This breaks the gumline loose from the substrate and it snaps up, launching the bug into the web above and the waiting jaws of the spider. So the gumlines catch prey on ground below while the upper part of the web catches flying insects.
More Webs
I could devote many blog posts to the different kinds of webs that araneomorphs weave. Since I don’t want this particular blog post to go on forever, I’ll just mention a few of my favorite ones.
Bolas spiders, which include several related genera of orb-weavers, don’t actually weave orb webs, or any other kind of web in the traditional sense of the word. Bolas spiders prey on moths. Moths are difficult to catch in orb webs, because they are covered in tiny, powdery scales. When a moth blunders into a web, usually only the scales stick to the silk and the moth flies free. So bolas spiders have come up with a unique hunting technique.
A typical bolas spider will dangle a single line of silk with a sticky blob of liquid silk on the end. The spider emits one or more pheromones that closely mimic the pheromones produced by female moths of the species (or small set of species) that the spider hunts. Male moths of that species are attracted to the scent. When the spider senses a moth nearby, it begins swinging the sticky blob around in a circle. The blob is large enough that, if it hits the moth, the sticky silk will soak through the scales and contact the insect’s body. Then the spider just reels it in like a fish.
Bolas spiders get their common name from the weapon called a bolas that was used by the gauchos in South America. This weapon consisted of weights on the end of interconnected cords. The gaucho would swing the weights around and throw the weapon at animals such as rheas (large, flightless birds). The cords would get tangled around the animal’s legs, bringing it down.292293294
I’ve only seen one bolas spider in my wanderings. It’s pictured below. I didn’t find out what it was until after I had caught and released it, so I didn’t get any photos of the bolas.
A bolas spider (Mastophora cornigera) San Diego County 9/28/18
Ventral view
A ray spider spins a traditional orb web, then follows up by anchoring a guy line to the center of the web and pulling it into a cone shape. When a bug brushes against the web, the spider releases the guy line and the web springs back, slamming against the insect.
A net-casting spider uses cribellate silk to weave a small net, which it holds outstretched between its front legs. When it spots a prey animal close by, it lunges at it, quickly wrapping it up in the net. Net-casting spiders hunt at night. Two of their eyes are greatly enlarged, giving them excellent night vision. Members of one genus, Deinopis, are called ogre-faced spiders because their massive eyes give them such a weird look.
Given all the amazing properties of spider silk, you might be wondering if anyone has tried using it to weave textiles. The answer, of course, is yes. Unfortunately, no one has figured out a way to harvest spider silk in the quantities needed to make it profitable. One of the reasons for researching spiders and their silk is the hope that we may one day find a way to produce spider silk in mass.
In the meantime, click here to watch a wonderful video of a researcher using a simple device made for extracting silk from a spider. The video also includes some fascinating info about the extracted silk.
People have actually succeeded in producing fabrics made of spider silk. In fact, “a complete set of bed hangings” was exhibited at the Paris Exhibition of 1898. It was the work of a French missionary, Father Paul Camboué, and his business partner, M. Nogué, who established a spider silk fabric industry on the island of Madagascar. Unfortunately, their business venture was not very successful and the bed hangings have since been lost.
More recently, in 2009, a cape made from the silk of about a million golden silk orb-weaver spiders was exhibited at the American Museum of Natural History. The cape took five years and almost $400,000 to make. For the entire story and some beautiful photos of the cape, click here.
One of the ways researchers have attempted to get around the problems of harvesting silk from spiders is by inserting spider genes into other organisms, such as bacteria. Scientists have even genetically engineered goats to produce spider silk in their milk! After milking, the silk protein is separated out, turned into a powder, and spun into a fiber. Click here to read an article about this fascinating project.
Have you ever seen a baby dragonfly? Would you know it if you had? A baby dragonfly is called a naiad (rhymes with ‘my ad’). In classical Greek mythology, a naiad was a minor female deity that lived in a body of fresh water such as a lake, river, or spring. Immature dragonflies are called naiads because they also live in fresh water. Although they are similar in form to adults, they lack wings and their coloration is much more muted, so you wouldn’t immediately think ‘dragonfly’ if you saw one.
A dragonfly spends most of its life as a naiad. This can range from two months to five years, depending on the species, but also on the environment. The members of a species may take much longer to develop if they live in a cold environment. In their adult form, dragonflies live for only two to four months. So what we usually think of as a dragonfly is really just the last stage of its life cycle.253
In some insects, the adult form is so different from the immature form that the insect’s body has to go through a major restructuring to get from one to the other. To accomplish this, the insect stops eating and becomes more or less immobile. In this immobile form it’s called a pupa. In some cases, it may first spin a cocoon around itself or make some other kind of preparation, but otherwise, it just stops moving and lets the transformation begin. And what a transformation it is! In the case of a caterpillar, its body almost completely liquifies. Most of the tissues and even the cells are broken down and rebuilt into the adult butterfly or moth.
An insect that undergoes this kind of transformation is said to undergo complete metamorphosis and the immature form of the insect is called a larva.
If an insect does not go through complete metamorphosis, its immature form is called a nymph. Although dragonflies do go through some rather drastic changes in their final molt, those changes are not so drastic that the insect has to go through a pupal stage, so you will sometimes hear a baby dragonfly referred to as a nymph, rather than a naiad. Both terms are correct. A naiad is just a nymph that lives in the water.297
Dragonflies are not the only insects whose immature forms are called naiads. The term is also used for damselflies and mayflies. All these insects are closely related and their nymphs live similar lives.
Notice two things about the dragonfly in this photo: the wings are held more or less straight out from the body and the eyes take up most of the head. In many species, including this one, the eyes actually touch at the top of the head. The eyes of a damselfly are much farther apart — they don’t come close to touching — and when at rest, the wings fold back towards the rear. You can see this in the photo below. A dragonfly is unable to fold its wings back like this. Also note that the body of the damselfly is more slender and delicate-looking.
Rambur’s forktail damselfly (Ischnura ramburii) Lake Murray, San Diego County 5/28/18
Adult mayflies can be distinguished from dragonflies and damselflies by their two or three long, thread-like tails. Like a dragonfly, a mayfly is unable to fold its wings flat over its abdomen. Unlike a dragonfly, it holds them upright when at rest.
Here’s several photos of a mayfly naiad. Notice that, like the adult, it has several very long tails.
Mayfly naiad (unidentified) Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County 9/1/18
A view from the bottom
Another view
In the last of the photos above, notice the fan-like structures attached to the sides of the abdomen. These are gills. They’re a defining feature of mayfly naiads. As we’ll see in a minute, dragonfly and damselfly naiads also have gills, but in very different locations. Notice also the mouthparts. Here’s a couple of closeups. I know you can’t see much detail. Just keep the general look of the mouthparts in mind, so you’ll be able to contrast them to those of the damselfly and dragonfly.
Damselfly naiad (unidentified) San Diego County 4/13/18
Right away, you can see that it doesn’t have the gills coming off the sides of the abdomen. Instead, the gills are the three long, fan-like structures attached to its rear.
The cool thing about the following photo is the almost perfect transparency of the body. I think the dark lines running through the legs and other body parts are the nerves.
Damselfly naiad (unidentified) San Diego County 4/13/18
The photo below (of a different naiad) also shows some amazing anatomy. Note the four wing buds attached to the thorax. This damselfly is probably getting close to maturity, as the wing buds are pretty well-developed.
Damselfly naiad (unidentified) San Diego County 7/16/18
This next photo is where things start to get really freaky. Again, you can see the wing buds extending from the thorax and lots of awesome anatomy, but what’s going on with that lower jaw?
Damselfly naiad (unidentified) San Diego County 7/16/18
I’m using the word ‘jaw’ loosely. The technical term is ‘labium’. Most insects have a labium, although they are usually much less freakish. I’ve also seen it described as a lower lip. In fact, the word ‘labium’ comes from the Latin word for lip.305306
Here’s a closer view of the labium. The jaw is attached to the underside of the head, as you would expect. From there, it extends backward to a joint. From the joint, it reverses direction, widens as it approaches the head, and ends in some kind of clasper.
Closeup
Dragonfly naiads have very similar lower jaws. We’ll get to them in the next section, but in the meantime, I’ll use an illustration of a dragonfly naiad to show you how this lower jaw works. In figure 1 below, the labium is highlighted in red. Obviously, the labium is extended in the figure. The dragonfly can retract it by rotating the first segment backward and bending the labium at the joint. This causes the jaw to fold up underneath the head and thorax. In the retracted state, the ‘mask’ at the end of the labium fits snuggly over the dragonfly’s face. You’ll get a good view of the mask in some later photos and videos. Not all dragonflies have this mask and, as far as I know, no damselflies do.
Note: For some inane reason, entomologists have decided to call the entire labium of a dragonfly naiad the mask, regardless of whether or not it covers the face of the insect. So to be technically correct, I would have to refer to the mask-like swelling at the end of the labium as ‘the mask-like swelling at the end of the labium’. For the purposes of this article, I’m just going to call it the mask.307
Figure 1: Labium of dragonfly naiad Date: 1890 Source: Insecta by Alpheus Hyatt (1838-1902) Authors: Alpheus Hyatt and J.M. Arms This work is in the public domain in its country of origin and other countries and areas where the copyright term is the author’s life plus 70 years or fewer. This work is in the public domain in the United States because it was published (or registered with the U.S. Copyright Office) before January 1, 1925. Note: This image has been altered to highlight the labium in red.
The damselfly’s labium works the same way, although, as already noted, the end doesn’t form a mask like it does in some dragonflies. The labium of the mayfly naiad is not able to extend in this way.
So what purpose does this bizarre jaw serve in dragonflies and damselflies? As you can probably guess, it’s for catching prey. When the naiad senses something potentially edible, the labium snaps out with incredible speed. The business end of the labium has its own set of ‘jaws’ lined with ‘teeth’. These jaws close around the prey and the naiad retracts the labium, pulling the prey against its mandibles.
The naiad doesn’t use muscles to extend the labium. Instead, it uses hydraulic pressure. The insect increases the pressure of the hemolymph (the insect equivalent of blood) feeding the labium and this causes it to unfold and shoot forward at blinding speed. Presumably, it does use muscles to close the jaws around the prey and retract the labium, although I haven’t been able to find any resources that explicitly say so.
Here’s a couple of photos that show the jaws at the end of the damselfly labium:
Damselfly naiad San Diego County 7/16/18
Damselfly naiad San Diego County 7/13/20
And because I know you want to see the labium in action, here’s a few photos of a damselfly naiad eating a bug. (Don’t worry, we’ll get to some videos later.)
Damselfly naiad with prey San Diego County 4/20/18
Damselfly naiad with prey San Diego County 4/20/18
Damselfly naiad with prey San Diego County 4/20/18
A dragonfly naiad is much more thick-bodied than that of a damselfly. The following photo shows the naiad of a common green darner dragonfly (Anax junius). It was quite large. I didn’t measure it, but I would estimate that it was about 5 cm or around 2 inches long! This was also a late-stage naiad, as it has fairly large wing buds. Notice that one of the buds is deformed. It had some kind of growth underneath it, which will be visible in some later photos.
Naiad of common green darner dragonfly (Anax junius) San Diego County 7/25/20
As you can see, it doesn’t have any external gills. It’s gills are inside its rectum! The dragonfly pumps water in and out of its rectum, creating a steady flow of oxygenated water over its gills. In other words, it breathes through its butt!
When threatened, a naiad can forcefully expel water from its anus, causing the insect to shoot forward — a rather novel form of jet propulsion.
Here’s a picture of the same naiad from the side. Obviously, it’s way more robust than the damselfly naiad. In fact, from this angle, it looks downright scary. It’ll look even more scary when you see it in action.
Naiad of common green darner dragonfly (Anax junius) San Diego County 7/25/20
In case you’re wondering, the fuzzy dark blob between the first and second pair of legs is a snail that I’m quite sure positioned itself there just to ruin my photo. Also, you may notice what appears to be another bug wedged underneath the dragonfly’s abdomen. That’s a diving beetle. I think it was conspiring with the snail.
Here’s a closeup of the head. As you can see, it has a lower jaw very similar to that of the damselfly. This particular species of dragonfly lacks the mask at the end of the labium, making it even more similar.
A closeup of the head. Note the folded labium
And here’s a closeup of the growth underneath the wing bud. I don’t if it’s an injury or a tumor or what. I was thinking that it might be some kind of parasite, but I haven’t been able to identify it.
A closeup of the deformed wing bud and the growth underneath it
Here’s a series of photos of another kind of dragonfly nymph. I don’t know the species, but it’s more typical of the kinds that I usually see. This one does have the mask, which is very evident in the photos as it’s in the process of eating a water boatman (a type of aquatic insect). It’s also quite a bit smaller than the green darner naiad.
Dragonfly naiad eating a water boatman San Diego County 4/18/18
A closeup showing the water boatman caught the mask
Another closeup
Here, the naiad has finished its meal
Here’s a couple of videos of the same nymph. The first one shows it with a water boatman caught in its mask.
And here it is “cleansing its pallet” after the meal:
Next, we have a video of the green darner dragonfly catching and eating a cricket. The strike is blurry, but it gets clearer later in the video. You can really see its labium and other mouthparts working. It consumes the entire cricket — legs and all. (You don’t want all that good protein to go to waste.)
The next video shows the same naiad trying and failing to eat a beetle. You get a better view of the strike in this one. Two strikes actually — it tries a second time. (Sorry about the red background. I had it in a god-awful ugly plastic bowl.)
Like all insects, naiads must periodically shed their exoskeletons as they grow. When the naiad of a dragonfly or damselfly is ready for its final molt — the one in which it changes into an adult — it climbs out of the water, usually by climbing up the stem of a reed or some other plant.314 The naiad will cling there while it undergoes metamorphosis. It’s not uncommon to find the shed exoskeleton of a dragonfly or damselfly still clinging to a stem or stuck to a rock face above the pool that it climbed out of.
Shed exoskeletons are called exuviae. The following two photos show the nicely preserved exuviae of a dragonfly. You can clearly see the labium with its mask. Even the corneas of the eyes have been cast off.
Dragonfly exuviae Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/18
Dragonfly exuviae Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/18
When a naiad molts, its old exoskeleton splits just behind the head and the insect wriggles out through the opening.
You may be wondering what the white strands are in the photos. I mentioned earlier that the dragonfly has gills in its anus. The oxygen taken up by the gills has to be distributed throughout the body. Surprisingly, this is not the job of the hemolymph (insect blood), which is only responsible for distributing nutrients. Instead, it’s distributed via tubes called trachea. Much finer tubes called tracheoles branch off from the trachea. The white strands are the linings of the trachea, which are shed at the same time as the exoskeleton.316317
Scientists believe that insects evolved about 480 million years ago — around the same time as land plants. The first insects were wingless. In fact, at the time, no animals had yet developed flight. Insects became the first to do so around 406 mya. Those insects were the ancestors of modern-day dragonflies, damselflies, and mayflies.
Mayflies form the order Ephemeroptera. The earliest fossils that have definitely been identified as mayflies are from the late Carboniferous.322 Some scientists believe they may have appeared as early as the Devonian, but this has not been confirmed. Most mayfly fossils are of nymphs, probably because the adults lived for only a few days, as is the case for modern mayflies.
The oldest known relatives of dragonflies and damselflies (order Odonata) are the extinct griffinflies, which form the order Meganisoptera. Fossil griffinflies have been found from as far back as 325 mya in the early Carboniferous. This was a time that is famous for its giant insects. In fact, the largest known insects of all time were in a genus of griffinflies, Meganeuropsis. One of the largest, Meganeuropsis permiana, had an estimated wingspan of up to 710 millimetres or 28 inches. Griffinflies look very similar to dragonflies and are sometimes called giant dragonflies in the media. This is not technically correct, since they lack some of the features that scientists use to define dragonflies. Also, they probably weren’t the direct ancestors of modern dragonflies — they just shared a common ancestor.
A few fossils of griffinfly nymphs have been found and they have mouthparts similar to dragonfly nymphs, which means they were probably also aquatic. None of the references I’ve found explicitly state that the mouthparts were extendable like modern dragonflies and damselflies, but I presume that they were, since they wouldn’t be very “similar” if they weren’t. So it’s likely that this weird lower jaw evolved very early in insect prehistory.
“An ant of velvet On a dusty hiking trail A wasp chirps softly” – Haiku310
Velvet ants are not really ants. They’re wasps. They’re called velvet ants because the females are wingless and look a bit like large, hairy ants. They’re also called cow killers. They earn this moniker by having excruciatingly painful stings.
You might be forgiven for thinking that the more painful a sting is, the more dangerous it is. In fact, the toxicity of a venom is unrelated to the level of pain it produces. The sting from a velvet ant is less toxic than that of a honey bee, but hurts way more. On the Schmidt sting pain index315, the velvet ant scores a 3. (The index only goes up to 4.) One of the few insects in Southern California with a more painful sting is the tarantula hawk wasp, which I covered in an earlier post. (See The Stuff of Nightmares.)
Dasymutilla magnifica – A beautiful desert species of velvet ant Anza Borrego State Park, San Diego County, CA 6/22/19
I’ve actually been stung by a velvet ant. While hiking near where I live, I saw a Sacken’s velvet ant, a species whose long white fur makes it look kind of like the seed-head of a plant — if a seed-head had long black legs. I wanted to show it to my grandnephew, who’s a huge fan of bugs (can’t imagine where he gets that from), so I caught it in a small plastic container. The young woman I was hiking with was worried that it wouldn’t have enough air, so, to make her happy, I decided to transfer it to a larger container that I happened to have with me. When I got home, I discovered that the container had gotten squeezed in my pack and the lid had popped loose …and it was empty. It seemed unlikely that the velvet ant would be able to find its way out of the pack, so it stood to reason that it was still in there. Somewhere…
I started very gingerly pulling things out. Finally, I upended the pack and dumped out the remaining items. No velvet ant. I had just about concluded that it had escaped altogether, when I detected movement out of the corner of my eye. I jerked my hand back just as the wasp struck. I must have reacted just in time to prevent the insect from injecting more than a tiny amount of venom, because the sting was very mild — much less painful than a typical spider bite — and the pain faded completely in a few minutes. Obviously, I was very lucky.
Here’s a couple of photos of a velvet ant like the one that stung me (but not the same individual):
Sacken’s velvet ant (Dasymutilla sackenii) Cuyamaca Rancho State Park, San Diego County, CA 8/8/20
Wasps are in the order Hymenoptera, which also includes bees, ants, and sawflies. All these insects are in many ways closely related. Bees have been described as vegan wasps (see my earlier blog post Vegan Wasps and Flying Mice) and ants could be thought of as wingless, social wasps.
Within the Hymenoptera, wasps form the suborder Apocrita and, within that, velvet ants make up the family Mutillidae. As noted, female mutillids are wingless. The males do have wings and often differ markedly in size, form, and coloration from the females. This presents a problem for entomologists. Velvet ants are solitary insects. The only time males and females hang out together are when they are actually in the process of mating. So, given any two velvet ants — one male and one female — how can you tell if they are the same species? Often the only way to know for sure is if you manage to catch them in flagrante. One entomologist who specializes in the group writes that, although he has frequently seen males in the vicinity of females (and actively searching for them), he’s only once seen them actually doing the deed. It seems that they prefer to conduct their affairs in private.
Obviously, this makes it very difficult for scientists to sort out the different species. Many times males and females of the same species have been given different species names. When the mistake is finally caught, one name (the first one given) becomes the official species name while the other becomes a synonym.325 Currently, there are around 150 species of velvet ant listed for North America. Of these, about a third are known from both males and females; another third are known only from males; and the final third are known only from females.
A male velvet ant in the subfamily Sphaeropthalminae Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County, CA 8/13/18
A closeup Note the three large ocelli on the top of the head. (See The Story of Eyes for an explanation of ocelli.)
A closeup of the abdomen
Dietary Habits
Adult velvet ants feed on nectar. I mentioned earlier that I caught a female to show to my grandnephew. Since hummingbirds also feed on nectar, but will accept sugar water as a substitute, I figured mutillids might do the same. So, we mixed up some sugar water, added a little red food coloring (this was more for the kid’s benefit than the bug’s — he thoroughly enjoyed making “nectar”), and put a few drops into the container with the wasp. The insect didn’t immediately go for it — she was probably distracted by all the unwanted attention — but later I saw her grazing on the sticky, drying droplets.
What the larvae of velvet ants eat is a bit more gruesome. Mutillid larvae are parasitoids — parasites that kill their hosts. With a few exceptions, they prey on the young of solitary, ground-nesting bees or wasps. After mating, the female velvet ant goes in search of a host nest. When she finds one, she invades the nest and lays an egg next to each larva or pupa. When an egg hatches, the mutillid larva begins feeding on the host larva/pupa. It takes only a week or two for the wasp to consume its host, after which, it metamorphoses into an adult and leaves the nest.
Naturally, a bee or wasp whose nest is invaded by a velvet ant defends it vigorously. And since the hosts are usually solitary, the nests tend to be scattered far and wide, so the female velvet ant has to spend a lot of time wandering around in the open searching for them. This means exposing herself to an increased risk of predation. As a result of these selection pressures, velvet ants have evolved a remarkable array of defenses. One of these is their extremely painful sting, which we’ve already discussed. I’ll cover the other defenses in the following sections.
Velvet ant (Dasymutilla sp.) Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 9/16/19
The velvet ant’s exoskeleton is heavily reinforced. So much so, that collectors often resort to using tiny drill bits to drill holes for the pins, instead of trying to force the pins through the bug’s carapace. If an entomologist does try to push a pin through by brute force, when it finally breaks through, it will often continue on through the bottom of the carapace and into the collector’s finger. So, a drill bit is probably the way to go.
The top and sides of a velvet ant’s exoskeleton are covered with pits and ridges. This serves to strengthen the exoskeleton without adding a lot of weight. The ridges may also serve to redirect attacks. When a mandible or stinger catches on a ridge, it tends to slide along it towards an even thicker part of the armor.
An aposematic signal is a warning directed toward potential predators. It’s a way of saying, “you really don’t want to mess with me”. Such signals often take the form of colorful, eye-catching patterns. Most velvet ants are covered in brightly colored fur. If a predator tries to eat one, it’s probably going to get a bad sting and, while the wasp in question may or may not survive the attack, the predator will quickly learn to avoid any similar-looking insects in the future. So, aposematic coloration helps to reduce predation on a species as a whole.
A defensive strategy often allied with aposematic coloration is Müllerian mimicry. This is when two or more species that share the same predators evolve very similar warning signals. If a predator learns to avoid members of one of the species, it will likely avoid members of all of the species, so sharing the same aposematic signals is mutually beneficial. There are many cases of velvet ants forming ‘Müllerian mimicry rings’ consisting of dozens of species. A study in “Current Biology” found that North American velvet ants form one of the largest known Müllerian mimicry complexes on the planet, consisting of eight extensive and distinct mimicry rings.329
Aposematic coloration is a pretty good warning signal, but what if your attacker is color blind? Perhaps to fill that gap in its defenses, the velvet ant has evolved the ability to secrete an alarm chemical from a gland in its mandible. This chemical serves as an olfactory alarm signal. A predator quickly learns to avoid any insects that smell like it.
Ok, but what if your attacker is color blind and has a head cold? Better to give him an auditory warning, too, just to be safe. Insects don’t have vocal cords, but many of them are able to produce sounds by rubbing together various body parts. This is called stridulation. Crickets, for example, are famous for their chirping, which they make by rubbing together their wings.333 When disturbed, a velvet ant emits a sound that has also been described as “chirping” or sometimes “squeaking”. It does this by rubbing together two of the segments of its abdomen.
When I showed that velvet ant to my grandnephew, we found that we could get it to stridulate by gently stroking its back with the cap from an ink pen. The sound was soft and difficult to hear, but then, it’s probably tuned to non-human ears. The vibration of the abdomen may also serve as a deterrent by provoking a startle response. In one experiment, a shrew was observed to drop a velvet ant as soon as it started stridulating, even though it hadn’t been stung.
I should note that stridulation may not be used exclusively for defense. According to one article, the female also uses it to attract males.334
In the following video, I’ve increased the volume to make the stridulation easier to hear. You can also clearly see the movement of the abdomen. Note: the velvet ant in the video looks a bit bedraggled. This is probably because of the time it spent loose in my backpack. It was not otherwise harmed and I later released it near where I found it. (It even got a nice meal of sugar water for its trouble. That’s the red splotches in the video.)
Scientists have actually studied the susceptibility of female mutillids to predation. In one study, entitled “The indestructible insect: Velvet ants from across the United States avoid predation by representatives from all major tetrapod clades”335, velvet ants from both the Eastern and Western United States were exposed to various potential predators that they would be likely to encounter in their native habitats. These included birds, shrews, lizards, toads, and one mole. (Apparently, moles were in short supply.) The results of the study can be summed up by the following excerpt from the paper: “…out of over 100 interactions between potential predators and various species of velvet ant, there were only 16 occasions where feeding strikes occurred. Only four velvet ants were eaten and three of the four were immediately regurgitated. Only one velvet ant was consumed and retained by a predator.”
Female mutillids probably lost their wings as an adaptation to entering the burrows of their hosts. Wings would be easily damaged by attacking insects, so better to just do away with them. This presents a problem, though — it limits species dispersal — and this puts them at an evolutionary disadvantage, because if a species is only found in a small area, it will tend to adapt itself to the specific environment found in that area. If that environment changes drastically, the species could be wiped out.
Some mutillids have overcome this handicap by evolving phoretic copulation. Phoresy is a type of behaviour in which one animal hitches a ride on another animal. Some types of mites, for instance, will hitch rides on beetles or other larger animals. This way, they get more widely dispersed than would be possible if they just walked. In phoretic copulation, the male of a species carries a female to a new location either before or during mating. In the case of velvet ants, the male transports the female by flying. He actually carries her attached to his genitalia, so mating is done in mid-air. To facilitate this behavior, males of these species have evolved to be significantly larger than the females.