If you’re a hiker, you might be familiar with oak apples. These aren’t really apples, of course. They’re plant galls, and they’re caused by a tiny wasp.

Harvey Moore Trail near Descanso, CA. San Diego County 7/3/22
A gall is a plant growth that’s caused by, and serves as home to, some other type of organism. Most gall-formers are insects, but they can also be mites, nematodes1, fungi, bacteria, viruses, rotifers,2 or phytoplasmas.3 4 The gall occupant or its parent initiates the growth of the gall, usually by injecting a substance into the plant that mimics the plant’s hormones, hijacking its cellular machinery. Once started, a gall might grow into its final form on its own, or it might need additional stimulation from its occupant(s).5
A gall can be very simple or highly-structured, and galls of many different shapes, sizes, textures, and colors can grow on the same species of plant. Somehow, the gall-former forces the plant to grow the gall to its own specifications!
Many types of galls are found on oak trees, and most of them are caused by wasps. The gall in the previous photo was caused by a California gall wasp (Andricus quercuscalifornicus).6 Here’s a photo of the wasp. It’s only 5 mm long.

Author: USGS Bee Inventory and Monitoring Lab from Beltsville, Maryland, USA
Source:
Andricus quercuscalifornicus usda buffington
This image is in the public domain in the United States because it only contains materials that originally came from the United States Geological Survey, an agency of the United States Department of the Interior. For more information, see the official USGS copyright policy.
Here’s a photo of another oak gall of the same type. This one was still soft, so I cut it open.

San Diego County 7/9/22
Inside, I found a wasp larva.


How an Insect Causes a Gall
There are two ways an insect can initiate a gall. It can injure the plant’s cells, causing an unorganized mass of protective tissue called plant callus to grow at the site of the wound, 7 8 or it can inject some substance into the plant that “instructs” it to form a gall. This substance is most likely a cocktail of chemicals that mimic the hormones the plant uses to control its growth.
Sometimes an adult insect uses its ovipositor9 to inject a substance that stimulates the growth of the gall. It then lays one or more eggs at or near the site. When the eggs hatch, the larvae find their way into the growing gall (or the gall simply grows around them). Sometimes the adult insect uses its ovipositor to inject both the larvae and the gall-stimulating substance at the same time.
In other cases, it’s the larva itself that initiates the growth of the gall. Often, its saliva contains a gall-stimulating substance. Even if the adult insect initiates the gall, the chewing of the larvae might be necessary to keep it growing. In more complex galls, the gall’s structure changes as it grows. Presumably, this means that the chemicals in the gall-former’s saliva are also changing as the larva develops.
For an amazing timelapse video of an aphid gall forming, check out this link.
Galls can take on some very strange shapes. Take, for example, the gall of the crystalline gall wasp in the following photos.

San Diego County 10/15/17

There were some more galls on the same plant that were probably crystalline galls in earlier stages of development.

Here are some more examples of crystalline galls.

San Diego County 10/6/22

In case you’re wondering, the two white, flower-shaped objects on the bottom leaf are not galls. They’re the pupal cases of a whitefly.
There is another type of gall in the photo, however. It’s in the fold of one of the leaves. I haven’t been able to identify it, but here are some closeups.


What Counts as a Gall?10
I already defined galls earlier in the article, but to reiterate, galls are “growths on plants formed of plant tissue but caused by other organisms”.11 Of course, like most things in biology, it’s not quite that simple.
For starters, the host isn’t always a plant. It usually is, but it could also be a fungus, a lichen, or an alga. I won’t be covering any of those other, rarer, types of hosts, though. For the purposes of this blog post, gallers gall plants.
Also, the above definition isn’t complete. It’s not enough for an organism to cause a growth on a plant. It must also benefit in some way from that growth. It isn’t always easy to tell if this is the case. When an herbivore feeds on a plant, the damage alone is often enough to induce the plant to grow a different kind of tissue around the site of the injury ─ the plant callus I mentioned earlier. Usually, a galler or its parent injects substances into the plant to control the grow of new tissue, but not always. Sometimes the galler simply benefits from feeding on the callus, and that’s enough to classify the callus tissue as a gall.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, some galls can be quite complex, consisting of multiple layers, some nutritive, others protective. Often, the substances injected by the organism cause the plant to divert extra resources to the gall, making it (or a layer within it) more nutritious than other parts of the plant.
The fuzzy, little round gall in the next photo was formed by the aptly-named round-gall wasp, Burnettweldia washingtonensis.12

Oakoasis County Preserve, San Diego County 7/2/22

Looking back at some of my pics on bugguide.net, I found a series of photos from 2018 of what looks like an older Burnettweldia washingtonensis gall. It was on a scrub oak, and it was definitely caused by some kind of gall wasp. I know this because when I cut it open, I found the wasp pupating inside! This was in February, so this species of wasp probably overwinters as a pupa inside the gall and exits as an adult in Spring.

Encinitas, CA 2/24/28
When I first cut the gall open, I was perplexed to find what appeared to be a loose nut inside. When I cut the “nut” open, I found the pupa.

The nut was actually a hardened inner layer of material ─ an “inner gall” ─ that formed around the pupa to protect it. This layer probably formed after the larva consumed all the tissue in the nutritive layer and decided it was time to pupate. The inner gall forms loose inside the outer gall because this makes it more difficult for a parasitoid13 to attack the pupa. The parasitoid uses its long, thin ovipositor to bore through the outer gall without too much problem, but when it tries to get a purchase on the inner gall, it’s like trying to spear a grape with a fork.
Here are several photos showing the wasp pupa from different angles.



A spined turban gall wasp (Cynips douglasii) formed this next gall on the underside of an oak leaf.

San Diego County 7/2/22

Types of Galls
Many kinds of plants are galled by many kinds of organisms. And, as we’ve seen, those galls can be very simple or very complex. There are several other ways that galls differ from each other.
First, different types of gall form on different parts of the plant. Some galls only grow on roots, for example. Others only grow on stems, leaves, buds, or flowers.14
Second, galls vary in size. They can be almost microscopic or bigger than your head.
Finally, and perhaps most obviously, they vary in form ─ from a simple swelling to a round ball to weird grows like the crystalline galls we saw earlier.
A particular organism doesn’t necessarily cause only one type of gall. Many insects, for example, have alternate generations ─ usually, a sexual one and an asexual one (where the insect reproduces without mating). Sometimes one of the generations forms galls and the other doesn’t. In other cases, both generations form galls, but on different types of plants, or on different parts of the same type of plant, or even on different parts of different types of plant.
Scientists who study galls (and who are called cecidologists) have come up with many descriptive terms for them. What follows is a list of some of the most common ones. I’m not going to show you examples of each one ─ that would make this post way too long. If you’re interested, check out “Plant Galls” by Margaret Redfern. Much of the info in this article comes from that book.
Fasciations, phyllathies, phyllodies, and virescences ─ Plants sometimes exhibit weird growth patterns called fasciations, which are caused by errors in their development. These can be genetic errors or they can result from environmental factors. If they aren’t caused by other organisms, then they don’t count as galls.15 A few organisms, however, cause fasciations and feed on them. These do count as galls.
A phyllody, to quote Wikipedia, is “the abnormal development of floral parts into leafy structures. It is generally caused by phytoplasma or virus infections, though it may also be because of environmental factors that result in an imbalance in plant hormones.”16
Phyllathy seems to be just another word for phyllody.
Virescences are “oddly shaped parts of plants, where shoots, roots, leaves, or flower parts are distorted, multiplied or bunched together.”17 When they occur on trees, virescenses are sometimes called witches’ brooms. Phyllodies are a type of virescence.
Solid swellings ─ These can be single enlarged cells in algae. In plants, they can be much larger ─ up to a meter or more on trees.18 Crown gall is a plant disease caused by the bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens. It results in tumor-like growths up to a foot in diameter on more than 600 different plant species, including both woody and herbacious plants.19 This is one way in which bacterial gallers differ from most other types of gall-formers. Most gallers gall only one or a few types of plants.
Erinea galls ─ Simple, hairy galls caused by eriophyid mites. The mites live among the hairs. Erinea galls often look like patches of velvet on the undersides of leaves. Sometimes they are reddish in color.20
Folds and rolls ─ These are simple leaf galls. The galler causes the edge of the leaf to fold over or roll up. It does this by stimulating cells on one side of the leaf to proliferate more than those on the other side.21 The galler benefits from the protection that the fold or roll provides, so, simple as they are, these do count as galls. Many types of mites and insects cause fold or roll galls.22
Pits, blisters, and pouches ─ These, like folds, rolls, and erinea galls, are open galls. And, like folds and rolls, they are fairly simple distortions of the leaf. Various mites and insects cause these types of galls.23
Big buds, cigars, pineapples, and rosettes24 ─ These types are lumped together because they all develop in buds, and they all form from young modified leaves that bunch together because their petioles (leaf stems) fail to develop. These are open galls. The mites or insects that cause them escape through openings between the leaves. Pineapple galls are sort of an exception. These are temporarily sealed, but changes in the gall tissue eventually provide openings for the insects to escape.
Closed chambered galls ─ These galls, as the name suggests, contain one or more closed chambers in which the gall-former(s) reside. These tend to be the most highly-structured types of galls.25
Burro-weed (Ambrosia dumosa), aka white bursage, is a type of ragweed that grows in the desert.26 The next two photos show an interesting gall that I found on a burro-weed. I think the gall-former is Procecidochares kristineae, a type of tephritid fly.27

Sonoran Desert, San Diego County 11/26/22

Cutting it open, I found that the occupant had already pupated and left, leaving behind its pupal skin.

The Australian eucalyptus leafgall wasp (Ophelimus maskelli) galls the leaves of eucalytus trees. The galls are tiny red swellings.28

San Diego County, California, USA 11/5/22
Let’s zoom in on a few of those galls.


I used an x-acto knife to slice one of the galls open, and to my surpise, I managed to do it without injuring the baby wasp inside.
This isn’t the first time I’ve seen these particular galls. Back in May of 2020, I collected some eucalyptus leaves with galls, most of which had exit holes.

San Diego County 5/4/20
A few still had the insect inside, though. I managed to capture this adult wasp after it exited one of the galls.

San Diego County 5/4/20
Manzanita (genus Arctostaphylos) is a very common plant in the chaparral of Southern California. Occasionally, you’ll come across one that’s absolutely covered in bright red fold galls. These are caused by Manzanita leaf gall aphids (Tamalia coweni). They mostly form on the edges of leaves, but they can also form on midribs and on the inflorescenses (flower clusters).29

San Diego County 7/10/16


Here are some more aphid galls on a manzanita. I saw these in Tulare County in central California.

Tulare County, CA 7/10/16




I found the next gall on a cottonwood tree. It was formed by poplar leaf-petiole gall aphids (Pemphigus populicaulis)30

San Diego County 11/29/17
Aphids in various stages of development were inside. The winged one is an adult.

Here’s a gall I found on a California sagebrush (Artemisia californica). The gall-former is probably a gall midge31 in the genus Rhopalomyia.

San Diego County 2/24/19


This next gall was on a Great Basin sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata). It was caused by a sponge gall midge (Rhopalomyia pomum). The gall was, indeed, soft and spongy.

San Diego County 4/28/18
One of the most common plants in the Sonoran Desert is the creosote bush (Larrea tridentata).32 It’s not uncommon to see these unusual-looking galls on them. They are caused by creosote gall midges in the genus Asphondylia.

Sonoran Desert, San Diego County 12/16/17

This next gall was formed by a wasp on a wild rose.

Northern San Diego County 4/28/18
Nancy Asquith on bugguide.net identified the gall-former as “definitely Diplolepis“. She thinks it was probably a spiny leaf gall wasp (Diplolepis polita), which is very common in California. This type of gall would normally have many long spikes instead of one short one. Ms. Asquith thinks that it could have been a D. polita gall altered by inquilines.
And what’s an inquiline, you ask…
Gall Ecosystems
According to Wikipedia, an inquiline is “an animal that lives commensally in the nest, burrow, or dwelling place of an animal of another species.”33 So, in the context of galls, an inquiline is an animal that moves into the gall after the gall-former forms it. The “commensally” part of the definiton means that the inquiline neither benefits nor harms the gall-former.
In fact, entire ecosystems of organisms often form inside a gall. In addition to inquilines, there are parasites, parasitoids, and predators. A parasite feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants) without killing it; a parasitoid feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants) and eventually kills it; a predator feeds on the gall-former (or one of the other occupants), kills it, and then moves on to prey on another occupant (or an occupant of another gall, or something else entirely). Some predators eat one or more of the occupants and then feed on the gall itself.
Of course, gall occupants are not just fed on by other occupants. Birds and mice will break open galls to get to the insects inside. Herbivores like caterpillars will feed on a gall and unintentionally eat the occupants in the process.
Even if the gall-formers make it to adulthood and exit the gall, other organisms might move in later. If nothing else, empty galls eventually serve as food for bacteria and fungi.
Some species of sawfly are gallers of willows. The next series of photos show galls of the willow apple gall sawfly (Pontania californica).

San Diego County 8/20/22



And here’s a live oak apple gallfly gall on a live oak.

San Diego County 9/24/17
The beaked twig gall wasp (Disholcaspis plumbella) makes brightly-colored galls. This one is a bit out-of-focus, sadly. It has three exit holes, so it looks like at least some of the occupants have already left.

San Diego County 9/24/17
This gall on coyote brush (Baccharis pilularis) was caused by a gall midge ─ probably a coyote brush bud gall midge (Rhopalomyia californica).

San Diego County 7/16/22

I think that what looks like long, whitish husks protruding from a few of the holes are the exuviae (discarded exoskeletons) left behind by adult midges emerging from the gall.34
This is a bud gall, meaning that it formed from tissue that would have formed into a bud if the galler hadn’t gotten there first. You can see in the cross-section below that it has a structure similar to a bud. I didn’t find any larvae or pupae inside, but a small larval cavity is visible in the right half.

A very common plant in my area is another species of baccharis ─ broom baccharis (Baccharis sarothroides).35 It’s also frequently galled by midges. I see them very often on my local hikes.

San Diego County 7/6/22
I don’t know what caused the galls on this leaf. Possibly mites.

San Diego County 10/7/17
The vast majority of gallers are parasites. In other words, the galler benefits from the relationship, but the host plant is harmed by it. Sometimes the damage is severe. A galled plant might be stunted or produce fewer seeds. If the infestation is bad enough, it might even die. In other cases, the plant hardly seems to notice.36
It’s very rare for gallers to form mutualistic relationships with a host, but it does happen. One well-known example is the fig wasp.
Fig wasps are wasps that spend their larval stage in figs. There are many different kinds of fig wasps, but the ones we’re interested in are in the family Agaonidae. These are the ones that act as pollinators for fig trees. The trees cannot reproduce without the wasps and the wasps cannot reproduce without the trees, so this is a clear case of mutualism.
A fig is not actually a fruit. It’s a syconium. An article on the Britannica website describes it as an “urn-shaped inflorescence”. The article goes on to explain that the syconium probably originated from the “invagination of a flat flower-bearing capitulum”.39 Maybe you’re having trouble making sense of this explanation, so let’s dissect it a bit.
An inflorescense is a cluster of flowers on a stem.
A capitulum is “An inflorescence that consists of closely packed flowers or florets which have no stalks and arise on a flattened axis, all at the same level.”40
An invagination is a surface that has folded into itself to form a cavity, pouch, or tube.41
So, Britannica seems to be saying figs evolved from an inflorescense of small, tightly-packed flowers that folded in on itself to form a pouch with the flowers inside. This makes sense because unripe figs actually do have flowers inside them! So, where do the wasps come in?
A female wasp enters a fig through a small opening. She has to force her way through this opening, and, in the process, she usually loses her wings and most of her antennae. In other words, she won’t be leaving. A female fig wasp only gets to pollinate one fig.
Once inside, the wasp lays eggs on some of the flowers. A flower that has an egg deposited on it develops a gall instead of a seed. The wasp deposits pollen that she picked up from her “home” fig (the one she hatched out in) on some of the other flowers.
When a male fig wasp hatches out of a gall, it searches in the same fig for galls containing females. When he finds one, he chews a hole in it and mates with the unhatched female. That’s right… the unhatched female. The female emerges from her gall already pregnant. The male dies inside the fig, but before he does (in many species, at least) he chews an escape hole for the female. When females emerge from their galls, they crawl over ungalled flowers on their way to the exit holes, picking up pollen as they go. Once outside the fig, they waste no time looking for a new, unripe fig in which to lay their eggs and die. What a life!
There are many kinds of fig wasps in the family Agaonidae. The description that I just gave of the fig wasp life cycle is somewhat generalised. Details vary from species to species. If you want to do some further reading, a good place to start is the Britannica article that I referenced earlier. It’s short, but it has a nice illustration of the life cycle. Click here to read it.
The Evolution of Gall-forming
Unsurprisingly, we don’t know a lot about how gall-forming evolved. One thing that’s certain is that it arose independently many times.42 Despite this, gall-forming is not all that common an adaptation. Apparently, it’s a successful enough strategy to have evolved many times, but not successful enough to be the “go-to” strategy for any large group like mites or insects.43
Although we don’t know many details, it’s not hard to imagine how an organism might evolve to form galls. At least, this is how I imagine it…
When an insect larva feeds on plant tissue, the plant typically responds by growing callus tissue44 to cover the wound. This might be a better source of nutrients than the regular tissue, so the insect proceeds to feed on it. Maybe some chemical in the larva’s saliva happens to stimulate the plant to change something about the way it grows this tissue. If the change is beneficial, the insect’s descendants are more likely to survive and more likely to keep secreting that substance in their saliva. Then, maybe a mutation occurs that causes a new chemical to be included in their saliva. If it also proves beneficial, the new mutation might be retained. And so on. Insects use many chemicals that are simular to plant hormones (they probably have similar evolutionary origins), so it’s not as unlikely as it might sound.
Similarly, if an insect lays an egg by injecting it into plant tissue, various substances get injected along with it. Some of these substances are probably meant to protect the egg from the plant’s defences, for example. A side effect of some of the substances might be to alter the way the plant grows tissue in the vicinity of the egg. Maybe this altered tissue benefits the larva in some way. And so on.
This just my take on how gall-forming might have evolved.
Evolution of gall morphology is affected by the pressure put on the gall-formers by their enemies. For example, an insect deep inside a large gall is often safer than an insect in a small gall or one farther from the center, simply because it’s harder for parasites, parasitoids, and small predaters to get to them. On the other hand, a large gall is more conspicuous, so there’s more chance that a large predator, such as a bird, will notice it.45 So, it’s a give and take. The gall-former will evolve in whichever direction gives the best results.46
Addendum
In the short time that’s passed since I published this article, I’ve already found a number of new galls. Also, my friend, Meridith Erickson, sent me a great photo that she took of a large, old oak apple. So, I figured I’d add a section at the end of the post for new photos.
I’ll start with Meridith’s photo.

Lots of exit holes in this one.
Photograph © Meridith Erickson. Used with permission.

Photograph © Meridith Erickson. Used with permission.
This next gall was on the stem of a grass called big galleta (Hilaria rigida). I haven’t been able to identify it, yet. It was a large gall ─ around an inch long.

Colorado Desert, San Diego County 1/29/23


I found this gall on a California sagebrush (Artemisia californica). It was about a quarter of an inch long.

San Diego County 2/7/23

When I cut it open, I found the larva still inside. I think it’s probably some kind of gall midge larva, but I’m not sure.



























