Tag Archives: shag

A Gulp of Cormorants

You can’t really miss them. If you visit La Jolla Cove1 in the Spring, you’re pretty much guaranteed to see throngs of large black birds with long necks congregating on the rocks along the shore. These are cormorants. Specifically, they’re Brandt’s cormorants (although there could be a double-crested cormorant or a pelagic cormorant in the mix).2 3 4

Brandt’s cormorants (Phalacrocorax penicillatus)
La Jolla Cove, San Diego County 12/26/20

Brandt’s cormorant (Phalacrocorax penicillatus) is the largest of San Diego County’s three cormorant species, and it’s by far the most common one at La Jolla Cove. Its species name, penicillatus, is Latin for painter’s brush (literally, pencil of hairs). This is a reference to the thin white plumes that appear on the necks and backs of adults in the early breeding season. You can see some of these plumes on a couple of the birds in the above photo. Another characteristic of P. penicillatus that appears during the breeding season is a bright blue pouch under the throat.5 You can get a glimpse of this on some of the birds in the photo. Here’s an image from Wiki Commons that offers a much better view of both the pouch and plumes, not to mention the patterning in the wings.

Brandt’s cormorant (Phalacrocorax penicillatus)
Author: Mike’s Birds from Riverside, CA, US
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.

Adult Brandt’s cormorants are about 79 cm (2.6 feet) tall, which one website helpfully points out is about the size of a human toddler. Their eyes have striking blue-green irises. Juvenile birds have brown and grey plumage and brown eyes. As for the chick, an early twentieth century ornithologist, Arthur Cleveland Bent, described it as “blind and naked, an ugly object with greasy black skin.”6

Bent also observed that gulls, which are much smaller birds, would steal eggs from the nests of Brandt’s cormorants. He wrote that the gulls would startle “the stupid birds” off their nests with loud noises.7 (I’m starting to think Bent didn’t have a high opinion of cormorants.)

Cormorants belong to the family Phalacrocoracidae, which has about 40 species. Birds in this family are commonly called either cormorants or shags. ‘Shag’ is usually reserved for species that have crests on their heads, such as the European shag, (Gulosus aristotelis). This isn’t an iron-clad rule, though. The same species can even be called by different names in different places. For example, Phalacrocorax carbo is called the great cormorant in Great Britain and the black shag in New Zealand. (The birds in New Zealand and other parts of Autralasia have a crest, while those in Europe do not, although they’re classified as the same species.) In this article, I’ll use ‘cormorant’ for both cormorants and shags, just to keep things simple.8

A group of cormorants, as the title suggests, is called a ‘gulp’.9 It’s certainly not a pretty name, and it seems a bit unfair that most other birds seem to have gotten much catchier group names. (A parliament of owls, a murder of crows, an unkindness of ravens, and so on.) On the other hand, it is pretty descriptive. All cormorants are fish-eaters, and, not having any teeth, they have to gulp their prey down whole.

Cormorants dive to catch fish. A cormorant begins its dive from the surface. The bird paddles around until it’s ready to dive, then it makes a little hop before plunging headfirst into the water. The hop probably helps it to position itself for a more streamlined entry into the water. Underwater, cormorants are really in their element. They swim underwater mostly using their large webbed feet. And they can dive deep — fishing vessels have caught Brandt’s cormorants in nets at depths of 70 meters (almost 230 feet). Other species dive even deeper. Imperial shags fitted with miniature video recorders have been filmed diving as deep as 80 meters (260 feet).10 11 To put this in perspective, human scuba divers usually don’t go below 30 meters (100 feet). (They certainly can, and do, go deeper, but deep dives require periods of decompression, and the deeper you go, the more risky the dive.)

Speaking of scuba diving, this post was inspired by a video taken by one of my hiking buddies, Maya Ma, while she was scuba diving off the San Diego coast. You can watch her video, which she entitled “Cormorant being a boss”, below.

[If you’re reading this on email, you may have to visit the website to view the video.]

Here’s a rather evocative still from the video. I was tempted to make this the featured image.

Being a great swimmer has its price. In the case of birds, the price is being a bad flyer. If you evolve to be a really spectacularly great swimmer, such as a penguin, you’re probably going to have to give up flying altogether. Cormorants haven’t gone quite that far, but they’re getting close. In fact, cormorants have the highest flight costs of any bird (not counting the flightless ones, of course).12

Brandt’s cormorants are basically coastal birds. They’re occasionally seen far offshore, but mostly they hang out within sight of land. The species is closely tied to the California Current, which runs along the Pacific coast, delivering cold water from Alaska to the Baja Peninsula. This current, combined with a convergence of northern winds, generates an upwelling of nutrients that lures the kinds of smaller fish that the cormorants like to eat.13

Here’s another video that I took while snorkeling in La Jolla Cove.

[If you’re reading this on email, you may have to visit the website to view the video.]

Once Were Ravens

If you look closely at the beak of a raven, you’ll see that it has a small hook at the end. Cormorants have a similar hook. For this reason, people back in the day (the day being the Middle Ages) assumed that cormorants were related to ravens. In fact, the terms used for raven in Germanic languages of the time usually translated to “sea raven”, or something similar. The word “cormorant” may be a contraction derived from the Latin corvus marinus, “sea raven”, although there are other possible origins.14

I kind of like the term “sea raven”. It’s a pity we don’t still use it. The title of this section, “Once Were Ravens”, is a take-off on a movie title, “Once Were Warriors”, about some Maoris in New Zealand.15 I was tempted to make it the title of the post, but I figured the reference was a bit too obscure.

Cormorants are actually not closely related to ravens. In fact, scientists believe that cormorants are most closely related to darters.16 You can see the similarity in the following photo.

Female Australian darter (Anhinga novaehollandiae)
Author: Brett Donald
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.5 Generic license.

Evolution

The fossil record for cormorants and their relatives isn’t great. However, we do know that cormorants “have a very ancient body plan, with similar birds reaching back to the time of the dinosaurs”, according to Wikipedia. The earliest known modern bird, Gansus yumenensis, had a very similar body plan.17 18

Genetic studies indicate that cormorants diverged from darters during the Late Oligocene. (The Oligocene epoch stretches from about 33.9 to 23 million years ago) This suggests that a few fossils from earlier periods that some people thought were cormorants were probably misidentified. It’s possible that the first “modern” cormorants might have evolved in eastern, south-eastern or southern Asia, but we don’t know for sure.19 20

One clue to the origin of cormorants is that the oldest lineage inhabits a freshwater habitat. This suggests that the original ancestor might have also been a freshwater bird.21

The Flightless Cormorants of the Galapagos22

Of the 40 species of cormorant, only one is completely flightless. This is the Galapagos cormorant (Nannopterum harrisi), aka flightless cormorant, which lives, unsurprisingly, on the Galapagos Islands.23 Presumably, living on an isolated island has meant having to deal with few, if any, predators, so the Galapagos cormorant was able to safely give up flying. This meant that it could divert the resources that it would ordinarily have had to devote to flying into other areas. For example, the Galapagos cormorant is the largest species of cormorant. (Obviously, not having to worry about getting airborne makes conserving weight a lot less crucial.)

I especially wanted to include a mention of this species, because of an interesting genetic study that came out in 2017. Scientists sequenced the genomes of Galapagos cormorants, as well as, three other cormorant species. They used a software program to figure out which of the genetic changes they found were likely to affect the structure and function of proteins, and this led them to zero in on a gene called CUX1. Galapagos cormorants were found to have a different version of this gene from the other species in the study. Flightless birds tend to have shortened wings, and, interestingly, mutations in this gene had previously been linked to shortened wings in chickens. The researchers confirmed that the changes in CUX1 altered the function of a protein that likely affected wing size.

The scientists also found that Galapagos cormorants have an unusually high number of mutations that affect cilia. Cilia are slender protuberances that project from cell bodies. They play a role in the regulation of embryonic development, including bone growth. As it happens, defects in cilia in humans have been shown to lead to a number of disorders collectively known as ‘ciliopathies’.24 People who are born with skeletal ciliopathies have shortened limbs, narrow chests, and stunted rib cages — just like Galapagos cormorants. This study suggests that CUX1 controls many aspects of the development of the cilia, and some of these aspects affect bone growth. So CUX1 could play a role in the human disorders, as well. (It’s interesting that what we think of as a “disorder” in humans just represents a different evolutionary pathway in the cormorants of the Galapagos Islands.)

Fishing with Cormorants

I decided to save one of the most interesting facts about cormorants for last. For thousands of years, humans have been using trained cormorants for fishing. Surprisingly, archeological evidence suggests that cormorant fishing was widespread in ancient times, being practiced in ancient Egypt, Korea, India, and Peru. I find Peru particularly interesting, since it implies that the technique must have been developed independently in different parts of the world. The tradition is most closely associated with China and Japan, however. It’s still done in these two countries today, but mostly just for the benefit of tourists.

So how do you fish with a cormorant? First, you have to catch it young so that it grows up to trust humans. When fishing, a snare is tied around the bird’s throat near the base. This allows the bird to swallow small fish, but larger ones get stuck in the bird’s throat. So when the cormorant catches a larger fish, the fisherman has it come back to the boat and spit the fish out. Sometimes, the bird just holds the fish in its beak instead of trying to swallow it.

In China, fishermen came up with a rather novel approach to cormorant fishing that basically amounts to making a “contract” with the bird. After every seven fish the bird catches, it gets to eat the eighth one. The cormorant quickly learns this and eagerly delivers seven fish to the fisherman’s boat, knowing that it’s going to get to eat the next one. (And this, incidentally, proves that a cormorant can count to eight! They’re very smart birds, despite Mr. Bent’s slurs.)25 26 27

Here’s a few pictures of cormorant fishing, taken from Wiki Commons. For some even better ones, click here.

Fishing with Cormorants
Notice the snares around the birds’ necks.
Date: 1911
Source: Frontispiece of Talks about Birds (available at https://archive.org/stream/talksaboutbirds00finniala)
Author: Frank Finn
{{PD-US}} This work is in the public domain in its country of origin and other countries and areas where the copyright term is the author’s life plus 70 years or fewer.
Cormorant fishing in Suzhou, China
Author: Cormorant_fishing_-Suzhou_-China-6July2005.jpg: tiarescott from Beverly Hills, California, USA
derivative work: Biomenne (talk)
This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.
Cormorant Fishing in Japan
Date: 30 August 2014, 20:17
Source: 嵐山の鵜飼 / Cormorant Fishing in Arashiyama
Author:
Kentaro Ohno
 from Tokyo, Japan