Category Archives: Plants

Hearing Things

Ironically, as I write this, I have an ear infection. It’s made me partially deaf in one ear. It’s also made me appreciate what a bang-up job my ears do under more normal circumstances. We hear so much about the amazing hearing abilities of other animals that you might assume humans have a rather poor sense of hearing. In fact, humans, like most mammals, have very good hearing. But I’m getting ahead of myself. Way ahead, in fact…

Hearing in Plants1 2

No, I’m not going to tell you that if you play Mozart to your houseplants they’ll grow better. That nonsense has long since been debunked. Plants don’t care about music. They probably don’t care about anything. But there are things that are important to them, like locating water, protecting themselves from herbivores, and attracting pollinators. To achieve these goals, they’ve evolved the capacity to respond to things in their environment. They ‘know’ to grow in a direction opposite the pull of gravity; they react to light and to the position of the sun; they follow chemical gradients; they even communicate with each other and with animals through chemicals; and evidence is mounting that at least some plants can hear.3

Sound waves cause objects in their path to vibrate. That’s how we hear things—sound shakes our eardrums. Leaves and petals aren’t as good as eardrums when it comes to vibrating, but they still do it. Is it possible that some plants have evolved to respond to certain types of vibrations?

A study published in 2014 showed that Arabidopsis, a plant in the mustard family, turns up its production of chemical toxins in response to caterpillar chewing sounds. When the cabbage butterfly caterpillar munches on an Arabidopsis leaf, it makes a distinctive, high-pitched sound. Researchers recorded this sound, then played it back to one group of plants for two hours, while leaving another group in silence. The plants exposed to the sound increased their production of mustard oil, a chemical that makes their leaves distasteful to most insects. The researchers tried playing other sounds to the plants, including sounds made by non-threatening insects. The plants showed no response. This was the first study to show evidence that some plants can detect sound.

In a 2017 study, evolutionary biologist Monica Gagliano and colleagues placed pea seedlings in pots shaped like upside-down Ys. One arm of each “Y” was placed in dry soil. The other arm was placed in either a tray of water or a coiled plastic tube that had water flowing through it. The roots always grew towards the arm with the water, even when the water was inaccessible inside the plastic tubing. Gagliano believes that the only way the plants could have known the water in the tubing was there was by the gurgling noises it made. She suggests that plants use sound waves to detect water at a distance, but use moisture gradients when they get closer to the source.4

Plants produce sugary nectar to attract pollinators. Sugar production comes at a metabolic cost, though—it uses energy. So, ideally, a plant should produce the sweetest nectar only when there are pollinators around for it to attract. But how can a plant tell if that’s the case? Recent studies suggest that some plants can hear them coming! Researchers studying evening primroses (Oenothera drummondii) found that when they played the sound of bees buzzing nearby, within minutes the plants increased the concentration of sugar in their nectar by 20%.

The scientists conducted several experiments on more than 650 evening primrose flowers, measuring their nectar production in response to silence, sound at three different frequencies, and recordings of buzzing bees. The recorded buzzing (and low-frequency sounds that closely matched the recorded buzzing) resulted in the plants starting to increase sugar concentration in their nectar in just three minutes! The other sounds had no effect.

The researchers repeated the experiments on flowers that had some of their petals removed. These flowers didn’t change their nectar production in response to buzzing sounds, implying that it’s the petals that are used to detect the vibrations. This could be one reason why many flowers, including those of evening primrose, are bowl-shaped since this shape tends to concentrate sound.5

Annual evening primrose (Oenothera deltoides ssp. deltoides)
Note: This is not the species the study was done on. And its color is different—Oenothera drummondii has yellow flowers. But the flowers are a similar shape (and I don’t have any photos of Oenothera drummondii).
Anza Borrego Desert State Park, San Diego County. 1/29/23

Hearing in Insects6

Invertebrates are animals that don’t have backbones—everything from sponges to squid in other words. There are, unsurprisingly, an enormous number of invertebrate species, so it might come as a surprise to learn that the ability to hear has only evolved in two groups of them—insects and crabs—and it’s only evolved in a tiny subset of those groups.

Why is this? Well, many invertebrates are able to sense vibrations in the substrate—the ground or leaf or whatever—that they’re standing on. That’s probably good enough for most purposes. And evolution always favors good enough. It doesn’t waste time and resources on perfection.

That said, there are a lot of insect species, so even though hearing is very rare among them, their sheer numbers ensure that there are a lot of insects that can hear. Ears can be found in butterflies, moths, grasshoppers, katydids, crickets, lacewings, preying mantids, honeybees, mosquitoes, flies, true bugs, beetles, and cockroaches. And the diversity of their ears is extraordinary. Unlike vertebrates, which tend to have ears on the head, insects can have them on almost any body part—abdomen, legs, wings, mouth—some even have them on their tongues!7

One reason for this diversity is that ears didn’t just evolve once in insects. Scientists believe they evolved independently at least 20 times. In butterflies and moths alone, they evolved on six different occasions!

But there’s another reason. With a few exceptions, insect ears are modifications of chordotonal organs.8 These are sensory organs found in insects and crustaceans but not in any other type of animal. A chordotonal organ stretches between two segments of a joint. When the segments move relative to each other (that is, when the appendage bends at the joint), it increases or decreases the tension on the organ, allowing it to sense the movement. Usually, chordotonal organs are used for proprioception—that is, giving the insect a sense of how its body parts are positioned—but they are often repurposed for other functions, including hearing. They are found at almost every joint, so it follows that insects can evolve ears on almost any body part.9 10

The insect in the following photo is a katydid (a relative of grasshoppers and crickets).

Least katydid (Brachyinsara hemiptera)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 11/7/18

Here’s a closeup of one of its legs. The arrow points to one of its ears.

A closeup, showing the ear

The ear, in this case, takes the form of a tympanal organ. This is a membrane (the tympanum) stretched across a frame. When sound causes the membrane to vibrate, the vibrations are picked up by a chordotonal organ that’s attached to it.

So, what do insects do with all those weird ears? As diverse as their ears are, so too are their uses. Various insects use them for courtship, to establish territories, for social communication, even to locate hosts to parasitize. And, in some cases, they use them to detect bats…

Bats Go High (Frequency)

The philosopher Thomas Nagel once wrote a paper about the nature of consciousness entitled “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” In it, Nagel asserts that “an organism has conscious mental states if and only if there is something that it is like to be that organism—something it is like for the organism.” He further asserts that we can never truly understand what it’s like to be a bat (or any other presumably-conscious organism) because we are limited to our own subjective viewpoint, which is very different from that of a bat.11

Why, we might ask, did Nagel choose a bat to illustrate his ideas? Bats are bizarre animals in many respects. For example, they are the only mammals that can fly. But I doubt Nagel was thinking about their flying ability when he chose them. More likely, he was thinking of their echolocation.

Echolocation is the ability to perceive one’s surroundings by emitting pulses of sound (aka clicks) and using the rebounding echoes to build a mental model of nearby objects. Most bats fly at night, and although they aren’t blind, they don’t need to see in order to hunt and find their way around. They can do it all with sound.

Bats echolocate using ultrasound—sound that’s at a frequency too high for humans to hear. When a bat searches for prey, it emits loud, long pulses that carry as far as possible. It also spaces the pulses out, so that the outgoing calls don’t interfere with the returning echoes. The frequency of each click typically varies from beginning to end. Different frequencies bounce off parts of an object in different ways, and this allows the bat to resolve shape and texture. In the search phase, the energy of each pulse is concentrated into a narrow range of frequencies. This improves the bat’s chances of detecting small objects at a distance, but limits its ability to identify them. (The resolution of the echoes is lower, in other words). So, the bat can tell that a small object in the distance might be an insect, but it won’t know for sure until it enters the second phase of the hunt.

In this phase, the bat homes in on the object. As it does, it broadens the frequency range of its calls to increase their resolution, and it calls more frequently to get faster updates. At the same time that it’s packing more frequencies into each click, it also shortens the click length. This is necessary to keep outgoing clicks from overlapping with incoming echoes, since it’s clicking at a faster rate. Finally, it softens the clicks. I suppose it does this because it’s getting closer to the target, so it doesn’t need to click as loudly.

All of this, mind you, is happening over a very short period of time, and the differences in wavelength of the incoming echoes are very small. And yet, the bat’s brain is able to process all this incoming information in real time, all while flitting around at high speed!

There are a lot of bat species, and not all of them do things exactly the same. For example, not all bats vary the frequency of their clicks. Most do, and those are called FM, or frequency-modulated, bats. However, around 160 species use single-note calls. These bats are called CF, or constant-frequency bats. CF bats have evolved fascinating ways of using that single note to their advantage. I won’t go into any of that here—we’ve got too much territory left to cover—but if you want the details, check out “An Immense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden World Around Us” by Ed Yong.12 It’s a great book and one of the main resources for this post.

What I’ve given you in this section is a very condensed and simplified introduction to bat echolocation. I encourage you to read Yong’s book to learn more. There are a couple of other things I’d like to mention, though. First, bat clicks are very loud. The call of a big brown bat can be 138 decibels—about as loud as a siren. Of course, since we’re talking about ultrasound, we can’t hear them—undoubtedly, a good thing! But how, you might ask, does the bat avoid going deaf from its own calls? Each time they make a call, they contract the muscles of their middle ears to muffle the sound, then relax them to listen for the echoes. Even more remarkably, bats are able to adjust the sensitivity of their ears as they get closer to an insect, so that they percieve the echoes at the same steady loudness. This probably helps to stabilize their hearing.13

The other thing I wanted to mention is something that at first glance might seem like a contradiction. Sometimes, when people have barricaded cave entrances to limit access, they’ve later found the bodies of bats that accidentally flew into the barricades. Similarly, if you see a bat flying around overhead and toss a small pebble into the air, the bat will often catch the pebble, thinking that it’s a bug. If bat echolocation is so sophisticated, why do they make such seemingly dumb mistakes?

Probably because they aren’t paying attention. Focusing takes energy. A small object sailing through the air is a lot more likely to be a bug than a pebble, so why bother checking? As for that barricaded cave entrance, when large numbers of bats enter or exit a cave at the same time, if they’re all echolocating, they’re going to have a very hard time distinguishing the echoes of their own calls from the calls and echoes of the other bats. Fortunately, they don’t need to. They’ve probably flown in and out of that cave hundreds of times. They know it like the backs of their wings. So, again, it’s not that they’re bad at echolocation, they’re just not paying attention. That barricade has never been there before, so they aren’t expecting it.

Human Echolocation

Seeing with sound is such an alien-sounding concept that it hardly seems possible. But remarkably, there are human beings who have learned to do it! As a newborn, David Kish had an aggressive form of eye cancer that left him blind by the age of 13 months. (In fact, both his eyes had to be removed.) Shortly thereafter, he started clicking with his tongue. By the age of two, he was crawling out of his crib and exploring the house, using his self-taught ability to echolocate. One night, he even crawled out of his bedroom window, dropped into a flower bed, and wandered around outside, clicking all the while. He remembers sensing the chain-link fence around his backyard and the house on the other side. He climbed that fence and others until, finally, a neighbor called the police, who took him back home.

Kish is now in his 50s. When he walks around outside his home, he uses a long cane to sense objects at ground level but uses clicks to locate everything else. And locate he does! Ed Yong, author of “An Immense World”, describes how Kish accurately narrated everything they passed as they walked around his neighborhood. He easily located houses, porches, shrubbery, and parked cars, and when they came to a place where a large tree branch had overgrown the sidewalk, Kish knew to duck under it.

Kish and people like him offer at least some push-back to Nagel’s assertion that we can never know what it’s like to be a bat, because, as Yong points out, Kish has language. So, even if he can’t explain what it’s like to be a bat, he can explain “what it’s like to be Kish”.14 According to Kish, when he clicks, “he gets a series of `’flashes’, like matches being struck in the dark, each one briefly illuminating the world around him.” Objects that return sharp echoes, like stone walls and glass panes, Kish describes as “bright”. Objects that return coarser echoes, such as foliage and rough stones, are “dark”. (Although, he has no memory of what it was like to see, he naturally uses the language of sight because that’s the language used by the sighted people around him.)15

Bugs Fight Back

For millions of years, bats have been eating bugs. Moths, being mostly nocturnal, are especially vulnerable. After reading about how good bats are at using echolocation to detect and then home in on flying insects, you might wonder how there are any moths left in the world. But millions of years of evolution have provided them with a few defenses.

First, they’re covered with scales. For some readers, this might come as a surprise. Moths certainly don’t look very scaly. However, if you look at a moth wing under a microscope, you’ll see what I mean. Their wings, and often their entire body, are covered in thousands of microscopic scales. These scales are useful in several of ways, but the one that concerns us here is their effect on a bat’s echolocation. Because the scales are so tiny and so numerous, they function as a soft, powdery, sound-absorbing coating, muffling the echoes of the calls.16

Painted tiger moth (Arachnis picta)
Jamul, CA 10/25/22
The color patterns on the moth are created by thousands of minute scales. The next couple of images show closeups of the scales.
A closeup of the wing of the moth in the last photo.
A closer view of the scales

Moths are not limited to passive defenses. More than half of moth species have evolved ears capable of hearing bat calls.17 In fact, that’s the only thing they’re used for. And they give the moths a significant advantage. When a bat emits a call, it has to wait for the sound to travel to the moth and back again. The moth, meanwhile, only has to hear the incoming sound. While the bat is still waiting for the echo, the moth can begin evasive maneuvers. Also, the sound that reaches the moth is much stronger than its echo, so the moth might have even more time to react before the bat detects it (or detects its latest dodge).18

Some moths have ears for detecting bats, but can’t be bothered with evasive maneuvers. Tiger moths in the family Arctiidae have a pair of drum-like organs on their thorax (chest area).19 When a tiger moth hears a bat, it vibrates these organs at high-speed, producing ultrasonic clicks that literally jam the bat’s sonar! Many tiger moths also contain chemicals that make them taste bad. In this case, the clicks also serve as a warning, letting the bat know that they aren’t worth eating.20

Yet another strategy moths have evolved is the ability to create illusions. Luna moths are large insects with lime-green wings that end in long streamers. I used to see them occasionally when I lived in Virginia.

Luna moth (Actias luna)
Tulsa, Oklahoma
author: woodleywonderworks
source: Luna
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

Luna moths don’t have ears, and they don’t have any fancy, sonar-jamming organs. What they do have are long tails that flutter and spin behind them as they fly. Somehow, the tails produce echoes that trick bats into attacking them instead of the moth’s body. The moth might lose its tails, but it can live just fine without them (as long as it doesn’t run into another bat).21

Dolphins Go High (in Their Own Special Way)22

As far as we know, only two major groups of animals have developed echolocation. We’ve already covered one of them: bats. The other group is dolphins.

Bats and dolphins are both mammals, which means they have a lot in common, but they also have some very obvious differences. Bats are small, flying animals that live on land. Dolphins are much larger and spend their entire lives in the water. Dolphins and most bats echolocate, but they evolved that ability independently. So, it’s to be expected that they would go about it somewhat differently.

Scientists first discovered echolocation in bats. In 1947, Arthur McBride, the curator of Marine Studios (later Marineland) in Florida, noticed that bottlenose dolphins were able to avoid nets in the dark. This made him wonder if they might be using some form of echolocation. Other scientists conducted research that proved McBride’s hypothesis.23

Dolphins are technically a type of whale—they belong to the group Odontoceti or odontocetes, aka toothed whales. The other members of this group, including such fan-favorites as sperm whales, orcas, and narwhals, also echolocate. All other whales belong to the group Mysticeti or baleen whales. They don’t need to echolocate, since they’re filter feeders. (Except that maybe they do. See the section “Whales Go Long” later in this article.) 24 25

Whales evolved from land animals. As their ancestors gradually adapted to marine life, their noses migrated to the tops of their heads and became blowholes. In the nasal cavity just below the blowhole, whales have two pairs of organs called phonic lips. These evolved from what was originally the nostrils. By forcing air past the phonic lips, the dolphin sets them to vibrating. The sound travels forward through a large, fatty organ called the melon. This organ focuses the sound, producing the clicks the dolphin uses for echolocation. The melon is also what gives dolphins their bulging brows.

Note that no vocal cords are involved in the production of the clicks. In fact, dolphins no longer have functional vocal cords. All that’s left of them are structures called vocal folds, and these lost the ability to make sound millions of years ago.26 So, a dolphin’s click begins in its nose and passes out through its forehead—a very different strategy from that of a bat, whose clicks begin in the throat and exit through the mouth or nose.

Dolphins (and other toothed whales) also capture returning echoes in a novel way. Part of a dolphin’s lower jaw is hollow with very thin walls and is filled with the same fats found in the melon. When the echoes arrive at the jaw, these fats channel the sound to the inner ear. In Ed Yong’s words, “A dolphin is an echolocator that clicks with its nose and listens with its jaw.”27

This beautifully-simple animation shows how a dolphin’s ping originates in its phonic lips and is focused by the melon. The returning echo is channeled through its lower jaw toward the inner ear.
Author: Malene Thyssen
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled GNU Free Documentation License.
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Despite major differences in the way they generate sounds and intercept echos, dolphins use their clicks in much the same way as bats. They manage the duration and frequency of their calls so that they don’t overlap with the returning echoes. They produce shorter clicks closer together when they need a more detailed ‘view’. They even adjust the sensitivity of their ears to avoid being deafened by their own calls and so that returning echos are all heard at the same steady volume.

But living in water allows dolphins to do things with their sonar that bats can only dream of. Sound travels faster and farther in water than in air, so dolphin echolocation has a much greater range than a bat’s. A dolphin’s large size also allows it to channel more energy into its calls. A bottlenose dolphin’s click can contain 40,000 times more energy than that of a big brown bat!

One thing that living in water allows dolphins to do is downright mind-blowing. Sound waves traveling through a substance (water, air, or whatever) tend to reflect back when they encounter another substance that has a greater density. If the new substance is dense enough, then most of the wave will be reflected. If it’s not that much denser, then only some of the sound is reflected (i.e. a weak echo is produced.) If the new substance has exactly the same density as the original substance, then the sound wave won’t be reflected at all.

Now, here comes the cool part. You’ve probably heard that your body is mostly water. The same is true of other animals. So, animal bodies have about the same density as water. Water is much denser than air, so when a ping from a bat encounters an insect, the insect’s body produces a strong echo. But dolphins live in water, so when a dolphin produces a click, it travels through the water, hits a fish whose body is not much denser than the surrounding water, and continues traveling into the fish’s body. Of course, the body of the fish is a little denser than the surrounding water, so some of the sound does get reflected back, but a large part of it continues on. And when that part hits a bone… Well, bone is quite dense, so most of the sound gets reflected back.

You can probably see where this is going. The returning echos don’t just carry information about the fish’s shape and texture. They allow the dolphin to perceive what’s inside the fish! In short, dolphin echolocation is very much akin to x-ray vision!

It’s hard to exaggerate the significance of this. If you go swimming with dolphins, they can see your lungs and skeleton. If you’re pregnant, they can probably see the fetus. Dolphins can perceive the swim bladders of the fish they eat. They can almost certainly identify the type of fish by the shape of its bladder. They can tell when a fish has a metal hook in it. In Hawaii, false killer whales will steal tuna off fishing lines, deftly avoiding being caught by the hooks themselves, presumably because they can “see” where the hooks are located in the fish.

The skulls of beaked whales (a type of toothed whale) are often decorated with crests, bumps, and ridges. These weird growths are invisible to us unless we dissect the whale—the head is perfectly smooth from the outside—but they would be easily detected by another whale’s echolocation. So, what are they for? A clue perhaps can be found in the fact that they are often only found in the males. Could they be sexual displays, used to attract mates? Normally, we would expect such displays to be on the outside of the body, but when your potential mates all have x-ray vision…

Yet another advantage to echolocating in water is something we briefly touched on earlier: greater range. Sounds travel farther in water before they dissipate too much to be useful. A flying bat typically has less than a second to decide what to do when it encounters a possible target. A swimming odontocete has more like 10 seconds. As Yong so eloquently puts it, “A bat must always react. A whale can plan.”28

This extra time also allows them to work together. At night, spinner dolphins hunt their prey in teams of up to 28 individuals. When they find a group of fish or squid, they form a tight row and plow into their prey, forcing them to crowd together. Then they surround them and take turns darting in from opposite sides to snap them up. The dolphins coordinate the sequence of their movements with precision, and they’re more likely to click when transitioning between steps in the sequence.

Spinner dolphins are obviously using echolocation to coordinate their movements, but exactly how they’re using it isn’t clear. Are they sending commands? Are they tracking each others positions? Are they able to use each other’s echoes to extend their own sense of their surroundings? We don’t yet know.

Elephants Go Low29 30 31

In 1984, zoologist Katy Payne was observing Asian elephants at the Portland Zoo, when she felt an unusual vibration in the air. This led her to suspect that the pachyderms might be using infrasound to communicate. (Infrasound is the opposite of ultrasound—its frequency is too low for us to hear.) Payne and her colleagues were able to confirm her suspicions by showing that the elephants changed their behaviors when exposed to recorded infrasonic calls, and they did so in ways that couldn’t be explained in any other way.

Payne and other researchers have gone on to spend many years studying infrasonic communication in elephants. It’s now known that elephants can produce lower-frequency sounds than any other land animal. They can also produce and detect sounds over a wider range than any other nonhuman mammal. Human hearing has a range of roughly 20Hz to 20,000Hz. In one study, a female elephant was shown to respond to frequencies from 17Hz to 10,500Hz. Other studies have found that elephants can respond to frequencies lower than 10Hz!

Scientists have shown that much of elephant communication occurs in the infrasonic. It’s possible that most of it does. But how and why did elephants evolve to communicate at such low frequencies?

Elephants evolved mostly in forested habitats. In dense forest, a relatively large animal like an elephant can’t rely on vision to keep track of other members of its group. So, early elephants evolved keen senses of smell and hearing to compensate. Hearing must have been especially important for communication.

But why favor low-frequency sounds over high-frequency? Partly, it could have been just a matter of anatomy. It’s hard to imagine a big animal making high-pitched squeaks or chirps. Deep, barrel chests are just more suited to low-pitched calls. But setting anatomy aside, low-frequency sound is just better suited to communicating in a dense forest. It passes easily through thick vegetation that would quickly dissipate higher frequencies. And the lower the frequency, the better, allowing a herd to spread out widely and still keep in touch.

Why Stop At Ears?32

When an elephant emits a low-frequency call, it doesn’t just set the air vibrating—the earth itself vibrates in response. The sound of the call travels through both air and earth. So, another elephant doesn’t just detect the sound as it passes from the air to its eardrums, it also detects the sound as it passes from the ground to its feet! That’s right, elephants hear with their feet!

What good, you might ask, does it do an elephant to hear two versions of the same call? Sound travels at different speeds through different mediums. In general, it travels faster in liquids and solids than through gases like air.33 So, the sound of the call reaches the elephant’s feet before it reaches its ears.

You might have heard that you can estimate the distance to a thunderstorm by counting the seconds between a flash of lightning and the crack of thunder that follows it. Since light travels so much faster than sound, the flash gets to you almost instantly. Sound, on the other hand, takes roughly 5 seconds to travel a mile in air.34 So, divide the time between the flash and the crack by 5 and you’ve got the approximate distance to the storm.

Similarly, when an elephant hears a call with its feet and then hears the same call with its ears a short time later, this allows it to estimate how far away the other elephant must be. Maybe this is inate or maybe it’s learned. Either way, the elephant gets an idea how far away the other elephant is.

At the same time, sound waves traveling through the air generally arrive at one of the elephant’s ears before the other one, giving the elephant an idea of the direction that the call is coming from. This isn’t anything out of the ordinary. We sense the direction of sounds the same way. However, by combining these two pieces of information—distance and direction—the elephant ends up with a pretty good idea of where the other elephant is in relation to itself!

I should mention that elephants probably don’t just detect sounds traveling through the ground by the touch sensors in their feet, although they do have a high concentration of such sensors in their foot pads. There’s also evidence that sound travels by bone conduction from their feet to their ears. So to some extent, they probably hear the sound coming from the ground with their ears, as well.

Before we move on, I want to mention one other interesting tidbit—elephants can hear clouds. Storm clouds, anyway. Apparently, storm clouds produce sounds at a frequency that’s below the range of human hearing, but not of elephant hearing. In a 2015 study, seven years’ worth of GPS data on the movements of elephants in 14 different herds was compared to weather data for the same region and period. In several instances, elephants in different areas all moved in the direction of the infrasound coming from distant storms.35 36

In 2013, I visited an elephant sanctuary in Thailand. It’s a place where they take care of elephants that have been injured or abused. Visitors can feed them (like the little girl is doing in these two pics) and “bathe” them (the elephant stood in the river, and we threw buckets of water on them.) If you go, make sure you pick a place that doesn’t let you ride the elephants. I’m sure that would be great fun, but it’s very bad for the elephant.
Another view. Somehow, sometime, I’m going to have to find a way to work elephant trunks into a blog post. Extraordinary animals!

Whales Go Long

We covered toothed whales or odontocetes in an earlier section, where we learned that they echolocate using ultrasound. The other whale group, the mysticetes or baleen whales, followed a different route. They evolved to use infrasound.

Mysticetes feed on tiny crustaceans called krill, which is a bit weird, given that mysticetes are themselves massive creatures. They include the blue whale, the largest animal on Earth. Obviously, one or two krill isn’t going to be much of a meal for such an animal. A baleen whale searches for huge swarms of krill, and when it finds one, it opens its mouth wide and engulfs as much of the swarm as it can, filtering out the krill and expelling the water. It filters the krill using baleen—bristle-like structures made of the same material as our fingernails.37

Krill are found all over the world, but they aren’t distributed evenly, so whales have to migrate long distances to find enough krill to sustain themselves. One whale, working alone, might have a hard time locating enough swarms, but what if a pod of whales could spread out over a wide area and let each other know when they find a good feeding area?

In 1971, biologist Roger Payne published two ground-breaking papers about baleen whales. The first introduced the public (and other scientists) to the haunting songs of humpback whales. These songs are low-pitched, but still within the hearing range of humans. (I suppose they could have an infrasound component, too, but I don’t know.) The second paper showed that fin whales—the second largest animals in the world—communicate using infrasound. Payne calculated how far a fin whale’s infrasonic call could travel in water. The answer he came up with was an astonishing 13,000 miles! To put this in context, the Pacific Ocean is only 12,300 miles across at its widest point!

Payne’s conclusion—that fin whales could communicate with other whales across an ocean—seemed so preposterous that other researchers scoffed at the idea. His career was almost ruined. Some people even questioned his sanity. Nevertheless, newer research supports Payne’s ideas. To be clear, we don’t know that the whales are actually communicating across that distance—it’s possible that they’re just using very loud calls to communicate with whales closer to them—but what would be the point of using louder calls than you need? Also, research has shown that blue and fin whales will repeat the same notes over and over at precise intervals. That kind of redundancy is often used by engineers when designing a system that will be used to communicate over very long distances. The Martian rovers, for example, use this strategy when sending data back to Earth.

I said earlier that baleen whales don’t use echolocation. But is that really true? A fin whale’s song can last for several seconds, and the wavelengths can be as long as a football field. If we could build a sonar system that used sound like that, we could map an entire ocean. And researchers have found evidence that whales could be doing just that. Blue whales have been observed traveling directly from polar waters to tropical Bermuda, singing as they go. Whales often swim directly from one landmark to another, even when those landmarks are hundreds of miles apart. Their movements certainly suggest that they have a mental map of the oceans—one they might have built up over their lifetimes using the echoes of their songs.

Songbirds Go Cryptic38

Bird songs are clearly audible to human ears, and we usually find them beautiful. But what does bird song sound like to a bird? The answer is a lot more complicated than you might expect.

For starters, birds seem to hear “faster” than we do. The song of a whip-poor-will, to our unaided hearing, has three notes. But if you slow it down, you’ll find that it actually has five. And when a mockingbird, which mimics the songs of other birds, mimics the song of a whip-poor-will, it mimics all five notes. So, the song sounds more complex to the mockingbird, and presumably to the whip-poor-will, than it does to us.

Researcher Robert Dooling performed a series of experiments that tested the ability of songbirds to distinquish between songs that differed only in their temporal fine structure. He presented the birds with two different buzzes. One of the buzzes consisted of chunks of sound that fell in pitch. That is, a chunk would start off high and end low, and the next chunk would repeat the pattern. The other buzz consisted of chunks that rose in pitch—each chunk started low and ended high. If the chunks were longer than three or four milliseconds, humans could detect the difference, but if the chunks were shorter than three milliseconds, they couldn’t. The birds tested performed better. Canaries and parakeets could distinguish between the buzzes until the chunks got down to one or two milliseconds, and zebra finches were able to tell the difference down to one millisecond, which was the limit of the researchers’ electronics! So, the birds could hear complexities that were too fast for human ears.

It’s interesting that songbirds are more sensitive to temporal fine structure than humans, but later experiments by some of Dooley’s colleagues and students produced more surprising results. A zebra finch always sings the same sequence of syllables, which we can represent as A-B-C-D-E. In one experiment, the researchers reversed one of the syllables: A-B-(reverse C)-D-E. Zebra finches almost always noticed the change, but humans couldn’t tell the difference. However, when the gap between two of the syllables was doubled, humans could hear the difference, but the zebra finches couldn’t.

Then things got really weird. Two of the students tried shuffling the order of the syllables: C-E-D-A-B. Unsurprisingly, the human listeners could easily tell the difference. But the zebra finches couldn’t.

Even though zebra finches always sing the same sequence of syllables for their entire life, they don’t actually care about (and apparently don’t even hear) the order of the syllables or the lengths of the gaps between them. The only thing that matters to them is the structure of the individual notes. And we humans can’t hear that structure. What does this mean? A zebra finch could be encoding all sorts of information in the fine structure of its song—sex, health, identity, who knows what—and to us it would sound like the exact same song repeated over and over again.

Owls Go Silent39 40

Owls are superbly adapted for hunting at night. In my earlier post The Story of Eyes: Part 2, I wrote briefly about the eyes of owls, which are some of the most unique eyes among vertebrates. Tubular, rather than globular, they act like telescopes, amplifying distance vision. And their huge size, taking up much of the owl’s head, allows them to collect as much light as possible.

But even on dark, moonless nights, an owl can still hunt. No, it doesn’t have echolocation. It depends on the faint sounds of its quarry—usually some luckless rodent—to tell it where to strike. Some species, like the great grey owl, can even snatch up small mammals hidden under a layer of snow.41

Let’s focus on barn owls, since they’re fairly representative of their ilk (and I happen to have pictures of one). We use the flaps of our ears to collect sound and funnel it towards our eardrums. Barn owls don’t have ear flaps. Instead, the stiff, dense feathers that make up their facial disk channel sound towards the ear holes. And the ear holes are enormous! In some owl species, if you part the feathers and look into the ear, you can see the backs of the eyeballs!

Barn owl (Tyto alba)
Dictionary Hill in Spring Valley, CA 5/13/23
A couple of rangers gave a talk about a red-tailed hawk and this barn owl that they have in captivity.

All this, plus a large eardrum and cochlea, give an owl very sensitive ears. But being able to hear the faint sounds of its prey isn’t enough. It needs to be able to pinpoint where the sounds are coming from. Since our ears are positioned on opposite sides of our skulls, a sound usually reaches one ear before the other. It’s also slight louder for that ear. This allows us to get an idea what direction the sound is coming from. This is true for owls, too. But because our ears are on the same level, sounds coming from above or below reach both ears at roughly the same time. In most owl species, the left ear is higher than the right. Having one ear positioned slightly above the other allows the owl to locate a sound’s source with much better accuracy. I couldn’t find a good, copyright-free image of an owl skull that showed the positions of the ear holes, so I’ll link you to an article with one. Click here to check it out.

Owls have one more feature that makes them formidable birds of prey: almost silent flight. I say feature, but it’s really a suite of features. First, they have large wings compared to their body mass, so they can fly very slowly with more gliding and less flapping. Second, they have comb-like serrations on the leading edge of their wing feathers. These break up the turbulance that’s responsible for much of the sound other birds make when they fly. Third, their feathers have a soft, velvety texture that further dampens the sound of their wings, as well as the sound that their body makes as it moves through the air. And fourth, they have a soft fringe on the trailing edge of the wings to break up the turbulance trailing behind. Almost silent flight has the obvious advantage of not alerting the owl’s prey, but it also makes it easier for the owl to detect faint sounds, since it doesn’t have to hear them over the sound of its own wing beats.42

The following video shows the same barn owl that was in the earlier photo. It’s in slow motion, but there is sound. You might have to turn the volume up on your computer or mobile device to tell. That’s just how quiet they are.

Journey of the Ossicles43 44 45

Terrestrial vertebrates—amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals—are called tetrapods because they have four legs. (Some of them, like snakes, have lost them, but that’s another story.) Tetrapods are descended from fish, so that’s where we need to start if we want to trace the evolution of their hearing. Fish have a number of ways to detect sound, including cilia (nerve hairs), swim bladders, ossicles, otoliths, and various mechanoreceptors. We’ll save all that for some future article. What we’re interested in here is their transition to land.

The first fish to make that transition probably didn’t have eardrums. Those seem to have evolved independently at least three, and maybe as many as six, times. Terrestrial vertebrates that lay their eggs on land (i.e. all of them that aren’t amphibians) are called amniotes.46 In early amniotes, the stapes bone was a large bone that was used to support the braincase. It couldn’t be used for hearing. However, there is evidence that by the Permian (298.9 to 251.9 million years ago), amniotes had evolved eardrums that connected the stapes to the inner ear. So, the stapes became the first of the three tiny bones called ossicles that modern mammals have in their inner ears. Reptiles and birds still have only the one ossicle.

The way mammals ended up with two extra ossicles is unexpected to put it mildly. When tetrapods first moved onto land, the organs that had allowed them to hear in water were useless for hearing in air. However, they could detect vibrations in the ground using the bones of their lower jaws. Those bones ended close to the ears, so when they laid their lower jaw on the ground (which those low-slung early tetrapods probably did most of the time), vibrations would pass from the ground to the ears through bone conduction. So, one could argue that they weren’t totally deaf, but they were certainly a long way off from having good hearing. As already noted, tetrapods did eventually evolve eardrums connected to the stapes bone, which was repurposed as part of the inner ear, and this gave them the ability to pick up sounds directly from the air.

At some point, the tetrapods split into two lineages—one that led to us mammals and another that led to all other amniotes. In the ancestors of mammals, the jawbones underwent some major changes. Figure 1 shows the jaw joints of an early mammal and a non-mammalian amniote.

Figure 1. Jaw joints in mammals and non-mammals
Author: Philcha
This image is in the public domain. Taken from the Wikipedia Commons page: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jaw_joint_-_mammal_n_non-mammal.png

Note that the lower jaw of the non-mammalian amniote consists of three bones, the articular, angular, and dentary bones, whereas the lower jaw of the mammal consists of just the dentary. Also, the upper jaw of the non-mammalian amniote has a large bone called the quadrate that was part of the jaw joint.

As the color coding in the images shows, the quadrate, articular, and angular bones are still present in the mammalian skull, but they’ve been greatly reduced in size, disconnected from the jaws, and repositioned. In fact, two of them—the articular and quadrate—have connected up with the stapes and become part of the inner ear! We now call them the malleus and incus, respectively. ‘Malleus’, ‘incus’, and ‘stapes’ are from the Latin and translate to ‘hammer’, ‘anvil’, and ‘stirrup’, respectively, which are the other common names for the ossicles. (In case you’re wondering, the other former jaw bone, the angular, now supports the eardrum and is called the ectotympanic bone, which is rarely mentioned.)

What drove this remarkable transformation is not fully understood, but it’s been proposed that mastication (chewing) provided the selective pressure. The reconfiguration of the bones allowed mammals to move their jaws from side to side, which is what makes chewing possible. And chewing was a great advance over just tearing up one’s food and gulping it down. But decoupling the ear from the jaw had another advantage. Hearing and mastication were now able to evolve independently.47

Having three ossicles in mammalian ears gave evolution more ‘knobs’ to play around with when fine tuning mammalian hearing. One result of this tuning, is that mammals are able to detect higher frequency sounds than reptiles and birds. They can also detect a wider range of frequencies overall.

To sum up, two things—the increased complexity of their inner ears and the decoupling of their hearing and chewing ‘modules’—have increased mammals’ evolvability or capacity to evolve.48

Kangaroo rat
San Diego County, CA 3/4/23
Kangaroo rats have such sensitive, and fast, ears that they can hear the strike of a rattlesnake, jump, turn in midair, and kick the snake with their powerful hind legs before making their escape.49

In Conclusion

As usual, this has been a long one. At least I resisted the temptation to break it up into two parts, like I did with eyes. There’s so much more material I could have covered. I already mentioned Ed Yong’s excellent book “An Emmense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us”. It covers, not only hearing, but many other animal senses. I can’t recommend it highly enough.

A Gallery of Galls

If you’re a hiker, you might be familiar with oak apples. These aren’t really apples, of course. They’re plant galls, and they’re caused by a tiny wasp.

A large “oak apple” on a scrub oak. Caused by the oak gall wasp or California gall wasp (Andricus quercuscalifornicus). This type of gall forms a hard, dry “shell” when it’s fully formed.
Harvey Moore Trail near Descanso, CA. San Diego County 7/3/22

A gall is a plant growth that’s caused by, and serves as home to, some other type of organism. Most gall-formers are insects, but they can also be mites, nematodes9, fungi, bacteria, viruses, rotifers,15 or phytoplasmas.18 41 The gall occupant or its parent initiates the growth of the gall, usually by injecting a substance into the plant that mimics the plant’s hormones, hijacking its cellular machinery. Once started, a gall might grow into its final form on its own, or it might need additional stimulation from its occupant(s).48

A gall can be very simple or highly-structured, and galls of many different shapes, sizes, textures, and colors can grow on the same species of plant. Somehow, the gall-former forces the plant to grow the gall to its own specifications!

Many types of galls are found on oak trees, and most of them are caused by wasps. The gall in the previous photo was caused by a California gall wasp (Andricus quercuscalifornicus).49 Here’s a photo of the wasp. It’s only 5 mm long.

The oak gall wasp (Andricus quercuscalifornicus)
Author: USGS Bee Inventory and Monitoring Lab from Beltsville, Maryland, USA
Source:
Andricus quercuscalifornicus usda buffington

This image is in the public domain in the United States because it only contains materials that originally came from the United States Geological Survey, an agency of the United States Department of the Interior. For more information, see the official USGS copyright policy.

Here’s a photo of another oak gall of the same type. This one was still soft, so I cut it open.

An oak apple caused by the California gall wasp (Andricus quercuscalifornicus).
San Diego County 7/9/22

Inside, I found a wasp larva.

A cross-section of the gall in the previous photo, showing a tiny wasp larva.
A closeup of the larva

How an Insect Causes a Gall

There are two ways an insect can initiate a gall. It can injure the plant’s cells, causing an unorganized mass of protective tissue called plant callus to grow at the site of the wound, 50 51 or it can inject some substance into the plant that “instructs” it to form a gall. This substance is most likely a cocktail of chemicals that mimic the hormones the plant uses to control its growth.

Sometimes an adult insect uses its ovipositor52 to inject a substance that stimulates the growth of the gall. It then lays one or more eggs at or near the site. When the eggs hatch, the larvae find their way into the growing gall (or the gall simply grows around them). Sometimes the adult insect uses its ovipositor to inject both the larvae and the gall-stimulating substance at the same time.

In other cases, it’s the larva itself that initiates the growth of the gall. Often, its saliva contains a gall-stimulating substance. Even if the adult insect initiates the gall, the chewing of the larvae might be necessary to keep it growing. In more complex galls, the gall’s structure changes as it grows. Presumably, this means that the chemicals in the gall-former’s saliva are also changing as the larva develops.

For an amazing timelapse video of an aphid gall forming, check out this link.

Galls can take on some very strange shapes. Take, for example, the gall of the crystalline gall wasp in the following photos.

Gall of a crystalline gall wasp (Andricus crystallinus) on a California scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia)
San Diego County 10/15/17
A closeup

There were some more galls on the same plant that were probably crystalline galls in earlier stages of development.

Some more galls on the same plant

Here are some more examples of crystalline galls.

Galls formed by the crystalline gall wasp (Andricus crystallinus) on a California scrub oak (Quercus berberidifolia)
San Diego County 10/6/22
A closer look at the galls from the last photo

In case you’re wondering, the two white, flower-shaped objects on the bottom leaf are not galls. They’re the pupal cases of a whitefly.

There is another type of gall in the photo, however. It’s in the fold of one of the leaves. I haven’t been able to identify it, but here are some closeups.

A closeup of the tiny, unidentified gall hidden among the crystalline galls in the last photo.
Closer still

What Counts as a Gall?53

I already defined galls earlier in the article, but to reiterate, galls are “growths on plants formed of plant tissue but caused by other organisms”.54 Of course, like most things in biology, it’s not quite that simple.

For starters, the host isn’t always a plant. It usually is, but it could also be a fungus, a lichen, or an alga. I won’t be covering any of those other, rarer, types of hosts, though. For the purposes of this blog post, gallers gall plants.

Also, the above definition isn’t complete. It’s not enough for an organism to cause a growth on a plant. It must also benefit in some way from that growth. It isn’t always easy to tell if this is the case. When an herbivore feeds on a plant, the damage alone is often enough to induce the plant to grow a different kind of tissue around the site of the injury ─ the plant callus I mentioned earlier. Usually, a galler or its parent injects substances into the plant to control the grow of new tissue, but not always. Sometimes the galler simply benefits from feeding on the callus, and that’s enough to classify the callus tissue as a gall.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, some galls can be quite complex, consisting of multiple layers, some nutritive, others protective. Often, the substances injected by the organism cause the plant to divert extra resources to the gall, making it (or a layer within it) more nutritious than other parts of the plant.

The fuzzy, little round gall in the next photo was formed by the aptly-named round-gall wasp, Burnettweldia washingtonensis.55

Burnettweldia washingtonensis gall on an oak
Oakoasis County Preserve, San Diego County 7/2/22
A closeup

Looking back at some of my pics on bugguide.net, I found a series of photos from 2018 of what looks like an older Burnettweldia washingtonensis gall. It was on a scrub oak, and it was definitely caused by some kind of gall wasp. I know this because when I cut it open, I found the wasp pupating inside! This was in February, so this species of wasp probably overwinters as a pupa inside the gall and exits as an adult in Spring.

A gall wasp gall on a scrub oak. This may be a Burnettweldia washingtonensis gall ─ the same kind shown in the earlier series of photos, but from later in the year.
Encinitas, CA 2/24/28

When I first cut the gall open, I was perplexed to find what appeared to be a loose nut inside. When I cut the “nut” open, I found the pupa.

The same gall cut open

The nut was actually a hardened inner layer of material ─ an “inner gall” ─ that formed around the pupa to protect it. This layer probably formed after the larva consumed all the tissue in the nutritive layer and decided it was time to pupate. The inner gall forms loose inside the outer gall because this makes it more difficult for a parasitoid56 to attack the pupa. The parasitoid uses its long, thin ovipositor to bore through the outer gall without too much problem, but when it tries to get a purchase on the inner gall, it’s like trying to spear a grape with a fork.

Here are several photos showing the wasp pupa from different angles.

The inner gall and the wasp pupa
Another view
And another

A spined turban gall wasp (Cynips douglasii) formed this next gall on the underside of an oak leaf.

Gall of a spined turban gall wasp (Cynips douglasii)
San Diego County 7/2/22
Another view

Types of Galls

Many kinds of plants are galled by many kinds of organisms. And, as we’ve seen, those galls can be very simple or very complex. There are several other ways that galls differ from each other.

First, different types of gall form on different parts of the plant. Some galls only grow on roots, for example. Others only grow on stems, leaves, buds, or flowers.57

Second, galls vary in size. They can be almost microscopic or bigger than your head.

Finally, and perhaps most obviously, they vary in form ─ from a simple swelling to a round ball to weird grows like the crystalline galls we saw earlier.

A particular organism doesn’t necessarily cause only one type of gall. Many insects, for example, have alternate generations ─ usually, a sexual one and an asexual one (where the insect reproduces without mating). Sometimes one of the generations forms galls and the other doesn’t. In other cases, both generations form galls, but on different types of plants, or on different parts of the same type of plant, or even on different parts of different types of plant.

Scientists who study galls (and who are called cecidologists) have come up with many descriptive terms for them. What follows is a list of some of the most common ones. I’m not going to show you examples of each one ─ that would make this post way too long. If you’re interested, check out “Plant Galls” by Margaret Redfern. Much of the info in this article comes from that book.

Fasciations, phyllathies, phyllodies, and virescences ─ Plants sometimes exhibit weird growth patterns called fasciations, which are caused by errors in their development. These can be genetic errors or they can result from environmental factors. If they aren’t caused by other organisms, then they don’t count as galls.58 A few organisms, however, cause fasciations and feed on them. These do count as galls.

A phyllody, to quote Wikipedia, is “the abnormal development of floral parts into leafy structures. It is generally caused by phytoplasma or virus infections, though it may also be because of environmental factors that result in an imbalance in plant hormones.”59

Phyllathy seems to be just another word for phyllody.

Virescences are “oddly shaped parts of plants, where shoots, roots, leaves, or flower parts are distorted, multiplied or bunched together.”60 When they occur on trees, virescenses are sometimes called witches’ brooms. Phyllodies are a type of virescence.

Solid swellings ─ These can be single enlarged cells in algae. In plants, they can be much larger ─ up to a meter or more on trees.61 Crown gall is a plant disease caused by the bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens. It results in tumor-like growths up to a foot in diameter on more than 600 different plant species, including both woody and herbacious plants.62 This is one way in which bacterial gallers differ from most other types of gall-formers. Most gallers gall only one or a few types of plants.

Erinea galls ─ Simple, hairy galls caused by eriophyid mites. The mites live among the hairs. Erinea galls often look like patches of velvet on the undersides of leaves. Sometimes they are reddish in color.63

Folds and rolls ─ These are simple leaf galls. The galler causes the edge of the leaf to fold over or roll up. It does this by stimulating cells on one side of the leaf to proliferate more than those on the other side.64 The galler benefits from the protection that the fold or roll provides, so, simple as they are, these do count as galls. Many types of mites and insects cause fold or roll galls.65

Pits, blisters, and pouches ─ These, like folds, rolls, and erinea galls, are open galls. And, like folds and rolls, they are fairly simple distortions of the leaf. Various mites and insects cause these types of galls.66

Big buds, cigars, pineapples, and rosettes67 ─ These types are lumped together because they all develop in buds, and they all form from young modified leaves that bunch together because their petioles (leaf stems) fail to develop. These are open galls. The mites or insects that cause them escape through openings between the leaves. Pineapple galls are sort of an exception. These are temporarily sealed, but changes in the gall tissue eventually provide openings for the insects to escape.

Closed chambered galls ─ These galls, as the name suggests, contain one or more closed chambers in which the gall-former(s) reside. These tend to be the most highly-structured types of galls.68

Burro-weed (Ambrosia dumosa), aka white bursage, is a type of ragweed that grows in the desert.69 The next two photos show an interesting gall that I found on a burro-weed. I think the gall-former is Procecidochares kristineae, a type of tephritid fly.70

A gall on burro-weed (Ambrosia dumosa), probably caused by Procecidochares kristineae.
Sonoran Desert, San Diego County 11/26/22
Another view

Cutting it open, I found that the occupant had already pupated and left, leaving behind its pupal skin.

Inside the gall. The dark object in the left section is the pupal skin. It was just a dry husk.

The Australian eucalyptus leafgall wasp (Ophelimus maskelli) galls the leaves of eucalytus trees. The galls are tiny red swellings.71

A eucalyptus leaf almost covered with galls of the Australian eucalyptus leafgall wasp (Ophelimus maskelli)
San Diego County, California, USA 11/5/22

Let’s zoom in on a few of those galls.

A closeup
Closer still

I used an x-acto knife to slice one of the galls open, and to my surpise, I managed to do it without injuring the baby wasp inside.

This isn’t the first time I’ve seen these particular galls. Back in May of 2020, I collected some eucalyptus leaves with galls, most of which had exit holes.

Empty O. maskelli galls on a eucalyptus leaf
San Diego County 5/4/20

A few still had the insect inside, though. I managed to capture this adult wasp after it exited one of the galls.

Australian eucalyptus leafgall wasp (Ophelimus maskelli)
San Diego County 5/4/20

Manzanita (genus Arctostaphylos) is a very common plant in the chaparral of Southern California. Occasionally, you’ll come across one that’s absolutely covered in bright red fold galls. These are caused by Manzanita leaf gall aphids (Tamalia coweni). They mostly form on the edges of leaves, but they can also form on midribs and on the inflorescenses (flower clusters).72

Fold galls formed by Manzanita leaf gall aphids (Tamalia coweni)
San Diego County 7/10/16
A closeup of a couple of galls on the same leaf
A small fly on one of the galls. I don’t know of any association between the fly and the gall, I just like the photo.

Here are some more aphid galls on a manzanita. I saw these in Tulare County in central California.

Aphid galls on manzanita
Tulare County, CA 7/10/16
A cross-section of one of the galls
A slightly closer look
One of the aphids
Another aphid

I found the next gall on a cottonwood tree. It was formed by poplar leaf-petiole gall aphids (Pemphigus populicaulis)73

Gall of poplar leaf-petiole gall aphid (Pemphigus populicaulis)
San Diego County 11/29/17

Aphids in various stages of development were inside. The winged one is an adult.

The same gall cut open

Here’s a gall I found on a California sagebrush (Artemisia californica). The gall-former is probably a gall midge74 in the genus Rhopalomyia.

Gall on California sagebrush (Artemisia californica), probably caused by Rhopalomyia sp., a gall midge.
San Diego County 2/24/19
Another view
A closeup

This next gall was on a Great Basin sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata). It was caused by a sponge gall midge (Rhopalomyia pomum). The gall was, indeed, soft and spongy.

Gall caused by a sponge gall midge (Rhopalomyia pomum) on Great Basin sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata)
San Diego County 4/28/18

One of the most common plants in the Sonoran Desert is the creosote bush (Larrea tridentata).75 It’s not uncommon to see these unusual-looking galls on them. They are caused by creosote gall midges in the genus Asphondylia.

Gall on a creosote bush (Larrea tridentata). Caused by a gall midge, Asphondylia sp.
Sonoran Desert, San Diego County 12/16/17
A closeup

This next gall was formed by a wasp on a wild rose.

Diplolepis sp. gall on a wild rose
Northern San Diego County 4/28/18

Nancy Asquith on bugguide.net identified the gall-former as “definitely Diplolepis“. She thinks it was probably a spiny leaf gall wasp (Diplolepis polita), which is very common in California. This type of gall would normally have many long spikes instead of one short one. Ms. Asquith thinks that it could have been a D. polita gall altered by inquilines.

And what’s an inquiline, you ask…

Gall Ecosystems

According to Wikipedia, an inquiline is “an animal that lives commensally in the nest, burrow, or dwelling place of an animal of another species.”76 So, in the context of galls, an inquiline is an animal that moves into the gall after the gall-former forms it. The “commensally” part of the definiton means that the inquiline neither benefits nor harms the gall-former.

In fact, entire ecosystems of organisms often form inside a gall. In addition to inquilines, there are parasites, parasitoids, and predators. A parasite feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants) without killing it; a parasitoid feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants) and eventually kills it; a predator feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants), kills it, and then moves on to prey on another occupant (or an occupant of another gall, or something else entirely). Some predators eat one or more of the occupants and then feed on the gall itself.

Of course, gall occupants are not just fed on by other occupants. Birds and mice will break open galls to get to the insects inside. Herbivores like caterpillars will feed on a gall and unintentionally eat the occupants in the process.

Even if the gall-formers make it to adulthood and exit the gall, other organisms might move in later. If nothing else, empty galls eventually serve as food for bacteria and fungi.

Some species of sawfly are gallers of willows. The next series of photos show galls of the willow apple gall sawfly (Pontania californica).

Galls of willow apple gall sawflies (Pontania californica)
San Diego County 8/20/22
The same galled leaf showing the top (dorsal) surface.
The bottom (ventral) surface.
A section through one of the galls. You can see that it has cavities for multiple larvae. One of the larvae is visible.

And here’s a live oak apple gallfly gall on a live oak.

Gall of live oak apple gallfly (Callirhytis quercuspomiformis)
San Diego County 9/24/17

The beaked twig gall wasp (Disholcaspis plumbella) makes brightly-colored galls. This one is a bit out-of-focus, sadly. It has three exit holes, so it looks like at least some of the occupants have already left.

Gall of a beaked twig gall wasp (Disholcaspis plumbella) on a scrub oak
San Diego County 9/24/17

This gall on coyote brush (Baccharis pilularis) was caused by a gall midge ─ probably a coyote brush bud gall midge (Rhopalomyia californica).

Gall midge gall on coyote brush
San Diego County 7/16/22
Another view. Lots of exit holes, so it must have had multiple occupants.

I think that what looks like long, whitish husks protruding from a few of the holes are the exuviae (discarded exoskeletons) left behind by adult midges emerging from the gall.77

This is a bud gall, meaning that it formed from tissue that would have formed into a bud if the galler hadn’t gotten there first. You can see in the cross-section below that it has a structure similar to a bud. I didn’t find any larvae or pupae inside, but a small larval cavity is visible in the right half.

A very common plant in my area is another species of baccharis ─ broom baccharis (Baccharis sarothroides).78 It’s also frequently galled by midges. I see them very often on my local hikes.

Unidentified gall midge galls on broom baccharis (Baccharis sarothroides).
San Diego County 7/6/22

I don’t know what caused the galls on this leaf. Possibly mites.

Unidentified galls. I think the plant is called basket bush.
San Diego County 10/7/17

The vast majority of gallers are parasites. In other words, the galler benefits from the relationship, but the host plant is harmed by it. Sometimes the damage is severe. A galled plant might be stunted or produce fewer seeds. If the infestation is bad enough, it might even die. In other cases, the plant hardly seems to notice.79

It’s very rare for gallers to form mutualistic relationships with a host, but it does happen. One well-known example is the fig wasp.

Fig Wasps80 81

Fig wasps are wasps that spend their larval stage in figs. There are many different kinds of fig wasps, but the ones we’re interested in are in the family Agaonidae. These are the ones that act as pollinators for fig trees. The trees cannot reproduce without the wasps and the wasps cannot reproduce without the trees, so this is a clear case of mutualism.

A fig is not actually a fruit. It’s a syconium. An article on the Britannica website describes it as an “urn-shaped inflorescence”. The article goes on to explain that the syconium probably originated from the “invagination of a flat flower-bearing capitulum”.82 Maybe you’re having trouble making sense of this explanation, so let’s dissect it a bit.

An inflorescense is a cluster of flowers on a stem.

A capitulum is “An inflorescence that consists of closely packed flowers or florets which have no stalks and arise on a flattened axis, all at the same level.”83

An invagination is a surface that has folded into itself to form a cavity, pouch, or tube.84

So, Britannica seems to be saying figs evolved from an inflorescense of small, tightly-packed flowers that folded in on itself to form a pouch with the flowers inside. This makes sense because unripe figs actually do have flowers inside them! So, where do the wasps come in?

A female wasp enters a fig through a small opening. She has to force her way through this opening, and, in the process, she usually loses her wings and most of her antennae. In other words, she won’t be leaving. A female fig wasp only gets to pollinate one fig.

Once inside, the wasp lays eggs on some of the flowers. A flower that has an egg deposited on it develops a gall instead of a seed. The wasp deposits pollen that she picked up from her “home” fig (the one she hatched out in) on some of the other flowers.

When a male fig wasp hatches out of a gall, it searches in the same fig for galls containing females. When he finds one, he chews a hole in it and mates with the unhatched female. That’s right… the unhatched female. The female emerges from her gall already pregnant. The male dies inside the fig, but before he does (in many species, at least) he chews an escape hole for the female. When females emerge from their galls, they crawl over ungalled flowers on their way to the exit holes, picking up pollen as they go. Once outside the fig, they waste no time looking for a new, unripe fig in which to lay their eggs and die. What a life!

There are many kinds of fig wasps in the family Agaonidae. The description that I just gave of the fig wasp life cycle is somewhat generalised. Details vary from species to species. If you want to do some further reading, a good place to start is the Britannica article that I referenced earlier. It’s short, but it has a nice illustration of the life cycle. Click here to read it.

The Evolution of Gall-forming

Unsurprisingly, we don’t know a lot about how gall-forming evolved. One thing that’s certain is that it arose independently many times.85 Despite this, gall-forming is not all that common an adaptation. Apparently, it’s a successful enough strategy to have evolved many times, but not successful enough to be the “go-to” strategy for any large group like mites or insects.86

Although we don’t know many details, it’s not hard to imagine how an organism might evolve to form galls. At least, this is how I imagine it…

When an insect larva feeds on plant tissue, the plant typically responds by growing callus tissue87 to cover the wound. This might be a better source of nutrients than the regular tissue, so the insect proceeds to feed on it. Maybe some chemical in the larva’s saliva happens to stimulate the plant to change something about the way it grows this tissue. If the change is beneficial, the insect’s descendants are more likely to survive and more likely to keep secreting that substance in their saliva. Then, maybe a mutation occurs that causes a new chemical to be included in their saliva. If it also proves beneficial, the new mutation might be retained. And so on. Insects use many chemicals that are simular to plant hormones (they probably have similar evolutionary origins), so it’s not as unlikely as it might sound.

Similarly, if an insect lays an egg by injecting it into plant tissue, various substances get injected along with it. Some of these substances are probably meant to protect the egg from the plant’s defences, for example. A side effect of some of the substances might be to alter the way the plant grows tissue in the vicinity of the egg. Maybe this altered tissue benefits the larva in some way. And so on.

This just my take on how gall-forming might have evolved.

Evolution of gall morphology is affected by the pressure put on the gall-formers by their enemies. For example, an insect deep inside a large gall is often safer than an insect in a small gall or one farther from the center, simply because it’s harder for parasites, parasitoids, and small predaters to get to them. On the other hand, a large gall is more conspicuous, so there’s more chance that a large predator, such as a bird, will notice it.88 So, it’s a give and take. The gall-former will evolve in whichever direction gives the best results.89

Addendum

In the short time that’s passed since I published this article, I’ve already found a number of new galls. Also, my friend, Meridith Erickson, sent me a great photo that she took of a large, old oak apple. So, I figured I’d add a section at the end of the post for new photos.

I’ll start with Meridith’s photo.

Meridith photographed this gall while hiking in Daley Ranch ─ a preserve in Escondido, California (San Diego County). 12/3/22
Lots of exit holes in this one.
Photograph © Meridith Erickson. Used with permission.
Here, I’ve zoomed in on the top of the gall, where it looks like something tried to chew its way in.
Photograph © Meridith Erickson. Used with permission.

This next gall was on the stem of a grass called big galleta (Hilaria rigida). I haven’t been able to identify it, yet. It was a large gall ─ around an inch long.

Unidentified gall on Hilaria rigida.
Colorado Desert, San Diego County 1/29/23
Another view
The same gall cut open

I found this gall on a California sagebrush (Artemisia californica). It was about a quarter of an inch long.

Unidentified gall on California sagebrush (Artemisia californica)
San Diego County 2/7/23
Another view

When I cut it open, I found the larva still inside. I think it’s probably some kind of gall midge larva, but I’m not sure.

Cut open
A closeup of the larva

A Most Disparaged Plant

“In spring, the ivory flowers bloom on the sunny hill or in sheltered glade, in summer its fine green leaves contrast refreshingly with dried and tawny grassland, in autumn its colors flame more brilliantly than in any other native, but one great fault, its poisonous juice, nullifies its every other virtue and renders this beautiful shrub the most disparaged of all within our region.” – John Howell82

Most of the people I hike with aren’t especially cognizant of the botanical life around them. If a flower is unusually pretty they might notice. They might even comment on it. For the most part, though, they hike for the scenery, the exercise, and the companionship.

One plant that does get a lot of attention, however, is poison oak. Whenever a patch is spotted, someone is sure to deliver a warning to the rest of the group. “Watch out, poison oak!” is a common refrain. I can’t really blame them. A poison oak rash is no fun. I have a habit of lying down on the ground in order to get a better shot of whatever small creature I’m photographing. I also have a habit of focusing so intently on my subject that I don’t pay attention to what I’m lying in. After one such ill-considered photo session, I came down with the worst case of poison oak in my life. It was on both arms and both legs. (A couple of people asked me why I didn’t have it on the rest of my body. I explained that I don’t normally hike naked.) It itched like crazy, and it lasted for three or four weeks. Calamine lotion, for all its sterling reputation, didn’t make much of a dent in my suffering. It was a long few weeks.

It’s a pity poison oak and its close relative, poison ivy, have such a “great fault”, because they’re actually very interesting and attractive plants. The poison ivy on the east coast of the United States is especially beautiful in the Autumn, when the leaves turn a bright red. As one floral designer put it, “It would be a great fall accent—if you could use it. The trouble is, you couldn’t count on re-orders.”87

The Genus

Both poison oak and poison ivy are in the genus Toxicodendron, which includes a number of other “poisonous” plants such as poison sumac (T. vernix) and the lacquer tree (T. vernicifluum), which grows in Asia.

There are a number of species of poison oak and poison ivy:90

  • Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) – very common in western North America. This is the one I normally see in Southern California. In fact, it’s the most common woody shrub in California.
  • Atlantic poison oak (Toxicodendron pubescens) – grows in eastern parts of the U.S., mostly in sandy soils.
  • Poison ivy (Toxicodendron radicans) – grows in all states east of the Rockies. It’s very common in my home state of Virginia. It also grows in Central America.
  • Western poison ivy (Toxicodendron rydbergii) – grows in northern parts of the eastern United States. It can also be found in the western U.S. and Canada, but it’s much less common than western poison oak.
  • Asian poison ivy (Toxicodendron orientale) – grows throughout east Asia. It could be a variety of western poison ivy (T. rydbergii), rather than a separate species.

The other member of the genus that most Americans will have heard of is poison sumac. The only species in North America is Toxicodendron vernix. It has leaves with 7 to 13 leaflets, as opposed to the usual three leaflets characteristic of poison oak and poison ivy. It grows as a small tree or a tall shrub. When I lived in Virginia, I often used to see what I thought was poison sumac, but, according to my reading, it’s not nearly as common as most people think, and what is often identified as poison sumac really isn’t. So maybe it was some other type of sumac I was seeing. According to one source, the best way to find true poison sumac is to find a bog, trip, and catch yourself. The plant you catch yourself on will be poison sumac.91 92

Poison sumac (Toxicodendron vernix)
Cedarburg Bog State Natural Area in Ozaukee County, Wisconsin 6/16/2013
Author: Freekee
This file is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.

The lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum), as the name suggests, is a tree. I’ll have more to say about it in a later section.

Leaves of Three

What English speaker hasn’t heard the rhyme “Leaves of three, let it be?” Unlike many such popular bits of folklore, this one is pretty accurate. Both poison oak and poison ivy tend to have their leaves (technically leaflets) arranged in groups of three. Certainly, there are other plants that have this characteristic, but not as many as you might think, so if you avoid all plants with “leaves of three”, you’ll probably be safe.

So how can you tell if what you’re looking at is poison oak or poison ivy? Well, where you’re at is your first clue. If you’re on the east coast of the U.S., chances are it’s poison ivy. If you’re here in the west, it’s probably poison oak. This isn’t always the case, though. A more reliable clue is the shape of the leaves. Poison ivy leaves are pointed at the tip. The leaves of poison oak have scalloped, toothed, or lobed edges and have blunt tips.

Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum)
San Diego County 4/4/21
Poison ivy (Toxicodendron radicans)
Author: Esculapio
This work has been released into the public domain by its author, Esculapio. This applies worldwide. In some countries this may not be legally possible; if so: Esculapio grants anyone the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.

I should mention that both poison oak and poison ivy drop their leaves for part of the year. So how do you identify one of these plants if they don’t have any leaves? Well, you could try rubbing one of the sticks on your arm, and see if you get a rash. Otherwise, I’m not sure. Probably, you should just try to remember where you’ve seen the plants growing in the past and avoid that area. (And, yes, you can definitely get a rash from the leafless twigs.)

Flowers and Fruit93

As noted in the quote from John Howell at the beginning of the post, T. diversilobum blooms in the spring with ivory or greenish-white flowers. The flowers of T. radicans are similar.

Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) in bloom
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/1/21
Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) flowers
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/1/21
@A closeup

When fertilized, they develop into greenish-white or tan berries. Technically, the berries are drupes. A drupe is a fruit that consists of a fleshy outer part surrounding a hard pit, which contains the seed. Poison oak, by the way, is one of the few plants in California with white (or nearly white) berries. Another one is snowberry (genus Symphoricarpos), whose berries are very white and are considered poisonous to humans.94 So another good rule to follow, at least in California, is to not mess with anything that has white berries.

The small, off-white berries of poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum)
San Diego County 4/16/21

The Cashew Family95

Surprisingly, the genus Toxicodendron, with all its not-so-popular plants, is in a very popular family: Anacardiaceae or the cashew family. Besides cashews (Anacardium occidentale), Anacardiaceae also includes the pistachio tree (Pistacia vera) and the mango tree (Mangifera indica). So, that’s kind of weird, but cashews, pistachios, and mangos obviously don’t contain whatever substance is found in poison oak that causes rashes, right? Well, actually, they do. The substance is an oil called urushiol. In the case of mangos, it’s found in the skin of the fruit, not the meat. If you eat a mango, make sure you peel it first. Also, wash it after you peel it. Your knife can transfer some of the urushiol from the skin to the fruit. Apparently, some people are able to eat mangos with the skin intact without suffering any negative consequences. Presumably, those people would also be immune to the effects of poison oak. But immunity to the effects of urushiol often wears off with repeated exposure. You can be immune to it for years, and then suddenly find yourself reacting. Many people who unwisely eat the skin of a mango will find themselves with a painful rash on their lips. This is known as ‘mango mouth’.96 97

So, what about cashews and pistachios? Most people seem to be able to eat these without any problem, but, yes, some people are allergic to them. Often, if you’re allergic to one of the three (cashews, pistachios, or mangos), you’ll be allergic to all three, although that’s not always the case.98 99 Just as most of the urushiol found in a mango is in the skin and not the meat of the fruit, most of the urushiol in cashews and pistachios is in the shell. Even so, cashews and pistachios are not eaten raw. (If you buy these nuts, they may be described as raw on the packaging, but they’ve probably been roasted at least enough to break down the urushiol.)100

More on Urushiol

I guess it’s a bit late in the game to be mentioning this, but poison oak and its relatives aren’t technically poisonous. Urushiol is an allergen, not a toxin. In other words, it doesn’t directly attack your body. Instead, it causes an immune reaction. This is why you can be seemingly immune to poison oak for years and then suddenly develop an allergy to it. Repeated exposure sensitizes your immune system to the substance, until it finally starts reacting to it.

It’s also worth noting that if you’re already sensitive to urushiol, you can’t build up an immunity to it by repeatedly exposing yourself to it in small amounts. It doesn’t work that way. In fact, you would just be increasing your sensitivity to it.

Why does our immune system react to urushiol? No one knows for sure. I could describe how urushiol “attaches to certain proteins of the skin, where it acts as a hapten, leading to a type IV hypersensitive reaction”, blah, blah, blah, but the fact is, in most animals, this doesn’t happen.101 Remarkably, humans and maybe a few other primates seem to be the only animals that have an immune reaction to the compound! Your dog can wallow in poison oak or poison ivy all day, and it’ll be just fine. You, not so much. The oil dries on the dog’s fur, and it can be transferred to you — over and over again — until you get around to giving the dog a bath.

The name ‘urushiol’ comes from ‘urushi’ — the Japanese word for the Chinese lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum). The sap of this tree is tapped to produce lacquer. The sap is filtered, heat-treated, or colored before it’s applied, and the applied sap must then be cured by drying it in a warm, humid environment for 12 to 24 hours. Curing causes the urushiol to polymerize, forming a clear, hard surface. In its liquid state, the sap can cause extreme rashes, even from the fumes. Once cured, it may still cause rashes in some people, but this is uncommon.102

Foliage of the Chinese lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum)
Author: Aomorikuma
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Exposure and Treatment

It can be a bit difficult to figure out what to believe when it comes to poison oak and poison ivy, since there’s a lot of misinformation out there. One thing I’ve read is that if you think you’ve been exposed to it, there’s no rush. It takes hours for the oil to penetrate the skin and, as long as you scrub the affected area thoroughly with soap and water when you get home, you should be okay. This doesn’t seem to be correct. The oil actually penetrates very quickly, and if you want to avoid a reaction, you need to scrub it off pretty quickly after coming into contact.

In theory, simply coming into contact with the plant is not enough to get a rash. The oil is contained within the tissues, not on the surface, so, in order to be exposed to it, you have to rupture the tissue containing it. Of course, you have no way of knowing if a plant you come in contact with has already been bruised or injured, in which case, the oil will be there waiting for you. Plus, some people are very sensitive to exposure, so better safe than sorry.

Urushiol is very sticky and, once released, it will dry onto surfaces and can take a very long time to degrade. (According to one account, the oil may stay active for one to five years!103) So if you’ve come down with a rash, it’s best to thoroughly wash everything that might still have some of the oil on it, such as the clothes you were wearing at the time.

Another misconception is that scratching the rash will spread it. The blisters do not contain urushiol, so breaking them doesn’t make the rash worse. You also can’t get it from someone else, unless they still have some of the oil on their skin or clothes.104

A popular belief that is correct is that you can get a rash from burning poison ivy, oak, or sumac and breathing in the smoke. Inhaling the fumes can cause a systemic reaction, as opposed to the usual contact reaction, and a systemic reaction can be much more serious. Symptoms may include headache, nausea, vomiting, fever, swollen lymph nodes, and difficulty breathing. Swelling in the respiratory system may even lead to death.

Calamine lotion can help make the symptoms of a rash more endurable, but it doesn’t make the rash go away any faster. It also won’t do anything for a systemic reaction. In that case, you should go to the doctor as soon as possible.105

Why Urushiol?

So why would a plant produce all that allergenic oil? Usually, when a plant produces a toxic substance, it’s to protect against herbivores. But, as I’ve already mentioned, urushiol is neither toxic nor allergenic to most animals. In fact, birds, deer, goats, and many other creatures happily dine on the urushiol-laden berries of poison oak and its relatives.

We don’t really know why some plants produce urushiol. It’s been suggested that it may protect from bacterial or fungal infection when the plant is injured, and the stickiness of the resin may help to seal wounds. This is all just speculation, though.106 107

What of the Pollen?

Some sources will tell you that every part of a poison ivy or poison oak plant contains urushiol. Apparently, this isn’t entirely true, because much of the honey produced in the U.S. contains pollen from one or the other of these plants. Honey bees are quite happy to visit the flowers of poison ivy and poison oak, and a study of honey produced in East Texas found that poison ivy pollen occurred in 83% of the samples. Granted, it wasn’t found in large amounts, so I suppose it could be that the low concentration makes it safe to eat.108 On the other hand, the book “Nectar and Pollen Plants of Oregon and the Pacific Northwest” (Burgett et al. 1989) describes poison oak as a “producer of light honey in areas where it grows in sufficient abundance”. In fact, you can buy “poison oak honey” online.109 (Click here if you want to order some.) So maybe the pollen really is free of urushiol.

Poisonous Honey110

“In the summer, in the College garden, the woolly foxglove, Digitalis lanata, is visited by little bees which become stuporose and lie upside down in the flowers, seeming unable to fly away when disturbed.” – Dr Henry Oakeley, Garden Fellow at the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) Medicinal Garden.

As long as we’re on the subject, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that, although pollen from poison oak and poison ivy seem to occur fairly regularly in honey without causing any ill effects, there is such thing as poisonous honey. Some plants produce nectar or pollen that is poisonous to humans and sometimes even to bees! If enough of this is incorporated into a batch of honey, then it could become toxic.

So why don’t we ever hear of people getting sick or dying from eating bad honey? Two reasons: First, bees usually visit a variety of flowers, so that no one plant species contributes the bulk of the pollen or nectar. When a problem does occur, it’s usually because of a lack of species diversity, forcing the bees to visit flowers that they might normally avoid. Second, when honey does become tainted, it often has a strong, unpleasant taste, so most people would naturally avoid it.

That said, there have been cases of poisoning by honey. Most often, the plant responsible is rhododendron. Rhododendron and other plants in the family Ericaceae produce chemicals called grayanotoxins, which are toxic to both bees and humans. Honey that becomes tainted with these chemicals can cause a reaction called ‘rhododendron poisoning’ or ‘honey intoxication’. I want to emphasize again that this happens very rarely, but it does happen. And sometimes it’s even changed the course of history.

Rhododendron poisoning is said to have caused Xenophon’s Greek army to have retreated from Persia in 399 bc. Later, during the Third Mithridatic War in 65 bc, the Roman general Pompey’s soldiers reportedly suffered casualties, some of them lethal, from eating rhododendron-tainted honey deliberately left behind by the enemy forces. According to historical accounts, consuming such honey would lead to a “feeling of drunkeness, to vomiting and purging, and madness that lasted for days” (Collins).111 112

The botanist Frank Kingdon-Ward and his companions experienced rhododendron poisoning while traveling towards Tibet through northern Burma. He describes the symptoms as similar to acute alcohol poisoning. The local Tibetans had apparently built up a tolerance for the toxins, as they were able to eat the honey without suffering any ill effects. (Collins) 113

In 2005, the British writer, Piers Moore Ede, published a travel book, “Honey and Dust: Travels in Search of Sweetness”, in which he describes traveling the world in search of the last of the tribes that still hunt wild honey. In the book, Ede tells of eating the “wondrous toxic honey” collected by the honey hunters of Nepal. This honey, too, was tainted by rhododendron. According to Ede, the effects of honey intoxication “resembled drunkenness at first, but then became visual, like a magic mushroom trip I remembered from university. Painted dots were dripping across my irises like technicolor rain. My body felt light and tingly, filled with warm rushes and heat-bursts. It was wild and strangely wonderful.”114 115

A Bit of History116 117

“The poisonous weed, being in shape but little different from our English ivie; but being touched causeth reddness, itchings, and lastly blysters, the which howsoever, after a while they pass away of themselves without further harme; yet because for the time they are somewhat painefull, and in aspect dangerous, it hath gotten itselfe an ill name, although questionless of noe very ill nature.” — Captain John Smith118

The term ‘poison ivy’ was coined by none other than our own Captain John Smith of Jamestown fame. Poison ivy is a native of North America, and its first mention in the literature is the above-mentioned quote from Smith. (Poison oak, of course, is so-named because of the resemblance of its leaves to those of oak trees, although the two plants are not closely related.)

European collectors were always looking to buy “exotic” new plants from the New World, and they were willing to overlook whatever disagreeable aspects some of those plants might have presented. In fact, some of those disagreeable aspects might have been regarded as a plus. What uses might medicine make of new substances that had such strong effects on the body? In those days, most medicines were plant-based, so it’s not surprising that physicians would have looked to poison ivy and its relatives for potential new treatments. Throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, scientists experimented with poison ivy as a medicine.

One physician-botanist, André-Ignace-Joseph Dufresnoy, was in the habit of giving botany lectures that were open to the public. During one such lecture, he displayed some leaves of poison ivy and described the ill effects of the plant. A young florist in the audience was skeptical. After the lecture, he approached Dufresnoy and proceeded to test the truth of his assertions by rubbing the leaves on his hands. No doubt the florist came to regret his impulsiveness, but when the rash finally cleared, he discovered that an old sore that he had had on his wrist had completely healed!

When Dufresnoy learned of this miraculous cure, he quickly concluded that poison ivy offered great potential as a medicine. He boiled some leaves in hopes of making an infusion that was safe for internal use. Apparently, this mostly worked, because Dufresnoy tested the concoction on himself and reported only mild side effects. Sweating and urination increased, and he experienced some slight stomach upset. He went on to prescribe such extracts to patients with various skin maladies and to at least one patient with paralysis of the legs. Reportedly, he had some positive results.

Dufresnoy, by the way, nearly went to the guillotine because of his infatuation with poison ivy. During the French Revolution, he sent some young plants to a physician friend. At the time, poison ivy was in the genus Rhus, instead of Toxicodendron, so Dufresnoy later wrote to his friend, asking “How are our dear Rhus? How I long to see them!” The word for Russians in French is ‘Russes’, and the Russians were threatening to join the wartime coalition against France. Dufresnoy’s letter was intercepted, and the revolutionaries interpreted ‘Rhus‘ as Russians (Russes). (People weren’t particularly consistent with their spelling back then.) Fortunately, the harsh judge who was originally due to hear the case was deposed, and Dufresnoy was able to explain to the authorities that he was just writing about plants.

In the 20th Century, botanists moved the “poisonous” members of the Rhus genus into a separate genus, Toxicodendron, which means “poison tree”. The chemist who identified urushiol as the allergen in poison ivy and figured out its chemical structure was a Japanese scientist named Rikō Majima. Japanese scientists at the time had a hard time competing with Western scientists, who were far ahead of them technologically, so Majima decided to focus on local natural products that western scientists were unlikely to spend much time on. He studied the lacquer tree from 1907 to 1922, eventually extracting the allergen and identifying it as a mixture of closely related products called alkyl catechols.

Poison Ivy in Popular Culture

For whatever reason, poison oak doesn’t receive a lot of attention in popular culture. Poison ivy is another matter. Something about the plant just seems to capture the public’s imagination. Here’s a few examples.

In 1959, the Coasters were the first group to record the song “Poison Ivy”, which was written and composed by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, respectively. Ostensibly, the song is about a woman who “comes on like a rose” and is “pretty as a daisy,” but will “really do you in if you let her get under your skin.” In reality, it’s about the clap (gonorrhea), a subject that didn’t normally get a lot of air time in 1959.

Another example, of course, is the Batman supervillain Poison Ivy. Dr. Pamela Lillian Isley is a botanist and biochemist, who survives a poisoning attempt, only to find that she has acquired an immunity to plant poisons and (perhaps more remarkably) the ability to control plants.119

Poison Ivy is also the name of a popular movie starring Drew Barrymore as a psychopathic teenager. The movie tagline is “What Ivy wants, Ivy gets”. It spawned several sequels.

Finally, Toxicodendron species have played starring roles in many a “poison garden”. As I’ve noted in other blog posts, plants routinely produce toxins to protect themselves from animals that would like to eat them. Animals, such as us, that do eat them, find or evolve ways to reduce the toxicity to a safe level. As a result, the line between toxic and non-toxic is blurred. Nevertheless, some botanical gardens have leveraged our natural proclivity towards sensationalism by fencing off an area which they designate as their “poison garden” and, of course, charging extra to see it. It’s silly, but mostly harmless, fun. If you’re ever in Northumberland, England, you can visit the “Deadliest Garden in the World” at Alnwick Castle;120 Ireland has a poison garden at Blarney Castle;121 and then there was the Medici Poison Garden in Florence, Italy, which I’m not sure ever actually existed, but was supposed to have supplied Catherine de Medici with the poisons that went into her various potions. (She had something of a reputation as a sorceress.)122

The Future is Looking Itchy123

Plants breathe carbon dioxide. This means that, in the short term, some plants will actually benefit from the increased CO2 levels associated with global warming. In a six-year study conducted by researchers in North Carolina, an experimental forest was subjected to increased levels of carbon dioxide. The researchers found that the greater availability of CO2 improved poison ivy’s ability to conduct photosynthesis and manage water usage, allowing it to grow larger and more abundant. Not only that, but the increase was greater for poison ivy than it was for similar woody plant species, meaning that, in the future, poison ivy could out-compete other plants and become even more common than it already is. And the bad news doesn’t end there. A higher carbon dioxide level also influences the production of urushiol, leading to a more potent form of the compound.

So, yeah, the future is looking very hot and very itchy.

Down a Rabbit Hole with Datura

I can tell you it’s a very disturbing experience to take a drag on your cigarette and find out you don’t have one.. Or to talk to your brother about himself thinking he’s someone else… or having your friends come round to see how you are, having a long chat with them only to realize they are not there. I cannot remember it all as it was only three days ago and I can’t operate properly (it’s taken 2 hrs so far to write this because I can’t see).

I do remember trying to smoke my belt, throwing my cat in the bathtub, thinking my mum was Spike Milligan. The list goes on.

-Mikey 92

What a long, strange trip it’s been researching this topic. I knew the plant Datura had a reputation as a psychedelic — and a dangerous one at that — but… wow. The above quote is one of the less disturbing ones I found. Many of them contained stuff that I didn’t feel comfortable including in a blog that’s supposed to be more or less family friendly. Of course, Datura didn’t evolve in order to send humans on bad trips, and there’s more to the plant than it’s psychoactive properties.

Instruments of Angels and Devils112

Datura is a small genus containing nine species, all with similar features. It’s in the family Solanaceae or the nightshades. Solanaceae is an unusual family. It contains many of our most important crops, including tomatoes, potatoes, eggplants, and peppers. Yet, it also contains many famously poisonous plants, such as nightshade, belladonna, and henbane.

It may seem counterintuitive that poisonous plants and food crops should be so closely related, but, in fact, it’s not really that strange. Just as animals tend to defend themselves when attacked, so do plants. And since plants can’t run or bite or sting, they have to rely on more passive methods of defense, such as toxins. If humans are able to eat a particular plant, it’s not necessarily because the plant doesn’t contain any toxins. Our bodies can naturally detoxify some foods, as long as we’re in good health and the toxin levels aren’t too high. Sometimes we only eat the less poisonous parts of the plant and avoid the other parts. We may also process a plant in such a way that most of the toxins are removed. Toxins in some dried beans are removed by soaking and boiling, for example.113

Some of the common names for members of Datura are raving nightshade (my personal favorite), thorn apple, stinkweed, Devil’s apple, jimsonweed, Devil’s weed, Devil’s trumpet, toloache, and moonflower. The most common species here in Southern California is Datura wrightii. This particular species is sometimes called sacred datura, due to its use in Native American religious rituals.114 116 D. wrightii is native to the Southwestern United States and northwestern Mexico. It’s also widespread in Central California, although the concentration is much higher in the south.124

Sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Datura is one of those plants that’s easy to recognize even when it’s not in flower.
San Diego County 4/19/17
Sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/2/21
Sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/2/21
Sacred datura (Datura wrightii) with a seed pod
Los Peñasquitos Canyon Preserve, San Diego County 9/16/17

Another Datura species, D. stramonium, is found scattered throughout California. According to Calflora125, it’s not native to California, although a number of other sources call it a native of North America, without being more specific.126 127 128 D. stramonium is a rather important member of the genus, since it very early on managed to spread to the Old World. It now grows all over the world, wherever the climate is warm and temperate.

D. stramonium looks a lot like D. wrightii, but its leaf margins have much deeper lobes.

Datura stramonium in Castel Beseno, Italy
Author: Syrio
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.
Datura stramonium in Luxembourg, France
Author: Chbaraka
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

Although the name ‘jimsonweed’ or ‘jimson weed’ is often used for other members of the genus, the name originated with D. stramonium. It’s actually a corruption of the name ‘Jamestown weed’. The story goes that some English soldiers were camped out in Jamestown, Virginia while trying to suppress Bacon’s Rebellion.129 They foolishly used the leaves of the plant in a salad and spent the next eleven days tripping out. Here’s a quote from one of the people who witnessed it.130

The James-Town Weed (which resembles the Thorny Apple of Peru, and I take to be the Plant so call’d) is supposed to be one of the greatest Coolers in the World. This being an early Plant, was gather’d very young for a boil’d Salad, by some of the Soldiers sent thither, to pacific the Troubles of Bacon; and some of them eat plentifully of it, the Effect of which was a very pleasant Comedy; for they turn’d natural Fools upon it for several Days: One would blow up a Feather in the Air; another wou’d dart Straws at it with much Fury; and another stark naked was sitting up in a Corner, like a Monkey, grinning and making Mows at them; a Fourth would fondly kiss, and paw his Companions, and snear in their Faces, with a Countenance more antick, than any in a Dutch Droll. In this frantick Condition they were confined, lest they should in their Folly destroy themselves; though it was observed, that all their Actions were full of Innocence and good Nature. Indeed, they were not very cleanly; for they would have wallow’d in their own Excrements, if they had not been prevented. A Thousand such simple Tricks they play’d, and after Eleven Days, return’d to themselves again, not remembring any thing that had pass’d.131

Another genus of plants in the nightshade family is Brugmania. This genus contains seven species and is closely related to Datura. The common name for members of Brugmania is angel’s trumpets. I’m not sure why these plants deserve such a positive rating, while Datura is stuck with Devil’s trumpet and Devil’s weed. It’s certainly not due to their being any less dangerous, as the members of Brugmania are among the most toxic of ornamental plants. Maybe it’s just because angel’s trumpets are woody shrubs or small trees, and their large, trumpet-shaped flowers hang down in such a distinctive manner, making them more popular as ornamentals. Datura is very attractive in it’s own right, but it’s a much smaller plant and the flowers are displayed in a more traditional, upright manner. 132

An interesting thing about angel’s trumpets is that they are only known from cultivars. The genus appears to be extinct in the wild, and it’s suspected that its extinction may be linked to the extinction of whatever animal was responsible for the dispersal of its seeds. If this is the case, then angel’s trumpets only survive today because humans decided to grow them as ornamentals. This would make them evolutionary anachronisms. (See my earlier post Strange Fruit and Other Anachronisms.)

Soon after I moved to California, I saw an angel’s trumpet growing alongside a street in San Diego. It was a hard plant to miss, with its huge, hanging flowers. I’ve got a photo of it somewhere. Until such time as I can dig it up, here’s one I found on Wiki Commons.

Angel’s trumpet (Brugmansia suaveolens)
Author: Jim Evans
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

A Moth Makes a Mistake

On a trip to South Korea in 2012, I visited Jeju Island, a large volcanic island just off the southern tip of the Korean Peninsula. It’s a beautiful place with lots to see, including some of the largest larva tubes in the world. A popular hiking destination is the crater and lake at the top of the central volcano, Mount Halla.133

At this period in my life, I was into oil painting, not hiking, so I wasn’t in any shape to hike all the way to the top of the mountain. Instead, I contented myself with hiking maybe a third of the way. There, I set up an easel and did a small painting. I had just squeezed out a large glob of titanium white paint onto my palette, when a large hawk moth suddenly appeared and hovered over my palette for a second before dipping its proboscis into the glob of paint. It didn’t take the moth long to realize its mistake, and it flew off with a bit of white paint stuck to the tip. It was a memorable experience, although I felt bad for the moth, which may have died as a result of the encounter — oil paint doesn’t come off easily.

So why would a moth do such a thing?

Attracting Pollinators

For millions of years, flowering plants and insects have been evolving mutualistic relationships. The plants provide insects with food in the form of pollen or nectar, and the insects pollinate the plants. When an insect visits a flower, it often gets some of the pollen stuck to its body. When it later visits the flower of another plant of the same species, some of this pollen may rub off onto the pistil of the flower, fertilizing the plant.134 This may sound like a simple, straightforward relationship, but it’s not. There are all kinds of complicating factors. Some insects want to eat other parts of the plant, such as the leaves, that the plant doesn’t want eaten, so plants have to figure out how to protect themselves from the “bad” insects while attracting the “good” ones. Some insects cheat by chewing through the petals to get to the nectar, bypassing the reproductive parts of the flower and doing nothing to pollinate the plant. And then, of course, there’s competition between plants to attract pollinators. As a result of this competition, many plants have evolved to specialize in one particular species or group of insects.

You can often make an educated guess what kind of bug or other animal pollinates a plant based on the color of its flowers. If the flowers are bright blue or violet, there’s a good chance the plant is pollinated by bees. If they’re bright red, hummingbirds may be the target pollinators. If a plant has white flowers, and, moreover, if those flowers open at night, they are probably evolved to attract moths or even bats.135

And therein lies our answer. Bright, white flowers are easier to see at night, so many plants have evolved white flowers to attract moths. And moths, in turn, have evolved to associate large, splotches of white color with a meal. That unlucky Korean moth mistook my blob of white paint for a flower! (In case you’re wondering, no, I wasn’t painting at night. Hawk moths tend to be nocturnal, but many fly during the day, as well.)

Datura flowers tend towards white, although they can also be pale yellow, pink, or pale purple. They also open at night. And they’re big. So, as you’ve probably guessed by now, they are pollinated primarily by big moths, namely hawk moths.

Sacred datura (Datura wrightii) with my hand for scale
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/21
Sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/21
Sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/21

Moths of the Family Sphingidae136 137

Hawk or sphynx moths make up the family Sphingidae. They are also called hummingbird moths, because from a distance they look remarkably like hummingbirds. They’re about the same size, and they hover in front of flowers to feed just like hummingbirds. The moth I saw in Korea was definitely a hummingbird moth.

I see plenty of hawk moths here in San Diego County, which isn’t surprising given how much Datura we have. Of course, they feed on other flowers, too. Here’s a bad photo of one feeding from a monkey flower.

A hawk moth sipping nectar from a sticky monkey flower (Diplacus aurantiacus)
San Diego County 4/24/17

And here’s a much better photo someone took of one in Bulgaria.

Hummingbird moth (Macroglossum stellatarum)
Yastrebets, Rila Mountains, Bulgaria
Author: Charles J. Sharp
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

Surprisingly, hawk moths don’t seem to be immune to the psychoactive properties of Datura and are said to sometimes become intoxicated on the nectar.138 As to what form this “intoxication” takes, I read somewhere that they kind of stumble around unsteadily. Unfortunately, I haven’t been able to locate the article I read this in.

One species of hawk moth, Manduca rustica, is especially fond of sacred datura.139 I suspect that many of the moths I see in my area belong to this species.

I did have one other close encounter with a hawk moth. I was hiking at night in Mission Trails Regional Park, and one landed on the back of my wrist. Naturally, it was my right wrist, and my phone was in the right pocket of my jeans, so I had to use my left hand to fumble around in my right pocket trying to get it out. And, naturally, the moth took off the moment I was ready to shoot.

Datura in Genetics Research140

Datura has become a very important model organism for genetic research, largely due to the botanist Albert Blakeslee.141 A normal Datura plant has twelve pairs of chromosomes, but, apparently, it’s relatively easy to create mutant strains that have extra chromosomes. Blakeslee used the chemical colchicine to induce such mutations. He was able to create trisomic plants — plants with three copies of a particular chromosome, instead of a pair.

Time for some terminology. In genetics, the letter n is used as a placeholder for the number of different chromosomes in an organism’s genome. A cell is haploid if it contains only one set of n chromosomes. Most germ cells (reproductive cells) are haploid. If a cell contains 2n chromosomes or two copies of each, it is said to be diploid. In most multicellular organisms, the somatic cells — that is, anything that isn’t a germ cell — are diploid. If a cell has more than 2 sets of chromosomes — that is, 3n or greater — then it’s said to be polyploid. These terms are also applied to organisms as a whole. For instance, if an organism’s somatic cells are polypoid, then the organism is also said to be polyploid.142

Aneuploidy is when an organism’s chromosome number differs from the wild type (i.e. the unmutated type) by part of a chromosome set. For example, an organism’s cells could have two copies of most chromosomes, but three copies of one of them. Such an organism is said to have 2n + 1 chromosomes in its genome. An organism could also have two copies of most chromosomes, but only one copy of one of them. Then, it’s said to have 2n – 1 chromosomes. If an otherwise diploid organism is missing one pair of chromosomes entirely, then it has 2n – 2 chromosomes. This type of mutation is usually lethal.143

Most organisms that have nuclei in their cells (that is, organisms that aren’t bacteria or Archeae) are diploid. We humans have 23 different chromosomes, but most of our cells have two copies of each one for a total of 46 or 23 pairs. So humans have 2n chromosomes, where n = 23.

Using colchicine, Blakeslee was able to produce Datura plants with a chromosome number of 2n + 1. He was even able to produce one plant that was haploid — it only had one set of chromosomes. “This was the first haploid to be found in vascular plants and created something of a sensation. Haploid plants, one thought, should be gamophytes, but here was a little plant, rather weak and nearly sterile, that was clearly a sporophyte, but that had only one set of chromosomes in its cells.”144

Blakeslee’s results inspired a great deal of research into polypoidy. Eventually, a total of six stages in the polyploidy series of Datura were identified (1n, 2n, 3n, 4n, 6n, and 8n). It’s not clear from my reading if Blakeslee himself identified any of the polypoids or if he just produced aneuploids and a haploid, but there is no doubt that his pioneering work was of vast importance to the field of genetics. It eventually led to the concept of genetic balance: “…an organism that has complete extra sets of all of its genes is not very different from a normal organism of its type, whereas an organism that has a single extra chromosome, giving it an extra ‘dose’ of the genes carried on this chromosome and thus changing the ratio of these genes to those borne on the other chromosomes, has a profoundly changed appearance.”145

Both Poison and Hallucinogen146 147

All species of Datura contain tropane alkaloids such as scopolamine and atropine, which are both toxins and hallucinogens. These chemicals are mostly found in the flowers and seeds. In some species, such as D. wrightii, there may also be high concentrations in the roots.

Within hallucinogens, Datura is classified as a deliriant. Most deliriants, including Datura, are anticholinergic drugs, meaning they inhibit the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. The state of delirium produced is generally characterized by stupor, agitation, restlessness, confusion, and realistic visual hallucinations. Scopolamine and atropine, in particular, are known for their tendency to produce dream-like hallucinations and these hallucinations tend to be disturbing and unpleasant. People who take Datura often lose control of their actions and have little or no memory of the experience.

The real danger presented by Datura, however, is not so much its toxicity or the often disturbing nature of the hallucinations it produces. The real danger is its unpredictability. As already noted, the amount of toxin varies according to the part of the plant, but it also varies according to its stage of development and the environment in which grows. The concentration of toxins decreases during the day and increases at night. It’s also more toxic after a rainy period than a dry period. All this makes it extremely difficult to estimate what a safe dose would be.148

Despite its dangers and the often dark nature of the “trips” it produces, Datura has long been used in folk medicine and religious rituals around the world. What follows are a very few examples of such use.

Early Times149 150 151

The Chumash were a Native American tribe who lived in the coastal regions of Central and Southern California, a bit north of where I live.152 They enter this story because, at some point, someone among them used red-ochre to paint an image of a 5-armed pinwheel on the ceiling of a cave. The cave is called Pinwheel Cave and it’s located in the Wind Wolves Preserve of the San Emigdio Mountains. The pinwheel is believed to represent a Datura blossom as it unwinds at dusk. The photo below is one I took of a real Datura blossom unwinding. I don’t have permission to show you any of the photos of the cave painting, but you can click here to see an article that contains a couple.

An unopened blossom of sacred datura (Datura wrightii)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/23/21

The idea that the pinwheel represents a Datura blossom is bolstered by the fact that around 50 clumps of chewed Datura have been found tucked into crevices in the stone alongside the painting. This strongly suggests that the chumash people were using the plant ritually at the time the painting was done around 400 years ago. (Give or take. Radiocarbon dating indicates that the site was occupied from around A.D. 1530 to 1890. I’m not sure how, based on that, it was decided that the painting must be 400 years old. You’ll have to take that up with the authors of the referenced articles.)

Archaeologists have long speculated that some of the more abstract, “psychedelic” art found in rock paintings might have been related to the ritualistic use of hallucinogens of one type or another, but this is the first time that traces of hallucinogens have actually been found associated with cave art. One popular theory is that such caves were the haunt of individual shamans whose artwork represented images from their “vision quests”, and that the caves were avoided by other members of the tribe. However, the number of chewed “quids” of Datura found in Pinwheel Cave, as well as the number of tools and other artifacts littering the cave floor, suggest that the site may have been used communally — maybe in initiation ceremonies or in rituals conducted before a hunt.

Besides the pinwheel, a number of other, less distinct blobs and smears are painted in red-ochre on the cave ceiling. Researchers have interpreted one of the figures as an insect, possibly a hawk moth.

Huskanawing

The Algonquin Indians of Virginia used Datura stramonium in an initiation ritual called huskanawing. The following is based on a description in Beverly’s “The History and Present State of Virginia, In Four Parts”.153

The ceremony took place every fourteen or sixteen years or oftener, depending on the ages of the young men in the tribe. A group of these young men would be selected based on “treasures” they had acquired in the course of their traveling and hunting. They would be taken into the woods, where medicine men carefully fed them a plant mixture called wysoccan, which contained D. stramonium. They would be kept confined there in isolation for several months “giving them no other sustenance, but the Infusion, or Decoction”.154 (This part may sound a bit hard to believe, but I suppose whatever plant matter was in the “Infusion” could have been enough to keep them alive for a few months.)

This steady dose of wysoccan would cause the boys to become “stark, raving mad” for eighteen to twenty days. Not only that, but they would supposedly lose all memory of their lives, their parents, and even their language. The dose would then be gradually reduced, but, before the effects had worn off, they would be brought back into the village, where they were carefully observed to see if they retained any memories of their former lives. If one of them showed any sign of remembering, then he would have to undergo the entire ritual again, only this time with even more severity, and he would be unlikely to survive it.

Once back in their village, the initiates were expected to learn everything over again, even their language, so that they could begin life again as men, having forgotten their previous lives as boys. Obviously, it’s likely that the young men only pretended to have forgotten everything and were very careful not to acknowledge that they recognized anyone in the village, not wanting to have to repeat the ritual (and probably die in the process). On the other hand, given some of the stories of modern people who’ve experimented with the plant, a total, if temporary, loss of memory may not be all that farfetched.

Witches and Werewolves

The medieval belief that witches flew around on broomsticks may have been the direct result of the said witches tripping out on D. stramonium. Supposedly, “flying ointments” were compounded out of the seeds and roots of Datura and applied to the body, producing states of “extraordinary derangement and delusion”. As for the broomsticks, the handles were used to apply the ointment to the “sensitive vaginal membranes “.

Title: The History of Witches and Wizards, 1720
This file comes from Science Museum Group, in the United Kingdom. Refer to Wellcome blog post (archive). This tag does not indicate the copyright status of the attached work. A normal copyright tag is still required. See Commons:Licensing.
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.

Experiments on these banned religious practices were actually carried out by Andres Laguna, a physician to Pope Julius III, and Giovanni Battista Porta, a colleague of Galileo. The results showed that the potions did take the women on “journeys”, but only in their dreams. It was also reported that men would drink potions of Datura and then put on wolf skins and run about on all fours.155

So, did D. stramonium really shape our legends about witches and werewolves? I don’t know, but, given the plant’s documented effects on people, it doesn’t seem like too much of a stretch.

The “Safe” Use of Datura

If Datura is really so dangerous and unpredictable, how is it that so many cultures have apparently learned to use it safely? First, tribal cultures are much closer to nature than we are. They are in everyday contact with the plants and animals they live among, and their knowledge of the attributes and uses of various plants is formidable. Second, the use of plants like Datura would likely have been controlled by shamans (a.k.a. medicine men), who had spent much of their lives learning under what conditions to harvest the plants and how high a dosage to use. And third, in most tribal cultures, Datura was limited to rituals. It probably wasn’t used as a recreational drug.

I hope I don’t come off sounding preachy by emphasizing how dangerous Datura can be. I think some hallucinogens have great potential in medicine and therapy. Some may even be safe to use recreationally, as long as you know what you’re doing. But I don’t think Datura is one of them. It’s just too dangerous. And why would you want to knowingly take a substance that has a reputation for bad trips?

The Tarweed Tribe

Nested within the sunflower family of flowering plants, known to botanists as the Asteraceae, is the tribe Madieae — the tarweeds and their relatives. Tarweed or tarplant is the common name for a number of different plants in this tribe. (There are a few plants outside of Madieae that are also sometimes called tarweeds, but we won’t concern ourselves with them here.)

Tarweeds are native to the Western United States.140 Two species I commonly see in Southern California are graceful tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata) and clustered tarweed (Deinandra fasciculata). Graceful tarweed is the more attractive of the two, in my opinion. (I suppose that’s why it’s called ‘graceful’.) Here’s a photo of a flower head of this species.

Graceful Tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

Note the dark brown on the stamens. This is a common characteristic of the tarweeds, and it’s what initially attracted me to these plants. The flower heads are not large — maybe half an inch across — but the dark specks against a yellow background really make them stand out when you see them in the field. Here’s a view from the side.

Graceful Tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

And, for the sake of completeness, here’s what the leaves look like.

Graceful tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

Clustered tarweed, as its name implies, has its flower heads in clusters.

Clustered tarweed (Deinandra fasciculata)
Dictionary Hill, San Diego County. 5/18/19

Here’s a closeup of one of those flower heads.

Clustered tarweed (Deinandra fasciculata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/24/19

The Sunflower Family150 156

As already mentioned, Madieae is a tribe in Asteraceae. This is the sunflower or aster family. If you know even a little bit about botany, then you probably know about the Asteraceae. If not, here’s a quick introduction.

With the possible exception of the orchids (family Orchidaceae), Asteraceae is the most diverse family of flowering plants. Their most distinctive feature is the flower head or capitulum. I say ‘flower head’, rather than flower, because what looks like a single flower is really a composite of many smaller flowers. For this reason, the family used to be called the Compositae. In fact, it’s often still called that, although it’s not technically correct. At some point, taxonomists decided that the scientific names for plant families should all end in -aceae. Hence, the name change. But Compositae has been used for so long, and it’s so (relatively) easy to pronounce, that it’s still used a lot, even in scientific papers.

In most Asteraceae, the capitulum is a composite of ray flowers and disk flowers. The disk flowers are clustered in the center. Surrounding them are the ray flowers. Each ray flower has a single petal that grows out, away from the central disk flowers. In the photo below, I’ve labeled the ray and disk flowers for a tarweed capitulum.

Capitulum (flower head) of a graceful tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

In some plants, the capitulum consists of only disk flowers or only ray flowers. When it does have both, often the ray flowers will be lacking pistils and stamens, or, if they do have them, they’ll be sterile. Only the disk flowers will have functional reproductive parts. Sometimes, it’s the other way around — the disk flowers will be sterile and the ray flowers will handle the reproductive duties.

Other Tarweeds157

Wikipedia lists seven genera of plants in the Madieae tribe that are commonly called tarweeds or tarplants. I won’t repeat that list here. Check out the Wikipedia article by clicking here, if you’re interested. They all share very similar characteristics. In all but one genus, Blepharizonia, the petals are yellow. In Blepharizonia, they’re white. Another genus, Hemizonella, is distinguished by having tiny flower heads, and the leaves and stems are very hairy.

Other Madieae

There are numerous genera in Madieae that don’t usually go by the common name tarweed. I should point out, though, that botanists will sometimes refer to any member of the tarweed tribe as a tarweed. (Similarly, you’ll sometimes hear a member of the sunflower family referred to as “a sunflower”, even though it’s obviously not literally a sunflower. It’s usually clear from the context that the person just means it’s in that family.)

Anyway, the only examples of these ‘not tarweed’ tarweeds that I’m familiar with are yarrows. Here’s some photos of golden or yellow yarrow (Eriophyllum confertiflorum).

Golden yarrow (Eriophyllum confertiflorum)
Volcan Mountain, San Diego County. 5/21/17
Golden yarrow (Eriophyllum confertiflorum)
Volcan Mountain, San Diego County. 5/21/17

One example that I haven’t seen is Raillardella, although it is found in California. I mention it here because it will come up later in this article.

Stem raillardella (Raillardella scaposa)
Author: Jim Morefield
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.
Silver raillardella (Raillardella argentea)
Author: Dcrjsr
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported license.

The “Tar” in Tarweed158 159

Tarweed gets its name from the sticky resin that it exudes. (It’s not really tar.) The resin probably helps prevent water loss — an adaptation to hot, dry environments. A flowering stem cut from a tarweed will remain fresh for two or three days without water.

Preventing water loss may not be the only thing the resin is good for, though. The plant’s sticky, resin-coated hairs trap a lot of bugs — bugs that might otherwise make a meal of it. The dead and dying insects attract predatory insects that feed on them and on any other herbivorous insects that happen by. Some predators seem to have evolved the ability to avoid getting stuck by the resin. These are probably nice to have around to pick off any herbivores that might have evolved the same talent.

One other way the resin could be helping the plant is that it may taste bad to herbivores. This isn’t known for certain, though.160

Note the resin oozing from glands on the back of the flower head in this photo.

Graceful Tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

Here’s a closer look at the resin glands on a bud.

Graceful Tarplant (Holocarpha virgata ssp. elongata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19

And a still closer look.

A very close look

Origin161

The tarweeds evolved in California. Their common ancestor probably lived in cooler, mid-elevation environments. As California’s climate became drier and warmer, the tarweeds gradually migrated to lower elevations, diversifying into different habitats as they went. This diversification happened fairly recently in geologic time. As a result, the differences between species can be rather subtle, making them difficult to tell apart. One tarweed, however, bucked that trend in a big way. We’ll get to that in a minute, but first, we need to pay a visit to Hawai’i.

How to Grow an Island162

The Hawaiian archipelago consists of 137 islands spread across 1,500 miles (2,400 km) in the Pacific Ocean. They were formed by volcanic activity. Specifically, the islands were formed (and are being formed) by a ‘hotspot’ — a huge source of magma (liquid rock) welling up from the Earth’s mantle (the part of the Earth just beneath the crust). The Earth’s crust is broken up into many ‘tectonic plates’ which move very slowly (typically 2 or 3 inches a year) as they are pushed around by convection currents in the mantle.163 The Hawaiian islands sit on the Pacific tectonic plate. As this plate slowly moves over the underlying hotspot, magma periodically breaks through, building a new island. As the island, riding the plate, moves away from the hotspot, the source of magma is cut off. The forces of erosion begin to shrink the island. Eventually, the magma breaks through at another spot on the ocean floor and forms yet another island.

As a result of this process, the islands that make up the Hawaiian Archipelago are strung out in a slightly curved line running north and slightly west, with the youngest and largest on the southern end of the line. Moving north from there, the islands in the chain get progressively older. They also tend to get progressively smaller because they’ve been eroding longer. Of course, this depends on how big they were to begin with, so it’s not a fixed rule. Going beyond the northern end of the archipelago, there are seamounts rising up from the ocean floor. These are the remnants of even older islands that have eroded beneath the waves.

When a volcanic island first forms, it’s completely lifeless. Eventually, it will be colonized by plants and animals coming from the surrounding land masses. The Hawaiian Archipelago, however, is one of the most isolated island chains in the world. It’s about 3,000 miles (4828 km) from the closest continent (North America) and 2,000 miles (3218 km) from the nearest other island.

So how did plants and animals get all the way to Hawai’i? Some birds can cross such distances, especially if they are caught up in a gale. Flying insects are light enough to be blown there on the wind. Plants and terrestrial animals can raft there on floating mats of vegetation. Such rafts may be produced, for example, by hurricanes, cyclones, and tsunamis (tidal waves) and can sometimes be quite large. Some seeds may be able to float to islands, although in this case, the distance they would have to traverse and the length of time they would have to survive in salt water may make this less likely. Seeds can also be carried to islands stuck to the feet or feathers of birds. This last example leads to our next topic…

Silverswords and Their Relatives164 165166

The silverswords or greenswords are a small group of plants native to the Hawaiian Archipelago that make up the genus Argyroxiphium. They are found only on the islands of Maui and Hawai’i, usually at high elevations. They are adapted to areas of low-nutrient soils, such as alpine deserts and bogs. Silverswords are unusual-looking plants, as you can see from the following photos.

Young silverswords on Haleakala, Maui, Hawai’i
Author: Caterpillar at English Wikipedia
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. Subject to disclaimers.
Silversword in haleaka crater
Author: Sputnikcccp at en.wikipedia
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. Subject to disclaimers.

Some more unusual plants native to the Hawaiian islands are those in the genera Dubautia and Wilkesia. Here’s some photos of a couple of species in these groups.

Dubautia menziesii
Silversword loop Haleakala National Park, Maui, Hawai’i
Source:
starr-011114-0055-Dubautia_menziesii-flowers-Silversword_loop_HNP-Maui

Author: Forest and Kim Starr
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States license.
Dwarf iliau (Wilkesia hobdyi) on the island of Kauaʻi
Author: David Eickhoff from Pearl City, Hawaii, USA
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

These plants all look very different from each other. And they certainly don’t look much like tarweeds. In fact, despite remarkably diverse morphological, anatomical, and ecological adaptations, molecular studies have shown that Argyroxiphium, Dubautia, and Wilkesia are very closely related. Even more surprising, it has been shown that all these plants are descended from a single species of tarweed that somehow made the journey from California to the Hawaiian Islands.

As discussed in the previous section, seeds can be carried to islands stuck to the feet or feathers of a bird. If this was the case with tarweeds, and it seems likely, the entire population of Argyroxiphium, Dubautia, and Wilkesia on the islands are probably descended from one small cache of seeds — or possibly even a single seed! Molecular studies have shown that the silverswords are most closely related to either Raillardella muirii or Raillardella scabrida. (Two different studies came up with the two different species.) This does not mean that the silverswords are descended from a species of Raillardella — it just means that the tarweeds in the Raillardella genus are their closest relatives among the tarweeds that are alive today. Their actual ancestor could have been a member of a species or genus that is no longer around. The important takeaway, though, is that, at some point in time, a seed or seeds from some member of the tarweed tribe made it to the Hawaiian islands and then diversified to become the Argyroxiphium, Dubautia, and Wilkesia we see today.

Researchers have dated the radiation of the silverswords on the islands to have begun about 5.2 million years ago, plus or minus 0.8 million years. Kauai, the oldest of the Hawaiian islands, has been dated at 5.1 million years old, plus or minus 0.2 million years. This suggests that the founding tarweed made it there soon after the oldest island formed.

Arriving on the island, the tarweed would have found a land almost barren of competitors, so there would have been many unoccupied niches for its descendants to fill. The relative lack of other plant life would have also meant that the soil would not have been very fertile, so the tarweeds may have had a tough time of it for a while, until they evolved the ability to thrive on more nutrient-poor soils. But they managed it, and it makes sense that their closest descendants, the silverswords, are still found mostly in such environments.

The radiation of silverswords and their relatives from a single wayfaring species of tarweed is a fascinating example of island evolution. This radiation took place very rapidly, leading to a great diversity of species with very different adaptations, despite being closely related genetically. By comparison, the tarweeds of North America, while also being closely related to each other, show much less diversity.

The relationship of tarweeds and silverswords has attracted a great deal of research, and there is so much more I would like to tell you about them, but this is a blog post, not a book, so I’ll resist the impulse and end it here. If you would like to know more, check out this link: Adaptive Radiation and Macroevolution in the Hawaiian Silverswords. There’s also a great article by the scientist who seems to be largely responsible for discovering the relationship between the tarweeds and silverswords. You can read that article by clicking here.

I should note that Argyroxiphium, Dubautia, and Wilkesia are all now included in the Madieae tribe. In fact, another name for the tarweeds is the silversword alliance167.

Hiding in Plain Sight

One of these days, I’m going to write an entire blog post entitled “Hiding in Plain Sight”. It’s going to be a collection of images whose only common feature is that I was trying to photograph one thing and inadvertently captured another thing that I didn’t even know was there. It happens a lot in macro photography. You photograph one bug and, later, when you pull the photo up on your laptop, you realize that there’s a much more interesting bug right next to it that you hadn’t even noticed. If you’re really lucky, it might even be in focus.

Yeah, someday I’m going to write that post. In the meantime, here’s a few tarweed pics that have incidental bugs in the image. The first three photos were cropped from much larger images.

Do you see it?
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19
Here’s a clue. It looks like a thrips (a type of insect.) Normally, they’re black. This one must have recently molted.
An unidentified insect on the stem of a tarweed.
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19
How about this one?
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 7/19/19
Pretty sure this is another thrips. And, yes, they really are that tiny.

Euphorbs

My introduction to the genus Euphorbia was a sandmat like the one pictured below. This one was growing in Southern California in chaparral country. It’s called smallseed sandmat (Euphorbia polycarpa). You can see why a macro photographer such as myself would be attracted to it. During the height of the blooming season, a single plant can form a fairly large mat, but it’s the tiny, delicate “flowers” that give this plant a such a striking appearance.

Smallseed Sandmat (Euphorbia polycarpa)
San Diego County, CA 3/9/20
Smallseed Sandmat (Euphorbia polycarpa)
San Diego County, CA 3/9/20

If you’re wondering why I put “flowers” in quotes, it’s because they technically aren’t. They’re inflorescences — clusters of flowers arranged around a main stem. The plant does have real flowers and they’re visible in the above photos, but just barely. Here’s a closeup, taken with a microscope. It’s of a similar species, Arizona spurge (Euphorbia arizonica), which grows in the desert:

Arizona spurge (Euphorbia arizonica)
Anza Borego Desert State Park, San Diego County, CA 12/22/18

What looks like white petals are actually bracts — a type of modified leaf often associated with inflorescences. Although they’re not true petals, they frequently serve the same purpose — attracting pollinators by being bright and showy. The dark red, oblong structures at the base of each bract are nectar glands.

The real flowers are in the center of the inflorescence. They don’t look much like flowers because they lack petals and sepals. In the very center is a single female flower, consisting of a bare pistil (the female organ). The three red, forked structures together make up the stigma of the pistil (the top part above the style and ovary). Arranged around the pistil are multiple male flowers. These consist of bare stamens (the male organs). Each stamen consists of a short red filament topped by a yellow anther. Only two stamens are visible in the photo, but there should be four — one for each bract. The other two may be hidden by the pistil.161 167 168

Here’s a couple more photos:

Arizona spurge (Euphorbia arizonica)
Arizona spurge (Euphorbia arizonica)

Note: Recent research suggests that this ‘inflorescence’ may not actually be an inflorescence after all. See the section Evolution of the Cyathium later in the article for details.

An Unusual Genus 169 170

Euphorbia is a large genus in the family Euphorbiaceae. The terms “Euphorbia” and “Euphorb” are sometimes used to refer to any member of the Euphorbiaceae family, but in this article I’ll be using it in its more restrictive sense for just the plants in the genus Euphorbia. There are over 2000 species, including many very popular ornamentals.

A common name for plants in this genus is “spurge”. The word comes from the Middle English/Old French espurge, meaning “to purge”, and reflects the use of the sap as a purgative in folk medicine. Indeed, all spurges contain a milky sap called latex which is toxic in varying degrees, depending on the species.

Euphorbia is a hugely diverse group, ranging from small herbs like sandmat all the way to trees. A great many species are succulents. Many also have thorns. If that sounds to you like a cactus, you’re not the only one who’s thought so. Euphorbias are often mistaken for cacti. The two groups are not closely related, though.

Cacti evolved in North America as an adaptation to arid environments. On the rare occasion of a rain, the shallow roots of a cactus quickly suck up any water they come into contact with and send it to the thick, fleshy stems for storage. The spines are actually modified leaves. In addition to its obvious defensive purpose, a thick mesh of spines also helps to shade the stems.

It’s not clear where euphorbs originated, but the succulent varieties, at least, appear to have evolved in Africa. In fact, they are Africa’s answer to cacti. Many of the spurges in Africa evolved in similarly arid environments and experienced similar evolutionary pressures. Sometimes, when two unrelated organisms experience very similar challenges, they come up with very similar solutions. This is called convergent evolution and it’s what happened with cacti and succulent euphorbs.

Despite their extraordinary variety, all spurges have some things in common. I already mentioned their toxic latex. Another thing is those weird inflorescences…

A Very Special Inflorescense 171

‘Inflorescence’ is a general term used with all flowering plants. The inflorescences of plants in the Euphorbia genus, however, are so unique that they’ve been given a special name: cyathia (singular cyathium). Every species of Euphorbia has cyathia, but no other type of plant has them. In most plant genera, the species differ in the details of the flowers themselves. In spurges, it’s mostly the cyathium that differs.

I already described a cyathium in the last section, but this is such an important feature of Euphorbia that it’s worth going through it again with maybe a few more details. According to Wikipedia172, a cyathium has the following characteristics:

  • Four or five bracteoles (small bracts)
  • One to ten nectar glands at the base of the bracteoles. These are sometimes fused.
  • Usually, there’s a single female flower in the center, consisting of a single pistil.
  • The female flower is surrounded by multiple male flowers — one for each bracteole. Each male flower consists of a single stamen.

The photo below shows a flower of an unidentified species of Euphorbia. A legend follows the photo. Even without referring to the legend, you can probably spot the female flower in the center and the bright yellow nectar glands surrounding it. The male flowers are a bit more difficult to identify, since they haven’t finished developing. “jmf” in the photo stands for “juvenile male flower”.

Cross-section of a cyathium
Author: Frank Vincentz
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
  • b Bract
  • i Involucre
  • g Gland
  • ag Appendage of the gland
  • bo Bracteole
  • mf Male flower
  • jmf Juvenile male flower
  • a Anthere
  • pmf Pedicel of the male flower
  • ff Female flower
  • o Ovary
  • s Style
  • pff Pedicel of the female flower

Evolution of the Cyathium 173

Researchers Gerhard Prenner and Paula Rudall at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew (England) have been studying the origin of cyathia. Euphorbia evolved from plants in the Old World — they have relatives in places like Australia, New Caledonia, Africa, and Madagascar. These relatives have a more open type of inflorescence called a thyrse. A thyrse is defined as a main axis that grows indeterminately (i.e. it doesn’t have a terminal bud), surrounded by cymes (floral arrangements where there is a terminal bud surrounded by younger buds). Figure 1 illustrates this.

Figure 1. The arrangement of flowers in a thyrse
Author: Michael G. Simpson. Redrawn and color: User:RoRo
This work is ineligible for copyright and therefore in the public domain because it consists entirely of information that is common property and contains no original authorship.

In the particular kind of thyrse that these researchers believe evolved into the cyathium, there is a terminal female flower surrounded by cymes of male flowers. (This seems to contradict the requirement that the main axis be indeterminate, so I’m a bit confused on that point. At any rate, that’s the type of inflorescence they’re calling a thyrse.) It’s not too hard to imagine how such a cluster of flowers might have gradually condensed into the form of a cyathium.

Prenner and Rudall’s research has also led to the fascinating suggestion that the cyathium may actually be neither an inflorescence nor a flower, but some kind of hybrid of the two. It appears that some of the regulatory genes that would normally determine the development of individual flowers have been recruited to help control the development of the cyathium. This could help to explain why the cyathium looks so much like a flower, even though it evolved from an inflorescence.

The Fruit

In the cyathium in the center of the following photo, the fertilized female flower has developed into a fruit. As you can see, it’s grown so large that the pedicel can no longer support it. The male flowers that used to surround it have all withered away.

Smallseed Sandmat (Euphorbia polycarpa)
San Diego County, CA 3/9/20

Another fruit is visible in the next photo. It has three compartments, which is typical of most euphorbs, although a few species have fruits with only two.

Smallseed Sandmat (Euphorbia polycarpa)
San Diego County, CA 3/9/20

Now that we’ve covered the general characteristics of the genus, let’s take a look a few more species…

Petty Spurge (Euphorbia peplus) 174 175

Note: This should not be confused with purple spurge (Euphorbia peplis).

Petty spurge is also called radium weed, cancer weed, and milkweed. (Milkweed is also used for plants in the unrelated genus Asclepius.) Petty spurge is native to Europe, northern Africa, and western Asia, but it’s been naturalized in many other parts of the world, including here in Southern California. It’s a small, annual plant that tends to grow in disturbed areas.

Petty spurge (Euphorbia peplus)
Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County, CA 4/13/19

The following photo shows one of the fruits. As with E. polycarpa, it has three compartments.

Petty spurge (Euphorbia peplus)
Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County, CA 4/13/19

The next several photos show the cyathium in various stages of development.

Petty spurge (Euphorbia peplus)
Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County, CA 4/13/19
Petty spurge (Euphorbia peplus)
Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County, CA 4/13/19
Petty spurge (Euphorbia peplus)
Ruffin Canyon, San Diego County, CA 4/13/19

In European folk medicine, the latex from petty spurge is sometimes used for removing warts, corns, sun spots and non-melanoma skin cancers. The sap is applied to the spot once a day for two or three days. The latex “burns” the spot off, forming a scab that drops off after about a week.

Medical research has been done on the use of this sap in cancer treatment. Laboratory experiments have shown that the active ingredient in the sap, ingenol mebutate, is selective in targeting leukemia cells and that the cells are sensitive to small doses. Clinical trials with the latex have shown significant clearance of human non-melanoma skin cancers. (Note: Please don’t try to self-medicate with petty spurge. Always consult with your doctor for treatment options.)

Caper Spurge (Euphorbia lathyris) 176 177

Caper spurge is native to southern Europe, northwest Africa, and parts of Asia. Unfortunately, it’s something of an invasive here in Southern California. All parts of the plant are toxic. It’s sold by some nurseries because it’s believed to repel moles. For this reason, it’s sometimes called mole plant. Another common name is gopher spurge or gopher plant.

E. lathyris has been used in folk medicine as a purgative and for removing corns, warts, and non-lymphoma cancers. (The plant is highly poisonous, so don’t try this yourself. There are safer, modern treatments for all those things.) Beggars have even been known to apply the leaves to their skin in order to raise sores and blisters in an attempt to elicit pity and, thereby, increase their revenue.

Caper spurge (Euphorbia lathyris)
Rancho San Diego, CA 9/27/17
Caper spurge (Euphorbia lathyris)
Rancho San Diego, Jamul, CA 9/27/17

A Few Ornamentals

The species of Euphorbia that I’ve been discussing up to this point were all found growing wild. However, spurges are such popular ornamentals and take such strange and varied forms that I felt I should include a few of the cultivars that I see growing in my neighborhood. So the rest of this article will be devoted to a few of the more common examples.

Crown of Thorns (Euphorbia milii) 178

Legend has it that the crown of thorns worn by Jesus at the Crucifixion was made from the stems of Euphorbia milii. Hence the common names: crown of thorns, Christ plant, and Christ thorn. Not surprisingly, there’s no hard evidence to back up this legend. It’s not entirely out of the realm of possibility, though. The stems are flexible and, as you can see from the following photo, they would certainly do the job. E. millii is native to Madagascar, but according to a number of websites, there exists “substantial” evidence that it was brought to the Middle East before the time of Christ. (Substantial though it may be, I haven’t been able to track down any of this evidence. Admittedly, I haven’t spent a lot of time trying.)

Crown of thorns (Euphorbia milii), cultivar 3/26/20
La Mesa, CA
Crown of thorns (Euphorbia milii), cultivar 3/26/20
La Mesa, CA
Crown of thorns (Euphorbia milii), cultivar 3/26/20
La Mesa, CA
A cyathium with the remnants of stamens and pistil
A cyathium with the remnants of stamens and pistil

Pencil Cactus (Euphorbia tirucalli) 179

Pencil cactus or pencil tree is, of course, not a real cactus. It’s a euphorb that’s native to Africa and it’s an example of a succulent euphorbia. It can grow into a small tree up to 7 meters tall.

Pencil cactus is a very popular ornamental in many parts of the world. It should be handled with care, however. Its latex can cause extreme irritation and a burning sensation if you get it on your skin. More alarmingly, it can cause blindness if you get some in your eyes. (I believe the blindness is temporary, but it’s not something I’d want to chance.) So it’s probably a good idea to wear gloves and eye protection when handling it, especially if you’re going to be pruning or cutting it.

Pencil Cactus (Euphorbia tirucalli)
La Mesa, CA 3/24/20
The leaves, such as they are, are tiny and easily fall off. You have to wonder why the plant bothers.
A closeup

Poinsettia (Euphorbia pulcherimma) 180 181 182 183

Yes, the famous poinsettia is a euphorb. The red “petals” are actually bracts. In this case, it’s pretty obvious that they are modified leaves — they look almost exactly like the other leaves, just a different color.

Pointsettia (Euphorbia pulcherimma)
Source: Max Wahrhaftig
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled GNU Free Documentation License.

Poinsettias are native to Mexico and Central America, ranging as far south as Guatemala. Most of the cultivated varieties are thought to be derived from a single population in the Mexican state of Guerrero.

Poinsettia gets its common name from Joel Roberts Poinsett, the man who was first responsible for popularizing the plant outside of its native range. Poinsett is an interesting character in his own right. Born in 1779 in Charleston, South Carolina, he had a long and storied career as a physician and diplomat. He was also an amateur botanist and maintained hothouses on plantations that he owned in Greenville, South Carolina.

From 1825 to 1829, Poinsett served as the first United States Ambassador to Mexico. He encountered poinsettias while visiting the Taxco area in 1828 and sent some back to his hothouses in South Carolina. He propagated the plants there and began sending them to friends and to botanical gardens.

Although not native to California, poinsettias nevertheless have a close connection to the state, thanks to the Ecke family. (Ecke is pronounced EH-kee.) Albert Ecke emigrated to Los Angeles from Germany in 1900, where he opened a dairy and orchard. Albert became interested in poinsettias and began selling them from street stands. Albert’s son, Paul, developed a grafting technique that made the plants significantly more attractive. It was Albert’s grandson, Paul Ecke Jr., however, that really got the ball rolling.

Paul Jr. seems to have been something of a marketing genius. He sent free plants to television stations where they would be displayed from Thanksgiving to Christmas. He even appeared on television shows like The Tonight Show and Bob Hope’s Christmas specials. The plants got screen time with Johnny Carson and Dinah Shore. By good fortune, poinsettias happen to flower during the Christmas season. (Remember, the plant is native to hot climates, so it’s not that too surprising that they would flower during the winter.) So the family began promoting poinsettia as “the Christmas flower”.

In 1923, the Ecke family moved their operation from Los Angeles to Encinitas, CA in San Diego County (only 30 miles from where I live, incidentally). The Paul Ecke Poinsettia Ranch is still located there.

The Eckes made pointsettias the best-selling potted plants in America. At its height, the family supplied 90 percent of the American market. Eventually, a grad student was able to figure out the secret grafting technique that was used to improve the appearance of the plants and, as a result, the company lost some of its market share. Nevertheless, the Eckes still retain a 70 percent share of the market.

A white variety of pointsettia (Euphorbia pulcherimma)
Source: https://www.flickr.com/photos/calliope/74116749/in/photostream
Author: Muffet
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

Although it’s widely believed that poinsettias are highly toxic to humans and pets, this is an urban legend. Poinsettia sap is toxic, but much less so than many other members of the genus. It may cause diarrhea or vomiting if swallowed, but the bad taste makes this unlikely and simple contact with the plant by children or pets often has no effect. Researchers trying to determine a poisonous dose by feeding the plant to rats were unable to find one. They fed rats the equivalent of 500 leaves and the rats still survived! So you shouldn’t have to worry too much about keeping poinsettias around the house.

Pseudanthia 184

Many other types of flowering plants have inflorescences that look like flowers. The general term for this type of inflorescence is pseudanthium (pl. pseudanthia). Other terms you’ll hear are flower head, composite flower, and capitulum.

The most well-known plants with composite flowers are members of the aster or sunflower family, Asteraceae. The pseudanthium of a sunflower consists of a large number of disk flowers surrounded by ray flowers. The ray flowers look for all the world like petals, but they’re not. Each one is an individual flower. Likewise with the disk flowers.

The flowers of some Asteraceae, like the dandelions, have only ray flowers. Others, like the thistles, have only disk flowers, but in all cases, what looks like a single flower is actually many flowers.

Here’s a photo of the flower head of a California sunflower:

California Sunflower (Helianthus californicus)
Author: Björn S…
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.

Another good example of flowering plants that have pseudanthia is the arum family, Araceae. Members of this family have a type of composite flower called a spadix, which is a tall column or spike, usually with female flowers arranged toward the bottom of the column and male flowers toward the top. The spadix is almost always surrounded by a modified leaf called a spathe.

A spadix surrounded by a spathe
Peace lily (Spathiphyllum cochlearispathum)
Author: W.carter
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

As discussed earlier in the article, researchers have found that the cyathium of a spurge may actually be a hybrid of a flower and an inflorescence. Some of the regulatory genes that determine the development of a flower have been recruited to help control the development of the cyathium. It would be interesting to know if this is the case with other types of pseudanthia. I don’t know if anyone has studied this.

(More or Less) Carnivorous Plants

What is a carnivorous plant? Seems like a simple question, right? Of course, nature is rarely simple. Suppose an animal dies next to a rosebush. Suppose also that, instead of being scavenged, its body decomposes where it fell. The rosebush will happily take up the nitrogen and other nutrients released by the decomposing body. Does that make the rosebush carnivorous? If so, that would mean that almost all plants are carnivores. So just being capable of absorbing nutrients from decomposing flesh is probably not a good definition of carnivory.

Various botanists have tried to come up with a more satisfactory definition. None of them is universally accepted, but the following, rather strict, definition is often used. According to this definition, a plant must meet the following criteria to be carnivorous: 173

  1. It has to do something to attract prey.
  2. It has to capture the prey.
  3. It has to digest the prey, using digestive enzymes that it secretes itself.
  4. It has to absorb the products of digestion. (I guess that one’s pretty obvious, but it’ll be important later.)

In this article, I’m going to go through most of the different kinds of (more or less) carnivorous plants and point out how they do or don’t meet these criteria.

Venus FlyTrap (Dionaea muscipula) 184

We may as well start with the most famous carnivorous plant, the Venus flytrap. Venus flytraps are native to the east coast of North and South Carolina. Each trap is a modified leaf, consisting of two lobes, hinged at the midrib. The interior of the lobes are a reddish color and there are small nectar-secreting glands along the rims. So any insects that happen by think they’ve found a flower and blithely crawl into the trap.

Venus FlyTrap (Dionaea muscipula)
The Huntington Botanical Garden, San Marino, CA 4/22/18
Interesting that all the traps seem to be sprung. I suspect that’s because the plant is in a botanical garden. A trap probably isn’t open for long before some kid comes along…

On the upper surface of each lobe are three trigger hairs. To trigger the trap, two of these hairs much be touched within 20 seconds of each other or one of the hairs must be touched twice in quick succession. The calibration of the triggering mechanism is so finely tuned that it will not normally be triggered by non-prey stimuli, such as raindrops. After snapping shut, the trap only begins digestion if it receives at least five more triggers. This ensures that it’s caught a live bug, not just some piece of detritus.

The trap doesn’t close completely right away, though. The edges of the leaf lobes are fringed by stiff hairs called cilia. When the trap closes part-way, the cilia mesh together blocking the escape of larger prey, but very small bugs that aren’t worth eating can get out through the gaps in the cilia. If the trap fails to capture a suitable bug, it will reopen after around 12 hours.

Once the trap closes all the way, it forms a hermetic seal and essentially becomes a stomach for digesting the prey. Glands on the leaf lobes release digestive enzymes that break down the body of the prey into small components that can be absorbed through the leaf surface. Digestion takes about ten days, after which, the trap reopens, releasing the empty husk. The flytrap catches mostly crawling arthropods, such as ants, beetles and spiders.

Is it carnivorous? D. muscipula fits all the criteria listed above. By any definition, it’s a carnivore.

Waterwheel Plant (Aldrovanda vesiculosa) 185

The only extant (non-extinct) plant with a trapping mechanism similar to the Venus flytrap is the waterwheel plant, which is the only living species in the genus Aldrovanda. The waterwheel is a free-floating aquatic plant with no roots. The traps are arranged in whorls around a central stem. They’re similar to the traps of the Venus flytrap, but much smaller — the lobes are only 2-3 mm long. They trap very small prey like nematodes and Daphnia (water fleas).

Waterwheel plant (Aldrovanda vesiculosa)
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

A. vesiculosa is the most widely distributed of all the carnivorous plants — it’s native to Europe, Africa, Asia, and Australia. This is due to its mechanism of distribution — the small plants stick to the feet of migrating waterfowl which drop them off at their next stop. Despite its wide distribution, the waterwheel is not doing well. There are only 50 confirmed populations left in the world.

Is it carnivorous? The waterwheel fits all the criteria of carnivory except one. It doesn’t appear to do anything to attract prey. Maybe its prey is so common that it doesn’t need to. Seems like nit-picking, though. I think most botanists would still consider it a carnivorous plant.

Sundews (genus Drosera) 186

The sundews make up the genus Drosera, which contains at least 194 species, making it one of the largest genera of carnivorous plants. It’s also very widespread — there are native sundews on every continent except Antarctica. Here in California, there are at least two native species — the great sundew (D. anglica) in the central and northern part of the state and the round-leaved sundew (D. rotundifolia), which seems to have a slightly larger distribution, extending a bit farther south. There are also a number of introduced species.187

Sundew (Drosera sp.)
The Huntington Botanical Garden, San Marino, CA 4/22/18

In most species of sundew, the leaves are covered with two types of glands. The first type takes the form of long tentacles, topped with sticky globs of sweet, glistening mucilage. These globs attract insects, snare them, and then secrete the enzymes that digest them. (Talk about multi-purpose!) The second type are sessile (stalkless) glands that absorb the products of digestion.

A fly trapped by a sundew
(Closeup from the last photo)

As soon as an insect is snared by the mucilage, the surrounding tentacles begin to bend toward the center of the leaf, bringing more globs of mucilage in contact with the bug. The mucilage clogs the spiracles (breathing pores) of the insect, causing it to suffocate. In some species, the leaf itself will bend around the insect to bring even more tentacles in contact with it. (You can see this behavior in the above photos.)

Are they carnivorous? Sundews easily meet the criteria for carnivory.

An Evolutionary Aside 188

The Venus flytrap (Dionaea), the waterwheel plant (Aldrovanda), and the sundews (Drosera) are grouped together into the family Droceraceae. Molecular and morphological studies suggest that Dionaea and Aldrovanda are more closely related to each other than to any other genera. Studies also suggest that Dionaea and Aldrovanda share a common ancestor with the sundews. The fossil record for carnivorous plants is far too sketchy to allow us to trace the evolution of these groups, but genetics and morphology can give us some clues. According to current thinking, Dionaea and Aldrovanda probably evolved from a sundew ancestor.

We’ve already seen that the leaves of many types of sundew will curl around a trapped insect and that this reflex is triggered by the insect touching the glandular tentacles of the leaf. The leaves of the various species of Drosera vary greatly in form. In the particular species shown above, the leaves are long and strap-like, but in many species they’re round. It’s not too hard to imagine how a round leaf with a propensity for closing around prey might have evolved into the snap-trap of a Venus flytrap or waterwheel. In this scenario, the glandular tentacles would have evolved into the trigger hairs of the trap, losing in the process their ability to secrete mucilage, which would no longer be needed.

Currently, there’s no evidence as to whether Dionaea evolved before Aldrovanda or vice versa. It could have happened either way.

Portuguese Sundew (Drosophyllum lusitanicum) 189

The Portuguese sundew is native to the Iberian Peninsula and Northern Africa. It’s not closely related to the true sundews (genus Drosera), but it does resemble them, having long glandular tentacles that trap insects. Unlike the tentacles of the sundews, however, these tentacles do not move in response to stimuli.

Portuguese sundew (Drosophyllum lusitanicum)
Author: Javier martin
Released into the public domain on Wikipedia Commons. Link to source page.

Is it carnivorous? D. lusitanicum excretes it’s own enzymes to digest trapped insects. So, although it’s traps are completely passive, it fits all the criteria for strict carnivory.

Bladderworts (genus Utricularia) 190 191 192

Bladderworts are found all over the world, except, of course, Antarctica. Quite a few species are native to California. Utricularia includes both terrestrial and aquatic species. In both cases, the main part of the plant grows beneath the surface.

Bladderwort (Utricularia dimorphantha) in Japan
Author: fischermans
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

All bladderworts are carnivorous, trapping small prey using bladder-like traps. These traps are quite sophisticated. In fact, Utricularia may be the among the most highly developed plants in the world. Each trap has a trapdoor with trigger hairs. When a prey animal touches a trigger, the trapdoor opens and the animal is sucked into the bladder. The trapdoor quickly closes, trapping the animal inside. This process takes only ten to fifteen milliseconds. The bladder secretes digestive enzymes into the trap and the plant absorbs the products of digestion.

Water is constantly being pumped out of the trap. This creates a negative pressure inside the trap, due to the elasticity of the bladder walls. That is, the walls of the bladder are sucked inwards as water is pumped out. When the trapdoor opens, the walls spring apart, creating the suction that pulls in the prey.

Terrestrial species of bladderwort tend to feed on very small prey such as protozoa and rotifers swimming in the water-saturated soil. Aquatic species usually have larger traps and can feed on larger prey such as Daphnia, nematodes, mosquitoes, young tadpoles, and even fish fry.

Are they carnivorous? Yes.

Butterworts (genus Pinguicula) 193 194 195

Butterworts are found throughout the Northern Hemisphere, as well as Central and South America. Mexico has the most numerous species. The common name comes from the greasy feel of the plant’s leaves.

Butterwort (Pinguicula conzattii) in Oaxaca, Mexico
Author: NoahElhardt
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Generic license.

Pinquicula tend to be small plants with flat leaves. They trap prey by means of tiny glandular hairs that cover the leaves. There are two types of these glands. The peduncular glands consist a of single stalk cell with a few secretory cells at the tip. These cells produce mucilage, which forms visible droplets on the leaf surface. This gives the leaf a wet appearance, which probably helps to attract insects. The peduncular glands secrete a small amount of digestive enzymes, but are mostly used for luring and trapping small insects. Some species are able to bend the leaf edges slightly, in order to bring more of the glands into contact with the prey.

The second kind of gland found on the leaves are sessile glands, which lie flat on the leaf surface. When the peduncular glands trap a bug and start the process of digestion, the flow of nitrogen stimulates the sessile glands to release additional enzymes that complete the process. The products of digestion are absorbed through the leave surface.

Butterworts will also digest pollen grains that land on their leaves.

Are they carnivorous? Butterworts fulfill all the criteria for carnivory.

Corkscrew Plants (genus Genlisea) 196 197 198

Corkscrew plants are small plants native to Africa and Central and South America. Genlisea have no roots. Instead, they have two types of leaves — above-ground leaves that carry out photosynthesis and highly modified subterranean leaves that attract, trap, and digest tiny invertebrates, especially protozoa. Each of these underground leaves forms a hollow tube which forks into a pair of capillary tubes. Spiral grooves along the length of each capillary tube allow the prey to enter and inwardly-pointing hairs prevent them from escaping. At the fork, the prey enters the main tube, which also has inwardly-pointing hairs. Eventually, the animal reaches the digestive chamber — a vesicle containing glands which secrete digestive enzymes.

Corkscrew plant (Genlisea lobata). Native to Brazil.
Author: Denis Barthel
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Besides trapping prey, the subterranean leaves of the corkscrew plant serve many of the functions of roots, including anchoring the plant and absorbing water and nutrients.

Are they carnivorous? Several of the articles I read mentioned that corkscrew plants attract prey, but I couldn’t find any that explained how they do this. So, assuming this is true, Genlisea does fit the strict definition of carnivory.

Another Evolutionary Aside 199 200

The bladderworts, butterworts, and corkscrew plants are grouped together into the family Lentibulariaceae. The corkscrews branched off first from the common ancestor of Lentibulariaceae and the other two genera branched off later. Scientists believe that the most recent common ancestor of all these plants was terrestrial and had a basal rosette of flat leaves and a primary root.

The carnivorous technique of the butterworts is pretty similar to that of the sundews, minus any movement of the glands. The bladderworts and corkscrews, on the other hand, seem to be totally unique in the carnivorous plant world. Unfortunately, I haven’t been able to find any information about the evolution of carnivory in these two genera. If I find anything in the future, I’ll update this page.

American Pitcher Plants (family Sarraceniaceae) 201 202

The pitcher plants in the Sarraceniaceae family may be the most well-known of the carnivorous plants after the Venus flytrap. The family contains three extant genera — Sarracenia, Darlingtonia, and Heliamphora.

Sarracenia composes the North American pitcher plants (excluding Darlingtonia). The pitchers are formed by long leaves that curl up to form tall, water-tight tubes. Usually, many pitchers radiate out from a central point. The tubes are partially filled with rainwater mixed with digestive enzymes.

Purple pitcher plant (Sarracenia purpurea)
Author: Geoff Gallice from Gainesville, FL, USA
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

The pitcher attracts insects with secretions from nectaries located around the lip. In most species, a waxy coating on the lip causes insects to fall in and more wax on the inside of the pitcher makes it difficult for them to climb out. Many species also have downward-pointing hairs on the inside the pitcher that make climbing out even more difficult. Further down the tube, the insects fall into the water where they drown and are digested.

At least some members of the Sarracenia genus produce their own digestive enzymes. However, most, if not all, species also use symbiotic bacteria and protozoa to supplement their supply of enzymes and some may rely on them entirely.

Members of the genus Darlingtonia are often called cobra lilies because of the their resemblance to the snake. Darlingtonia californica is the only species in the genus and it’s native to Northern California and Oregon. D. california is unusual in that it doesn’t trap rainwater in its pitchers. The water is drawn up from the roots. The hood prevents rainwater from diluting the contents of the pitcher.

California pitcher plant (Darlingtonia californica) a.k.a. cobra lily, Botanical Trail, Butterfly Valley Botanical Area, Plumas County, California
Author: NoahElhardt (talk · contribs)
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

It used to be believed that the cobra lily did not produce any of its own digestive enzymes and, instead, relied entirely on symbiotic microorganisms to digest its prey. However, recent studies have shown that it does secrete at least one such enzyme.

Heliamphora is the genus of South American pitcher plants, which are called sun pitchers in common parlance. They’re similar to the other plants in Sarraceniaceae with the exception that most of the species in the genus do not produce their own digestive enzymes. Instead, they rely on symbiotic bacteria.

Are they carnivorous? As already mentioned, many of the species in Saraceniaceae do secrete at least some of their own digestive enzymes. Those species, at least, fit the strict definition of carnivory. Most of the members of the genus Heliamphora, however, rely entirely on symbiotic bacteria for digestion and, so, would only fit a looser definition.

Tropical Pitcher Plants (genus Nepenthes, family Nepenthaceae) 203

The pitchers of Nepenthes are remarkably similar in form to the pitchers of Sarraceniaceae, even though the the two groups are not closely related. They’re a wonderful example of convergent evolution, which is where two unrelated organisms evolve very similar features simply because they are under similar evolutionary pressures. In other words, they find similar solutions to a common problem. In this case, the common problem is how to supplement their diets. One thing all carnivorous plants have in common is that they grow in areas that are nutrient poor. Carnivory is a way of getting the nutrients that they can’t get from the soil.

Upper pitcher of Nepenthes alata photographed on Mt Ambucao, near Sagada and Banaue, Luzon in The Philippines
Author: Attenboroughii
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

Unlike the pitcher plants of the Americas, most species of Nepenthes grow as woody vines (lianas). Most of them produce two types of pitchers. The lower pitchers typically sit on the ground. The upper or aerial pitchers are usually smaller and have different features. In both cases, the pitchers grow from tendrils of the liana. The tendril of an upper pitcher will often loop around a branch to steady the pitcher. In some cases, the upper and lower pitchers are specialized to attract different types of prey.

The prey of Nepenthes usually consist of insects, but the species with the largest pitchers sometimes catch vertebrates such as lizards and even rats! A plant that eats small mammals… that may be the closest we’ll ever get to Audrey II! 204

Are they carnivorous? The members of Nepenthes are believed to secrete at least some of the digestive enzymes found in their pitchers, although these are supplemented with enzymes produced by symbiotic microorganisms. So Nepenthes seems to fit the strict definition of carnivory.

A Special Mention for Nepenthes lowii 205 206

We’re not quite finished with Nepenthes yet, because now we come to the one carnivorous plant that I absolutely had to write about. Nepenthes lowii is a tropical pitcher plant that grows in Borneo. Lower pitchers are rare, because the plant quickly enters the climbing stage in which the upper pitchers are produced. And the interesting thing about these upper pitchers is that they look a lot like toilet bowls. With lids. But the really interesting thing is that they are toilet bowls.

Nepenthes lowii
Author: JeremiahsCPs
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

The underside of the lid produces a white secretion that looks a lot like snail eggs, but is actually produced by the plant itself. This secretion attracts birds, tree shrews, and the occasional rat. The opening of the pitcher and the placement of the lid have evolved in such a way that a tree shrew or rat feasting on the secretion will naturally straddle the opening of the pitcher. In fact, the pitcher appears to have evolved to be a perfect fit for tree shews. Any excrement produced by the rodent will drop into the pitcher. Poop is high in nitrogen — just what the plant is looking for. So, to put it bluntly, N. lowii eats poop.

Oh, and I almost forgot… the white secretion seems to contain a fast-acting laxative.

Is it carnivorous? Nepenthes lowii meets all the criteria for carnivory except one: it doesn’t eat the animals — just their excrement. Actually, that’s not entirely true. Insects do fall into N. lowii‘s pitchers and they do get eaten, so technically I guess it is carnivorous. However, the plant eats mostly feces and studies have shown that it is quite capable of subsisting entirely on a diet of poop. So N. lowii seems be a case of a carnivorous plant that is evolving away from carnivory.

Bromeliads (family Bromeliaceae) 207

The bromeliads are one of the few groups of monocots that includes carnivorous plants. (Monocots and dicots are two of the major groups into which the flowering plants are divided. The seeds of monocots contain only one embryonic leaf. Those of dicots contain two.) Bromeliads include both terrestrial species and epiphytes. An epiphyte is a plant that grows on another plant and gets its water and nutrients from air, rain, water (in aquatic environments) or debris that accumulates around them. Epiphytes are not parasites. They just use other plants for support.

In many bromeliads, a rosette of leaves forms a tank that catches rainwater. A pool forms in the tank and the leaves absorb water from the pool. Entire ecosystems often form in these pools, including insects and tree frogs. Animals defecate and die in the pools. Other plants, such as algae, grow in the pools and detritus collects in them. All this supplies the bromeliad with a rich source of nutrients to be absorbed by the leaves.

Brocchinia reducta. Native to South America.
Author: BotBln
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

A number of bromeliad species have been found to attract insects, which drown in the pools and are digested at least partly by enzymes produced by the plants.

Are they carnivorous? The bromeliads that attract, kill, and digest insects appear to fit the definition.

Another Special Mention: The Sheep-Eating Plant 208

Puya chilensis is a tree-like bromeliad that grows in the Andes. Its leaf rosettes are used by several bird species as nests. I’m not sure if P. chilensis absorbs any nutrients through its leaves, but run-off from the nests may fertilize the roots.

P. chilensis has very sharp, outwardly-pointing spines, which it probably uses to discourage predators. Birds are often trapped and killed by these spines and run-off from their decomposing bodies might also fertilize the roots of the plant. Where it gets crazy, though, is that sheep sometimes get their wool entangled by the spines of these plants and, if not rescued, they may die and decompose at the base of the plant. The roots of the plant would, of course, absorb the nutrients released by that decomposition and a rotting sheep carcass releases a lot of nutrients. For this reason, P. chilensis is sometimes called the “sheep-eating plant”.

P. chilensis does’t produce digestive enzymes, so it doesn’t fit the strict definition of a carnivorous plant. It’s still pretty amazing, though. It makes you wonder kinds of bizarre, now-extinct carnivorous plants might have existed in the past.

Click here to watch a video of some sheep caught by P. chilensis.

Dewstick or Fly Bush (genus Roridula, family Roridulaceae) 209

Roridula is a genus of shrubs native to South Africa. The leaves and sepals are covered with sticky tentacles, which trap insects. The dewstick does not digest the insects directly, however. Instead, there are two species of insect, both in the genus Pameridia, that prey on the captured bugs. These insects deposit their droppings on the leaves, which absorb nutrients from them.

Dewstick (Roridula gorgonias) in Kew Gardens
Author: Polypompholyx
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Are they carnivorous? The members of Roridula don’t excrete their own digestive juices. They don’t even eat the trapped insects — just the feces of the symbiotic Pameridia. So they certainly don’t fit the strict definition of carnivory. And yet, they do attract and capture insects and, eventually, the nutrients from those insects get into the plant by way of the Pameridia. So maybe the strict definition is too strict.

Protocarnivorous Plants 210 211

Occasionally, we encounter a plant that seems to meet all the criteria for carnivory except one: they don’t actually eat their prey. For instance, there are plants that attract insects, capture the insects, and even secrete digestive enzymes to digest the insects, but they don’t absorb the products of digestion. What could possibly be going on here?

In fact, the solution to this conundrum is pretty simple. Plants don’t just kill insects in order to eat them. They also kill them to protect themselves from being eaten. It’s not hard for plants to attract insects. They do it all the time without meaning to. So plants have had to evolve defenses against being eaten. Often this means producing toxic or bad-tasting chemicals to discourage the bugs. Another approach is to secrete a sticky substance that traps them and clogs up their pores.

Suppose a plant has taken this second approach and evolved sticky glands to trap insects. How could it take the next step and evolve a way to eat them? Actually, this isn’t as hard as it sounds. It turns out that regular, non-carnivorous plants are able to absorb nutrients through their leaves. They do it through their stomata (breathing pores), but also directly through the epidermis — the outer layer of the leaf. Some horticulturalists and other plant people have taken advantage of this by applying liquid fertilizer directly to the leaves — a process called foliar feeding.212

So some plants that trap and kill insects, but don’t eat them, may be on their way to becoming fully carnivorous. This kind of plant is sometimes called a protocarnivorous plant. The term is also used more broadly to refer to any plant that comes close to being fully carnivorous, but doesn’t quite fit the bill. Many of the plants discussed above could be classified as protocarnivorous. (You may also encounter terms like paracarnivorous, subcarnivorous, and borderline carnivorous. They’re all used pretty much interchangeably.)

A great many groups of plants have been examined for possible carnivory or protocarnivory — many more than I care to cover in this post. But if you’re interested, you can click here to read a paper that goes through various plant families, examining each one for evidence for carnivory. It’s actually a pretty good read and I used it as a reference for much of the information presented here. For the purposes of this article, though, I’ll just mention one of the possibly protocarnivorous plants that I’ve encountered in Southern California…

The Catchfly, a Possible Protocarnivore

Plants in the genus Silene (family Caryophylaceae) are called catchflies because many species have sticky hairs on their stems and calyxes that trap and kill insects. They don’t seem to digest the insects, though, so they’re probably doing it as a defense against predation.

I’ve seen a couple of species of Silene in San Diego County. The beautiful scarlet catchfly (Silene laciniata angustifolia) is a California native:

Scarlet catchfly (Silene laciniata angustifolia)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 5/30/19

Small-flowered catchfly or common catchfly (Silene gallica) is another commonly seen catchfly in my area. A non-native, unfortunately.

Small-flowered catchfly (Silene gallica)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/15/19
Small-flowered catchfly (Silene gallica)
Note the hairs on the stem and leaves.
Small-flowered catchfly (Silene gallica)
Note the glands on the calyx of the flower.

Carnivorous Seeds? 213 214

Because… why not? Shepherd’s purse (Capsella bursa-pastoris) is a small plant in the mustard family (Brassicaceae). According to findings presented in Nature,215 nematodes — very tiny roundworms that are super-abundant in soil — are attracted to the seeds of this plant, get stuck in the sticky mucilage coating the seeds, and eventually die, fertilizing the soil around the plant. The researchers found that plants germinated in soil containing nematodes did better than those germinated in soil without nematodes, especially if the soil was nutrient-deficient.

Capsella bursa-pastoris seed
Author: Alexander Klepnev
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.

Is it carnivorous? It’s not known whether or not enzymes produced by the seeds play a role in the digestion of captured nematodes. It’s possible they may enlist the aid of symbiotic microorganisms to do the job, but there’s no conclusive evidence for that, either. So, at present, C. bursa-pastoris cannot be said to fit the strict definition of a carnivorous plant. It certainly counts as a protocarnivorous plant, though. And, in any case, a seed that eats worms is pretty freaking awesome!

Diving Deep Into Dodder

It’s been called witch’s hair, devil’s hair, devil’s guts, devil’s ringlets, scaldweed, beggarweed, fireweed, strangleweed, strangle tare, hairweed, pull-down, hailweed, and hellbine — the parasitic plant dodder doesn’t get a whole lot of love.190 If you do much hiking in southern California, you’re probably used to seeing huge, yellow-orange masses of dodder draping vegetation. Many people assume it’s invasive, but it’s actually native to California.

A buckwheat plant almost completely smothered in dodder
Noble Canyon, Pine Valley, CA 07/07/19

Dodder is in the genus Cuscuta, which contains between 100 and 170 species, all of them parasites. It has a world-wide distribution. Cuscuta used to be treated as the only genus in the family Cuscutaceae, but it’s now been incorporated into the morning glory family (Convolvulaceae). The various species can be yellow, orange, or red. At least one species, Cuscuta reflexa or giant dodder, is green. (That one’s found in India, so I probably won’t be posting any photos of it here.)

Dodder (Cuscuta sp.)
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 05/31/19

Cuscuta is classified as a stem parasite, because it invades the stems of other plants (as opposed to their roots). Like all parasitic plants, dodder evolved from photosynthetic ancestors. At least some species still retain traces of chlorophyll, although not nearly enough to survive without a host. Generally, if a plant is parasitic, but still does some of its own photosynthesis, it’s called a hemiparasite. If, on the other hand, it has totally lost the ability to photosynthesize, it’s called a holoparasite. Dodder seems to be an edge case. Some of the articles I’ve read confidently state that it’s a hemiparasite. Others just as confidently call it a holoparasite. To some extent, it probably depends on the species. As mentioned earlier, the Indian species — C. reflexa, is green, so it retains more chlorophyll than the other species and probably photosynthesizes at least slightly. When it comes to the other dodders, the various articles can’t seem to agree on whether they photosynthesize just a little bit or none at all.

C. subinclusa growing on laurel sumac. The leaves have been reduced to tiny scales.
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 07/23/19

When a dodder stem contacts a plant, it wraps itself around the plant. (It even wraps itself around itself, as you can see from the photos in this post). If the plant is a potential host, the dodder will produce very thin, modified roots called haustoria (singular haustorium), which burrow into the stems of the host plant and invade its vascular system, tapping into both xylem and phloem.194 The dodder then proceeds to extract all the water, sugar, and nutrients it needs from the other plant.

A Closer Look at Haustoria

The following description is based on an article published in the online journal “Frontiers of Plant Science“. You can read that article here.

When a dodder stem comes into contact with an appropriate host, it goes into an “attachment phase”, in which the cells at the contact point develop into a secondary meristem.198 This secondary meristem forms an adhesive disk or “prehaustorium”, which adheres to the stem of the host plant. Cuscuta even induces the host plant to produce sticky substances of its own to reinforce the connection.

This photo shows a couple of dodder stems wrapped around the green stem of a buckwheat plant. The swellings where the dodder contacts the host stem are the prehaustoria or adhesive disks.
San Diego County 05/31/19

Next comes the “penetration phase”, in which a haustorium grows from the adhesive disk and penetrates the stem of the host. Cuscuta secretes enzymes that work to degrade the cell walls of the host and the developing haustorium forces its way through the weakened or ruptured walls. Meanwhile, the dodder stem continues to grow longer, attaching a second prehaustorium, then a third, and so on.

Cells at the tips of the haustoria form “searching hyphae”, which search for xylem and phloem. When hyphae come into contact with one of the sieve cells of the phloem, they grow around the cell “like the fingers of a hand”. The hyphae then fuse with the cell so completely that it’s hard to tell where the parasitic hyphae end and the host cell begins.

This is a section of dodder stem that I pulled loose from the host plant. You can see the undersides of the prehaustoria. Haustoria would have been growing from the prehaustoria into the stem of the host plant. They were too integrated with the host tissue to be pulled free.

Similarly, when the searching hyphae find xylem tissue, the dodder stimulates the host xylem to develop synchronously with its own xylem tissue (formed within the hyphae), resulting in a continuous tube of xylem connecting the two plants.

Another view of adhesive disks pulled loose from a host stem
Here you can see the wounds left by the prehaustoria ripping loose from the buckwheat stem. The haustoria are still imbedded in the host stem.

To quote from the referenced article:

“The haustorium […] is the defining feature of all parasitic plants, representing the interface where nutrients, solutes, and carbohydrates are exchanged between host and parasite. […] This interface also allows the exchange of macromolecules between the host plant and the parasite.”

And:

“… the impressive extent of exchanged macromolecules such as RNAs confirms the haustorium as an ‘open door’ between host and parasite that seems not especially guarded.”

Cuscuta can reproduce asexually from bits of stem spread by birds or other animals. Dodder is a flowering plant, however, so it can also grow from seed. Most, if not all, species are annuals, so I suppose it has to regrow from seeds each year. A newly germinated seedling has roots, but little or no chlorophyll, so it has to reach a host as soon as possible. The endosperm of the seed, which is much like the yolk of an egg, contains enough food to keep the young plant alive for 5 to 10 days after germination, but if it fails to find a host within that time period, it dies. Experiments have shown that dodder locates potential hosts by sensing airborne chemicals released by the plants. In other words, it smells them. Dodder has been shown to be sensitive to a number of different volatile compounds and to be repelled by others. Once a seedling attaches itself to a host, its roots are no longer needed, so they wither away.

Dodder seeds don’t have any obvious dispersal mechanism — they simply drop to the ground. The plants probably rely on the dispersal of bits of stem by animals to spread to new areas.

The white flowers belong to California buckwheat. Remarkably, even loaded down with dodder, buckwheat still manages to produce flowers.
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 05/31/19
Cuscuta flowers (C. californica)
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 07/12/19

Many people who are familiar with dodder don’t realize that it’s a flowering plant. That’s probably because they’ve never bothered to take a close look. Dodder produces flowers in abundance, but they’re very tiny — around 3 mm wide. In most species, they’re white or cream-colored, so they don’t stand out against the pale yellow-orange of the stems.

There are a number of species of dodder in southern California, but the two most common ones are Chaparral or California dodder (C. californica) and canyon dodder (C. subinclusa). I’ve seen both species growing on Cowles Mountain in Mission Trails Regional Park, just west of San Diego. California dodder grows at or near the bottom of the mountain. It infests mostly buckwheat. The flowers are short, white, and urn-shaped.

The canyon dodder in the park grows mostly on laurel sumac. Its stems are noticeably thicker than those of California dodder. The flowers are also white, but longer and more tube-shaped. The petals are joined for maybe two-thirds of their length.

A dodder flower has five petals. The petals are joined together near the base, but peel back at the ends to expose five stamens200 and two pistils.207 The pistil of a dodder consists mostly of a style — a long, thin stalk — sporting a very small, round stigma on the end. When a pollen grain sticks to a style, it grows a thin tube that penetrates the style and follows it down to the ovary, which it fertilizes. As a flower matures, the styles grow longer. They may not grow equally, though. In many species, one style will grow noticeably longer than the other.

Cuscuta flower (C. californica)
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 07/12/19
Cuscuta flower (C. californica). Note the unequal length of the styles.
The reddish plant matter to the left of the flower is part of the buckwheat host.
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 07/12/19
Cuscuta flower (C. californica)
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 07/12/19

Why would a flower have two unequal styles? This represents two different methods of assuring reproductive success. An insect flying from flower to flower will pick up pollen from one flower and transport it to the next. The long pistil stands a better chance of getting pollen from the visiting insect stuck to it, so it has a better chance of picking up pollen from a different plant. The short pistil, on the other hand, has a better chance of receiving pollen from the stamen growing next to it. In other words, one pistil favors cross-pollination and the other favors self-pollination.

The whole point of sexual reproduction is to give a species a better chance of coping with changes in the environment by producing offspring with many different characteristics. If the environment changes in such a way that one individual has less chance of survival, maybe another individual with different characteristics will stand a better chance. So, all things being equal, cross-pollination is better than self-pollination. On the other hand, what if the pollinators that a flower usually relies on are in short supply? In that case, the plant can still reproduce by self-pollination.

Which is better — cross-pollination or self-pollination — can vary with circumstances. For instance, many plants have evolved to take advantage of disturbed ground. When a large tree falls, clearing a space in the forest, or a fire kills all the vegetation in an area, some plants have evolved to quickly colonize the newly vacated plot of ground, squeezing in a few generations before other plants crowd them out. For this kind of plant, self-pollination may be the more successful strategy, simply because it’s quicker — the plant doesn’t have to wait for a bug to come by or for the wind to blow a few pollen grains of the right sort in its direction. Believe it or not, some flowers have evolved to grow flower buds that never open! They still have stamens and styles, but the pollen from the stamens always ends up on the styles in the same bud.

As a plant species encounters different environments, it will often evolve different pollination strategies that allow it to adapt to those environments. If some members of a species evolve a new strategy that is so different from the old strategy that they are no longer able to breed with the plants that use the old strategy, then those members have formed a new species.

In his Master’s thesis, which you can read online here, Michael Wright discusses the evolution of sexual reproduction in Cuscuta. He comes to the conclusion that the evolution of two styles of unequal length was crucial to the success of the genus. To quote Dr. Wright, “The more flexible floral design enabled Cuscuta to evolve different mechanisms of reproductive assurance in coordination with their exploitation of novel host species and new pollination environments.”

Some of the examples he gives are fascinating. In one subspecies, a style tends to collect pollen from it’s own flower near its tip, but, as it grows longer and the stamens begin to wither and die, the style bends over, so that its lower part is exposed to any visiting insects. In this way, if it collects a pollen grain from an insect, that grain will likely be closer to the bottom of the style than any pollen that it picked up from its own stamens. So the tube that grows from the foreign pollen may be able to reach the ovule first. Thus, preference is given to the potentially more beneficial foreign pollen.

This springtail (order Collembola) was crawling around inside the flower of a California dodder. I don’t know if springtails are an effective pollinator of dodders, though. Just because an animal visits a flower, it doesn’t follow that it acts as a pollinator. For this reason, pollination studies

The Consequences of Intimacy

A single Cuscuta plant will routinely infect multiple host plants and multiple Cuscuta plants will routinely infect the same host. And, as already noted, the haustoria of Cuscuta form a very intimate connection with the vascular tissue of the host plant, allowing all sorts of things to pass between them. These several facts have some important consequences:

The transfer of viruses. Viruses seem to pass freely from an infected host plant to Cuscuta and from there to an uninfected host. Sometimes a virus is able to infect the dodder, as well as the host plant. In this situation, the dodder can go on to pass on the virus to other host plants even if all the original hosts have died. In other cases, Cuscuta may be immune to infection by the virus. This does not prevent it from transferring the virus between hosts, however.

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT). HGT is most familiar in microbes. Bacteria, for instance, routinely exchange DNA. This is one reason they are able to evolve resistance to antibiotics so quickly. What scientists have only recently begun to appreciate is that HGT can also occur in plants and animals. The mechanisms are not fully understood and it probably doesn’t happen very often, but there is good evidence that parasitic plants, such as Cuscuta, can exchange genes with their hosts. It’s likely that much of Cuscuta‘s success as a parasite is a result of its ability to incorporate useful genes from host plants and express them in its haustoria.

Communication between hosts. The fact that Cuscuta steals resources from its host plant is obviously detrimental to the host. There’s no getting around that. However, it doesn’t benefit a parasite if its host dies. So, perhaps it’s not so surprising that a parasite will sometimes do things that actually benefit the host. There is experimental evidence that when a dodder connects multiple host plants, it forms a communication network between them, passing useful info from plant to plant. See the section below for more details.

How Dodder Helps Its Hosts

A study published in PNAS210 showed that when two host plants are connected by a Cuscuta bridge and one of the hosts is attacked by an insect, the dodder will pass signals to the other host that cause that host to react in a way that makes it more resistant to attack. (Click here to read the original paper.)

Multiple buckwheat plants connected by dodder bridges

The study was done on Cuscuta australis. The insect pest in the study was tobacco cutworm (Spodoptera litura). Several host plants were used.

A number of experiments were done in the study. In a typical experiment, C. australis was allowed to infect two host plants growing close together, but not in contact. S. litura was allowed to feed on one of the host plants. I’ll call this plant A and I’ll call the other plant (which was not being fed on) plant B. After a period of time (say 48 hours), leaves from both host plants and vines from the dodder were collected and subjected to RNA-sequencing analysis to determine what changes had occurred in gene expression (up-regulation or down-regulation of the genes).

When an insect feeds on a leaf of a plant, the other leaves will typically start to produce chemicals that make them less attractive to the insect. The results of this study showed that the same thing happened in plant B. Apparently, when an insect feeds on a leaf of a host plant, the leaf produces signals that cause its other leaves to ramp up their defenses. These same signals are passed along by the dodder to any other host plants that it is attached to, causing them to follow suit.

The same experiment was done on plants that were close together, but not connected by dodder. In this case, plant B did not ramp up its defenses. This shows that whatever signals were being produced by plant A, they were only passed on to plant B if A and B were connected by dodder. Surprisingly, the results were similar even when plants A and B were in different families.

After collecting the leaves and vines for analysis, S. litura was allowed to feed for a time on plant B. Data was then collected on the amount of damage caused by the insects. This data showed that when a Cuscuta bridge was present, plant B experienced less insect damage, lending support to the conclusions drawn from the RNA-sequencing analysis.

Some Clues About How Dodder Became Dodder

A genetic analysis done on C. australis found that dodder split from its common ancestor with Ipomoea (the largest genus in the morning glory family) around 33 million years ago. This analysis produced a number of other interesting results. Apparently, the common ancestor of Cuscuta and Ipomoea experienced a whole-genome triplication event before the split. This is not too uncommon in plants. Such an event in an animal would almost certainly be fatal, but plants tend to be less affected by such things. In fact, having multiple copies of a gene often allows the extra copies to go on to evolve new functions, thus helping to drive evolution. Chances are, it was this triplication event that led to the split between Cuscuta and Ipomoea.

Two other results of this analysis were that Cuscuta experienced accelerated molecular evolution and large-scale gene loss. Both of these findings are typical of parasitic plants, especially holoparasites. Since a holoparasite has no need to photosynthesize and no need to extract resources from the soil, it can safely rid itself of the genes that control those functions. The parasite also has less need to produce substances to defend itself from infection and predation, since it can often use substances produced by its host plant for that purpose.

As for the accelerated molecular evolution, I haven’t been able to find any explicit explanation for that in my reading. My guess would be that the switch to a parasitic lifestyle introduces novel selective pressures that other plants in an area would not experience.

Click here to read this study.

Parasitic Plants

We expect plants to be green. Sure, flowers come in pretty much every color of the rainbow and even leaves may contain pigments that mask the underlying green, but, because plants contain chlorophyll and chlorophyll is green, we know the green must be there somewhere.

Except when it isn’t. About 1% of angiosperms (flowering plants) have either partly or wholly given up photosynthesizing in favor of becoming parasites. If you’re no longer using sunlight to make your own food, you no longer need chlorophyll. If you no longer need chlorophyll, then, over the course of millions of generations, you’re going to slowly lose the genes that allow you to make it. And so, you slowly lose the green.

A plant that is just trying out the parasitic lifestyle will still be green. Maybe the only difference you’ll notice is that its leaves are unusually small. Eventually, though, as it commits more and more to the life of a thief, its leaves will be reduced to scales or disappear altogether and its stems will turn a pasty yellow or a ghostly white. The stems may even disappear altogether as the parasite moves underground or into the body of its host. In that case, you’ll never see it at all until it flowers.

I said that 1% of flowering plants are parasites. So what about non-flowering plants? For some reason, parasitism is much rarer outside the angiosperms, but there are a few examples. Some people argue that, in bryophytes (mosses, liverworts, and hornworts), the sporophyte is parasitic on the gametophyte. (See my earlier post, In Among the Mosses – An Introduction to Liverworts.) That seems like a bit of a stretch to me, since the gametophyte depends on the sporophyte to reproduce itself and vice versa, but I guess that’s just quibbling over terminology.

There’s only one known parasitic species of conifer — a plant named Parasitaxus usta, which grows in New Caledonia. (Or maybe two. We’ll get to that later.) Other than that, the only non-flowering parasitic plants that I know of are some types of algae. Helicosporidium is a genus of algae that parasitizes the guts of insects214. As a general rule, parasitic plants tend to have greatly reduced genomes216, simply because they rely on their host to perform many of the functions that they would otherwise have to handle themselves. Interestingly, scientists have found that Helicosporium has retained most of its functions that are not directly related to photosynthesis. This suggests that Helicosporium may be fairly new to the parasite game. Given time, the species in this genus will probably lose many more genes that they no longer use or use very little. Another genus of algae, Cephaleuros, is parasitic on higher plants217. There are probably many others.

Getting back to angiosperms, parasitic flowering plants can be broadly divided into stem parasites and root parasites. In both cases, the plants have evolved thin, root-like filaments called haustoria (singular haustorium) that penetrate into the tissues of their host plants (stems, in the case of stem parasites, or roots, in the case of root parasites) and steal resources from them. Parasitic plants can also be classified by the degree of parasitism. A holoparasite is a parasite that has completely lost the ability to photosynthesize and relies entirely on its host to survive. A hemiparasite, on the other hand, still retains some ability to photosynthesize and only gets some of its resources from its host. In many cases, a hemiparasite may be on its way to becoming a holoparasite. It just hasn’t gotten there yet.

There are about 4,500 known species of parasitic flowering plants in approximately 20 families. Most of these families contain both parasites and non-parasites. The last common ancestor of the plants in such a family must have been photosynthetic (since it’s very unlikely that a plant will re-evolve photosynthesis once it has lost it.) It follows that plants have independently evolved parasitism many times. It also follows that haustoria (the thin, root-like organs) have evolved independently many times.

Now that we’ve gone over a few of the general characteristics of parasitic plants, let’s take a closer look at some of them. Each of the groups of parasitic plants that I discuss here is certainly deserving of its own article and I plan to devote future articles to some of them. For the moment, though, I’ll just give each of them a brief mention.

The one parasitic plant that most people have heard of is mistletoe. Mistletoe is actually the common name for a great many hemiparasites in the order Santalales. In fact, molecular studies have shown that plants in this order evolved parasitism independently five different times. So the different kinds of plant that we call mistletoe are not necessarily very closely related. As such, they have widely varied lifestyles.

Phainopepla poop on a mesquite branch. It looks like it’s entirely mistletoe seeds.
Lyceum Wash in Anza Borrego State Park 03/24/19

The mistletoe that I see most commonly in southern California is desert mistletoe (Phoradendron californicum), also known as mesquite mistletoe. It’s found in the Sonoron and Mojave Deserts, where it grows as a stem parasite mostly on trees in the pea family, such as mesquite and catclaw. P. californicum extracts water and nutrients from its host plant through its haustoria, but it does its own photosynthesis. (This despite having no leaves — I guess it has enough chlorophyll in its stems.) Mistletoe is spread by birds that eat the berries and poop out the indigestible seeds. A song bird called the Phainopepla is the main disperser of mistletoe seeds in western North American. It’s not uncommon when hiking in the Sonoron Desert to see a limb of a mesquite tree covered in seed-ridden droppings from this bird.

Dodder (Cuscuta sp.) on California buckwheat
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 05/31/19

Another common parasitic plant in southern California is dodder. Dodder is any member of the genus Cuscuta. The most common dodder in my area is Cuscuta californica, but there are a number of other species found here. All of them take the form of huge masses of stringy, orange-yellow tangles of thin stems and tendrils draping host plants such as buckwheat and laurel sumac. Dodders still retain traces of chlorophyll and may photosynthesize to varying degrees, so they should probably be classified as a hemiparasites. They are well on their way to being holoparasites, however, extracting water, nutrients, secondary metabolites, proteins, and even mRNAs218 from their hosts.

Update 8/25/19: Actually, the articles I’ve been reading can’t seem to agree on whether Cuscuta is a hemi- or holoparasite. Some of them say it’s totally parasitic, others say it still does a bit of photosynthesis. Maybe it varies according to the species. I would guess that most species are pretty close to being holoparasitic, but, hey, I’m not even a professional botanist.

Dodder (Cuscuta sp.)
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 05/31/19

Dodders are stem parasites. When a dodder first germinates from a seed, it has a small, rudimentary root that serves to anchor it, but it absorbs no nutrients from the soil and this root starts to degenerate once the plant acquires a host. The plant soon becomes entirely rootless. Dodder produces tiny white or cream flowers in abundance, but they usually go unnoticed by the casual observer, since they are only a few millimeters wide.

A buckwheat stem completely swathed in dodder
Cowles Mountain, San Diego County 05/31/19

The broomrape family, Orobanchaceae, is a large family of mostly root parasites. It includes both hemi- and holoparasites. Of the hemiparasites, some are obligate parasites (i.e. they can’t survive without a host). Others are facultative parasites — they can get along on their own, if necessary.

A common genus of broomrapes found in southern California is Castilleja. This includes coast Indian paintbrush (C. affinis), a perennial herb with beautiful red flowers that is well-known to hikers. Indian paintbrush is a hemiparasite. It can still photosynthesize, but its leaves are noticeably reduced. C. affinis is never found in nature without a host plant. It can survive and reproduce in a greenhouse without a host, but the plants will be less vigorous than they would be with a host. So does this make C. affinis an obligate or a facultative parasite? It’s not clear. This is another case where it’s just a matter of how you define your terms.

Coast Indian paintbrush (Castilleja affinis)
A root hemiparasite in the broomrape family
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 04/16/19

Another very common member of the genus Catilleja is the oddly named purple owl’s clover, Catilleja exserta. (Apparently, it’s also called exserted Indian paintbrush, although not by anyone I know.) C. exserta is also a hemiparasite. It’s somewhat similar in form to coast Indian paintbrush, growing in erect stems with small, thin leaves, but its flowers are a striking purple or lavender color with large spots of white. Purple owl’s clover is an annual plant. It seems to be much pickier about when it blooms than its relative, C. affinis, but, in the Spring, when the time is right, it can be seen blooming in profusion.

Purple owl’s clover (Castilleja exserta)
Other common names include escobita and exserted Indian paintbrush.
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 04/16/19

Yet another hemiparasitic broomrape in my area — one that I just recently learned about — is bird’s beak, specifically stiffbranch bird’s beak (Cordylanthus rigidus). It’s an odd-looking plant, again with small, much reduced leaves on thin stems. The flowers are strange white blossoms that apparently remind some people of bird’s beaks. The dark-tipped bracts219 that surround the blossoms are what really give the plant its weirdness.

Stiffbranch bird’s beak (Cordylanthus rigidus)
A root hemiparasite in the broomrape family
Otay Mountain, San Diego County 06/22/19

Two more species of broomrape found in southern California are chaparral broomrape (Orobranche bulbosa), which I saw on Otay Mountain near the Mexican border, and Parish’s broomrape (Orobanche parishii), which I encountered a bit farther North near Pine Valley, CA. Both are holoparasites, depending entirely on resources extracted from the roots of their host plants. Lacking both leaves and chlorophyll, the only parts of these plants visible above ground are the thick clusters of flowers growing from single stems.

Chaparral broomrape (Orobanche bulbosa)
A weird, root holoparasite in the broomrape family
Otay Mountain, San Diego County 06/22/19
More chaparral broomrape (Orobanche bulbosa)
Otay Mountain, San Diego County 06/22/19
Parish’s broomrape (Orobanche parishii)
Another weird, beautiful member of the genus Orobanche
Noble Canyon, Pine Valley, CA 07/07/19
Parish’s broomrape (Orobanche parishii)
Noble Canyon, Pine Valley, CA 07/07/19

That about covers the parasitic plants I’ve come across on my hikes, but there are a few others I want to mention. One plant that I’ve looked for unsuccessfully for years is Thurber’s stemsucker (Pilostyles thurberi). P. thurberi is only a few millimeters long. It has no roots or leaves and lives entirely inside the stem of its host plant. The only time the plant is visible is when it blooms, sending out a tiny flower that protrudes from the stem of the host.

P. thurberi parasitizes shrubs in the pea family, especially Emory’s indigo bush or dyebush (Psorothamnus emoryi). This plant is very common in parts of the Sonoran Desert. Every time I see dyebush, I look for the flowers of the parasite, but, so far, I haven’t had any luck.

I mentioned earlier that there was only one known species of parasitic conifer — Parasitaxus usta, which grows in New Caledonia. This plant always grows attached to the roots of another conifer, Falcatifolium taxoides. It has no roots of its own, but also, no haustoria, so it’s not entirely clear how it gets its sustenance. Scientists think P. usta is a myco-heterotrope — a parasite on the mycorrhizal fungi that form symbiotic relationships with many plants. Studies have shown that it gets carbohydrates from the fungus. However, it also appears to get nitrogen and water directly from the host tree. (I’m not sure how it does this without haustoria. None of the articles I read were clear about it.) Click here to read an interesting article about this unique parasite.

This would not be the first time a plant evolved to parasitize fungi. Ghost plant or ghost pipe (Monotropa uniflora), which grows in a small part of northern California (and other parts of the world), is a known parasite of mycorrhizal fungi. Lacking chlorophyll, it sprouts a single stem that looks like a frilly white candy cane without the stripes.

I hinted earlier that there may be one more example of a parasitic conifer. I say may be, because this one’s a little different. Ever heard of an albino redwood? I hadn’t either until I started researching this article. An albino redwood is a mutant coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) that grows from the base of a normal redwood and lives on sugars extracted (usually) from the parent tree. It has no chlorophyll and so, its needles are a ghostly white. It’s also much smaller than a normal redwood, which makes sense, considering that it has to live off what it can get from its parent. Although it’s usually regarded as a parasite, in 2016 one scientist suggested that normal redwoods may actually support the albinos because they store toxic heavy metals. The albinos have defective stomata (breathing pores) that cause them to accumulate the metals in their tissues. If this is the case, then, far from being a parasite, the albino redwood could be benefiting the surrounding trees by absorbing poisons from the soil. There are only around 400 albino redwoods known and their locations are secret.

I’ll end this post with another plant that I’ve never seen in the wild (and probably never will, since it’s native to Sumatra and, possibly, Borneo). The corpse lily or corpse flower (Rafflesia arnoldii) is a parasite of a few species of vines in Tetrastigma, a genus in the grape family. R. arnoldii is most famous for producing the largest single flower in the world. This flower grows to a diameter of around one meter (3.3 feet), which is even more remarkable considering that, as with Pilostyles thurberi, the rest of the plant grows entirely inside its host. The name corpse flower comes from its scent, which mimics the smell of rotting flesh to attract its pollinators, carrion flies.

The Spineflowers

One of my favorite plants in southern California is fringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata). It’s a wonderfully strange-looking plant. The leaves form a tiny rosette around the base of the stem and are usually not visible unless you push the inflorescence out of the way. Even then, they’re often dry and shriveled up. The flower petals are narrow and pointed and, as the name suggests, fringed. At the base of each flower is a number of tiny spines. Closeup, the flowers are really spectacular, as you can see from the following photos. Fringed spineflower is found in a variety of habitats from chaparral to woodlands.

Fringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata var. laciniata)

The spineflower in the photo above and the one in the next photo are different varieties of the same species. The first one is Chorizanthe fimbriata var. laciniata and the one below is Chorizanthe fimbriata var. fimbriata. When members of a species routinely exhibit different characteristics, but those characteristics don’t prevent them from interbreeding, they’re sometimes classified as different varieties.

Fringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata var. fimbriata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 05/31/19

Just to give you an idea how small we’re talking here…


Fringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 06/11/19

The plant shows a bit more green before it’s in full bloom.

HereFringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 06/11/19

And here’s a photo of the rosette.

Fringed spineflower (Chorizanthe fimbriata)
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County. 06/11/19

There are many other species of spineflower in Chorizanthe. A common one in chaparral and scrub environments is Chorizanthe staticoides or Turkish rugging. (Is that a cool name or what?) It’s very similar to C. fimbriata, but the petals look more like regular petals, without the elaborate fringes.

Turkish rugging (Chorizanthe staticoides)
Sunshine Mountain, near Descanso, CA. 06/02/19
Turkish rugging (Chorizanthe staticoides)
Sunshine Mountain, near Descanso, CA. 06/02/19

A common species of Chorizanthe in the Sonoran desert is devil’s spineflower (C. rigida). It looks quite a bit different from C. fimbriata and C. staticoides. It can be single-stalked or multi-stalked, but it doesn’t form mats and the spikes are much more pronounced. The leaves are also more visible. They form an interesting contrast to the spikiness of the stems and add to the overall strangeness of the plant. Devil’s spineflower grows to around 4 or 5 inches tall. Its flowers are yellow, but very tiny and hard to see. After flowering, the plant dies and the leaves and stems dry up, but the stiff skeleton retains its shape, turning grey, brown, or almost black.

Devil’s Spineflower (Chorizanthe rigida)
Anza Borrego State Park. 03/24/19

In desert flats, debris washed downstream often collects around the plant’s skeleton, forming a small hillock which can obscure the plant in the center. This debris may serve as fertilizer for the next generation. Although small and easy to overlook, the evil-looking spines of devil’s spineflower makes it easy to see how it got its common name.

Brittle spineflower (Chorizanthe brevicornu) is a widely distributed plant, but it’s most common in the desert. It has a similar form to C. fimbriata and C. staticoides, but, unlike them, the whole plant is usually bright green. It has very tiny white or greenish-yellow flowers.

Brittle spineflower (Chorizanthe brevicornu)
Anza Borrego State Park. Probably March, 2019

Last, but not least, we have prostrate spineflower (Chorizanthe procumbens). It’s often yellowish-green, as in these photos, but can be gray or reddish. The tiny flowers are white or yellow. You can see a white one near the center of the following photo.

Prostrate spineflower (Chorizanthe procumbens)
Los Penasquitos Canyon, San Diego County. 06/09/19
Prostrate spineflower (Chorizanthe procumbens)
Los Penasquitos Canyon, San Diego County. 06/09/19

All the spineflowers mentioned above are annuals. To find perennial species, you’ll have to go down to Chile or Argentina, which I haven’t gotten around to doing yet. Maybe someday.

Chorizanthe and Eriogonum

Spineflowers are in the buckwheat family, Polygonaceae. In particular, they’re very closely related to plants in the genus Eriogonum. If you do any hiking at all in southern California, you’ve seen lots of California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum). The following photos show E. fasciculatum in various stages of development. Can you see similarities to any of the spineflowers?


California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum)
San Diego County. 07/04/19
California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum)
San Diego County. 07/04/19
California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum)
San Diego County. 07/04/19

A common species of Eriogonum in the Sonoran and Mohave deserts of southern California is E. inflatum or desert trumpet. Here’s a photo I took of this weird plant in the badlands of the Sonoran desert. You can just see the dried remains of a rosette of leaves at the bottom of the plant.

Desert trumpet (Eriogonum inflatum)
Anza Borrego State Park. 12/09/17

According to a molecular study done by A. S. Lamb Frye and referenced in an article on the Flora of North America website, Chorizanthe is actually embedded within Eriogonum. This means that either all the species in Chorizanthe should be moved into Eriogonum or Eriogonum should be broken up into multiple genera. You can check out the Flora of North America article here.

So it looks like any botanists out there that happen to specialize in Chorizanthe or Eriogonum can expect a bit of an upheaval in the near future as taxons are reorganized. As always, I’m amazed by the extraordinary variety of forms exhibited by organisms that are, nevertheless, very closely related.