Tag Archives: mango

A Most Disparaged Plant

“In spring, the ivory flowers bloom on the sunny hill or in sheltered glade, in summer its fine green leaves contrast refreshingly with dried and tawny grassland, in autumn its colors flame more brilliantly than in any other native, but one great fault, its poisonous juice, nullifies its every other virtue and renders this beautiful shrub the most disparaged of all within our region.” – John Howell1

Most of the people I hike with aren’t especially cognizant of the botanical life around them. If a flower is unusually pretty they might notice. They might even comment on it. For the most part, though, they hike for the scenery, the exercise, and the companionship.

One plant that does get a lot of attention, however, is poison oak. Whenever a patch is spotted, someone is sure to deliver a warning to the rest of the group. “Watch out, poison oak!” is a common refrain. I can’t really blame them. A poison oak rash is no fun. I have a habit of lying down on the ground in order to get a better shot of whatever small creature I’m photographing. I also have a habit of focusing so intently on my subject that I don’t pay attention to what I’m lying in. After one such ill-considered photo session, I came down with the worst case of poison oak in my life. It was on both arms and both legs. (A couple of people asked me why I didn’t have it on the rest of my body. I explained that I don’t normally hike naked.) It itched like crazy, and it lasted for three or four weeks. Calamine lotion, for all its sterling reputation, didn’t make much of a dent in my suffering. It was a long few weeks.

It’s a pity poison oak and its close relative, poison ivy, have such a “great fault”, because they’re actually very interesting and attractive plants. The poison ivy on the east coast of the United States is especially beautiful in the Autumn, when the leaves turn a bright red. As one floral designer put it, “It would be a great fall accent—if you could use it. The trouble is, you couldn’t count on re-orders.”2

The Genus

Both poison oak and poison ivy are in the genus Toxicodendron, which includes a number of other “poisonous” plants such as poison sumac (T. vernix) and the lacquer tree (T. vernicifluum), which grows in Asia.

There are a number of species of poison oak and poison ivy:3

  • Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) – very common in western North America. This is the one I normally see in Southern California. In fact, it’s the most common woody shrub in California.
  • Atlantic poison oak (Toxicodendron pubescens) – grows in eastern parts of the U.S., mostly in sandy soils.
  • Poison ivy (Toxicodendron radicans) – grows in all states east of the Rockies. It’s very common in my home state of Virginia. It also grows in Central America.
  • Western poison ivy (Toxicodendron rydbergii) – grows in northern parts of the eastern United States. It can also be found in the western U.S. and Canada, but it’s much less common than western poison oak.
  • Asian poison ivy (Toxicodendron orientale) – grows throughout east Asia. It could be a variety of western poison ivy (T. rydbergii), rather than a separate species.

The other member of the genus that most Americans will have heard of is poison sumac. The only species in North America is Toxicodendron vernix. It has leaves with 7 to 13 leaflets, as opposed to the usual three leaflets characteristic of poison oak and poison ivy. It grows as a small tree or a tall shrub. When I lived in Virginia, I often used to see what I thought was poison sumac, but, according to my reading, it’s not nearly as common as most people think, and what is often identified as poison sumac really isn’t. So maybe it was some other type of sumac I was seeing. According to one source, the best way to find true poison sumac is to find a bog, trip, and catch yourself. The plant you catch yourself on will be poison sumac.4 5

Poison sumac (Toxicodendron vernix)
Cedarburg Bog State Natural Area in Ozaukee County, Wisconsin 6/16/2013
Author: Freekee
This file is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.

The lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum), as the name suggests, is a tree. I’ll have more to say about it in a later section.

Leaves of Three

What English speaker hasn’t heard the rhyme “Leaves of three, let it be?” Unlike many such popular bits of folklore, this one is pretty accurate. Both poison oak and poison ivy tend to have their leaves (technically leaflets) arranged in groups of three. Certainly, there are other plants that have this characteristic, but not as many as you might think, so if you avoid all plants with “leaves of three”, you’ll probably be safe.

So how can you tell if what you’re looking at is poison oak or poison ivy? Well, where you’re at is your first clue. If you’re on the east coast of the U.S., chances are it’s poison ivy. If you’re here in the west, it’s probably poison oak. This isn’t always the case, though. A more reliable clue is the shape of the leaves. Poison ivy leaves are pointed at the tip. The leaves of poison oak have scalloped, toothed, or lobed edges and have blunt tips.

Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum)
San Diego County 4/4/21
Poison ivy (Toxicodendron radicans)
Author: Esculapio
This work has been released into the public domain by its author, Esculapio. This applies worldwide. In some countries this may not be legally possible; if so: Esculapio grants anyone the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.

I should mention that both poison oak and poison ivy drop their leaves for part of the year. So how do you identify one of these plants if they don’t have any leaves? Well, you could try rubbing one of the sticks on your arm, and see if you get a rash. Otherwise, I’m not sure. Probably, you should just try to remember where you’ve seen the plants growing in the past and avoid that area. (And, yes, you can definitely get a rash from the leafless twigs.)

Flowers and Fruit6

As noted in the quote from John Howell at the beginning of the post, T. diversilobum blooms in the spring with ivory or greenish-white flowers. The flowers of T. radicans are similar.

Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) in bloom
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/1/21
Western poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum) flowers
Mission Trails Regional Park, San Diego County 4/1/21
@A closeup

When fertilized, they develop into greenish-white or tan berries. Technically, the berries are drupes. A drupe is a fruit that consists of a fleshy outer part surrounding a hard pit, which contains the seed. Poison oak, by the way, is one of the few plants in California with white (or nearly white) berries. Another one is snowberry (genus Symphoricarpos), whose berries are very white and are considered poisonous to humans.7 So another good rule to follow, at least in California, is to not mess with anything that has white berries.

The small, off-white berries of poison oak (Toxicodendron diversilobum)
San Diego County 4/16/21

The Cashew Family8

Surprisingly, the genus Toxicodendron, with all its not-so-popular plants, is in a very popular family: Anacardiaceae or the cashew family. Besides cashews (Anacardium occidentale), Anacardiaceae also includes the pistachio tree (Pistacia vera) and the mango tree (Mangifera indica). So, that’s kind of weird, but cashews, pistachios, and mangos obviously don’t contain whatever substance is found in poison oak that causes rashes, right? Well, actually, they do. The substance is an oil called urushiol. In the case of mangos, it’s found in the skin of the fruit, not the meat. If you eat a mango, make sure you peel it first. Also, wash it after you peel it. Your knife can transfer some of the urushiol from the skin to the fruit. Apparently, some people are able to eat mangos with the skin intact without suffering any negative consequences. Presumably, those people would also be immune to the effects of poison oak. But immunity to the effects of urushiol often wears off with repeated exposure. You can be immune to it for years, and then suddenly find yourself reacting. Many people who unwisely eat the skin of a mango will find themselves with a painful rash on their lips. This is known as ‘mango mouth’.9 10

So, what about cashews and pistachios? Most people seem to be able to eat these without any problem, but, yes, some people are allergic to them. Often, if you’re allergic to one of the three (cashews, pistachios, or mangos), you’ll be allergic to all three, although that’s not always the case.11 12 Just as most of the urushiol found in a mango is in the skin and not the meat of the fruit, most of the urushiol in cashews and pistachios is in the shell. Even so, cashews and pistachios are not eaten raw. (If you buy these nuts, they may be described as raw on the packaging, but they’ve probably been roasted at least enough to break down the urushiol.)13

More on Urushiol

I guess it’s a bit late in the game to be mentioning this, but poison oak and its relatives aren’t technically poisonous. Urushiol is an allergen, not a toxin. In other words, it doesn’t directly attack your body. Instead, it causes an immune reaction. This is why you can be seemingly immune to poison oak for years and then suddenly develop an allergy to it. Repeated exposure sensitizes your immune system to the substance, until it finally starts reacting to it.

It’s also worth noting that if you’re already sensitive to urushiol, you can’t build up an immunity to it by repeatedly exposing yourself to it in small amounts. It doesn’t work that way. In fact, you would just be increasing your sensitivity to it.

Why does our immune system react to urushiol? No one knows for sure. I could describe how urushiol “attaches to certain proteins of the skin, where it acts as a hapten, leading to a type IV hypersensitive reaction”, blah, blah, blah, but the fact is, in most animals, this doesn’t happen.14 Remarkably, humans and maybe a few other primates seem to be the only animals that have an immune reaction to the compound! Your dog can wallow in poison oak or poison ivy all day, and it’ll be just fine. You, not so much. The oil dries on the dog’s fur, and it can be transferred to you — over and over again — until you get around to giving the dog a bath.

The name ‘urushiol’ comes from ‘urushi’ — the Japanese word for the Chinese lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum). The sap of this tree is tapped to produce lacquer. The sap is filtered, heat-treated, or colored before it’s applied, and the applied sap must then be cured by drying it in a warm, humid environment for 12 to 24 hours. Curing causes the urushiol to polymerize, forming a clear, hard surface. In its liquid state, the sap can cause extreme rashes, even from the fumes. Once cured, it may still cause rashes in some people, but this is uncommon.15

Foliage of the Chinese lacquer tree (Toxicodendron vernicifluum)
Author: Aomorikuma
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Exposure and Treatment

It can be a bit difficult to figure out what to believe when it comes to poison oak and poison ivy, since there’s a lot of misinformation out there. One thing I’ve read is that if you think you’ve been exposed to it, there’s no rush. It takes hours for the oil to penetrate the skin and, as long as you scrub the affected area thoroughly with soap and water when you get home, you should be okay. This doesn’t seem to be correct. The oil actually penetrates very quickly, and if you want to avoid a reaction, you need to scrub it off pretty quickly after coming into contact.

In theory, simply coming into contact with the plant is not enough to get a rash. The oil is contained within the tissues, not on the surface, so, in order to be exposed to it, you have to rupture the tissue containing it. Of course, you have no way of knowing if a plant you come in contact with has already been bruised or injured, in which case, the oil will be there waiting for you. Plus, some people are very sensitive to exposure, so better safe than sorry.

Urushiol is very sticky and, once released, it will dry onto surfaces and can take a very long time to degrade. (According to one account, the oil may stay active for one to five years!16) So if you’ve come down with a rash, it’s best to thoroughly wash everything that might still have some of the oil on it, such as the clothes you were wearing at the time.

Another misconception is that scratching the rash will spread it. The blisters do not contain urushiol, so breaking them doesn’t make the rash worse. You also can’t get it from someone else, unless they still have some of the oil on their skin or clothes.17

A popular belief that is correct is that you can get a rash from burning poison ivy, oak, or sumac and breathing in the smoke. Inhaling the fumes can cause a systemic reaction, as opposed to the usual contact reaction, and a systemic reaction can be much more serious. Symptoms may include headache, nausea, vomiting, fever, swollen lymph nodes, and difficulty breathing. Swelling in the respiratory system may even lead to death.

Calamine lotion can help make the symptoms of a rash more endurable, but it doesn’t make the rash go away any faster. It also won’t do anything for a systemic reaction. In that case, you should go to the doctor as soon as possible.18

Why Urushiol?

So why would a plant produce all that allergenic oil? Usually, when a plant produces a toxic substance, it’s to protect against herbivores. But, as I’ve already mentioned, urushiol is neither toxic nor allergenic to most animals. In fact, birds, deer, goats, and many other creatures happily dine on the urushiol-laden berries of poison oak and its relatives.

We don’t really know why some plants produce urushiol. It’s been suggested that it may protect from bacterial or fungal infection when the plant is injured, and the stickiness of the resin may help to seal wounds. This is all just speculation, though.19 20

What of the Pollen?

Some sources will tell you that every part of a poison ivy or poison oak plant contains urushiol. Apparently, this isn’t entirely true, because much of the honey produced in the U.S. contains pollen from one or the other of these plants. Honey bees are quite happy to visit the flowers of poison ivy and poison oak, and a study of honey produced in East Texas found that poison ivy pollen occurred in 83% of the samples. Granted, it wasn’t found in large amounts, so I suppose it could be that the low concentration makes it safe to eat.21 On the other hand, the book “Nectar and Pollen Plants of Oregon and the Pacific Northwest” (Burgett et al. 1989) describes poison oak as a “producer of light honey in areas where it grows in sufficient abundance”. In fact, you can buy “poison oak honey” online.22 (Click here if you want to order some.) So maybe the pollen really is free of urushiol.

Poisonous Honey23

“In the summer, in the College garden, the woolly foxglove, Digitalis lanata, is visited by little bees which become stuporose and lie upside down in the flowers, seeming unable to fly away when disturbed.” – Dr Henry Oakeley, Garden Fellow at the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) Medicinal Garden.

As long as we’re on the subject, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that, although pollen from poison oak and poison ivy seem to occur fairly regularly in honey without causing any ill effects, there is such thing as poisonous honey. Some plants produce nectar or pollen that is poisonous to humans and sometimes even to bees! If enough of this is incorporated into a batch of honey, then it could become toxic.

So why don’t we ever hear of people getting sick or dying from eating bad honey? Two reasons: First, bees usually visit a variety of flowers, so that no one plant species contributes the bulk of the pollen or nectar. When a problem does occur, it’s usually because of a lack of species diversity, forcing the bees to visit flowers that they might normally avoid. Second, when honey does become tainted, it often has a strong, unpleasant taste, so most people would naturally avoid it.

That said, there have been cases of poisoning by honey. Most often, the plant responsible is rhododendron. Rhododendron and other plants in the family Ericaceae produce chemicals called grayanotoxins, which are toxic to both bees and humans. Honey that becomes tainted with these chemicals can cause a reaction called ‘rhododendron poisoning’ or ‘honey intoxication’. I want to emphasize again that this happens very rarely, but it does happen. And sometimes it’s even changed the course of history.

Rhododendron poisoning is said to have caused Xenophon’s Greek army to have retreated from Persia in 399 bc. Later, during the Third Mithridatic War in 65 bc, the Roman general Pompey’s soldiers reportedly suffered casualties, some of them lethal, from eating rhododendron-tainted honey deliberately left behind by the enemy forces. According to historical accounts, consuming such honey would lead to a “feeling of drunkeness, to vomiting and purging, and madness that lasted for days” (Collins).24 25

The botanist Frank Kingdon-Ward and his companions experienced rhododendron poisoning while traveling towards Tibet through northern Burma. He describes the symptoms as similar to acute alcohol poisoning. The local Tibetans had apparently built up a tolerance for the toxins, as they were able to eat the honey without suffering any ill effects. (Collins) 26

In 2005, the British writer, Piers Moore Ede, published a travel book, “Honey and Dust: Travels in Search of Sweetness”, in which he describes traveling the world in search of the last of the tribes that still hunt wild honey. In the book, Ede tells of eating the “wondrous toxic honey” collected by the honey hunters of Nepal. This honey, too, was tainted by rhododendron. According to Ede, the effects of honey intoxication “resembled drunkenness at first, but then became visual, like a magic mushroom trip I remembered from university. Painted dots were dripping across my irises like technicolor rain. My body felt light and tingly, filled with warm rushes and heat-bursts. It was wild and strangely wonderful.”27 28

A Bit of History29 30

“The poisonous weed, being in shape but little different from our English ivie; but being touched causeth reddness, itchings, and lastly blysters, the which howsoever, after a while they pass away of themselves without further harme; yet because for the time they are somewhat painefull, and in aspect dangerous, it hath gotten itselfe an ill name, although questionless of noe very ill nature.” — Captain John Smith31

The term ‘poison ivy’ was coined by none other than our own Captain John Smith of Jamestown fame. Poison ivy is a native of North America, and its first mention in the literature is the above-mentioned quote from Smith. (Poison oak, of course, is so-named because of the resemblance of its leaves to those of oak trees, although the two plants are not closely related.)

European collectors were always looking to buy “exotic” new plants from the New World, and they were willing to overlook whatever disagreeable aspects some of those plants might have presented. In fact, some of those disagreeable aspects might have been regarded as a plus. What uses might medicine make of new substances that had such strong effects on the body? In those days, most medicines were plant-based, so it’s not surprising that physicians would have looked to poison ivy and its relatives for potential new treatments. Throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, scientists experimented with poison ivy as a medicine.

One physician-botanist, André-Ignace-Joseph Dufresnoy, was in the habit of giving botany lectures that were open to the public. During one such lecture, he displayed some leaves of poison ivy and described the ill effects of the plant. A young florist in the audience was skeptical. After the lecture, he approached Dufresnoy and proceeded to test the truth of his assertions by rubbing the leaves on his hands. No doubt the florist came to regret his impulsiveness, but when the rash finally cleared, he discovered that an old sore that he had had on his wrist had completely healed!

When Dufresnoy learned of this miraculous cure, he quickly concluded that poison ivy offered great potential as a medicine. He boiled some leaves in hopes of making an infusion that was safe for internal use. Apparently, this mostly worked, because Dufresnoy tested the concoction on himself and reported only mild side effects. Sweating and urination increased, and he experienced some slight stomach upset. He went on to prescribe such extracts to patients with various skin maladies and to at least one patient with paralysis of the legs. Reportedly, he had some positive results.

Dufresnoy, by the way, nearly went to the guillotine because of his infatuation with poison ivy. During the French Revolution, he sent some young plants to a physician friend. At the time, poison ivy was in the genus Rhus, instead of Toxicodendron, so Dufresnoy later wrote to his friend, asking “How are our dear Rhus? How I long to see them!” The word for Russians in French is ‘Russes’, and the Russians were threatening to join the wartime coalition against France. Dufresnoy’s letter was intercepted, and the revolutionaries interpreted ‘Rhus‘ as Russians (Russes). (People weren’t particularly consistent with their spelling back then.) Fortunately, the harsh judge who was originally due to hear the case was deposed, and Dufresnoy was able to explain to the authorities that he was just writing about plants.

In the 20th Century, botanists moved the “poisonous” members of the Rhus genus into a separate genus, Toxicodendron, which means “poison tree”. The chemist who identified urushiol as the allergen in poison ivy and figured out its chemical structure was a Japanese scientist named Rikō Majima. Japanese scientists at the time had a hard time competing with Western scientists, who were far ahead of them technologically, so Majima decided to focus on local natural products that western scientists were unlikely to spend much time on. He studied the lacquer tree from 1907 to 1922, eventually extracting the allergen and identifying it as a mixture of closely related products called alkyl catechols.

Poison Ivy in Popular Culture

For whatever reason, poison oak doesn’t receive a lot of attention in popular culture. Poison ivy is another matter. Something about the plant just seems to capture the public’s imagination. Here’s a few examples.

In 1959, the Coasters were the first group to record the song “Poison Ivy”, which was written and composed by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, respectively. Ostensibly, the song is about a woman who “comes on like a rose” and is “pretty as a daisy,” but will “really do you in if you let her get under your skin.” In reality, it’s about the clap (gonorrhea), a subject that didn’t normally get a lot of air time in 1959.

Another example, of course, is the Batman supervillain Poison Ivy. Dr. Pamela Lillian Isley is a botanist and biochemist, who survives a poisoning attempt, only to find that she has acquired an immunity to plant poisons and (perhaps more remarkably) the ability to control plants.32

Poison Ivy is also the name of a popular movie starring Drew Barrymore as a psychopathic teenager. The movie tagline is “What Ivy wants, Ivy gets”. It spawned several sequels.

Finally, Toxicodendron species have played starring roles in many a “poison garden”. As I’ve noted in other blog posts, plants routinely produce toxins to protect themselves from animals that would like to eat them. Animals, such as us, that do eat them, find or evolve ways to reduce the toxicity to a safe level. As a result, the line between toxic and non-toxic is blurred. Nevertheless, some botanical gardens have leveraged our natural proclivity towards sensationalism by fencing off an area which they designate as their “poison garden” and, of course, charging extra to see it. It’s silly, but mostly harmless, fun. If you’re ever in Northumberland, England, you can visit the “Deadliest Garden in the World” at Alnwick Castle;33 Ireland has a poison garden at Blarney Castle;34 and then there was the Medici Poison Garden in Florence, Italy, which I’m not sure ever actually existed, but was supposed to have supplied Catherine de Medici with the poisons that went into her various potions. (She had something of a reputation as a sorceress.)35

The Future is Looking Itchy36

Plants breathe carbon dioxide. This means that, in the short term, some plants will actually benefit from the increased CO2 levels associated with global warming. In a six-year study conducted by researchers in North Carolina, an experimental forest was subjected to increased levels of carbon dioxide. The researchers found that the greater availability of CO2 improved poison ivy’s ability to conduct photosynthesis and manage water usage, allowing it to grow larger and more abundant. Not only that, but the increase was greater for poison ivy than it was for similar woody plant species, meaning that, in the future, poison ivy could out-compete other plants and become even more common than it already is. And the bad news doesn’t end there. A higher carbon dioxide level also influences the production of urushiol, leading to a more potent form of the compound.

So, yeah, the future is looking very hot and very itchy.

Strange Fruit and Other Anachronisms

When a bird eats a berry, it digests the pulp and poops out the seed. But not right away. It takes a while for the seed to work its way through the bird’s digestive tract, and by the time it reaches the exit, it’s likely to have traveled a long way from the plant that produced it. In this way, the plant is dispersed.

Every species must have some means of dispersal. Animals can walk or swim or fly to new locations, but plants don’t have that luxury. They have to find more indirect methods of dispersal, and one of the most common is reliance on animals. Usually, this means enclosing the seed in a tough coating that can withstand acidic digestive juices, grinding gizzards, and mashing molars, then wrapping the whole thing in tasty, nutritious pulp that some animal will find irresistible. If the resulting fruit is a small berry, it’ll probably be a bird that’s recruited to disperse it. But many fruits are much larger than your typical berry,5 and larger fruit likely evolved to attract larger, more earth-bound animals.

This leads to a mystery. Some plants produce very large fruit that have very tough rinds. And sometimes the seed or seeds inside are also intimidatingly large. Think of an avocado. I’ll help you out — here’s a photo of one.

Avocado (Persea americana)

And here’s a photo showing the pit inside.25

An avocado sliced open to reveal the pit

That is a big pit. What kind of animal could possibly swallow an avocado pit whole? Sure, lot’s of small animals could just eat around it, but that doesn’t help the plant disperse its seed.

Now, I’ll grant you, the avocados of today are the result of thousands of years of domestication, so it’s quite possible that larger fruit have been selected for. But why would the seed also increase in size? In fact, there is evidence that the original version of the fruit had less flesh than today’s avocado. But the pit was actually larger. A larger pit and less pulp — the mystery deepens.

Avocado plants are native to South America, and there is one South American animal that may sometimes eat avocados whole. Surprisingly, that animal is the jaguar! Yes, jaguars are carnivores. Nevertheless, they do occasionally eat avocados, but probably not that often. Also, being carnivores, jaguars are very uncommon. Why? Simple math. A carnivore has to eat lots of other animals during its lifetime, so its prey animals have to greatly outnumber it. For this reason, it’s unlikely that avocados evolved to be dispersed by jaguars — there just aren’t enough of them.26

Maybe you’ve already guessed where I’m going with this. If not, I won’t keep you in suspense any longer. The reason you won’t find any animals in South America large enough to be the dispersal agents for avocados is that they’re all extinct, and they went extinct thousands of years ago!27

The Americas in the Pleistocene

According to current estimates, humans first colonized the Americas around 15,000 years ago. This was toward the end of the Pleistocene epoch, which lasted from 2,580,000 to 11,700 years ago.29 The Americas in the Pleistocene were very, very different from the Americas we know today. And I don’t just mean no cars or roads or white picket fences. I mean, there were some seriously large animals roaming the landscape. 15,000 years ago, North America was home to mammoths, mastodons, giant ground sloths, lions, camels, wild horses, short-faced bears, saber-toothed cats, a beaver the size of a bear, and lots of other beasts you’ve probably never heard of.

Giant beaver (Castoroides ohioensis)
Minnesota Science Museum: Mississippi River Gallery
Author: Ryan Somma from Occoquan, USA
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

In South America, the situation was much the same, although the selection of large mammals was different. North and South America were separated until around 2.8 million years ago when the Isthmus of Panama formed, so the southern continent evolved its own set of mammals.37 Giant ground sloths actually evolved in South America before crossing the isthmus into the north, so South America did have them.

If you’re not familiar with giant ground sloths, you should look them up. The largest one, Megatherium americanum, was around 20 feet long, 4 tons, and about the size of a modern elephant. On its hind legs, M. americanum would have stood around 12 feet (3.5 meters) tall!38 39

Skeleton of a giant ground sloth (Megatherium sp.)
Natural History Museum, London
Author: Markus Trienke
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.

South America didn’t have any mammoths or mastodons, but it had gomphotheres, a family of elephant-relatives, many of which easily held their own in the behemoth department.40

A gomphothere, Amebelodon britti, from the Late Miocene to Early Pliocene of North America
Author: DiBgd
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

Another large South American mammal of the Pleistocene was the toxodon. Actually, Toxodon is an entire genus nested within an order of extinct hoofed animals called Notoungulata. The most well-known species of toxodon is Toxodon platensis. It’s estimated to have weighed over a ton and was around the size of an American bison or an African black rhino.41

A toxodon skeleton on display in the Bernardino Rivadavia Natural Sciences Museum
Author: WereSpielChequers
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

Yet another group of large extinct mammals from South America are the glyptodonts, members of the suborder Glyptodontinae. They were closely related to modern armadillos and had a similar armored body plan. In fact, molecular studies have found that the glyptodonts actually were armadillos — Glyptodontinae is nested within the family Chlamyphoridae, which includes most modern armadillos.

The best-known of the glyptodonts belong to the genus Glyptodon. These were about the size and weight of a Volkswagon Beetle.42 43 44 Here’s a very old (probably 1920) drawing of a glyptodon.

Glyptodon sp.
Source: The Wonderful Paleo Art of Heinrich Harder
Author: Heinrich Harder
This work is in the public domain in the United States because it was published (or registered with the U.S. Copyright Office) before January 1, 1926.

This is just a small sampling of the large mammals that inhabited the Americas of the Pleistocene epoch. Note that all the mammals mentioned here are actually genera or even families. In other words, there wasn’t just one type of gomphothere or one type of glyptodont. These were groups of animals that contained many, many variations. The New World had an incredibly diverse collection of very large mammals .

Scientists use the term megafauna to mean very large animals. How large varies somewhat — the term is a bit loose. Some people define megafauna as including any animal with a mass as great or greater than a human being. Others apply the term only to really big animals — those weighing in over a ton. For the purposes of this article, I’ll stick with the first definition.45

Today, most of the megafauna are gone from North and South America. In fact, most of the megafauna are gone from everywhere except Africa (and we’re working on that). As mentioned, the megafauna were mostly extinct in the New World by 13,000 years ago. (A few literal die-hards, like the giant sloth, managed to hold on until about 11,000 years ago). So what happened to them? Well, humans showed up in North America around 15,000 years ago. 2,000 years later, most of the big mammals were extinct. Seems like a no-brainer.

Actually, some pretty good arguments have been made that humans couldn’t have driven all those animals to extinction in such a short period of time just by over-hunting. It’s possible that other factors, such as climate change, were involved. Still, it’s highly suspicious that most of the megafauna went extinct so soon after humans appeared. Maybe it was a combination of human over-hunting and some other factors. I don’t know. The important thing is, by about 13,000 years ago, most of the really big mammals were gone.

The Concept of Evolutionary Anachronisms46

In modern Africa, large herbivores such as elephants routinely take large fruit into their mouths whole, mash the soft pulp, and swallow the seeds whole, along with the pulp. Later, they poop out the seeds in another location, along with a generous helping of natural fertilizer. Many African plants have evolved large fruit specifically in response to the presence of large megafauna such as elephants, rhinos, giraffes, and so on.47 48

There’s no reason to think that things were any different in the Pleistocene of North and South America. Many plants, including the avocado, must have evolved to rely on the large megafauna for dispersal. When these animals went extinct, the plants were left without their primary dispersal agents, which means it suddenly became much harder for them to spread their seeds. Now, 13,000 years later, these plants are still producing ridiculously large fruit — as if they were still expecting a giant sloth or gomphothere to show up. And, in a sense, they are. 13,000 years is a blip in evolutionary time, especially for plants, which tend to evolve more slowly than animals. It’s as if the plants haven’t yet “noticed” that the megafauna are gone!

When a fruit evolved to be eaten by an animal or group of animals that are no longer around, botanists refer to such a fruit as an evolutionary anachronism. An anachronism, in the general sense, is something that is out of place in time. If you’re reading a story that’s supposed to be taking place in the Middle Ages, and one of the characters uses a slang term from the 21st Century, that’s an example of a literary anachronism. Botanists and evolutionary scientists have adopted the term to describe these strangely out of step fruit.

But strange fruit are not the only examples of evolutionary anachronisms. In general, anytime a species preserves intact a physical or behavioral trait that evolved in response to evolutionary pressures that no longer exist, the trait is said to be an example of an evolutionary anachronism.

So, maybe you’d like to see an example of an evolutionary anachronism that doesn’t involve fruit…

The American Pronghorn49 50

The American pronghorn is sometimes called the American antelope. It’s not a true antelope, although it does resemble one. In scientific terms, it’s a member of the order Artiodactyla, the even-toed ungulates. This is a large order, which includes deer, pigs, true antelopes, giraffes, and (surprisingly) hippos.

The pronghorn is the fastest land mammal in the New World. It’s been clocked at 55 mph for 0.5 mi (88.5 km/h for 0.8 km). The interesting thing about that figure is that it’s too fast! Nothing alive today in North America is anywhere near fast enough to catch a pronghorn. Why would an animal evolve to be so much faster than it needs to be?

The answer, of course, is that it wouldn’t. There’s nothing alive in North America today that can catch a pronghorn, but what about back in the Pleistocene? When I was listing the various megafauna that lived in North America during the Pleistocene, I forgot to mention cheetahs. That’s right, cheetahs used to live in what’s now the United States! Other predators, such as hyenas, short-faced bears, and lions, might also have posed a threat to pronghorns.

So the American pronghorn is likely an example of an evolutionary anachronism — a prey animal that’s still ready to run super-fast at the first glimpse of a cheetah or whatever other scarily-fast predator might have been around all those years ago.

Anachronistic vs. Vestigial51

When I defined the term ‘evolutionary anachronism’, I specified that it had to be an ‘intact’ trait. In other words, the trait cannot have noticeably devolved. Let me give you an example of what I mean.

Many animals that live their entire lives in caves have lost their eyesight. In some cases, they’ve lost their eyes entirely. In other cases, they still have eyes, but those eyes no longer function. In other words, they’re vestigial. If, for whatever reason, a species with vestigial eyes were to migrate out of its cave and re-colonize the surrounding area, the environmental condition that caused animals to evolve eyes in the first place — namely, the presence of light — would reappear. But its vestigial eyes would not start functioning again. By this time, the species has presumably been blind for many thousands of years. So, it’s too late — its eyes are permanently broken.

On the other hand, the pulp and seed of an avocado are still functional. If an animal were to come along tomorrow that liked the taste of the pulp and was big enough to swallow the fruit whole, it could easily fill the role of disperser for the plant. Ergo, the avocado is an anachronistic fruit, not a vestigial one.

Holding On52

So, it’s likely that the fruit of avocados evolved to be swallowed whole by animals like gomphotheres and giant sloths. Such animals were very common for most of the Pleistocene, and, sure enough, avocados had a much larger natural range back then than they do today. But, if the animals that were responsible for dispersing them have been extinct for all this time, why haven’t avocados also gone extinct?

Well, note my use of the phrase ‘natural range’ in the last paragraph. Most of the avocado’s megafaunal dispersers went extinct towards the end of the Pleistocene, but not quite all of them. There was one survivor: humans. Fortunately for the avocado, people like how they taste. And people can be very good dispersers when they want to be. So, it may be that the avocados would have gone extinct if humans hadn’t decided to fill in for the sloths and gomphotheres.

Then again, maybe avocados could have held on for a long time without humans. Just because their primary dispersers went extinct, that doesn’t mean that nothing would ever disperse them. I already mentioned the possibility that jaguars might occasionally disperse an avocado seed. It’s very unlikely that jaguars could have kept the avocados going indefinitely, but they might have enabled them to hold on for a little while, if only by the skin of their non-existent teeth.

Most fruits float. They didn’t evolve for floating. It’s merely a side-effect of the way they’re constructed — most fruits are light enough and waterproof enough to float for a while. For that reason, many plants that appear to be anachronistic can still be found alongside rivers. When the river floods, some of the fruit get washed downstream, and, with luck, some of them may come to rest in a place where they can take root.

Even animals that don’t routinely disperse a plant’s seeds may occasionally disperse them. For example, an animal may be in the habit of eating the pulp of a fruit and spitting out the seeds or eating around them. This doesn’t help the plant because it doesn’t disperse the seeds. Unless, of course, the animal decides to carry the fruit someplace else before it eats it. In that case, the discarded seeds may still be able to find a suitable new location in which to germinate.

If a seed has evolved to survive passage through the digestive tract of an animal, it has necessarily evolved a thick coating. This could make it very hard for the seed to absorb water and germinate. For this reason, many plants have evolved seed coatings that are just barely tough enough to make it through the target animal’s guts. In fact, many won’t make it through, but those that do should be scarified enough by the passage that water will be able to penetrate the coating. The seed absorbs the water, swells up, and germinates. Thus, many plants have evolved seeds that almost have to pass through an animal’s gut if they are ever to germinate.

It’s a tricky balancing act. A seed that hasn’t passed through a digestive tract may eventually germinate, but it may take months or even years. So, if a plant’s primary dispersers are gone, it may still be able to hold on for a long time thanks to that very occasional seed that doesn’t pass though an animal’s gut, but manages to germinate anyway.

But many plants may not be able to hold on without their primary dispersers. Plants rarely fossilize, so we have no way of knowing how many plants went extinct along with their megafaunal dispersers. It seems likely that at least some did, especially the ones for which humans didn’t have any use.

More Strange Fruit

I’d like to spend the rest of the article showcasing a few interesting, and very strange, fruit that are likely anachronistic. It turns out that grocery stores are great places to go hunting for the “ghosts” of extinct megafauna.

“…the most delicious fruit known to men”53

That’s what Mark Twain called the fruit of cherimoya (Annona cherimola), a plant that grows from central Mexico, through Central America, and down the west coast of South America, almost to its very tip. I won’t argue with Twain’s assessment. The one I tried was exquisite, delectable, scrumptious… just seriously good. Its taste is complemented by the texture of the flesh, which is similar to custard and gives it the other common name it goes by — custard apple.

My only complaint is that the seeds are numerous and evenly distributed throughout the pulp, so that you have to spit them out with every mouthful. This makes eating one a bit of a hassle. If someone could come up with a seedless variety, I expect it would take the world by storm.

Cherimoya

I googled “seedless cherimoya” just to see if, by chance, anyone had come up with one. I found a number of articles referencing work done at UC Davis that isolated a mutant gene in a closely related fruit — the sugar apple — that caused it to be seedless. It seems like it would be a simple matter to knock out the same gene in cherimoya, thereby producing a seedless variety. But the articles I saw were from 2011, and I haven’t found any follow up articles, so I guess it’s not that easy.54

Cherimoya
A cherimoya fruit sliced down the middle

The best evidence that cherimoya is anachronistic is its large size. The seeds are also fairly large and not super easy to separate from the pulp, so it seems likely that the fruit evolved to be eaten by large mammals that would mash the fruit and swallow the pulp along with the seeds.

Sliced for eating
A cherimoya seed
A cherimoya seed dissected

There are at least two other edible fruits produced by plants in the Annona genus that may be anachronistic: soursop (Annona muricata)55 and sweetsop or sugar apple (Annona squamosa).56. Both are similar in appearance to cherimoya, but I haven’t tried them, so I don’t know how they compare taste-wise.

Way down yonder in the pawpaw patch57 58

I’ve never eaten a pawpaw (Asimina triloba). Chances are, you haven’t either. In fact, it’s possible your only clue to the existence of this fruit is the lyrics of that old folksong. (If you’re not familiar with the song, well now… you should just click here and have a listen.)

The plant is a small deciduous tree that’s native to the eastern United States and Canada. It’s in the same family, Annonaceae, as the aforementioned cherimoya, and is quite closely related. Supposedly, the fruit has a “sweet, custardish flavor somewhat similar to banana, mango, and pineapple”.59 The fruit has a shelf life of only about three days, which explains why you don’t find them in supermarkets. If you’re lucky, you might find some in a roadside stand. Otherwise, unless you happen to live way down yonder near a pawpaw patch, you probably won’t run across them.

Pawpaws (Asimina triloba)
Author: Agnieszka Kwiecień (Nova)
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled GNU Free Documentation License.

Several things point to pawpaws being anachronistic. First, of course, is their large size. The seeds are also fairly large, although not ridiculously so. Second, the fruits tend to fall from the tree within a day of ripening, and then they rot very quickly. This suggests that they are targeted towards animals large enough to pick them directly from the tree.

Third, pawpaw patches are rare, except where indigenous people routinely eat them. This suggests that their only remaining primary dispersers may be humans. Finally, wild pawpaw trees usually only grow in floodplains, and yet, they grow just fine when they’re planted in uplands. This, again, suggests that people are their only remaining primary dispersers.

…the largest fruit of all trees60 61

The jackfruit (Artocarpus heterophyllus) has the distinction of being the largest fruit of all trees. Here’s a photo of a jackfruit that was found in Kerala, India.

A jackfruit found in Kerala, India
Author: Suniltg at English Wikipedia
Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation; with no Invariant Sections, no Front-Cover Texts, and no Back-Cover Texts. A copy of the license is included in the section entitled GNU Free Documentation License. Subject to disclaimers.

The one I bought in an Asian market wasn’t quite that big, but it wasn’t exactly small, either. Here it is on the cutting board.

Jackfruit

And here’s one of my grandnephews for scale.

Mother, son, and jackfruit

I don’t know if anyone has ever been killed by a jackfruit falling from a tree, but it wouldn’t surprise me. Then again, maybe people just instinctively avoid walking under something that looks like this.

Jackfruit on a jackfruit tree
Kerala Agricultural University, Ambalavayal, Kerala, India
Author: Prof. Mohamed Shareef from Mysore
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.

When I cut my specimen open, I was surprised how tough the rind was. It took some effort to cut through it. I was also surprised by how sticky the insides were. The pulp stuck to my hands like glue. It took a lot of soap and water to get it off. It was also kind of slimy. My grandnephew (the older one, who’s four) refused to eat it because it was “too slimy”. (This is the same kid who routinely handles earthworms and thinks they’re “cute”!)

A jackfruit cut open

The fruit is very good. According to Wikipedia, it has a “subtle pineapple- or banana-like flavor”.62 Personally, I thought it tasted more like cantaloupe.

A closeup of the pulp and a few seeds
My grandnephew holding a couple of seeds

The seeds can also be eaten. I boiled and ate a bunch of them. After 10 minutes of boiling, the water was stained a dark reddish-brown from all the tannins. After boiling, the seeds have to be peeled, which is no fun, but they do have a nice, sweet taste to them.

A closeup of a seed
Dangsuriya Jackfruit ready to eat
Thailand
Author: Tris T7
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

So is jackfruit anachronistic? It’s important to realize that, like the avocado, and like most fruit consumed by people, the jackfruit has been domesticated. It’s probably quite a bit larger than the original, wild variety. But also like the avocado, the original fruit was probably still pretty big, and the seeds likely haven’t changed significantly.

So the huge size, tough rind, and large seeds strongly suggest a fruit that evolved to be mashed in the mouths of megafauna and the seeds swallowed whole without grinding. The presence of high levels of tannins in the seeds would be a deterrent to insects, but it would also make them distasteful to any large animal that bit into them or ground them between its molars.

So what kind of megafauna are we talking about? It’s not known exactly where jackfruit originated, but they’re believed to be indigenous to the rainforests of the Western Ghats in southern India. This area is a hotspot of biodiversity. Among the many large animals found there is the Indian elephant (Elephas maximus indicus) — an obvious candidate seed disperser for the ancestral jackfruit. Turn the clock back around 50,000 years, and India was home to, not one, but two giant elephants — Palaeoloxodon namadicus and Stegodon namadicus. P. namadicus, in particular, may have been the largest land mammal that ever lived. According to one estimate, it weighed around 24 tons (21,772 kg) and stood 16 feet (4.8 m) tall at the shoulder.63 The largest mammal and the largest fruit? Seems like a good match.64

Mango

The mango (Mangifera sp.) is another fruit that probably originated on the Indian subcontinent. The most common variety, appropriately named the common mango, is Mangifera indica. I’m not sure what variety I got when I visited the local grocery, but here it is.

A mango (Mangifera sp.)

And here it is cut in half. Notice how the pulp clings to the pit.

A mango sliced in half

In the next photo, I’ve extracted the pit. Notice how large it is compared to the fruit as a whole. I actually used a scouring pad to remove most of the pulp from the pit and I still couldn’t get it all off — that’s how tightly the pulp is bound to it. This is no accident. A large animal eating the fruit isn’t going to spit out the pit — that would be a waste of pulp — it’s going to mash the fruit and swallow both pulp and pit.

…and with the pit extracted.

I continued my dissection, extracting the seed from the pit.

Extracting the seed…
The final cut

Papaya65

Papayas (Carica papaya) are sometimes called pawpaws, but they are unrelated to the pawpaw (Asimina triloba) discussed earlier. They have the usual large size, suggestive of an affinity for megafauna, but the seeds are a surprise.

A papaya (Carica papaya)

Instead of one huge seed or a few dozen moderately large ones, the papaya has lots of very small seeds concentrated in a large central cavity. This is an interesting variation. The large cavity reduces the weight of the fruit, so the stalk attaching it to the tree doesn’t have to be quite as thick. The large number of seeds increases the chances that one of them will successfully germinate and grow to maturity.

A papaya cut in half

The seeds themselves are fascinating. They’re wrapped in some sort of gelatinous pouch. Here’s a photo of a whole seed (right) and a seed with its pouch removed (left).

A papaya seed with its covering removed (left) and with its covering intact (right)
I dried this one off as best I could…
…before slicing it open.

Papaya seeds are edible and taste a bit like horseradish. I would love to know more about that gelatinous pouch. I’m not familiar with any other type of seed that has such a covering. I’ve been searching for more info online, but all I’ve found so far is some stuff about papaya seeds’ reputed health benefits and a lot of rather dubious articles extoling their value for detoxing and parasite cleansing.

Papaya is thought to be native to Mexico, Central America, and northern South America. Several members of the papaya family can be found growing wild in the tropical valleys of the Andes. If papaya originated in South America, then, like the avocado, it was probably dispersed by South American giants such as ground sloths, gomphotheres, and toxodons.

Osage-Orange66 67 68

The osage-orange or hedge-apple (Maclura pomifera) is a small tree or large shrub, which has a small natural range in parts of Texas, Oklahoma, and Arkansas. The fruit is neither an orange nor an apple. It’s technically edible, but no humans actually eat it, because it contains an unpalatable milky latex. Even horses don’t much care for it, although one of its many names is horse-apple.

Osage-orange (Maclura pomifera)
Winfield, IL USA
Author: Bruce Marlin
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.5 Generic license.

In fact, nothing much eats it. When the fruits ripen, they drop to the ground. There, unless they roll downhill or get dispersed by a flood, they rot underneath the tree that produced them. This is, itself, a clear sign of anachronism. Nothing today eats them, but something must have eaten them at one time — something that’s no longer around. Molecular analysis indicates that M. pomifera probably diverged from other members of Maclura during the Oligocene, around the same time that some groups of mammoths, mastodons, and ground sloths first appear in the evolutionary record. This suggests that these mammals could have been the original seed dispersers for the plant.

You might be wondering, if the latex contained in the osage-orange is distasteful to horses and people, why would these larger mammals be any different? The fact is, many plants that people do eat produce chemicals that are toxic to some degree. Peppers, for instance, are eaten by no other animal other than humans. Large mammals, such as us, are able to handle limited amounts of mild toxins, and much larger mammals, such as elephants, are able to eat some fruits that would be toxic or unpalatable to us. Partly, this is because their slower digestion gives them more time to break down the toxins. Bad-taste is often an indication that something is not safe to eat. If something is safe for an animal to eat, chances are it won’t taste bad to that animal. So, to a mammoth or ground sloth, an osage-orange might have tasted pretty good.

Although we don’t eat the fruit, people have managed to find other uses for osage-orange. The wood was prized by Native Americans as the best wood for making bows (from which it gets another one of its common names, bois d’arc, which is French for bow wood.) They prized it so much, in fact, that they would travel hundreds of miles to get it.

The common name ‘hedge-apple’ refers to its use by European settlers as living fences or hedges around their fields to keep out free-range livestock. Pruning the plants would cause them to sprout adventitious roots from their bases. These would interweave, forming a dense, thorny barrier.

The use of osage-orange as hedges allowed it to become naturalized far beyond its limited natural range. The invention of barbed wire eventually ended its use by farmers, but, by that time, it had become well-established in much of the U.S. It’s still occasionally used as an ornamental.

More Anachronisms and More Theory69

I’ve concentrated on fruits in this article because they represent the most obvious examples of anachronisms, and because most of the research has been focused on them. This is probably only scratching the surface of the subject, though. One thing I haven’t mentioned is the presence on some plants of ridiculously large thorns — thorns that seem unnecessarily large to fend off the tiny herbivores the plants have to deal with in their modern environment. In the case of trees, these thorns often go far up the trunk — far beyond the reach of any modern animal — and then stop. Plants don’t waste resources any more than they have to. If nothing can reach beyond a certain height, then there’s no point in growing thorns beyond that height.70 There are many more examples of evolutionary anachronisms that I haven’t covered here, and as more research is done on the subject, many more examples will undoubtedly be found.

One final thing I should point out is that whether or not a particular trait is anachronistic rarely, if ever, has a simple yes or no answer. The person responsible for originating the concept of evolutionary anachronisms is a scientist named Dan Janzen, and as Janzen points out “…each trait is to some degree anachronistic.” The reason for this is simple. Evolution is slow. When the environment changes, it takes time for poorly adapted organisms to die out, leaving better adapted ones to carry on. This means that organisms are not really adapted to their current environment — they are adapted to their past environment.

Another important point is that the fruits I’ve been discussing are probably not adapted to a particular species of megafauna, or even a particular genus or family. As has already been pointed out, plants tend to evolve more slowly than animals. If most of a plant’s original dispersers have gone extinct, chances are, another set of dispersers will have evolved to take their place. (At least, that was the case until humans came along and upset the apple cart.)

All this leads to the concept of degrees of anachronism. Some organisms represent extreme anachronisms and are probably on their way to extinction (unless, of course, humans have stepped in and taken the place of their former dispersers.) Other organisms may have evolved traits in response to environmental conditions that have long since changed, but they still manage to get by pretty well, and they will probably have time to adapt to the new conditions. As in all things biological, it’s complicated.